Tamil Nadu Brick Industries v. Te Tahsildar

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 28-04-2025

CORAM

THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE N. ANAND VENKATESH 1.Tamil Nadu Brick Industries Represented By Its Managing Partner Mr. Ramamurthy No.47, Mangali Nagar, First Street, Arumbakkam, Chennai 600106 Petitioner(s) Vs

1. The Tahsildar Maduravoyal Taluk, Chennai District.

2.The Revenue Divisional Officer Maduravoyal Taluk, Chennai Central Division, Anna Nagar West Extension Chennai - 600 040 3.Mr. K. Chellappan D2, Flat No. 0360, No.1, Chanakyan 4.Mr. R. Govindarajulu

S/o. G. Madhuvanesh Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

5.Mr. B.J. Ravi Kumar C2, Flat No. 0238, No.1, Chanakyan 6.Mr. Murugesan D1, Flat No. 0352, No.1, Chanakyan 7.Mr. S. Arunachalam D2, Flat No. 0063, No.1, Chanakyan 8.Mr. Ar Gunasampath Padmavathi Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

9.Mr. Ajox Frederick A2, Flat No. 0215, No.1, Chanakyan 10.Mr. M. Muthusamy

D2, Flat No. 0263, No.1, Chanakyan 11.Mr. D. Gowdhaman D2, Flat No. 0363, No.1, Chanakyan 12.Mr. Henry Mohandas A2, Flat No. 0215, No.1, Chanakyan 13.Mr. Sathiaseelan A2, Flat No. 0012, No.1, Chanakyan 14.Mr. Vikram Dhuru Malkani C2, Flat No. 0146, No.1, Chanakyan 15.Mr. Susai Arul Raj Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0019, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

16.Mr. Vasudevan Srinivasan

A1, Flat No. 0308, No.1, Chanakyan 17.Dr. M. Rajkumar D1, Flat No. 0352, No.1, Chanakyan 18.Mr. G. Madhuvanesh D1, Flat No. 0152, No.1, Chanakyan 19.Mr. Murugesan D2, Flat No. 163, No.1, Chanakyan 20.Mr. L.S. Marthandam C2, Flat No. 0237, No.1, Chanakyan 21.Mr. D.S. Prasad C1, Flat No. 0028, No.1, Chanakyan 22.Mr. Badharudeen N.M.

A1, Flat No. 002, No.1, Chanakyan 23.Mr. Adam Khan A2, Flat No. 0314, No.1, Chanakyan 24.Mr. P. Sreedhara Menon C2, Flat No. 0040, No.1, Chanakyan 25.Mr. M. Dhanasekar D2, Flat No. 0063, No.1, Chanakyan 26.Mr. Sundaresan K.

S/o. Karthik Murali. S Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

27.M.S.P. Thamburaj A1, Flat No. 0108, No.1, Chanakyan 28.Mr. Srinivasan G.V.

D2, Flat No. 0258, No.1, Chanakyan 29.Mr. Raja A1, Flat No. 0202, No.1, Chanakyan 30.Mr. Veerasamy A2, Flat No. 0014, No.1, Chanakyan 31.Mr. N. Alagappan C1, Flat No. 0131, No.1, Chanakyan 32.Mr. Durairaj D2, Flat No. 0166, No.1, Chanakyan 33.Mr. K.O. Ninan D2, Flat No. 0365, No.1, Chanakyan 34.Dr. Preetham M.V.

D2, Flat No. 0357, No.1, Chanakyan 35.Mr. Viswanathan Nair D1, Flat No. 0350, No.1, Chanakyan 36.Mr. A.Sriramulu D2, Flat No. 0161, No.1, Chanakyan 37.Mr. Sitaraman D1, Flat No. 0047, No.1, Chanakyan 38.Mr. Saravana Kumar Gajendran D1, Flat No. 0355, No.1, Chanakyan 39.Mr. Aravindan Sriramulu D2, Flat No. 0161, No.1, Chanakyan 40.Mr. Ganeshram Swaminathan

C2, Flat No. 0246, No.1, Chanakyan 41.Mr. D. Periyasamy A2, Flat No. 0210, No.1, Chanakyan 42.Mr. R. Ramanujam D2, Flat No. 0361, No.1, Chanakyan 43.Mr. Aravindraj Vt B2, Flat No. 0062, No.1, Chanakyan 44.Mr. Muthuswamy D1, Flat No. 0055, No.1, Chanakyan 45.Mr. Giridhar Jambunathan A2, Flat No. 0211, No.1, Chanakyan 46.Mr. Arun Karthik

D1, Flat No. 0055, No.1, Chanakyan 47.Mr. Kesavan K D1, Flat No. 0151, No.1, Chanakyan 48.Mr. Premanand S C2, Flat No. 0137, No.1, Chanakyan 49.Mr. M. Srinivasan A1, Flat No. 028, No.1, Chanakyan 50.Mr. Karukkuvel B1, Flat No. 0218, No.1, Chanakyan 51.Mr. Gurusamy V A1, Flat No. 0301, No.1, Chanakyan 52.Mr. Venkataramani

C1, Flat No. 0327, No.1, Chanakyan 53.Mr. Waryamsingh Chandhok S/o Amandeepsinghwaryamsingh Chandhok Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

54.Mr. Pochareddy Mohan Reddy D2, Flat No. 0160, No.1, Chanakyan 55.Mr. Thirumavalavan D2, Flat No. 0362, No.1, Chanakyan 56.Mr. Veerasamy Thirumavalavan A2, Flat No. 0014, No.1, Chanakyan 57.Mr. Parthasarathi. N.R.

D2, Flat No. 0058, No.1, Chanakyan

58.Mr. Sridhar Subramanian A2, Flat No. 0011, No.1, Chanakyan 59.Mr. S.P.S. Krishnan S/o. Karthik Krishnan Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

60.Mr. S.A. Hameed D1, Flat No. 0147, No.1, Chanakyan Nolambur, Chennai 600 095 61.Mr. Shanmugasundaram C2, Flat No. 0137, No.1, Chanakyan 62.Mr. R. Bhooramoorthy D1, Flat No. 0049, No.1, Chanakyan 63.Mr. Karthik Murali. S A1, Flat No. 0306, No.1, Chanakyan

64.Mr. Shaik Dawood Abdulla A2, Flat No. 0213, No.1, Chanakyan 65.Mr. Chandrasekhar Pillai C2, Flat No. 0039, No.1, Chanakyan 66.Mr. N.V. Gopal C1, Flat No. 0327, No.1, Chanakyan 67.Mr. R.S. Sathish C1, Flat No. 0030, No.1, Chanakyan 68.Mr. Kvs Ravi Prakash A2, Flat No. 0113, No.1, Chanakyan 69.Mr. Syed Mohamed Abdulla A2, Flat No. 0213, No.1, Chanakyan

70.Mr. Vedanthachari Ranganathan D1, Flat No. 0048, No.1, Chanakyan 71.Mr. Suresh Babu Abaranji C1, Flat No. 0133, No.1, Chanakyan 72.Mr. Govindarajan A2, Flat No. 214, No.1, Chanakyan 73.Mr. Janarthan S/o. B.J. Ravikumar Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

74.Mr. S. P. Ganesh D1, Flat No. 0047, No.1, Chanakyan 75.Mr. Krishna Murthy S/o. Sugumar Krishnamurthy Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan

76.Mr. Ayyamperumal D2, Flat No. 0358, No.1, Chanakyan 77.Mr. K. Muralidharan D2, Flat No. 0158, No.1, Chanakyan 78.Mr. C. Gopalakrishnan C2, Flat No. 0039, No.1, Chanakyan 79.Mr. H. Abdul Sathar D1, Flat No. 0147, No.1, Chanakyan 80.Mr. Anand Vishwanathan Nair D1, Flat No. 0350, No.1, Chanakyan 81.Mr. Subramanian Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0021, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

82.Mr. T.K. Parthasarathy A2, Flat No. 0214, No.1, Chanakyan 83.Mr. Pream Munaswamy Naidu A1, Flat No. 0106, No.1, Chanakyan 84.Mr. Anand Viswanathan Nair D1, Flat No. 0351, No.1, Chanakyan 85.Dr. Imran Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0322, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

86.Mr. Krishnamurthy D1, Flat No. 151, No.1, Chanakyan 87.Mr. Nagarajan Murugesan D2, Flat No. 0065, No.1, Chanakyan

88.Mr. M. Subramani A2, Flat No. 0209, No.1, Chanakyan 89.Mr. Nachiappan S/o. N. Alagappan Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

90.Mr. C. Unnikrishnan C1, Flat No. 0234, No.1, Chanakyan 91.Mr. Harish Kumar Gurusamy A1, Flat No. 0301, No.1, Chanakyan 92.Mr. Varadharaj D1, Flat No. 0349, No.1, Chanakyan 93.Mr. Gajendran D1, Flat No. 0355, No.1, Chanakyan

94.Mr. M.R. Krishnan D1, Flat No. 0054, No.1, Chanakyan 95.Mr. Sathappan Arunachalam A1, Flat No. 0001, No.1, Chanakyan 96.Mr. Radhakrishnan. N.G.

D2, Flat No. 0058, No.1, Chanakyan 97.Mr. M. Manamohan D2, Flat No. 0159, No.1, Chanakyan 98.Mr. Ayyamperumal D2, Flat No. 0359, No.1, Chanakyan 99.Mr. T. Surendra Reddy A1, Flat No. 0008, No.1, Chanakyan

100.Mr. Karthik Krishnan A2, Flat No. 0109, No.1, Chanakyan 101.Mr. Babu Reddy Pemma Reddy D2, Flat No. 0262, No.1, Chanakyan 102.Mr. Ganesapandian D2, Flat No. 0266, No.1, Chanakyan 103.Mr. Raja Srinivasan A1, Flat No. 028, No.1, Chanakyan 104.Mr. Jambunathan. A.

A1, Flat No. 0211, No.1, Chanakyan 105.Mr. Saravana Kumar Gajendran D1, Flat No. 0356, No.1, Chanakyan

106.Mr. Shovatranathoes C2, Flat No. 0141, No.1, Chanakyan 107.Mr. Selvaraj D2, Flat No. 0362, No.1, Chanakyan 108.Mr. V. Srinivasan C2, Flat No. 0242, No.1, Chanakyan 109.Mr. Srinivasan A1, Flat No. 0308, No.1, Chanakyan 110.Mr. Vijayendra Raj. N D2, Flat No. 0264, No.1, Chanakyan 111.Mr. Krishnamurthy A1, Flat No. 0206, No.1, Chanakyan

112.Mr. Thirumalai. G S/o. Karthikeyan G.T Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

113.Mr. Asaithambi Ramasami, C1, Flat No. 0136, No.1, Chanakyan 114.Mr. Adaikalasamy C2, Flat No. 0141, No.1, Chanakyan 115.Mr. Rajagopal A1, Flat No. 102, No.1, Chanakyan 116.Mr. Mahendran S.

C2, Flat No. 0346, No.1, Chanakyan 117.Mr. Murugesan D2, Flat No. 0065, No.1, Chanakyan

118.Mr. Ramesh Pocha Reddy D2, Flat No. 0160, No.1, Chanakyan 119.Mr. Dhuru P. Malkani C2, Flat No. 0146, No.1, Chanakyan 120.Mr. P.G. Dharmalingam D2, Flat No. 066, No.1, Chanakyan 121.Mr. Harish Sruti Sreedharan Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

122.Dr. S. Saravanan D2, Flat No. 0257, No.1, Chanakyan 123.Mr. Jayaraman. M C2, Flat No. 0143, No.1, Chanakyan

124.Mr. P. Koshy A1, Flat No. 0302, No.1, Chanakyan 125.Mr. Venkata Rao Mandru A2, Flat No. 0216, No.1, Chanakyan 126.Mr. P. Vijayakumaran D1, Flat No. 0256, No.1, Chanakyan 127.Mr. S. Manickam A1, Flat No. 0001, No.1, Chanakyan 128.Mr. B. Swaminathan C2, Flat No. 0246, No.1, Chanakyan 129.Mr. Manamohan C2, Flat No. 0345, No.1, Chanakyan

130.Mr. S. Sethuraman A2, Flat No. 0013, No.1, Chanakyan 131.Mr. P. Abaranji C1, Flat No. 0133, No.1, Chanakyan 132.Mr. N. Moorthy C2, Flat No. 0340, No.1, Chanakyan 133.Mr. G. Panneerselvam D2, Flat No. 0162, No.1, Chanakyan 134.Mr. Srinivasan . S D2, Flat No. 0165, No.1, Chanakyan 135.Mr. Peram Munaswamy Kamalakar Rao A1, Flat No. 0106, No.1, Chanakyan

136.Mr. Muthukrishnan. A.

A1, Flat No. 0003, No.1, Chanakyan 137.Mr. Ganesapandian A2, Flat No. 0015, No.1, Chanakyan 138.Mr. Manamohan D2, Flat No. 0159, No.1, Chanakyan 139.Mr. S. Nambi Narthandam C2, Flat No. 0237, No.1, Chanakyan 140.Mr. K.S. Mani C1, Flat No. 0129, No.1, Chanakyan 141.Mr. Saikannan Sethuraman Olga Tatiana Seeligman Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan

142.Mr. Kannan C1, Flat No. 0231, No.1, Chanakyan 143.Mr. Hariharan Raja A1, Flat No. 0202, No.1, Chanakyan 144.Mr. N. Achuthan D2, Flat No. 0158, No.1, Chanakyan 145.Mr. Venkataramanan Lakshminarayan D1, Flat No. 0049, No.1, Chanakyan 146.Mr. Damodharam Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0119, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

147.Mr. Asokan D2, Flat No. 0265, No.1, Chanakyan

148.Mr. Manamohan C2, Flat No. 345, No.1, Chanakyan 149.Mr. Rajesh Veerasekaran A1, Flat No. 0105, No.1, Chanakyan 150.Mr. Vishwanathan Nair D1, Flat No. 0351, No.1, Chanakyan 151.Dr. M. Rajkumar D1, Flat No. 0353, No.1, Chanakyan 152.Mr. Subramaniyan Mirunalini Subramaniyan Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan 153.Mr. Murugesan D1, Flat No. 0353, No.1, Chanakyan

154.Mr. Ramasubban C1, Flat No. 0030, No.1, Chanakyan 155.Mr. Gajendran D1, Flat No. 0356, No.1, Chanakyan 156.Mr. K. Sundaram S/o. S. Swaminathan Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

157.Mr. Srivatsan Ramanujam D2, Flat No. 0361, No.1, Chanakyan 158.Mr. Senthil Prasanna C2, Flat No. 0340, No.1, Chanakyan 159.Mr. Benoy Tharakan D2, Flat No. 064, No.1, Chanakyan

160.Mr. C. Chandran C1, Flat No. 0234, No.1, Chanakyan 161.Mr. V. R. Narendra Raj D2, Flat No. 0264, No.1, Chanakyan 162.Mr. Bakthavarudeen Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0322, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

163.Mr. Allursubbaraya Krishnamurthy Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, Block No. B, Flat No. 0024, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

164.Mr. K. Satyanarayana A2, Flat No. 0013, No.1, Chanakyan 165.Mr. Sadurdeen A1, Flat No. 0304, No.1, Chanakyan

166.Mr. Thiagarajan V.

S/o. Arvindaraj Vt. Aspiro, Brigade Xanadu, No.1, Chanakyan Main Road, Annamalai Avenue, Nolambur, Chennai 600 095.

167.Mr. K.M. Cherian A2, Flat No. 0316, No.1, Chanakyan 168.Mr. K. Veerasekaran A1, Flat No. 0105, No.1, Chanakyan 169.Mr. K. Sugumar D1, Flat No. 0148, No.1, Chanakyan 170.Mr. Veerappan C1, Flat No. 0333, No.1, Chanakyan Respondent(s) PRAYER Writ petition filed under Article 226 of Constitution of India for the issue of writ

of Mandamus directing the 1st Respondent to dispose of the Petition dated 19.09.2024 filed by the Petitioner, pending on the file of the 1st Respondent within a stipulated time fixed by this Court. For Petitioner(s):

Mr.V.Kuberan For Respondent(s):

Mr.A.Selvendran Special Government Pleader for R1 and R2

ORDER

This writ petition has been filed for the issue of writ of Mandamus directing the 1 st respondent to dispose of the petition dated 19.09.2024 wherein the petitioners have sought for recalling the patta that has been issued in the name of the individual flat owners by sub-dividing the property. 2.

Heard Mr.V.Kuberan, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.A.Selvendran, learned Special Government Pleader for respondents 1 and 2. 3.

Taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case and considering the materials placed before this Court, there shall be a direction to the 2 nd respondent to deal with the representation made by the petitioner dated 30.01.2025 on its own merits and in accordance with law, after affording opportunity to the private respondents and a decision shall be taken within a period of twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

4.

This writ petition is disposed of with the above directions. No costs.

28-04-2025 rka Index:Yes/No Speaking/Non-speaking order Internet:Yes

To 1.The Tahsildar Maduravoyal Taluk, Chennai District.

2.The Revenue Divisional Officer Maduravoyal Taluk Chennai Central Division, Anna Nagar West Extension, Chennai - 600 040

N.ANAND VENKATESH J.

rka 28-04-2025