Bombay High CourtWP/3526/2013dispossed offdismiss for default

Sheetal Subhashrao Chopede v. University Grants Commission National Edu. Testing Bureau Uni. Of Delhi Thr. Its Head And Another

2015-01-13Hon'Ble Shri Justice B. P. Dharmadhikari,Hon'Ble Shri Justice A.P. Bhangale7 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY, NAGPUR

BENCH, NAGPUR.

WRIT PETITION NO.2739 OF 2013 Ku. Shewatali Dhurve vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.979 OF 2013 Sapna Ronghe vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.1853 OF 2013 Priti Sahu vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.1990 OF 2013 Mrs Kirti Kulkarni @ Kirti Verma vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.2256 OF 2013 Nandkishor Bhandari vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.2262 OF 2013 Hemant Korde vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.2485 OF 2013 Ms. Suvarna Inamdar and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.2627 OF 2013 Pratibha Kaware and anr vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.2699 OF 2013 Ku. Rekha Zoting vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.2700 OF 2013 Ku. Rameshwari Yadav vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr .....2/-

WRIT PETITION NO.2705 OF 2013 Rahul Raut and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and an WRIT PETITION NO.2752 OF 2013 Shri Raju Dayal vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.2837 OF 2013 Ku. Pratibha Dubey vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.2840 OF 2013 Ashish Kubde vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3037 OF 2013 Raosaheb Yadgire vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3040 OF 2013 Trupti Rajhansa and anr vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3043 OF 2013 Anupam Pandey and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3049 OF 2013 Radhika Aparajit and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3063 OF 2013 Ms. Vrushali Kale vs.

University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3153 OF 2013 Rajani Wadhai and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3165 OF 2013 Ku. Akshara Gonnade vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3298 OF 2013 Ku. Sunita Lahane and anr vs. University Grants Commission, New .....

Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3312 OF 2013 Shri Chandramohan Bishit vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3329 OF 2013 Edgar Machenzie and ors vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi WRIT PETITION NO.3408 OF 2013 Megharaj Meshram and anr vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3469 OF 2013 Priya Gedam vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3494 OF 2013 Gajendra Irwe vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3525 OF 2013 Archana Paliwal vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3526 OF 2013 Sheetal Chopde vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3528 OF 2013 Sangita Somwanshi vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.

3545 OF 2013 Mahesh Jogi vs. University Grants Commission, New Delhi, and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3547 OF 2013 Sajjansingh Chandel vs. Union of India, Ministry of Human Resource Department and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3549 OF 2013 Sumit Rathi vs. Union of India, Ministry of Human Resource Department and ors .....

WRIT PETITION NO.3612 OF 2013 Purushottam Wankhede vs. Union of India, Ministry of Human Resource Department and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3633 OF 2013 Vishnu Gawali vs. Union of India, Ministry of Human Resource Department and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3664 OF 2013 Vinita Yadav vs. University Grants Commission and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3669 OF 2013 Laila Bhairaiya vs. University Grants Commission and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3735 OF 2013 Faizan Ahmed vs. University Grants Commission and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3756 OF 2013 Sharayu Dhole vs. University Grants Commission and ors WRIT PETITION NO.3792 OF 2013 Ms. Amala Nahar vs. University Grants Commission and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3793 OF 2013 Vivek Khunkar vs. University Grants Commission and anr WRIT PETITION NO.3800 OF 2013 Sumeet Chandegave vs. University Grants Commission WRIT PETITION NO.

3842 OF 2013 Aniruddha Gachake vs. University Grants Commission and anr WRIT PETITION NO.4008 OF 2013 Gajanan Khade vs. University Grants Commission and ors .......................................................................................................................................... Office Notes, Office Memoranda of Coram, appearances, Court's orders Court's or Judge's order of directions and Registrar's orders ........................................................................................................................................... Shri Vikas Kulsange, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P. No. 2739/13).

Shri P.S. Patil, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P. No.979, 3408/13).

.....5/-

Shri S.M. Ukey, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 11853/13).

Shri P.M. Chandekar, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 1990/13).

Shri Harshal Bobade, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 2256, 2262, 3842, 5013/13).

Ms. T.H. Udeshi, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.2485, 3063, 3494, 3664, 3669/13).

Ms. Kirti Satpute, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.2627 & 3298/13).

Shri V.K. Paliwal, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.2699, 2700, 2837 & 2840/13).

Shri S.G. Karmarkar, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 2705, 3445/13).

Shri A.M. Sudame, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.2752, 3312/13).

Shri R.D. Dhande, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 3037/13).

Shri V.B. Bhise, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3040/13). Shri P.P. Thakare, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3043, 3049 & 3153, 3329, 3800/13).

Shri S.M. Samarth, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 3165/13).

Shri Haque, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3469/13). Shri Qazi, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3525, 3526/13). Shri S.J. Kadu, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3528/13). Shri V.B. Gawali, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3547, 3549, 3612/13).

Shri S.M. Gaikwad, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 3633/13).

Shri S.A. Mohta, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 3735/13).

Shri Aul Pathak, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 3756/13).

Shri D.T. Shinde, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No.3792, 3793/13).

Shri U.J. Deshpande, counsel for petitioner/s (W.P.No. 4008/13).

Shri P.B. Patil, counsel for R-2 & 3 (in W.P.Nos.2739, 1853, 1990, 2485, 2627, 2699, 2752, 2837, 3298, 3312, 3494, 3525, 3526, 3528, 3612, 3664, 3656, 4008/13) & for R-4 & 5 (W.P.No.3633/13).

Shri Abhay Sambre, counsel for R-4 (W.P.No.979/13). Shri S.K. Mishra, counsel for R-1 (W.P.Nos.1990, 2262, 2627, 2700, 3037, 3040, 3043, 3063, 3153, 3312, 3329, 3525, 3526, 3528/13) & for R-1 to 3 (W.P.No.3633/13). .....6/-

Ms. Tajwar Khan, counsel for R-2 in (W.P. Nos.2256, 2700, 3842/13) & for R-3 (W.P. No.2262/13).

Ms. Sweta Kulkarni, counsel for R-2 (W.P.No.2705/13). Shri Arun Agrawal, counsel for R-2 (W.P.No.3165/13).

CORAM

: B.P.DHARMADHIKARI & A.P.BHANGALE, JJ.

DATE : JANUARY 13, 2015.

Heard learned counsel appearing for the respective parties.

It is not in dispute that the Judgment of the Division Bench of this Court, in Writ Petition No.4996 of 2012 and connected writ petitions, has been set aside by the Honourable Apex Court in its Judgment in the case of University Grants Commission and anr ..vs.. Neha Anil Bobde (Gadekar) reported at (2013)10 SCC 519.

This Court had adjourned the matters even thereafter because of the requests made by the parties pointing out that review of that Judgment has been sought before the Honourable Apex Court.

Today, it is not in dispute that the review petition is also dismissed.

.....7/-

Learned counsel appearing for the respective parties, however, state that a curative petition has now been filed and it is pending. 6.

Learned counsel for the respondents are opposing any adjournment.

As the Judgment of this Court is already set aside by the Honourable Apex Court and the review is also dismissed, we are not inclined to adjourn the matters further.

Accordingly, in the light of the Judgment of the Honourable Apex Court cited supra, these writ petitions are disposed of.

Needless to mention that, in case the curative of petition is granted by the Honourable Apex Court, respective petitioners can renew their requests before this Court.

JUDGE JUDGE !! BRW !!

...../-