The Secretary To Government v. S.Sagaya Selvan,

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 01.09.2015 C O R A M THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI and THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.K.SASIDHARAN W.A. Nos. 1302 to 1316 of 2015 and connected miscellaneous petitions 1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND WATER SUPPLY DEPARTMENT FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9.

2 THE DIRECTOR OF TOWN PANCHAYAT KURALAGAM BUILDINGS CHENNAI 108.

...1st and 2nd APPELLANTS in WA.No.1302,1303,1304,1305,1306,1307, 1308,1309,1310,1311,1312, 1313,1314,1315,1316 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KEELKULAM TOWN PANCHAYAT KEELKULAM KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

...3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1302 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER VALVACHAGOSTAM TOWN PANCHAYAT VALVACHAGOSTAM NAGERCOIL DISTRICT ...3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1303 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KALIAKKAVILAI SECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KALIAKKAVILAI KANYAKUMARI DIST ...3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1304 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KAMBAI NALLUR FIRST GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KAMBAI NALLUR DHARMAPURI DISTRICT ...3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1305 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER TIRUPORUR TOWN PANCHAYAT TIRUPORUR KANCHIPURAM DIST ... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1306 of 2015

3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER VEERAKKAL PUDUR SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT VEERAKKAL PUDUR SALEM DISTRICT.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1307 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KULASEKARAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KULASEKARAM KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1308 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER PENNAGARAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT PENNAGARAM DHARMAPURI DIST.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1309 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KARIMANGALAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT DHARMAPURI DISTRICT ... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1310 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER TIRUPORUR TOWN PANCHAYAT TIRUPORUR ERODE DIST ... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1311 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER COMMISSIONER KEERANUR SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT ... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1312 of 2015 3 THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF TOWN PANCHAYATS REGIONAL OFFICE SALEM.

4 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER ELAMPILLAI TOWN PANCHAYAT SALEM.

... 3rd AND 4TH APPELLANT in WA No.1313 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KAPPIYARAI TOWN PANCHAYAT KAPPIYARAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1314 of 2015

3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER KOOKALOOR TOWN PANCHAYAT KOOKALOOR ERODE DISTRICT.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1315 of 2015 3 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER ARIYAPPAM PALAYAM TOWN PANCHAYAT ARIYAPPAM PALAYAM ERODE DISTRICT.

... 3rd APPELLANT in WA No.1316 of 2015 vs.

1 S.SAGAYA SELVAN S/O.SUSAIMARIYAN PARAKKANVILAI KEELKULAM POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

2 F.STALIN RAJA S/O.FRANCIS PANDARAVILAAGAM THOLIKODU THERUVUKADAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

3 T.JEYAMANI S/O.THANGA NADAR KATTUVILAI SENTHARAI KEELKULAM POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

4 K.RAJESH KUMAR S/O.KUMARA DOSS SARASVILAI OLIPPARAI PUTTATRI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

... RESPONDENT in WA No.1302 of 2015 1 P.RUSSEL RAJ S/O.PAUL CHETTIYAKUDI VILAI PALLIYADI POST NAGERCOIL DISTRICT 2 M. JEYASEELAN S/O.MARIYADOSS NESAVALAR STREET PALLIYADI POST NAGERCOIL DISTRICT 3 S. NATARAJAN S/O.SUDALAIMADAN VALVACHAGOSTAM TOWN PANCHAYAT VALVACHAGOSTAM NAGERCOIL DISTRICT ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1303 of 2015

1 N.V.SAJI KUMAR S/O.NARAYANA PILLAI KALIAKKAVILAI SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KALIAKKAVILAI KANYAKUMARI DIST ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1304 of 2015 1 M.ADHIMOOLAM S/O.MOOKAN VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR (VIA) HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 2 C.RAJENDRAN S/O.CHENNU VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR (VIA) HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 3 C.AKKUMARI S/O.CHOKKAN VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR (VIA) HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 4 M.RAGHUPATHY S/O.MOOKAN VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR (VIA) HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 5 K.NAGARAJAN VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR (VIA) HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 6 M.VELU S/O.MURUGAN M.G.R.NAGAR KAMBA NALLUR HARUR TALUK DHARMAPURI DISTRICT ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1305 of 2015 1 LAKSHMI W/O.MANNANGKATTI ALL RESIDING AT NO. 45 PADAVETTAMMAN KOIL STREET TIRUPORUR KANCHEEPURAM DIST.

2 M.TAMIZHARASI D/O.MANNANGKATTI AGE 20 YEARS.

3 M.MALATHI D/O.MANNANGKATTI AGE 18 YEARS.

4 M.KANIMOZHI D/O.MANNANGKATTI AGE 15 YEARS.

5 M.ARCHANA D/O.MANNANGKATTI AGE 13 YEARS.

6 M.SAKTHIVEL S/O.MANNANGKATTI AGE 10 YEARS.

PETITIONERS 3 TO 6 REP BY THEIR MOTHER ALL RESIDING AT PADAVETTAMMAN KOIL STREET TIRUPORUR KANCHEEPURAM DIST.

... RESPONDENT in WA No.1306 of 2015 1 KUPPAMMAL W/O. KUPPUSAMY ALL ARE RESIDING AT NO.1/6-5 KOLLAN ARUNTHATHIYAR STREET KARUPPUREDDIYOOR POST VEERAKKAL PUDUR METTUR DAM-4 SALEM DIST.

2 K.VIJAYA W/O. ANNADHURAI ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1307 of 2015 1 A.KUMAR S/O.AYYAPPAN THUNDUVILAI SERUPPALOOR POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT. ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1308 of 2015 1 K.GOWRI SHANKARI W/O.KUMARESAN AGED 26 YEARS ALL ARE RESIDING AT NAGANOOR VILLAGE SENGANOOR POST DHARMAPURI DISTRICT 2 KALAVATHY W/O.NARASHIMHA AGED 53 YEARS 3 K.LOGAPRIYAN S/O.KUMARESAN AGED 7 YEARS 4 K.NARASIMHA MOORTHY AGE 5 YRS (RESPONDENTS 3 AND 4 ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN 1ST RESPONDENT) ALL ARE RESIDING AT NAGNOOR VILLAGE SENGANOOR POST DHARMAPURI ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1309 of 2015 1 C.JAYA KARIMANGALAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT DHARMAPURI DISTRICT

2 K.MUNIAPPAN ..

3 G.KUPPUSAMY SANITARY WORKERS ALL ARE WORKING IN KARIMANGALAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT DHARMAPURI DISTRICT ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1310 of 2015 1 LOGU S/O.PARASAN PADAVATTAMMAN KOIL STREET TIRUPORUR KANCHEEPURAM DIST ...RESPONDENT in WA No.1311 of 2015 1 M.ANANDAN S/O.MUNIYANDI ECHANGKADU PARAPATTY ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 2 D.CHINNAPPA W/O.DURAISAMY OLD KALLUKADAI STREET KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 3 C.MAGHESWARI W/O. RAVICHANDRAN VADIVASAL OORANI KULATHUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 4 B.SITHIRAN S/O.BALAMUTHU PUSHPA NAGAR PULIYUR ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 5 C.SANTHIYAGU S/O.CHINNAPPAN PUSHPA NAGAR PULIYUR ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 6 V.KUZHANTHAIVELU S/O.VELLAIKANNU NO.339 ZHAGU NAGAR KULATHUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 7 P.MARIYAMMAL W/O.PERUMAL ECHANGKADU PARAPATTY ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 8 B.EDWARDRAJ S/O.BACKIYAM PUSHPA NAGAR PULIYUR ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT

9 A.ANTHONYAMMAL W/O.AROKIYAM KALLAR STREET KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 10 M.GANESAN S/O.MARIMUTHU AMBALAKARAR VEEDHI KALLAR STREET KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 11 R.KARUPPIAH S/O.RAMAN ODUKKUR POST KULATHUR TALUK PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 12 R.CHELLAMMAL W/O.RAJENDRAN ECHANGKADU PARAPATTY ROAD KEERANUR PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1312 of 2015 1 A.MURTHY S/O.ARDHANARI AMBEDKAR NAGAR PERUMKOUNDAMPATTI ELAMPILLAI TOWNSHIP ... RESPONDENT in WA No.1313 of 2015 1 C.ANAND (DIED) S/O.SINGARAYAN

1) K.RAMASAMY S/O.KOLLAPPAN KAPPIYARAI TN PANCHAYAT KAPPIYARAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

2 M.GNANADOSS S/O.MUTHAIYAN KAPPIYARAI TOWN PANCHAHAT KAPPIYARAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

3 T.RABI S/O.THANGAPPAN VAZHAVILAI KAPPIYARAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

4 T.JOSEPH STEPHEN S/O.THANGAPPAN VALIYAVITTU VILAGHAM BABY COTTAGE KAPPIYARAI POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

5 V.V.GIRISH KUMAR S/O.VIKRAMAN YAGAR BHADHMA VILLASAM KUZHIKODU POST KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

(Cause title amended vide order court dt.13.02.2015 made in M.P.No.1 of 2015) ... RESPONDENTS in WA No.1314 of 2015 1 K.MARICHAMY S/O.KARUPPAN MANUVAKADU KOOKALOOR ERODE DISTRICT.

2 M.DEVARAJ S/O.MARI JEYA PRAKASHI STREET KOOKALOOR ERODE DISTRICT.

... RESPONDENTS in WA No.1315 of 2015 1 P.M.RAJ, S/O.PALANISWAMY NO.70 PERUMAL KOVIL STREET PERIYOOR POST SATHYMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

2 P.SELVAN, S/O.PONGIYANNAN NO.200 NEHRU NAGAR RENGASAMUTHIRAM POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

3 P.SUBRAMANIAN S/O.PALANIYAPPAN NO.35 THIMAYYAN PUDUR RENGASAMUTHIRAM POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

4 G.SENTHIL KUMAR S/O.GOPALAN NO.4 AMBEDKAR STREET PERIYOOR POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

5 R.SUNDARARAJAN S/O.RAMASAMY NO.161 NEHRU NAGR RENGASAMUTHIRAM POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

6 M.RUKMANI D/O.MUTHUSAMY NO.68 NEHRU NAGAR RENGASAMUTHIRAM POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

7 R.RAMASAMY S/O.RENGA NAYAKKAR PERIYOOR POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

8 P.RENGASAMY S/O.PALANI NO.58/64 AZHAGIRI COLONY PERIYOOR POST SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

9 S.A.REYASATHULLAH S/O.AHAMADULLAH NO.154 NEHRU NAGAR SATHYAMANGALAM TALUK ERODE DISTRICT.

... RESPONDENT in WA No.1316 of 2015 Writ Appeals filed under Clause 15 of Letters Patent to set aside the order dated 25/6/2013 24.07.2013, 2.08.2013, 25.06.2013, 3.10.2013, 25.6.2013, 24.07.2013, 20.02.2014, 24.07.2013, 25.06.2013, 2.08.2013, 24.07.2013, 13.12.2012, 25.6.2013, and 25.06.2013 respectively.

and made in W.P.Nos.9403 of 2013, 18332 of 2013, 29457 of 2012, 12792 of 2013, 26403 of 2013, 31841 of 2012, 18356 of 2013, 34477 of 2013, 17127 of 2013, 6376 of 2013, 21341 of 2013, 17691 of 2013, 27350 of 2012, 29851 of 2012 and 9407 of 2013 respectively;

W.P.Nos.9403/13, 18332/13, 29457/12, 12792/13, 18356/15, 6376/13, 21341/13, 27350/12, 29851/12 & 9407/13:- Writ petitions praying issue a writ of Certiorarified Mandamus or order or direction, in the nature of writ, calling for the records relating to the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dt 27.7.2006 issued in Na. Ka. No. 3051/2006/A3 and the proceedings of the 3rd respondent dt 3.8.2006 2.08.2006, 7.08.2006, 26.07.2006, 2.08.2006, 31.7.2006, 31.07.2006, 31.7.2006, 7.08.2006 and 4.08.2006 respectively, issued in Na. Ka. No.117/2006/A1 288/06/A1, 96/06, 252/2006(A1), 136/2006, 36/2006, 215/1999, 92/A1/2006, 370/06 A and 386/2006/A1 respectively, and quash the same restricting the date of bringing the petitioners into time scale with effect from 23.6.2006 onwards alone and to issue consequential direction to the respondents to bring the petitioners into the regular time scale from the date on which they completed three years

consolidated pay services in the light of the Judgment of Division Bench dt 23.6.2010 passed in W.A. No. 385 of 2010 and 47 of 2010 with all consequential service and monetary benefits (W.A.Nos.1302, 1303, 1304, 1305, 1308, 1311, 1312, 1314, 1315, & 1316 of 2015) W.P.No.26403 of 2013: Writ Petition praying to issue a writ of certiorarified Mandamus or order or diretion, in the nature of writ, calling for the records relating to the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 25.7.2006 issued in Na.Ka.No. 3051/2006/A3 and the proceedings of the 3rd respondent dated 31.7.2006 issued in Na.Ka.No.36/2006 and quash the same restricting the date of bringing the Petitioners husband namely E.Mannangkatti into time scale with effect from 23.06.

2006 onwards alone and to issue consequential direction to the respondents to bring the Petitioners husband into the regular time scale from the date on which her husband completed three years consolidated pay services in the light of the Judgment of Division Bench dated 23.06.2010 passed in W.A.No.385 of 2010 & 47 of 2010 and consequentially to direct the respondents to pay all consequential benefits to the petitioners arising out of such retrospective regularization of the services of the deceased employee of the 3rd 3rd respondent as well as the husband of the 1st petitioner within the prescribed time limit (A.W.1306/2015) W.P.No.31841 of 2012: Writ petition praying to issue writ of certiorarified Mandamus or order or direction, in the nature of writ, calling for the records relating to the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dt 27.7.

2006 issued in Na. Ka. No. 3051/2006/A3 and the proceedings of the 3rd respondent dt 7.8.2006 issued in Na. Ka. No.53/2006 and quash the same restricting the date of bringing the petitioners husband namely M. Kuppusamy into time scale with effect from 23.6.2006 onwards alone and to issue consequential direction to the respondents to bring the petitioners husband into the regular time scale from the date on which her husband completed three years consolidated pay services in the light of G.O. M.S. No.199 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dt 26.10.1998 and 12.8.1997 and the G.O.M.S. No.84 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dated 26.10.1998 and 12.08.1997 and the G.O.M.S.No.84 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dated 21.05.1998 and the Judgment of Division Bench dated 23.06.

2010 passed in W.A.No.385 of 2010 & 47 of 2010 and consequentially to direct the respondents to pay all consequential benefits to the petitioners arising out of such retrospective regularization of the services of the deceased employee of the 3rd respondent as well as the husband of the 1st Petitioner namely M. Kuppusamy within the prescribed time limit (A.w.

WP.No.34477 of 2013:- Writ petitions praying writ of certiorarified Mandamus or order or direction, in the nautre of writ, calling for the records relating to the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 25.07.2006 issued in Na.Ka.No. 3051/2006/A3 and the proceedings of the 3rd respondent dated 25.7.2006 issued in Na.Ka.No. 263/2006 (A1) and quash the same restricting the date of bringing the Petitioners Husband namely N.Kumaresan into time scale with effect from 23.06.2006 onwards alone and to issue consequential direction to the respondents to bring the Petitioners husband into the regular time scale from the date on which her husband completed three years consolidated pay services in the light of the G.O. Ms. No.198 Municipal Administration and water supply Department dated 26.10.1998 and the G.O.MS.No.

84 Municipal Administration and Water supply Department dated 21.05.1998 and the Judgment of Division Bench dated 23.06.2010 passed in W.A.No.385 of 2010 & 47 of 2010 and consequentially to direct the respondents to pay all consequential benefits to the petitioners arising out of such retrospective regularization of the services of the deceased employee of the 3rd respondent as well as the husband of the 1st petitioner namely N. Kumaresan within the prescribed time limit (AW.1309/2015) W.P.No.17127 of 2013:- Writ petitions praying to issue a writ f certiorarified Mandamus or order or direction, in the nature of writ, calling for the records relating to the proceeding of the 3rd respondent dt 25.7.2006 issued in his Pro. Na. Ka. No.

382/2006/A1 and quash the same in so far as the petitioners are concerned and consequently extend the benefit of the G.O.Ms.No.570 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dt 15.11.2010 to the petitioners by bringing them into regular time scale of pay from the date of completion of the 3 years of service in the consolidated pay services i.e. (25.6.2001)in the light of G.O.Ms.No.199 Municipal Administration and Water supply Department dated 12.08.1997 and G.O.Ms.No.84 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dated 21.5.1998 and the orders of this Hon'ble High Court passed in W.P.No.25620/06 dated 17.9.2008 and the Judgment of Division Bench dated 23.06.2010 passed in W.A.No.47/2010 with all consequential service and monetary benefits (W.A.1310/2015) W.P.No.

17691 of 2013:- Writ petition praying to issue a writ of Mandamus directing the 4th respondent herein to grant the petitioner herein time scale of pay with effect from 16.5.2001 and pay the arrears of wages and all other attendant benefits (W.A.1313/2015).

For appellants in All the Appeals : Mr.V. Jayaprakash Narayanan Spl. Govt. Pleader For respondents in alla the Appeals : Mr. P.I. Thirumoorthy

J U D G M E N T

(Judgment of the Court was delivered by SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI,J.,) The instant appeals are filed by the State Government and the respective Town Panchayats against the orders passed separately by learned Single Judges, whereby and whereunder, the respondents therein were directed to regularise the service of the writ petitioners on completion of three years from the date when they were appointed on consolidated pay into regular time scale of pay and to pay consequential monetary benefits.

2. The aforesaid issue involved in these writ appeals came up for consideration in a batch of writ appeals filed by the Government in The Secretary to Government of Tamil Nadu, Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department and two others - Vs. - M. Rani1, which was partly allowed by a Division Bench of this Court, of which one of us was a Member (Satish K. Agnihotri, J.), vide common judgment dated 30th June 2015, observing as under:- "29 Resultantly, for the reasoning and analysis made hereinabove, the appeals are partly allowed to the extent that the respondents are entitled to consideration for grant of time scale on regular basis on the basis of performance assessment to be done on completion of three years and in the event, the performance of the respondents, is found satisfactory, they are entitled to regularisation on completion of three years, with all consequential monetary benefits. Costs made easy.

Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed."

1 W.A.No.1289 of 2014 etc. batch

3. In view of the foregoing, the instant writ appeals also stand partly allowed on the same terms. Costs made easy. Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed. Sd/- Assistant Registrar(CS III) //True Copy// Sub Assistant Registrar ra TO

1. THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND WATER SUPPLY DEPARTMENT FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF TOWN PANCHAYAT, KURALAGAM BUILDINGS, CHENNAI.108.

3. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KEELKULAM TOWNTOWN PANCHAYAT, KEELKULAM, KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

4. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICERS, VALVACHAGOSTAM TOWN PANCHAYAT VALVACHAGOSTAM NAGERCOIL DISTRICT 5 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KALIAKKAVILAI SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT KALIAKKAVILAI KANYAKUMARI DIST 6 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, VEDARAMPATTI COLONY & POST KAMBAI NALLUR FIRST GRADE TOWN PANCHAHAT KAMBAI NALLUR.

7 THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, TIRUPORUR TOWN PANCHAYAT, TIRUPORUR, KANCHEEPURAM DISTRICT.

8. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, VEERAKKAL PUDUR SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT, VEERAKKAL PUDUR, SALEM DISTIRCT.

9. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KULASEKARAN SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYET, KULASEKARAM, KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

10. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PERNNGARARM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYET, PENNGARAM, DHARMAPURI DISTRICT.

11. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KARIMENGALAM SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAYAT, DHARMAPURI DISTRICTD.

12. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, TIRUPURUR TOWN PANCHAHAT, TIRUPORUR, ERODE DISTRICT.

13. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, COMMISSIONER, KEERANUR SELECTION GRADE TOWN PANCHAHAT, KEERANUR, PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT.

14. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF TOWN PANCHAHAT, REGIONAL OFFICE, SALEM.

15. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ELAMPILLAI TOWN PANCHAHAT, SALEM.

16. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KAPPIYARAI TOWN PANCHAYAT, KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT.

17. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, KOOKALOOR TOWN PANCHAHAT, KOOKALOOR, ERODE DISTRICT.

18. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ARIYAPPAM PALAYAM TOWN PANCHAHAT, ARIYAPPAM PALAYAM, ERODE DISTRICT.

+ 7 ccs to Mr.P.I. Thirumoorthy, Advocate SR.48226 W.A. Nos. 1302 to PA(CO) EU 26.10.15