C.V.Raghavan v. The Chairman
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 16.07.2024 CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.M.SUBRAMANIAM AND THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.KUMARAPPAN 1.
C.V.Raghavan V.Krisnamurthy 3.
M.s.Sugavanam 4.
C.R.Narayana Kurup 5.
P.Krisnasamy 6.
M.P.Vasudevan 7.
M.Madhavan 8.
C.V.Syriac 9.
V.Rukmani ... Applicants in Rev.Appl.No.89 of 2006 Thoothukudi District Electricity Board, Pensioners Association (Regd.No.51/98), Represented by its General Secretary A.Subramanian (Pottu).
... Applicant in Rev.Appl.No.90 of 2006 1.
V.Raghunathan R.V.Duraisamy 3.
Syed Abdulgani 4.
M.Velmurugan 5.
S.Swedaranyam 6.
S.Ayyasamy 7.
K.Badrinarayanan 8.
A.M.Kannayan Page No.1 of 7
9.
R.Natarajan 10.
S.Govindan 11.
N.Vedavyasam 12.
D.Ramanathan 13.
S.Ramadoss 14.
S.Viswanathan 15.
V.R.Masilamani 16.
A.G.Subramaniam 17.
T.V.Arumugam 18.
M.R.Kothandaraman 19.
A.Tyagarajan 20.
N.Subramaniam 21.
R.Seshadri 22.
V.Natarajan 23.
S.Kanagasundaram 24.
R.Subramanian 25.
V.Narasimhan 26.
L.Kalyanasundaram 27.
N.Raghavendra Rao 28.
R.M.Arumugam 29.
A.G.Menon 30.
M.S.Raghavan 31.
N.R.Srinivasan 32.
V.Swaminathan 33.
N.Ganesan 34.
C.N.Parameswaran 35.
P.Sethumathavan 36.
V.Chandrasekaran 37.
C.K.Sundaresan 38.
S.R.Ramakrishnan 39.
K.Thiruvanai 40.
V.S.Gopala Rao 41.
D.S.Arunachalam 42.
S.Govindarajan 43.
M.Kuppusamy 44.
P.S.Subbanarasimhan 45.
P.Krishnamurthy Page No.2 of 7
46.
S.Kailasam 47.
M.Krishnan 48.
M.Sankarapandian 49.
S.Seetharaman 50.
P.G.Sundararajulu 51.
P.C.Subramaniyam 52.
S.Chandrasekaran 53.
N.S.Abdul Latiff 54.
K.Narayanan 55.
S.Sowrirajan 56.
A.Thangavelu 57.
M.S.Sheik Ibrahim 58.
T.A.Ramasamy 59.
M.R.Varadarajan 60.
I.Sadasivam 61.
K.T.Ramasamy 62.
S.Bhoominathan 63.
S.Narasimhan 64.
T.P.Veerappan 65.
Y.P.Siva Subramaniam 66.
N.V.Balakrishnan 67.
M.Krishnamurthy 68.
V.Nagarajan 69.
V.Kalahastheeswaran 70.
A.V.Swaminathan 71.
T.A.D.Samy 72.
P.K.Kunhi Moosa 73.
N.S.Desigan 74.
K.S.Ramiah 75.
S.Padmanaban 76.
R.Duraisamy 77.
K.A.Ahamaed Basha 78.
K.V.Thyagarajan 79.
V.Kamalam 80.
S.Srinivasan 81.
E.Sundaram 82.
K.Ragavan Page No.3 of 7
83.
R.Venkatesan 84.
T.P.Rathinasamy 85.
S.Manian 86.
K.R.Ramanujam 87.
S.Srinivasan 88.
M.Kalyana Sundaram 89.
K.Sathia Muthy 90.
S.Sheik Babu 91.
M.A.Perumal 92.
N.A.Krishnamurthy 93.
P.S.Srinivasan 94.
V.Venkateswaran 95.
M.V.Venugopalan 96.
C.Kuppusamy 97.
K.S.Jayaraman 98.
A.V.Krishnan 99.
R.Subramaniam
100. S.Muthuraman
101. S.Abdul Kadar
102. Padma
103. G.Saroja
104. R.Rahima Bi
105. K.Manikkammal
106. R.Govindammal
107. Girija
108. Ganga ... Applicants in Rev.Appl.No.91 of 2006 Vs.
1.
The Chairman, Tamilnadu Electricity Board, 800, Anna Salai, Chennai - 600 002.
The Secretary to Government, Energy Department, Fort St.George, Chennai - 600 009.
... Respondents in all Rev.Appln's Page No.4 of 7
Common Prayer: Review Applications filed under Order 47 Rule 1 r/w Section 114 of Civil Procedure Code, to review the order made in a batch of writ appeals in W.A.Nos.2700, 2703 & 2704 of 2004 dated 07.02.2006 respectively.
For Respondents : Mr.A.L.Namasivayam [in all Rev.Appln's] C O M M O N O R D E R (Order of the Court was made by S.M.SUBRAMANIAM,J.) The Division Bench of this Court elaborately considered the issues raised in the writ appeal and delivered Judgement on 07.02.2006. The issue relating to adopting Government Order left with the discretion of the Tamil Nadu Electricity Board. Board being an independent entity well within its power shall take decision on administrative matters. 3.
The writ appeal since decided on merits, the grounds raised in the present review applications to readjudicate the said issues are Page No.5 of 7
impermissible. We could not able to trace out any error apparent on record warranting interference. Thus, all the Review Applications stand dismissed. [S.M.S., J.] [C.K., J.] 16.07.2024 Index :
Yes/No Speaking Order :
Yes/No :
Yes/No veda To 1.
The Chairman, Tamilnadu Electricity Board, 800, Anna Salai, Chennai - 600 002.
The Secretary to Government, Energy Department, Fort St.George, Chennai - 600 009.
Page No.6 of 7
S.M.SUBRAMANIAM, J.
AND C.KUMARAPPAN, J.
veda Rev.Appl.Nos.89, 90 & 91of 2006 16.07.2024 Page No.7 of 7