P.S.Sairam v. State (Govt. Of Tamil Nadu)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 29.03.2021 CORAM :
THE HON'BLE MR.SANJIB BANERJEE, CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SENTHILKUMAR RAMAMOORTHY Review Application No.14 of 2021 1 P.S.SAIRAM 2 V. VISHNUPRIYA 3 BALARISUK BYRSAT 4 K. GAYATHRI 5 ASHWINI MUTHUSAMY 6 HARITHA 7 VIDHYA MOHAN 8 PRIYADHARSHINI JEYAPRAKASH 9 HRIDYA VASUDEVAN 10 JAYASREE RAJENDIRAN 11 SNEHA SURESH 12 SREE DIVYA M 13 SRINIDHI V 14 R. AISWARYA 15 SATHIYA T 16 ARULSELVAN 17 S. PRAVINSELVAM 18 AMBUJA SEKHAR 19 J. HEMILDA PERIANAYAKI ...
Petitioners Vs.
1 STATE (GOVT. OF TAMIL NADU) THROUGH ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 600 009 2 DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION DIRECTORATE OF MEDICAL EDUCATION DME 156 POONAMALLEE HIGH ROAD KILPAUK CHENNAI 600 010 3 SAAD ASLAM KHAN 4 NEIMENUO KUOTSU 5 DR.AMIT KUMAR 6 JYOTHIS PULIYAMKUNNATH JOSE 7 T.M.VAISHNAVI 8 K.KOKILA 9 MIDHUN MOHAN 10 VIJAY G 11 M.RAMYA JOTHI 12 WARANG OMKAR SHARAD 13 NEHA DHOK 14 SUGUMARAN KANDASAMY 15 ANUSREE A KARUN 16 POORNIMA K NAIR 17 UDAY SRINIVAS 18 THAMARAIKANNAN A 19 POORNIMA 20 MERIIN VARGHESE 21 MARTUM JOKIK 22 GANGA CHELLAMUTHU 23 K.SANGHEETHA 24 NISHANT KUMAR SAHU 25 POURNAMI 26 R.SRINATH 27 PRIYANKA V K 28 KETHAVATH ANITHA 29 FLAICY VARGHESE 30 SAVITHA MANOKARAN 31 CHIDAMBARAM SETHURAMAN 32 VYAS NARAYAN 33 SANJANA 34 KARTHIKA SANKAR
35 SUHAN DINESH NARAYAN 36 VAISHNAVI VK D/O SHRI VP KAR 37 KOCHAMI P.A 38 M.AMALA GRACE 39 NANDHINI M.V.
40 SHARADHA SUNDARARAMAN 41 HANGSHING THANGLAWMLAL 42 PRADEEP RAM 43 J.NIVEDITA 44 G.DHIVYALAKSHMIN 45 NAZIA HUSSAIN 46 SHRUTHI JAYAPAL 47 RAJESH M 48 MALAVIKA S 49 LEKSHMI MOHAN 50 KALIRAJ ALWAR MURUGARAJ 51 SUSAN JACOB 52 R.AFREEN NAHAR 53 SOUNDARYA BALAJEE 54 AJAY ABRHAM 55 THURAKA SHILPA REDDY 56 NIVETHA KAMESWARI V 57 ANN MARY ZACHARIAS 58 SARATH R S 59 KANDKURTIKAR RACHANA RAMACHA 60 G.PRASANTH 61 K.LOHIT SAI 62 SONY P S 63 TEENA K 64 VIDHYA RENGARAJU 65 C.S.SRI SUGHANYA 66 A K ROOPA 67 S.ANU 68 ANTONY THOMAS 69 DEVI KRISHNA G S 70 K.PRAVEEN 71 SUDHA JANAKY M S 72 THOMAS BABU 73 R JAY GANESH
74 RITIKA GAUTAM 75 GOKUL PRASANNAN 76 SWATHY RAJU 77 TRUPTI NARASIMHAPPA 78 GOMATHI V 79 REMAN RAJENDRAN 80 A SUJA RAJAN 81 SHRAAVAN KUMAR B S 82 MANOCHITHRA 83 SWETHA K 84 VIJAYARAGAVAN R 85 K G RAJ NIHEDAN 86 A. ABDUL RAHIM 87 AMEENA ASLAM 88 JITHU GEORGE 89 ASHWINI RAJASEKARAN 90 KRISHNA KUMAR S 91 ATCHYA ELANGOVAN 92 LALITHA RAJALAKSHMI 93 ANUSHA RAMADOSS 94 TREESA P VATTAKUZHI 95 JERRIN C JOY 96 ARUNA S.K 97 ANUPAMA S 98 C. MADHUMITHA 99 RAUT ASHWINI SANJAY 100 RUBU ANU 101 POORNIMA NAIR 102 T.D. VARNEIKIP CHIRU 103 PRASANTH J 104 SWATHI PRAKASH J 105 P. EZHIL 106 ROJET DAVID BINNY V 107 ANBARASAN S 108 G. NAGAPRIYA 109 SAI SHIVA G 110 MANJU MUNIYAPPA 111 DHIVYAA M 112 SWATI GUPTA
113 REMYA E 114 SHIBIN SASIDHARAN 115 UTPAL SUTARIA 116 N. SUDHA PRIYADHARSHINI 117 SALAHUDHEEN M 118 AJITHA D 119 SARANYA S 120 ABDUL LATHEEF ABDUL GAFOOR 121 SHIRLEY T LEIVON 122 S. ANBARASAN 123 ARJUN C 124 INGERSAL N 125 VARUN P.G 126 KARTAVYA KAVADYA 127 JERRY ABRAHAM JOSEPH 128 SINJU SANKAR P 129 ANI THAMPI 130 SHABIN J 131 SUNGANYA E 132 N EZHIL 133 LAKSHMI 134 REMYA PARVATHY R 135 BOGALA GOWTHAMI 136 SRUTHI R.S 137 INAN LOLLEN 138 VIVEK NAGAPPA 139 M SRILAXMI 140 DELPHIN SUPRIYA J 141 SARATH HARIDAS 142 ASWATHY B.S 143 JAMKHOPUM BAITE 144 MOHAMMED THARIQ 145 ANJU ROSE GEORGE 146 K PRAVEEN 147 MEGHANA SLVARAJ 148 R. KARTHIK 149 NAMITHA RAJENDRAN 150 ARUN GOVIND 151 AARUSHI MANU
152 ISHWARYA JEYAGANTHI 153 T. RAJAKUMARI 154 INSHA MEHRAJ KAK 155 ARUL MURUGAN A 156 ARUNKUMAR A 157 NIRANJANA ASOKAN 158 J. MANOJ 159 AMUTHAVALLI K 160 MOHANAPRIYA ARUMUGAM 161 JAYA JARIKA 162 MIDHUN K PRAKASH 163 KAVIYA MURUGESAN 164 GNANESHWARI P S 165 DEEPIKA M 166 HIMA SURENDRAN 167 SANJU S T 168 ARUN PRASANTH K 169 ASHWINI B 170 KUNAL KISHOR TAWARD 171 S.MURALI KRISHNAN 172 S.THALABATHIK KUMARA VIKRAM 173 SANJEEV P 174 SANJANA S 175 RAGINI RAJAN 176 NIKHIL RAJ R 177 DR.B.AGNI 178 VASANTH KARTHIKEYAN 179 ABDULLA ANCHUKANDAN 180 PC HMINGMUANPUII 181 ANWIKA KIRTHI KUJUR 182 JAMSHEER VT 183 DR. KARTHIKEYAN M 184 DR.M. MARIAM HABEEBA 185 DR. VIJAYAKUMAR .A 186 DR. ESAKKI 187 DR. SUBASHINI M.R 188 SRIRADHU V.G 189 SINDHU KALYANARAMAN 190 MEENAXI P MEHTA
191 M.Y. MOHAMD YASAR 192 REGISTRAR THE TAMIL NADU DR. M.G.R. MEDICAL UNIVERSITY GUINDY CHENNAI 25.
193 THE REGISTRAR TAMIL NADU MEDICAL COUNCIL 914 POONAMALLEE HIGH ROAD ARUMBAKKAM CHENNAI 106.
...
Respondents Prayer: Application under Order XLVII, Rule 1, read with Section 114 of Civil Procedure Code, to review the order dated 06.10.2020 made in W.A.No.799 of 2019.
For Petitioners : Mr.R.Arumugam For Respondents 1 & 2 : Mr.T.M.Pappiah Special Govt. Pleader
ORDER
(Made by SENTHILKUMAR RAMAMOORTHY,J) The review applicants seek to review an order dated 06.10.2020 in a batch of writ petitions and writ appeal, wherein the lead case is W.A.No.799 of 2019.
2. The review applicants contend that the finding at paragraph 103(ii) to the effect that the conditions in the brochures for the years 2014-15 and 2015-16 do not exempt the candidates of All India Quota seats from executing a bond is an error apparent on the face of the record. In support of this contention, learned counsel for the review applicants relies upon the rejoinder of the Directorate of Medical Education which contains a statement to the effect that such a condition had not been included in the prospectus.
3. In the order under review, the Court had taken into consideration the fact that each of the review applicants and other candidates who filled up the All India Quota seats, had duly executed bonds that required them to put in two years of government service. In addition, it was noticed at paragraph 75 that an Information Bulletin for All India Post Graduates Medical Entrance Examination 2014 was provided to all the candidates and that it contained a compilation of frequently asked questions for the All India Quota. In response to question No.30, it was specified that different conditions, including the rendering of service in rural/tribal areas, may be imposed and the conditions may vary from State to State. Consequently, the
candidates were instructed to examine these aspects before opting for a seat in a medical college in a particular State. Thus, the order under review duly took into consideration, analysed and interpreted all the documents that were placed for consideration before concluding that there was no exemption for candidates of All India Quota seats as regards the execution of bonds.
4. The next contention advanced by learned counsel for the review applicants is that certificates were released to certain candidates in a discriminatory manner. This aspect has also been taken into consideration in the order under review, wherein it was concluded that such action by the authorities was contrary to the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the judgment reported in (2019) 8 SCC 607 (Association of Medical Superspecialty Aspirants and Residents v. Union of India), wherein the requirement of execution of such bonds was upheld. Learned counsel also relies upon an earlier judgment of this Court reported in (2009) 1 MLJ 1103 (Dr.S.Rajesh v. State of Tamil Nadu) wherein it was concluded that the condition of execution of bond does not apply to All India Quota seats.
This judgment was also taken into consideration in the order under review.
5. For the reasons aforesaid, the review applicants have failed to establish that there is an error apparent on the face of the record or any other sufficient ground to review the order dated 06.10.2020. Consequently, keeping in mind the limited scope of review jurisdiction, we find that the review applicants have failed to make out a case. Therefore, Review Application No.14 of 2021 is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.
(S.B., CJ.) (S.K.R., J.) 29.03.2021 Index : Yes/No kpl To 1 THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 600 009 2 DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION DIRECTORATE OF MEDICAL EDUCATION DME 156 POONAMALLEE HIGH ROAD KILPAUK CHENNAI 600 010
THE HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE AND SENTHILKUMAR RAMAMOORTHY, J.
(kpl) Rev.Appln.No.14 of 2021 29.03.2021