Upendra Gupta v. Sudhir V.Joshi
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
( Civil Appellate Jurisdiction ) Wednesday, the Twenty Second day of December Two Thousand Twenty One PRESENT THE HON`BLE MR.JUSTICE N.SESHASAYEE C.M.P.Nos.20621 & 20624 of 2021 in A.S.No.1137 of 1995 UPENDRA GUPTA [ PETITIONER IN CMP.No.20621 of 2021] N.RAJENDRAN [ PETITIONER IN CMP.No.20624 of 2021] Vs 1 SUDHIR V.JOSHI [ RESPONDENTS IN CMP.No.20621 of 2021 ] S/O.V.J.JOSHI, REP. BY POWER OF ATTORNEY AGENT PRITAM LALCHAND MAHTANI, 13, THAMBUCHETTY STREET, CHENNAI-600 001 R.N.SURYANARAYANA IYER, (DECEASED) NAME DELETED VIDE ORDER DATED 31.08.2005 IN CMP.No.3754 & 9654 of 2005 2 S.NAGAMMAL 3 R.S.RAMAKRISHNAN R2, R3 ADDED AS PARTY RESPONDENTS AND THE RANK OF EXISTING RESPONDENTS ALTERED AS 3 TO 59 VIDE ORDER DATED 31.08.2015 IN CMP.No.3754 & 9654/2005 4 V.VARADHAN 5 R.BALAKRISHNAN 6 INDIAN BANK, NO.17, NORTH BEACH ROAD, CHENNAI-600 001 7 K.S.GOVINDASWAMY 8 P.V.SOUNDARI AMMAL
9 S.CHANDRAVADANA 10 S.MANI 11 E.KANNIAPPAN 12 R.ARJUN NADAR 13 P.SUSHEELA 14 P.MANICKAM 15 P.BHAVANI 16 A.N.GOVINDAN 17 K.MURTHI 18 K.VEERASWAMY 19 A.VALLABHADAS 20 S.NAGARATHINAMMAL 21 K.RADHA 22 R.RAJASANTHANAM 23 P.SAKTHIVEL 24 M.SANKARALINGAM 25 K.RAMACHANDRAN 26 S.DEVLATH BEEVI 27 R.RAJKUMAR 28 SHALINI GUPTA 29 S.DEVIKA 30 VENKATRAMAN 31 ARPUTHARAJ MARIAL (DECEASED) 32 G.KRISHNAVENIAMMAL 33 M.SHANMUGASUNDARAM 34 K.JOTHIBAI
35 S.SAMBANDAN 36 A.SAROJA 37 G.SANDHALINGAM 38 SEETHARAMAN 39 HARMINA MIRANDI 40 R.RAMAMURTHI 41 P.SAKUNTHALA 42 R.JEYAKODI 43 C.MUTHURAMALINGAM 44 N.RAJENDRAN 45 S.RANGANAYAKI 46 R.RAGHU 47 IKRAMULLA 48 S.KANAKA 49 S.VEDAPURI 50 R.KASTURI RAJALAKSHMI 51 S.PADMAVATHI AMMAL 52 M.BHARGAVI AMMAL (DECEASED) 53 S.SOMASUNDARAM 54 KOTTEESWARAN 55 VARUVEL 56 N.GOPINATH 57 G.LAKSHMANASWAMY 58 R.GOPINATHAN 59 N.MURUGESAN 60 JOSEPHINE ARPUTHARAJ
61 MARIA CAROLINE 62 PRIYANKA CHRISTINA 63 ANTONIAMMAL RR 60 TO 63 BROUGHT ON RECORD AS LRS DECEASED R 31 VIDE ORDER DATED 09.01.2012 MADE IN CMP.Nos.248 TO 250/2011 IN AS.No.1137 OF 1995 64 MALIKA BEGUM 65 T.THANGAIAH 66 E.EMPERUMAN 67 GOVINDAMMAL@ RAMA THILAGAM 68 RADHARAMU 69 K.GOWRIBAI 70 G.SEKAR 71 P.KAMALA 72 P.HARESH 73 BALAN 74 SOUTH INDIA ASSEMBILES OF GOD REP. BY REVERENT I. CHRISTHUDOSS, THE REGIONAL OVERSEER, NORTH CENTRAL REGION AND SENIOR PASTOR, HOPE A.G. CHURCH, NO.1, DEVI KARUMARIAMMAN NAGAR, PALLIKARANAI, CHENNAI 600100 75 T.CHRITHUDOSS RR 64 TO 75 IMPLEADED AS PARTY, RESPONDENT VIDE ORDER OF COURT DT.
23/02/2007 BY RSMJ MADE CMP.Nos.2315 TO 2322, 2337, 3030 & 3022/2017 IN AS No.1137/1995.
76 HEMALATHA 77 PREMALATHA RR 76 & 77 BROUGHT ON RECORD AS LRS OF THE DECEASED 52 RESPONDENT VIDE COURT ORDER DATED 22.06.2017 BY NKKJ CMP.No.3551/2017.
78 DILDAR JAHAN RR 78 RESPONDENT IMPLEADED AS PARTY VIDE ORDER OF COURT DATED 22/06/2017 BY NKKJ IN CMP.NO.4980/2017.
1 SUDHIR V.JOSHI [ RESPONDENTS IN CMP.No.20624 of 2021 ] S/O.V.J.JOSHI, REP. BY POWER OF ATTORNEY AGENT PRITAM LALCHAND MAHTANI, 13, THAMBUCHETTY STREET, CHENNAI-600 001 R.N.SURYANARAYANA IYER, (DECEASED) NAME DELETED VIDE ORDER DATED 31.08.2005 IN CMP.No.3754 & 9654 of 2005 2 S.NAGAMMAL 3 R.S.RAMAKRISHNAN R2, R3 ADDED AS PARTY RESPONDENTS AND THE RANK OF EXISTING RESPONDENTS ALTERED AS 3 TO 59 VIDE ORDER DATED 31.08.2015 IN CMP.No.3754 & 9654/2005 4 V.VARADHAN 5 R.BALAKRISHNAN 6 INDIAN BANK, NO.17, NORTH BEACH ROAD, CHENNAI-600 001 7 K.S.GOVINDASWAMY 8 P.V.SOUNDARI AMMAL 9 S.CHANDRAVADANA 10 S.MANI 11 E.KANNIAPPAN 12 R.ARJUN NADAR 13 P.SUSHEELA 14 P.MANICKAM 15 P.BHAVANI 16 A.N.GOVINDAN
17 K.MURTHI 18 K.VEERASWAMY 19 A.VALLABHADAS 20 S.NAGARATHINAMMAL 21 UPENDRA GUPTA 22 K.RADHA 23 R.RAJASANTHANAM 24 P.SAKTHIVEL 25 M.SANKARALINGAM 26 K.RAMACHANDRAN 27 S.DEVLATH BEEVI 28 R.RAJKUMAR 29 SHALINI GUPTA 30 S.DEVIKA 31 VENKATRAMAN 32 ARPUTHARAJ MARIAL (DECEASED) 33 G.KRISHNAVENIAMMAL 34 M.SHANMUGASUNDARAM 35 K.JOTHIBAI 36 S.SAMBANDAN 37 A.SAROJA 38 G.SANDHALINGAM 39 SEETHARAMAN 40 HARMINA MIRANDI 41 R.RAMAMURTHI 42 P.SAKUNTHALA 43 R.JEYAKODI
44 C.MUTHURAMALINGAM 45 S.RANGANAYAKI 46 R.RAGHU 47 IKRAMULLA 48 S.KANAKA 49 S.VEDAPURI 50 R.KASTURI RAJALAKSHMI 51 S.PADMAVATHI AMMAL 52 M.BHARGAVI AMMAL (DECEASED) 53 S.SOMASUNDARAM 54 KOTTEESWARAN 55 VARUVEL 56 N.GOPINATH 57 G.LAKSHMANASWAMY 58 R.GOPINATHAN 59 N.MURUGESAN 60 JOSEPHINE ARPUTHARAJ 61 MARIA CAROLINE 62 PRIYANKA CHRISTINA 63 ANTONIAMMAL RR 60 TO 63 BROUGHT ON RECORD AS LRS DECEASED R 31 VIDE ORDER DATED 09.01.2012 MADE IN CMP.Nos.248 TO 250/2011 IN AS.No.1137 OF 1995 64 MALIKA BEGUM 65 T.THANGAIAH 66 E.EMPERUMAN 67 GOVINDAMMAL@ RAMA THILAGAM 68 RADHARAMU
69 K.GOWRIBAI 70 G.SEKAR 71 P.KAMALA 72 P.HARESH 73 BALAN 74 SOUTH INDIA ASSEMBILES OF GOD REP. BY REVERENT I. CHRISTHUDOSS, THE REGIONAL OVERSEER, NORTH CENTRAL REGION AND SENIOR PASTOR, HOPE A.G. CHURCH, NO.1, DEVI KARUMARIAMMAN NAGAR, PALLIKARANAI, CHENNAI 600100 75 T.CHRITHUDOSS RR 64 TO 75 IMPLEADED AS PARTY, RESPONDENT VIDE ORDER OF COURT DT.
23/02/2007 BY RSMJ MADE CMP.Nos.2315 TO 2322, 2337, 3030 & 3022/2017 IN AS No.1137/1995.
76 HEMALATHA 77 PREMALATHA RR 76 & 77 BROUGHT ON RECORD AS LRS OF THE DECEASED 52 RESPONDENT VIDE COURT ORDER DATED 22.06.2017 BY NKKJ CMP.No.3551/2017.
78 DILDAR JAHAN RR 78 RESPONDENT IMPLEADED AS PARTY VIDE ORDER OF COURT DATED 22/06/2017 BY NKKJ IN CMP.NO.4980/2017.
Petition praying that in the circumstances stated therein and in the affidavit filed therewith the High Court will be pleased to record the compromise memo entered the Petitioner/ 20th respondent and the respondent/ appellant and pass order in A.S.No.1137 of 1995 and thus render justice [in CMP.No.20621 of 2021 ]; 2.To record the Memo of Compromise entered the Petitioner/ 44th respondent and the respondent/appellant in A.S.No.1137 of 1995 and thus render justice [in CMP.No.20624 of 2021 ]
Order : These petitions coming on this day for hearing upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of MR.M.KAMALANATHAN, Advocate for the petitioner in both the petitions and of MR.K.V.ANANTHAKRISHNAN, Advocate for the 1 to 4 Respondents in both the petitions, the court made the following order:- This matter has been reserved for orders and this Court was alerted that given the nature of the case and the complexities involved, rather than going for an adjudicatory option, settlement would be a better option. This Court has accordingly waited and this Court is now informed there is a settlement happening between both sides. As part of that process, earlier there was another matter settled in C.M.P. No. 2680 of 2016. Today, two more respondents have come forward to compromise the matter. 2.
This Court is satisfied with the legality of compromise made and the compromise is accordingly recorded. 3.
Registry is directed to return Ex.P26 and Ex.P40 to the respective petitioners herein. Registry is further directed to return Ex.A38 to the petitioner in C.M.P. No. 2680 of 2016. -sd/- 22/12/2021 / TRUE COPY / Sub-Assistant Registrar ( Statistics / C.S. ) High Court, Madras - 600 104.
TO THE XII ASSISTANT JUDGE, CITY CIVIL COURT, MADRAS COPY TO THE SECTION OFFICER, VR SECTION, HIGH COURT, MADRAS Order in C.M.P.Nos.20621 & 20624 of 2021 in A.S.No.1137 of 1995 Date :22/12/2021 From 26.2.2001 the Registry is issuing certified copies of the Interim Orders in this format RA 07/01/2022