D.Paranthaman v. The State Of Tamil Nadu
THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS Dated : 11.09.2023
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR W.P.No.18029 of 2022 and W.M.P.Nos.17357, 17359 & 17361 of 2022 1 D.PARANTHAMAN 2 R.PANDI 3 J.SAMPATH 4 M.SUDHAKAR 5 D.MOHANA SUNDARAM 6 R. REVATHI 7 N.THILAGAVATHI 8 S.P.CHITRA 9 V.SHANTHI 10 S. REVATHI SUBASHINI 11 P.RAJESH 12 P. SHANTHI 13 K.VANITHA 14 P. VELANGANNI 15 G MANIGANDAN 16 T.VIKRAM 17 M. VASHANTHI 18 S SWEETY 19 M.THANGADURAI 20 M.MARIPANDI MANIKANDAN 21 S.AHILANDESWARI 22 K.R.RAJAKUMARI 23 N.BHARATHI 24 T.SAVITHA 25 T. PREMALATHA 26 S.SADHAN DHEV 27 R.SAKTHIVEL 28 D.LINGA KUMAR Page 1 / 13
29 V. SHANKAR 30 S.PRABHU 31 R. MOHANA 32 C. REVATHY 33 V. ANITHA 34 P.SONIA 35 O.LALITHA 36 P.MYVIZHI 37 D.VASUDEVAN 38 S.A.BUVANESSHWARI 39 R.AMBIKA 40 R. TAMIZHARASI 41 B.VASANTHI 42 R.VASANTHAKUMARI 43 T.MANJULA 44 K.VELMURUGAN 45 G. PARGUNAN 46 M.MUTHAPPAN 47 P.KAVITHA, 48 V.PANNEERSELVAM 49 K.KOHLA 50 C. KALAVATHI 51 B.GOKULAPRIYA 52 M.JAYAPAL 53 P. PRIYA GANDHI 54 M.SUDHAKAR 55 M.DEEPANCHAKKRAVARTHY 56 M.THIRUMAL 57 V.NANDHINI, 58 C.CLAMENT CHRISTANSON 59 A.SENTAMIL ELAKKIA 60 S. DINESH KUMAR 61 M.SURESHKUMAR 62 S.ACHUDHA 63 R. SASIKUMAR 64 N.KASTHURI RACHEL, 65 D.CHITRA 66 B. NITHYADEVI 67 R.GURUVALAKSHMI Page 2 / 13
68 A.KOWSALYA 69 M.THIRUMAL, 70 A.THIYAGU 71 S.DHAARANI 72 A.SITHARA 73 S.ALOSIA VIMALA MARY, 74 M.ANGELINE PRIYALATHA 75 P.RAJALAKSHMI 76 K KALIDAS 77 G.ELUMALAI, 78 M.VARALAKSHMI 79 M.PRIYANKA 80 S.SUNDARAVADIVEL 81 K.RAMAR 82 A.AJITHKUMAR, 83 S. ANTONY DOMINIC CHRISTOPHER 84 P.ILAMURUGAN, 85 R.KAVITHA 86 C.MOHANALAKSHMI 87 P.ARJUNAN 88 A.KOHILA 89 K.ASHOK KUMAR 90 S.PREMA 91 P.TAMILSELVI, 92 C.THIRUGNANAMOORTHI 93 J.JEYAMANI 94 S.RAMKUMAR 95 G.GNANASEVIYAR 96 K.GAWASKAR 97 E.BABU 98 S.VANNIMUTHU 99 V.ARULSELVI 100 D.RAJPAL 101 P. VASANTHAKUMARI 102 S.VIJAYALAKSHMI, 103 M.SUMATHI AGED 104 S. PARIMALA 105 V.RAJAVELU, 106 A.CHINNADURAI Page 3 / 13
107 P. ARULSELVI, 108 J. LALITHA, 109 S.NAGARAJAN, 110 L.PACKIYALAKSHMI 111 . S.RAJAMANI, 112 V.PREMAKUMARI, 113 R.DEEPA 114 SANTHANALAKSHMI, 115 . L.KAVITHA, 116 S. BABY, 117 S.RAJIVGANDHI, 118 T.CHELLADURAI 119 K.KUMAR, 120 D.MAHESWARI 121 R.VIJAYARANGAN, 122 RAVIKUMAR, 123 N.KANNAN, 124 A.MANIMOZHI 125 V.SHANMUGARAJU, 126 K. PRAKASAM 127 P.KARTHIKEYAN, 128 N.VASUDEVAN, 129 R.AYYAPPAN 130 K.PANDISELVI, 131 P. PRABHU, 132 M.NAGOOR MEERA, 133 R.CHITRA, 134 V.PUSHPALATHA, 135 R.SATHISH, 136 S.MUTHURAJ, 137 K.PANDISELVI, 138 S.SAVURI 139 P.KRISHNAVENI 140 N. SENTHILKUMAR 141 M.UMASELVI 142 S.NAVANEETHA RAJA 143 R.SARALADEVI 144 D.VIMALA, 145 K GUNASEKARAN Page 4 / 13
146 R.GOVINDAMMAL 147 A.VANITHA 148 A.MURUGALAKSHMI 149 P.LOGESHWARI, 150 P.HEMALATHA 151 R.VADIVEL 152 S.ELAMATHY 153 P. KAVITHA 154 K.VEDIYAPPAN 155 N.PRIYA 156 M.NIRMALA 157 K.PERIYA KARUPPAN 158 R. VIMAL 159 T.RAJESWARI, 160 K.VASANTHA, 161 D.ANANDHI 162 P.SAVITHIRI 163 D.VIDHYA, 164 K.VANITHA, 165 V.SANGEETHA DEVI 166 G.BACKIYALAKSHMI, 167 M. VASANTHI, 168 J.EZHIL, 169 A. VENKATESAN, 170 R.BHARATHI 171 A.THIRUMURUGAN 172 S.BHUVANESHWARI, 173 P.PITCHAIYAMMAL DEVI 174 R.HARIGARAN, 175 P.VIMALA 176 M.KAMARNABISHA, 177 S.MYNOORTHEEN 178 M.VEDHA 179 R.SUBAYADAV 180 N.DHANALAKSHMI 181 S. NITHYA 182 S.LATHA SHREE, 183 V.THANGAMANI 184 P.ASVINI Page 5 / 13
185 U.SUGANYA DEVI, 186 V.K.MANIMARAN 187 P.DEEPAN 188 K.SAVITHA 189 N.T.DEEPA 190 P.SRINIVASAN, 191 K.KALAIYARASI 192 S SIVAPRAKASH 193 SAKUNTHALADEVI , 194 D.RUBELLA, 195 P.KARTHIKA, 196 N. SARANYA, 197 V .KARTHIK, 198 K PALANI, 199 M.UDAYAKUMAR 200 S.K.VASANTHA KUMAR 201 S.SANJEEVI 202 N.NIRMALKUMAR, 203 A.REVATHI 204 M.ANBARASAN 205 P.SATHISHKUMAR 206 C.GEETHA 207 K.PALANI 208 V.INDHUMATHI 209 R.KAVITHA 210 K.S.SANGEETHA 211 M.MUGESHKUMAR 212 G.USHA 213 G.CHITRA 214 V.JAMUNARANI 215 R.DHIWAKAR, 216 M. KANIMOZHI 217 A.POOBALAN 218 S.SATHYA 219 S.RAJESH, 220 A.MANJULA, 221 K.PUNITHA 222 M.SUBBULAKSHMI 223 D.SENTHIL Page 6 / 13
224 N.AMBIGA, 225 N.SAMBAMOORTHI 226 P.SARANYA, 227 S.NATARAJAN 228 J.PRAVEEN KUMAR 229 G MARI, 230 R.JAYAPRIYA 231 M PALANICHAMY, 232 M.VIJAYAPRABHAKAR 233 P.SUGUNA 234 L.CHANDRA 235 V.NANDHINI 236 B.MANJULA, 237 S. ANANDHA MURUGAN 238 A AROKKIYA SELVARAJ 239 T.KIRUBA 240 M.SUDHAKAR 241 V. ELUMALAI 242 M.GRACY 243 P.VASANTHI 244 G.MAYAKRISHNAN, 245 M.R.SUHITHA 246 D.JAYAPRAKASH 247 M.MOHAMMAD SHAKUL 248 B.ANANDHI, 249 S.RADHA 250 C.AMBIKA 251 R.RAJASEKAR, 252 P.SUBRAMANI, 253 M.SELVARAJ, 254 R.NAGALAKSHMI 255 S.SARANYA 256 F.GEORGE ANAND 257 N.BABU 258 S.SATHISHKUMAR 259 R.SHANMUGAM 260 S.PRIYA 261 R.PANEERSELVAM 262 P.T. SUVARNA KUMAR Page 7 / 13
263 V.YASOTHA 264 J.SAMPATH, 265 K.MURUGAVEL 266 S.K.VIVETHA 267 N.SAKTHINATHAN 268 B.ANEEBA 269 B.SENTHILKUMAR 270 K MANIKANDAN 271 S.SATHISKANNAN 272 S KANNIYAPPAN 273 D.SELVARANI, 274 G.ANGURAJ 275 M NITHYA 276 D.KAVITHA 277 R JAYALAKSHMI, 278 R.AYYAPPAN, 279 S.SAKKANAN 280 M.PRAKASH 281 S.DHARANI 282 R.TAMILARASAN 283 T.BALASUBRAMANIYAM, 284 R.ELAVARASAN 285 S.SANTHI, 286 P.ANBU 287 C.SENTHIL KUMAR 288 K.GOPALAKRISHNAN 289 K.N.ABIRAMI 290 V.SHANKAR 291 N.BHARATHI, 292 C. PONNUSAMY 293 R.VELAYUTHAM 294 V.HEMALATHA 295 K.SELVAM 296 P.MANIMEKALAI 297 K.L KEERTHANA 298 A BALAMURUGAN, 299 P.L.MEENAKSHI 300 K.PRABU 301 S.KUMARAVEL Page 8 / 13
302 G MUTHUSAMY 303 S ARIVAZHAGAN 304 V.KUMAR 305 M.VIJAYARAGAVAN 306 A JAYASHRI 307 P.SIVARANJINI 308 A.SUGUMAR 309 R. VIDYA 310 M.KASIRAJAN 311 K VENKATESAN 312 D. ARCHANA 313 A POORNIMA 314 N KAVITHA 315 D.NIRMALA 316 R.DHANASEKARI 317 T.RAMACHANDRAN 318 V.DURGADEVI 319 K.NIRMALA 320 V.HARIHARASUTHAN 321 M.KASIRAJAN 322 S.NITHYAPRIYA 323 S.PARAMASIVAN 324 A.JOTHI 325 R.RAJADURAI, 326 L.KAYAMBOOMENI 327 M.NITHYA 328 V.NITHYA 329 S.VEERAPANDIYAN 330 R MANIKUMARI 331 S.HEMALATHA ... Petitioners vs.
1. The State of Tamil Nadu Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government, School Education Department, Fort St.George, Chennai 600 009.
2. The Commissioner of School Education - cumPage 9 / 13
Director of Elementary Education Directorate of School Education, DPI Complex, College Road, Chennai 600 006
3. Teachers Recruitment Board Rep. by its Chairman, EVK Sampath Maaligai, DPI Campus, College Road, Chennai - 600 006 ... Respondents Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Section 226 of the Constitution of India to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus or any other writ, order or direction, calling for the records relating to the proceedings dated 23.06.2023 having Ref.No. Na.Ka.No.34087/C2/E2/2022 issued by the 2nd Respondent and quash the same as without jurisdiction and arbitrary and consequently issue a direction to the 2nd Respondent to appoint the Petitioners in the 3188 vacancies on a regular basis who are already in the list of candidates who have written the Post Graduate Teachers Recruitment Board Exam and completed certificate verification pursuant to Notification No.10/2019, dated 12.06.2019.
For Petitioners : Mrs. Nalini Chidambaram Senior Counsel.
For Respondents : Mr.T. Chezhiyan Addl. Government Pleader [for R1 & R2] Mr. R. Neelakandan Additional Advocate General Assisted by Mr.C.Kathiravan [for R3]
O R D E R
When the matter is taken up for hearing today, the learned counsel Page 10 / 13
appearing for the Petitioners seeks permission of the Court to withdraw the Writ Petition as the same has become infructuous. She has also made an endorsement to that effect.
2. Recording the above submission and also the endorsement made by the learned counsel for the petitioners, the Writ Petition is dismissed as infructuous. No costs. Consequently, connected W.M.Ps.are closed. 21.09.2023 (2/2) Index : Yes/No ggs copy to:
1. The Principal Secretary to Government, School Education Department, Fort St.George, Chennai 600 009.
2. The Commissioner of School Education - cum- Director of Elementary Education, Directorate of School Education, DPI Complex, College Road, Chennai 600 006.
Page 11 / 13
3. Teachers Recruitment Board Rep. by its Chairman, EVK Sampath Maaligai, DPI Campus, College Road, Chennai - 600 006. N. SATHISH KUMAR, J.
ggs Page 12 / 13
W.P.No.18029 of 2022 and W.M.P.Nos.17357, 17359 & 17361 of 2022 11.09.2023 Page 13 / 13