Pramod N. Naik And 2 ORS., v. Audhut S. Naik And 35 ORS.,

Maria S.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

FIRST APPEAL NO. 302 OF 2007

1. Shri Pramod N. Naik, son of late Nilkanth Naik, about 50 years old, retired, married, Indian national, residing at Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

2. Shri Gurudas S. Naik, son of late Sagun naik, major, unmarried, service,

3. Kum. Anandini S. Naik, daughter of late Sagun S. Naik, major, unmarried, Both Indian Nationals, residing at Virlosa, Penha de Franca, Bardez, Goa.

Versus

1. Shri Audhut S. Naik, son of late Shriram Naik, 59 years old, married, business, r/o H. No.D41, 1a) Shri Kiran Audhut Naik; (son) 1b) Kripa Kiran Naik; (daughter-in-law) 1c) Smt. Kiran Naik (Volvoikar); (daughter) 1d) Shri Samil Volvoikar; (son-in-law) ..... Appellants.

1c and 1 d are represented by their mother Smt. Rasvanti A. Naik, residing at House No.D-41, Chalbhat, Dhausi Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi-Goa.

2. Smt. Rasavanti A. Naik, wife of Audhut S. Naik, 54 years old, r/o H.No.D-41,

3. Shri Ramakant S. Naik, son of late Shriram Naik, 78 years old, married, r/o H.No.D-41, (A) Shri Mandar Ramakant Naik (son);

(B) Jagruti Ramakant Naik (daughter), Both residents of H.No.D-41, Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi-Goa, both represented by their mother the Respondent No.4, SMT.

SUKANTI R. NAIK.

4. Smt. Sukanti R. Naik, wife of Ramakant S. naik, 60 years old, housewife, H. No.D-41,

5. Shri Gopinath @ Chandrakant S. Naik, son of late Sakharam S. Naik, 90 years old, retired, 5)A) Avinash C. Naik.

5)B) Jaiwant C. Naik.

5)C) Shri Santosh C. Naik.

5)D) Sufala C. Naik (Married).

5)E) Jaywanti C. Naik (Married).

5)F) Nutan C. Naik. (Married) All represented by Shri Avinash Naik, Resident of Chalbhat, House no-D/57, Old Goa) Since deceased

6. Shri Madhusudan B. Naik, son of late Balaram Naik, 59 years old, married, retired, Amendment carried out as per order dated 29/11/13 in MCA/643/2014.

(A) Shri Amresh Madhusudan Naik (son).

(B) Mrudula Madhusudan Naik (daughter).

Both residents of House No.567, Malim, Betim, Bardez-Goa both represented by their mother the Respondent No.7, SMT. SARITA M.

NAIK.

7. Smt. Samita M. Naik, wife of Madhusudan Naik, 51 years old, housewife, ` Both Indian Nationals, residing at H. No.567, Malim, Betim, Bardez-Goa.

8. Shri Dattadas B. Naik, son of late Balaram Naik, 46 years old, housewife,

9. Smt. Bharati D. Naik, wife of Dattadas B. Naik, 42 years old, housewife,

10. Shri Gurudas B. Naik, son of late Balaram Naik, 33 years old, unmarried, service,

11. Shri Madhav B. Naik, son of late Balaram Naik, 34 years old, business,

12. Kum, Anusuya B. Naik, daughter of late Balaram Naik, 42 years old, domestic,

13. Kum. Mangala B. Naik, daughter of late Balaram Naik, 35 years old, unmarried, domestic, All Indian Nationals, residing at H. No.304, Verem, Bardez, Goa.

14. Smt. Megha @ Rekhabai Nilkanth Naik, widow of late Nilkanth Naik, 75 years old, housewife, Indian National, residing at Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

15. Shri Ashok N. Naik, son of late late Nilkanth Naik, 59 years old, married, retired,

16. Smt. Tulsi A. Naik, wife of Shri Ashok Naik, 54 years old, domestic,

All Indian Nationals, residing at H. No.82, Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

17. Shri Sanjeev N. Naik, son of late Nilkanth Naik, 38 years old, business, married,

18. Smt. Varsha S. Naik, wife of Sanjeev Naik, 37 years old,

19. Shri Yeshwant N. Naik, son of late Nilkanth Naik, 62 years, married, retired,

20. Smt. Shanta Y. Naik, wife of Yeshwant Naik, 57 years old, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at Yashdeep Niwas, Dhawali, Ponda, Goa.

21. Shri Prakash D. Narvekar, 52 years old, married, service,

22. Smt, Pratima P. Narvekar, wife of Prakash Narvekar, 45 years old, major, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at H. No.220/1, Near KTC Depot, Porvorim, Bardez, Goa.

23. Shri Uday N. Naik, son of late Nilkanth naik, 52 years old, Advocate by profession

24. Smt. Nita U. Naik, wife of Uday Naik, major, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at H.No. not known, Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

25. Shri Shrikrishna N. Tari Narvekar, son of late Namdev Tari Narvekar, 46 years old, business,

26. Smt. Ratan S. Tari Narvekar, wife of Shrikrishna Tari Narvekar, 44 years old, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at St. Estevem, Tiswadi, Goa.

27. Shri Rajaram N. Naik, son of late Nilkanth Naik, 43 years old, business,

28. Smt. Leena R. Naik, wife of Rajaram Naik, 40 years old, Both Indian Nationals, residing at H. No.D-46, Chalbhat, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

29. Shri Vishwanath Chodankar, 45 years old, married, business,

30. Smt. Vishaka V. Chodankar, wife of Vishwanath Chodankar, 42 years old, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at Near Ganesh Temple, Ganeshpuri, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa.

31. Shri Nilkanth Naik Karekar, 47 years old, business, married,

32. Smt. Tanuja Nilkanth Naik Karekar, wife of Nilkanth Naik Karekar, housewife,

33. Shri Naresh Nilkanth Naik, son of late Nilkanth Naik, 39 years old, married, business,

34. Smt. Sampada Naresh Naik, wife of Naresh Naik, 35 years old, housewife, Both Indian Nationals, residing at Gold Tiles Factory, Dhauji Road, Old Goa, Tiswadi, Goa.

35. State of Goa represented by the Chief Secretary, Government of Goa, Secretariat, Alto Porvorim, Bardez, Goa.

36. The Joint Mamlatdar-II of Tiswadi, Panaji, Goa. .. Respondents.

Mr. Parikshit Sawant, Advocate for the Appellants. Mr. R. G. Ramani, Senior Advocate with Mr Pranay Sinai Kakodkar, Advocate for the Respondents No. 1 to 11 and 13.

CORAM:

VALMIKI SA MENEZES, J.

9th November 2023.

DATED:

JUDGMENT:

 

 

 

1 2002 (1) Goa LT 109

2 1999 (1) Goa LT 77

VALMIKI MENEZES, J.

Date: 2024.05.14 15:47:33 +05'30'

MARIA SUZANA REBELLO