Dr.J.Shanti Swarup v. The Government Of Tamilnadu

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

( Civil Appellate Jurisdiction ) Wednesday, the Thirteenth day of September Two Thousand Seventeen PRESENT THE HON`BLE MR JUSTICE M. VENUGOPAL AND THE HON`BLE MR JUSTICE P.D.AUDIKESAVALU REV.APPL NO.122 OF 2017 IN WA.384 OF 2009 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU [ PETITIONER ] RE BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVT FINANCE (PAY CELL) DEPT FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI-09 2 THE STATE OF TAMILNADU REP BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVT PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPT FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI-09 Vs 1 K.SAHADEVAN [ RESPONDENT ] EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ELECTRIC DIVISION II PUBLIC WORKS DEPT CHEPAUK CHENNAI-5 2 G.MANI EMPOYED AS DRIVER IN MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION DEPT EZHILAGAM CHENNAI-5 3 R.KANNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TAX DEPT GREAMS ROAD CHENNAI-6 4 M.ELUMALAI EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TX DEPT GREAMS ROAD CHENNAI-6 5 S.P.RAJAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN HEAD INDUSTRIAL INSPECTORATE DEPT

6 R.VIJAYAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN AGRICULTURAL ENGIEERING DEPT NANDANAM CHENNAI-35 7 K.RAMAKRISHNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION DEPT EZHILAGAM CHENNAI-5 8 G.SELVARAJ EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TAX DEPT GREAMS ROAD CHENNAI-6 9 V.SUKUMARAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TAX DEPT GREAMS ROAD CHENNAI-6 10 A.ABDUL JAFAR EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TAX DEPT GREAMS ROAD CHENNAI-6 11 J.IYAPPAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN REVENUE DEPT KANYAKUMARI 12 K.NARAYANAPERUMAL EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN AGRICULTURAL DEPT NAGARCOIL 13 P.SWARNAPPAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN FOREST DEPT NAGARCOIL 14 C.A.J.CHANDRAMOHAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN REVENUE DEPT NAGARCOIL 15 K.SUKUMARAN NAIR EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN REVENEUE DEPT NAGARCOIL 16 S.KOCHUKUNJAN EMPLOYED ASDRIVER IN COMMERCIAL TAX DEPT KANYAKUMARI 17 Y.ANDERSON EMPLOYED AS DRIVER INCOMMERCIAL TAX DEPT KANYAKUMARI 18 S.MURUGAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT NAGERCOIL 19 S.VALLINAYAGAM

EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN PUBLIC WORKS DEPT NAGAERCOIL 20 M.DURAISAMY EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN SUPTD ENGINEER PWD WATER RESOURCE COIMBATORE 21 R.K.SUNDARA RAJAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST ENGINEER PWD COIMBATORE 22 R.MANICKAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER ASST ENGINEER PWD TIRUPURTALUK COIMBATORE 23 A.SAKTHIVEL EMPLOYED AS DRIVER ASST ENGINEER PWD WATERRESOURCE COIMBATORE 24 B.PALANISAMY EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST ENGINEER PWD IDAYAKOTTAI DINDIGUL DIST PALANI 25 S.SREEDHARAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASSTENGINEER PWD IDYAKOTTAI DINDIGUL DISTRICT PALANI 26 K.BALU EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST ENGINEER PWD COIMBATORE 27 M.MOHAMED ANWAR EMPLOYEDAS DRIVER IN GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE ODAPATTI THENI DIST 28 A.MANIMARAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE ODAPATTI THENI DIST 29 C.MANICKAVASAGAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE KUDALUR THENI DIT 30 SAHUL HAMEED EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN FOREST DEPT VARUSANADU SOIL SECURITY DIVISION THENI 31 P.KANNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT.PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, NAINAR PALAYAM, VILLUPURAM

32 P.SANTHANAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.DIRECTOR OF RURAL HEALTH WORKS, DIST. FAMILY WELFARE, DINDIGUL 33 V.MURUGESAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT. PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, AMMAIYANAYAKANUR, NILAKOTTAI TALUK, DINDIGUL DIST 34 R.MUNIYANDI EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT. PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, AMMAIYANAYAKANUR, NILAKOTTAI TALUK, DINDIGUL DIST.

35 M.GOPINATHAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT. PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, KANNIVADI, AUTHUR TALUK, DINDIGUL DIST.

36 V.RAJENDRAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. DIRECTOR OF RURAL HEALTH WORKS, DIST, FAMILY WELFARE, DINDIGUL 37 L.AMEER BATCHA EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.DIRECTOR OF RURAL HEALTH WORKS, DIST.FAMILY WELFARE, DINDIGUL 38 A,RADHAKRISHNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF LEPROSY, DINDIGUL 39 N.KAMATCHI EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, AMMAIYANAYAKANUR, NILAKOTTAI TALUK, DINDIGUL DIST.

40 A.ALPHONSE EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF GENERAL HEALTH AND PREVENTIVE MEDICINE, DINDIGUL 41 N.KARMEGAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF GENERAL HEALTH AND PREVENTIVE MEDICINE, DINDIGUL 42 A.WILLIAM

EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN , GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, AALAMARATHUPATTI, DINDIGUL 43 K.PALANISAMY EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, PERUMAL MALAI, DINDIGUL 44 M.MUTHURAMALINGAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT. HOSPITAL, NATHAM, DINDIGUL 45 S.BABU EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN O/O THE SENIOR ENTOMILOGIST, DINDIGUL 46 K.RAJU EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. ENGINEER OFFICER, HIGHWAYS DEPARTMENTS, TIRUNELVELI 47 J.JEYASELVAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN PANCHAYAT UNION, PALAYAMKOTTAI 48 P.RAMAKRISHNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN FOREST DEPARTMENT, N.

G.O.COLONY, TIRUNELVELI 49 B.KANDAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN JT. DIRECTOR AGRL.

DEPT., PALAYAMKOTTAI, TIRUNELVELI 50 S.THIRUMAL KUMAR EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.EXECUTIVE ENGINEER P.W.D., SANKARANKOIL, TIRUNELVELI 51 M.SAYEED ALI EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN , ASST. DIRECTOR , ANIMAL HUSBANDRY DEPT., THENKASI, TIRUNELVELI 52 C.MANIDASAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN DY. DIRECTOR, HEALTH DEPT., TIRUNELVELI 53 V.CHANDRASEKAR EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN REGIONAL TRANSPORT DEPT., TIRUNELVELI 54 A.JAMBU EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN CHIEF ENGINEER P.W.D., POLLACHI DIVISION, COIMBATORE

55 K.DAMODARAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. EXE.ENGINEER, P.

W.D.PARAMBIKULAM SUB DIVISION, COIMBATORE DIST.

56 K.KANDASAMY EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.EXE.ENGINEER, P.

W.D.BUILDING DEPT. COIMBATORE 57 N.THANGARAJ EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN GOVT. PRIMARY HEALTH CENTRE, KARADIMADAI THENKARAI, COIMBATORE-1 58 M.K.THAMBU EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. COMMR. OF CT, DR.BALASUNDARAM SALAI, COIMBATORE-18 59 N.JAYARAMAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. COMMR. OF CT., DR.BALASUNDARAM SALAI, COIMBATORE-18 60 K.BALAKRISHNAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.EXE.ENGINEER, P.

W.D.IRRIGATION SUB DIVISION-1, L.P.P.SUB DIVISION, KONAVAIKAL, ERODE-2 61 M.RAMACHANDRAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST. EXE. ENGINNER, P.W.D.BHAVANI SUB DIVISION, BHAVNAI COIMBATORE 62 S.VELLIANGRI EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN ASST.EXE.ENGINEER, P.

W.D.BHAVANI SUB DIVISION, ERODE-2 63 S.KESAVAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN DIST. ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER, VELLROE-4 64 D.RAGHUPATHY EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN P.W.D.CHEPAUK, CHENANI-5 65 N.NAGARATHINAM EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN P.W.D.CHEPAUK, CHENNAI-5 66 C.THIYAGARAJAN EMPLOYED AS DRIVER IN REHABILITATION DEPT.,

EZHILAGAM, CHENNAI-5 Review Petition U/S 114 and order 47 Rule 1 & 2 of Civil Procedure Code against the order of Hon'ble Division Bench consist THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ELIPE DHARMA RAO and THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.VENUGOPAL dated 01/09/2009 made in W.A.No.384 of 2009 and the order of His lordship THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.JYOTHIMANI dated 30/09/2008 and made in W.P.2865 of 2008 on the file of the Hon'ble Court of Judicature, Madras (in ) Order : This petition coming on for orders upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of MRS.J.SRI JAYANTHI, Special Government Pleader Advocate for the petitioner the court made the following order:- Mrs.J.

Sri Jayanthi, Learned Special Government Pleader undertakes to file a Working Sheet or Chart exhibiting how the Revised Pay Scales (Different Grades) relating to each individual Employee (Driver) is fixed in terms of G.O.Ms.No.162, Finance (Pay Cell) Department, dated 13.04.1998 on or before 12th October, 2017. In the meanwhile, the Learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the Government is directed to serve copies of the aforesaid Worksheet/Chart to the Learned Counsels appearing for the Petitioners/Respondents well in advance. Thereafter, the Registry is directed to list the matter.

-sd/- 13/09/2017 / TRUE COPY / Sub-Assistant Registrar ( Statistics / C.S. ) High Court, Madras - 600 104.

TO 1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, STATE OF TAMIL NADU, FINANCE (PAY CELL) DEPARTMENT, FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT STATE OF TAMIL NADU, PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT, FORT ST.

GEORGE CHENNAI 9

THE SPECIAL GOVERNMENT PLEADER, HIGH COURT, MADRAS.

C.C. to GOVERNMENT PLEADER Advocate on payment of necessary charges The Government Advocate, High Court, Madras - 104. Order in REV.APPL NO.122 OF 2017 IN WA.384 OF 2009 Date :13/09/2017 From 26.2.2001 the Registry is issuing certified copies of the Interim Orders in this format T.R (13/09/2017)