The Special Tahsildar v. Krishnan
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
( Civil Appellate Jurisdiction ) Friday, the Thirty First day of July Two Thousand Twenty PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE R.MAHADEVAN C.M.P.Nos.7913, 7916, 7918, 7919, 7920, 7922, 7923, 7925, 7928, 7929, 7933, 7935 of 2020 in A.S.Nos.594 to 605 of 2020, C.M.P.Nos.7938 and 7942 of 2020 in A.S.Nos.607 and 608 of 2020, C.M.P.Nos.7945, 7964, 7967, 7965, 7966, 7969, 7968, 7970, 7972, 7971,7973, 7974, 7975, 7976, 7977, 7978, 7981, 7980, 7997, 7979, 7982, 7983, 7990, 7984, 7985, 7986, 7987, 7988, 7993, 7992, 7994, 7995, 7996, 7998, 7999, 8001, 8003, 8004, 8010, 8011, 8012, 8013, 8016, 8015, 8017, 8018, 8020, 8021, 8022, 8024, 8025, 8028, 8031 and 8036 of 2020 inA.S.Nos.610 to 663 of 2020 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR [ PETITIONER IN ALL THE PETITIONS] LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER TIRUPATTUR Vs KRISHNAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7913 OF 2020 IN AS NO.594 OF 2020 SARJAN RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7916 OF 2020 IN AS NO.595 OF 2020 CHITRA ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7918 OF 2020 IN AS NO.596 OF 2020 JAYARAMAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7919 OF 2020 IN AS NO.597 OF 2020 CHINAKRISHNAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7920 OF 2020 IN AS NO.598 OF 2020 MANICKAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7922 OF 2020 IN AS NO.599 OF 2020 PANJACHARAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7923 OF 2020 IN AS NO.600 OF 2020 THANGAMMAL ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7925 OF 2020 IN AS NO.601 OF 2020
RAMESH RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7928 OF 2020 IN AS NO.602 OF 2020 SARJAN RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7929 OF 2020 IN AS NO.603 OF 2020 NARANDRA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7933 OF 2020 IN AS NO.604 OF 2020 DEVASANABAI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7935 OF 2020 IN AS NO.605 OF 2020 VAJRAGOUNDER ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7938 OF 2020 IN AS NO.607 OF 2020 PREMABHAI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7942 OF 2020 IN AS NO.608 OF 2020 RAJA ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7945 OF 2020 IN AS NO.610 OF 2020 DURAISAMY ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7964 OF 2020 IN AS NO.611 OF 2020 SAKRAVARTHI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7967 OF 2020 IN AS NO.612 OF 2020 JANARTHANAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7965 OF 2020 IN AS NO.613 OF 2020 SELVARAJ ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7966 OF 2020 IN AS NO.614 OF 2020 NADESAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7969 OF 2020 IN AS NO.615 OF 2020 BOOPATHI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7968 OF 2020 IN AS NO.616 OF 2020 JAYAKODI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7970 OF 2020 IN AS NO.617 OF 2020 NIRANJANABAI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7972 OF 2020 IN AS NO.618 OF 2020 SARAVANAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7971 OF 2020 IN AS NO.619 OF 2020 VITTAL RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7973 OF 2020 IN AS NO.620 OF 2020 CHINNATHAMAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7974 OF 2020 IN AS NO.621 OF 2020
SRIDHAR ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7975 OF 2020 IN AS NO.622 OF 2020 INDRANI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7976 OF 2020 IN AS NO.623 OF 2020 SANTHU RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7977 OF 2020 IN AS NO.624 OF 2020 LOGANATHA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7978 OF 2020 IN AS NO.625 OF 2020 DEVENTHIRA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7981 OF 2020 IN AS NO.626 OF 2020 SRINEEVASAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7980 OF 2020 IN AS NO.627 OF 2020 NATESAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7997 OF 2020 IN AS NO.628 OF 2020 G.KALIYAPPAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7979 OF 2020 IN AS NO.629 OF 2020 MEERABAI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7982 OF 2020 IN AS NO.630 OF 2020 KARUNANITHI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7983 OF 2020 IN AS NO.631 OF 2020 VITAL RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7990 OF 2020 IN AS NO.632 OF 2020 LAKSHMI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7984 OF 2020 IN AS NO.633 OF 2020 ANANDHA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7985 OF 2020 IN AS NO.634 OF 2020 GOVARTHANA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7986 OF 2020 IN AS NO.635 OF 2020 SURENDIRA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7987 OF 2020 IN AS NO.636 OF 2020 KABURA GOUNDER ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7988 OF 2020 IN AS NO.637 OF 2020 DEVINDRA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7993 OF 2020 IN AS NO.638 OF 2020 MANJUNATH RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7992 OF 2020 IN AS NO.639 OF 2020
PURUSOTHAMA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7994 OF 2020 IN AS NO.640 OF 2020 GANESH RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7995 OF 2020 IN AS NO.641 OF 2020 VIJAYSANKAR ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7996 OF 2020 IN AS NO.642 OF 2020 NARENDIRA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7998 OF 2020 IN AS NO.643 OF 2020 CHINNARAJ GOUNDER ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.7999 OF 2020 IN AS NO.644 OF 2020 CHINNARAJ ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8001 OF 2020 IN AS NO.645 OF 2020 SAKARAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8003 OF 2020 IN AS NO.646 OF 2020 MALLIKA ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8004 OF 2020 IN AS NO.647 OF 2020 THUKKARAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8010 OF 2020 IN AS NO.648 OF 2020 PUDHUKALAN @ KABEERA GOUNDER ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8011 OF 2020 IN AS NO.649 OF 2020 VADIVEL ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8012 OF 2020 IN AS NO.650 OF 2020 GOVINDARAJ, ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8013 OF 2020 IN AS NO.651 OF 2020 NARISINGA RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8016 OF 2020 IN AS NO.652 OF 2020 KUDIANNAN ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8015 OF 2020 IN AS NO.653 OF 2020 ARUMUGAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8017 OF 2020 IN AS NO.654 OF 2020 GOVINDARAJ, ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8018 OF 2020 IN AS NO.655 OF 2020 SAROJABAI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8020 OF 2020 IN AS NO.656 OF 2020 RAMASAMY ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8021 OF 2020 IN AS NO.657 OF 2020
SHITHOGE RAO ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8022 OF 2020 IN AS NO.658 OF 2020 CHINNAMOGU ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8024 OF 2020 IN AS NO.659 OF 2020 RAJI ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8025 OF 2020 IN AS NO.660 OF 2020 EKAMBARAM ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8028 OF 2020 IN AS NO.661 OF 2020 MANJUNATH RAO, ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8031 OF 2020 IN AS NO.662 OF 2020 P.SELVARAJ ..
RESPONDENT IN CMP NO.8036 OF 2020 IN AS NO.663 OF 2020 Petition praying that in these circumstances stated therein and in the respective affidavits filed therewith the High Court will be pleased to 1 CMP No.7913 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.605 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 2 CMP No.7916 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.688 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 3 CMP No.7918 of 2020 NO.694/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 4 CMP No.7919 of 2020 NO.697/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal 5 CMP No.
7920 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.899 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 6 CMP No.7922 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No. 692/2013 dt.
7 CMP No.7923 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.620 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 8 CMP No.7925 of 2020 To stay the execution of the judgment and decree made in LAOP No. 569/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 9 CMP No.7928 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No. 759/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 10 CMP No.7929 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.575 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 11 CMP No.7933 of 2020 No.636/2013 dt. 12.10.2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore 12 CMP No.7935 of 2020 No.
762/2013 dt. 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore 13 CMP No.7938 of 2020 No.642/2013 dt. 12.10.2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore 14 CMP No.7942 of 2020 No.656/2013 dt. 12.10.2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore 15 CMP No.7945 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.693/2013 dt.12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
16 CMP No.7964 of 2020 No.735/2013 dt.26/11/2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 17 CMP No.7967 of 2020 No.618/2013 dated 12.10.2015 on the file of the Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
18 CMP No.7965 of 2020 No.710 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 19 CMP No.7966 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.565 of 2013 dated 12.10.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 20 CMP No.7969 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.711/2013 dt.12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
21 CMP No.7968 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.725 of 2013 dated 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 22 CMP No.7970 of 2020 No.838 of 2013 dated 12.10.2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
23 CMP No.7972 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.932 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 24 CMP No.7971 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.610 of 2013 dated 12-10-2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 25 CMP No.7973 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.824/2013 dt.12/10/2015 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
26 CMP No.7974 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No. 696/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 27 CMP No.7975 of 2020 No.634 of 2013 dated 12.10.2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
28 CMP No.7976 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.706 of 2013 dated 12-10-2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 29 CMP No.7977 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.551 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
30 CMP No.7978 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.763/2013 dt.26/11/2015 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
31 CMP No.7981 of 2020 NO.625/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 32 CMP No.7980 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.71 of 2014 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
33 CMP No.7997 of 2020 No.757/2013 dated 12.10.2015 on the file of the Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 34 CMP No.7979 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.755 of 2013 dated 26-11-2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 35 CMP No.7982 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.590 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 36 CMP No.7983 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.135 OF 2015 dated 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
37 CMP No.7990 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.793/2013 dt.17/02/2016 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
38 CMP No.7984 of 2020 No.563/2013 dt. 12/10/2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate 39 CMP No.7985 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.812 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 40 CMP No.7986 of 2020 No.770/2013 dt. 26/11/2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 41 CMP No.7987 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No.658 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 42 CMP No.7988 of 2020 No.613/2013 dt. 17/02/2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 43 CMP No.7993 of 2020 No.701/2013 dated 12.10.
2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of th above appeal. 44 CMP No.7992 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP o. 894/2013 dt.17/02/2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 45 CMP No.7994 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.785 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
46 CMP No.7995 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.609/2013 dt.17/02/2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
47 CMP No.7996 of 2020 No.638/2013 dt. 17/02/2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
48 CMP No.7998 of 2020 No.628 of 2013 dated 17-02-2016 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
49 CMP No.7999 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.573 of 2013 dated 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
50 CMP No.8001 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.791/2013 dt.17/02/2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
51 CMP No.8003 of 2020 No.897/2013 dated 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 52 CMP No.8004 of 2020 No.775 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate 53 CMP No.8010 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.699 of 2013 dated 12.10.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
54 CMP No.8011 of 2020 No.621 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate 55 CMP No.8012 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.890/2013 dt.26/11/2015 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
56 CMP No.8013 of 2020 No.840/2013 dated 26-11-2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 57 CMP No.8016 of 2020 No.806/2013 dated 26-11-2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
58 CMP No.8015 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.695 of 2013 dated 12.10.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
59 CMP No.8017 of 2020 No.646 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate 60 CMP No.8018 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and Decree made in LAOP NO.834/2013 dt.26/11/2015 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore.
61 CMP No.8020 of 2020 No.787 of 2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate 62 CMP No.8021 of 2020 No.137/2015 date 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 63 CMP No.8022 of 2020 No.814 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate 64 CMP No.8024 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP No. 761 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 65 CMP No.8025 of 2020 No.619 of 2013 dated 26-11-2015 on the file of the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal.
66 CMP No.8028 of 2020 To stay the execution of the judgment and decree made in LAOP No.674/2013 dated 17.02.2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellore and pending disposal of the above appeal. 67 CMP No.8031 of 2020 o.795/2013 dated 17-02-2016 before the Special Subordinate Court, Vellor and pending disposal of the above appeal.
68 CMP No.8036 of 2020 To stay the execution of the Judgment and decree made in LAOP.No.707 of 2013 dated 26.11.2015 before the Special Subordinate Judge, Vellore.
Order : This petition coming on for orders upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of MR.J.RAJAGOPAL, SPL.GOVT.PLEADER(AS), on behalf of the petitioner in all the petitions and of MS.S.S.MEENKAKUMAR, Advocate for the Respondents in each of the petitions, the court made the following order:-
ORDER
When these petitions were taken up, the learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the petitioner / appellant in these appeals, has submitted that the same subject matter had already been decided in similar appeals and hence these appeals may also be taken up for final disposal. Ms.S.S.Meenakumary, learned counsel, undertakes to file vakalat for the respondents. 2.Recording the above submissions, Registry is directed to list these appeals on 12.08.2020. Since date has been fixed for final hearing of the appeals, these Civil Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
-sd/- 31/07/2020 / TRUE COPY / Sub-Assistant Registrar ( Statistics / C.S. ) High Court, Madras - 600 104.
TO THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER TIRUPATTUR.
The Special Government Pleader[AS], High Court, Madras - 104. C.C. to MS.S.S.MEENAKUMARY, Advocate on payment of necessary charges Order in C.M.P.Nos.7913, 7916, 7918, 7919, 7920, 7922, 7923, 7925, 7928, 7929, 7933, 7935 of 2020 in A.S.Nos.594 to 605 of 2020, and C.M.P.Nos.7938 and 7942 of 2020 in A.S.Nos.607 and 608 of 2020, and C.M.P.Nos.7945, 7964, 7967, 7965, 7966,7969, 7968, 7970,7972, 7971, 7973,7974, 7975, 7976, 7977, 7978, 7981,7980, 7997, 7979, 7982, 7983, 7990, 7984, 7985, 7986, 7987, 7988, 7993, 7992, 7994, 7995, 7996, 7998, 7999, 8001, 8003, 8004, 8010, 8011, 8012, 8013, 8016, 8015, 8017, 8018, 8020,8021, 8022, 8024, 8025, 8028, 8031 and 8036 of 2020 in A.S.Nos.610 to 663 of 2020 Date :31/07/2020 From 26.2.2001 the Registry is issuing certified copies of the Interim Orders in this format RR 21/08/2020