Mr.P.Subba Reddy v. Mr.S.D.Saravanan
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 18.03.2016
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, CHIEF JUSTICE and THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.M.SUNDRESH O.S.A.Nos.51 to 62; 70 to 84 and 85 to 87 of 2016 and CMP.Nos.4525 to 4535; 5104 to 5114; 5164 to 5170 of 2016 MR.P.SUBBA REDDY ...Appellant in OSA Nos.51,52,53,54,55, 56,57,58,59,60,61,62 of 2016 A.GANESAN ...Appellant in OSA Nos.70,71,72,73,74, 75,76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83,84 of 2016
1. UDAYARANI PLOT NO 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANAGARAI CHENNAI 600 041.
2. SIVARAMAKRISHNAN PLOT NO 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANAGARAI CHENNAI 600 041.
...Appellants in OSA Nos.85,86,87 of 2016 Vs.
1.MR.S.D.SARAVANAN S/O. MR. DHANDAPANI BOTH RES AT GROUND FLOOR NO.30/2 GOPALA KRISHNA ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI-17.
2.MRS.G.LAKSHMI W/O.MR.S.D.SARAVANAN.
3.MR.A.GANESAN NO.13 MELONY ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI-17.
...Respondents 1 to 3 in
OSA.51 to 57 of 2016 THE ASST. GENERAL MANAGER STATE BANK OF INDIA OVERSEAS BRANCH MID-CORPORATE GROUP NO. 86 RAJAJI SALAI CHENNAI -1 ...4th Respondent in OSA.51 of 2016
THE COMMISSIONER EMPLOYEES PROVIDENT FUND NO. 20 RAYAPETTAH HIGH ROAD CHENNAI -14 ...4th Respondent in OSA.52 of 2016 THE DEPUTY CHIEF INSPECTOR OF FACTORIES CHENNAI 1ST DIVISION CHENNAI - 06.
...4th Respondent in OSA.53 of 2016 THE ASSESSING OFFICER RANGE.1 INCOME TAX BUILDINGS AAYAKAR BHAVAN NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 34.
...4th Respondent in OSA.54 of 2016 THE SECRETARY TAMILNADU LABOUR WELFARE BOARD ANNA SALAI CHENNAI-06.
...4th Respondent in OSA.55 of 2016 THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR INSURANCE IV BRANCH ESI CORPORATION NO.143 STERLING ROAD CHENNAI-34.
...4th Respondent in OSA.56 of 2016 1.G. LAKSHMI W/O. SARAVANAN BOTH RES AT GROUND FLOOR NO.30/2 GOPALA KRISHNA ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI-17.
2.S.D. SARAVANAN S/O. DHANDAPANI.
3.MR.A.GANESAN NO.30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 17 NOW AT NO.13 MELONY ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI-17.
...Respondents 1 to 3 in
OSA.58 to 60 of 2016 1.LAKSHMI D/O A.GANESAN W/O S.D.SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA RD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS GROUND FLR T.NGR CHENNAI 17 2.A.GANESAN NO.13 MELONY T.NAGAR CHENNAI
3.KUPPAMMAL 30/2 NU ECH PADMAM APARTMENTS 3RD FLR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017 4.SARASWATHI NO.32 ADAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 13 5.G.SHANKAR NO.30/2 NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS 3RD FLR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017 6.UDAYARANI PLOT NO.28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 600 041 7.SIVARAMAKRISHNAN PLOT NO.28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 600 041 8.SRK EXPORTS PVT LTD REP BY ITS DIRECTOR A.GANESAN NO.13 MELONY RD T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017 9.GRANT ENTERPRISES REP BY TIS PARTNER K.SARASWATHI NO.32 ADAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 600 013 10.SBI OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY TIS CHIEF MANAGER NO.86 RAJAJI SALAI CHENNAI 600 001 11.SMALL INDUSTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK OF INDIA LTD REP BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER NO.480 ANNA SALAI NANDANAM CHENNAI 600 035 12.UCO BANK OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY ITS SENIOR MANAGER THAMBU CHETTY ST CHENNAI 600 001 13.G.KANTHILAL NO.11 SHANMUGAROYAN ST OLD WASHERMANPET CHENNAI 600 031 14.KOMALA W/O SUNDARAPANDIAN NO.23/1 TONDIAR NAGAR MAIN ST TONDIARPET CHENNAI 81
15.GIRIJA NO.23 SRIPURAM 1ST ST ROYAPETTAH CHENNAI 600 014 16.G.DHAYLAN OLD NO.78 NEW NO.104 ARAPERUNCHELVI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
17.R.RAJASEKAR NO.3/23 VIJAYALAKSHMI NAGR CANOTNMENT POONAMALLEE CHENNAI 36 18.N.KARPUKKARASI NO.27 THIRUPARUTHIKUNDREM VILALGE SEVILIMEDU POST KANCHIPURAM.
19.S.NIRMALA NO.386-A OTTAKUTHAR ST MAMALLAN NAGR ARAPANCHERI KANCHIPURAM.
20.A.JEYANTHY NO.93/35B EKAMBARANATHAN SANNITHI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
21.S.SARAVNAAN NO.12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
22.A.PUNNIAKOTI NO.2/352 2ND ST PANDIAN RD SARASWATHI NAGR NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 600 041 23.S.RAMESH DOOR NO.112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
24.R.JAYACHITRA DOOR NO.112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
25.S.MAYILSAMI DOOR NO.38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR TIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI.
26.M.MERCY DOOR NO.38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR TIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI.
27.D.J.RAVICHANDRAN NO.36 CO OP B COLONY K.K.PUDUR COIMBATORE 641 038 28.G.SHANMUGASUNDARAM OLD NO.5A NEW DOO NRO.3/2 SENTHILVELAN NAGR M.K.P.COLONY GANAPATHY COIMBATORE 641 006 29.K.SUMATHI NO.37B THIRUVALLUVAR ST RAMAPURAM AMBATTUR CHENNAI 600 058 30.D.PALANI NO.44 3RD MAIN RD LAKSHMI NAGR PORUR CHENNAI 116 31.M.RAJALAKSHMI OLD DOOR NO.9-A NEW DOORN O.19 KUPPU ST BIG KANCHIPURAM.
32.R.V.INDRAJITH OLD DOOR NO.9-A NEW DOORN O.19 KUPPU ST BIG KANCHIPURAM.
33.S.JOTHIALAKSHMI NO.12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
34.G.GAYATHRI NO.208 VALLALAR ST NASARATHPETTAI CHINNA KANCHIPURAM.
35.T.JAYANTHI NO.26E/109 SOUTH ST SEKKUPETTAI 2ND DIVISION KANCHIPURAM TOWN.
36.S.SURIYAKUMAR OLD DOOR NO.5/1 NEW DOOR NO.25 JAGANATHA SWAMI KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DIST.
37.KALAIVANI OLD DOOR NO.5/1 NEW DOOR NO.25 JAGANATHA SWAMI KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DIST.
38.S.VIVEKANANDAN NO.5A SEKKUPETTAI KAVARAI ST 3RD KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
39.M.S.VARADHARAJAN NO.90/38 THUMBAVANAM ST 2ND KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
40.S.KANCHANA PAPATHIAMMAN KOIL ST SATHUVACHARI VELLORE 632 009 41.P.SULOCHANA NO.7 ANGAMUTHU ST ROYAPETTAH 14 42.S.PREMA NO.8 KOSA ST KOSAPETTAI VELLORE 43.THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER NO.97 ENNATHUR PANCHAYAT WALAJAPET TK KANCHIPURAM DIST KANCHIPURAM.
...Respondents 1 to 43
in OSA.61 & 62 of 2016 1.S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (GROUND FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 600 017.
2.LAKSHMI D/O. A. GANESAN W/O. S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (GROUND FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 600 017.
3.P.SUBBA REDDY 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (1ST FLOOR) T.NAGAR CHENNAI - 17 4.THE ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER (RM-IV) STATE BANK OF INDIA OVERSEAS BRANCH (MID-CORPORATE GROUP) NO.86 RAJAJI SALAI CHENNAI - 600 001.
...Respondents 1 to 4
in OSA.70 & 71 of 2016 1.S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (GROUND FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 600 017.
2.LAKSHMI D/O. A. GANESAN W/O. S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (GROUND FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 600 017.
...Respondents 1 & 2 in OSA.72 to 77,
79 & 80 of 2016 THE COMMISSIONER EMPLOYEES PROVIDENT FUND NO. 20 ROYAPETTAH HIGH ROAD CHENNAI -14 ...3rd Respondent in OSA.72 of 2016 THE DEPUTY CHIEF INSPECTOR CHENNAI I DIVISION CHENNAI 600 006 ...3rd Respondent in OSA.73 of 2016 THE SECRETARY THE TAMILNADU LABOUR WELFARE BOARD ANNA SALAI CHENNAI - 600 006.
...3rd Respondent in OSA.74 of 2016 THE ASSESSING OFFICER RANGE - I INCOME TAX BUILDING AAYAKAR BHAVAN NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600 034.
...3rd Respondent in OSA.75 of 2016 THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR INSURANCE IV BRANCH ESI CORPN NO.143 STERLING RD CHENNAI 600 034 ...3rd Respondent in OSA.76 of 2016 P.SUBBA REDDY 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA RD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS 1ST FLR T.NGR CHENNAI 600 017 ...3rd Respondent in OSA.77 to 80 of 2016 ..5th Respondent in OSA.83,84 & 87 of 2016 1.G. LAKSHMI W/O. S.D. SARAVANAN BOTH ARE RESIDING AT GROUND FLOOR NO.30/2 GOPALA KRISHNA ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI - 17.
2.S.D. SARAVANAN S/O. DHANDAPANI.
...Respondents 1 & 2 in OSA.78 of 2016
1.LAKSHMI 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNAN ROAD NU TECHPADMAM APTS T NAGAR CHENNAI 17 2.KUPPAMMAL 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APTS (THIRD FLOOR) T NAGAR CHENNAI 17 3.SARASWATHI 12 ADAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 13 4.G SHANKAR 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APTS (THIRD FLOOR) T NAGAR CHENNAI 17 5.UDAYARANI 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARAI CH 41 6.SIVARAMAKRISHNAN 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 41 7.SRK EXPORTS PVT LTD REP BY ITS DIRECTOR A GANESAN 8.GRANT ENTERPRISES REP BY ITS PARTNER K SARASWAHI 32 ADAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 13 9.S.B.I. OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY ITS CHIEF MANAGER 86 RAJAJI SALAI CHENNAI 1 10.SMALL INDUSTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK OF INDIA LTD REP BY ITS REGIONAOL MANAGER 480 ANNA SALAI NANDANAM CHENNAI 11.UCO BANK OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY ITS SENIOR MANAGER THAMBU CHETTY ST CHENNAI 1
12.G KANTILAL 11 SHANMUGARAYAN ST OLD WASHERMENPET CHENNAI 21 13.KOMALA 23/1 TONDIAR NAGAR MAIN ST TONDIARPET CHENNAI 81 14.GIRIJA 23 SRIPURAM 1ST ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 14 15.P SUBBA REDDY 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APT T NAGAR CHENNAI 17 16.G DHAYALAN 78 NEW NO.104 ARAPERUNCHELVI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHEPURAM 17.R RAJASEKAR 3/23 VIJAYALAKSHMI NAGAR CONTONMENT POONAMALEE CHENNAI 36 18.N KARPUKKARASI 27 THIRUPARUNTHIKUNDRAM VILAGE SEVILIMEDU POST KANCHIPURAM 19.S NIRMALA 386-A OTTAKUTHAR ST MAMALLAN NAGAR ARAPANCHERI KANCHIPURAM 20.A JEYANTHY 93/35B EKAMBARANATHAR SANNITHI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 21.S SARAVANAN 12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 22.A PUNNIAKOTI 2/352 2ND ST PANDIAN ROAD SARASWATHI NAGAR NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 41 23.S RAMESH 112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM
24.R JAYACHITRA 112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 25.S MAYILSAMI 38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR THIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI 26.M MERCY 38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR THIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI 27.D.G. RAVICHANDRAN 36 CO OP B COLONY KK PUDUR COIMBATORE 28.G SHANMUGASUNDARAM 5A NEW DOOR NO.3/2 SENTHILVELAN NAGAR MKP COLONY COIMBATORE 29.K SUMATHI 37B THIRUVALLUVAR ST RAMAPURAM AMBATTUR CHENNAI 58 30.D PALANI 44 3RD MAIN ROAD LAKSHMI NAGAR PORUR CHENNAI 116 31.M. RAJALAKSHMI 9A NEW DOOR NO.19 KUPPU ST KANCHIPURAM 32.R.V. INDRAJITH 9A NEW DOOR NO.19 KUPPU ST KANCHIPURAM 33.S JOTHILAKSHMI 12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 34.G GAYATHRI 35.T JAYANTHI 26E/109 SOUTH ST SEKKUPETTAI 2ND DIVISION KANCHIPURAM 36.S SURIYAKUMAR 5/1 NEW DOOR NO.25 JAGANTHA SWAMY KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DT
37.S. KALAIVANI 5/1 NEW DOOR NO.25 JAGANATHA SWAMY KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DT 38.S VIVEKANANDAN 5A SEKKUPETTAI KAVARAI ST 3RD KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 39.M.S. VARADHARAJAN 90/38 THUMBAVANAM ST 2ND KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM 40.S KANCHANA PAPPATHIAMAMN KOIL ST SATHUVACHERI VELLORE 41.P SULOCHANA 7 ANGAMUTHU ST ROYAPETTAH CHENNAI 14 42.S PREMA 8 KOSA ST KOSAPETTAI VELLORE 43.THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER NO.97 ENNATHUR PANCHAYAT WALAJAPET TK KANCHIPURAM DIST KANCHIPURAM.
...Respondents 1 to 43 in
OSA.81 & 82 of 2016 1.LAKSHMI D/O. A. GANESAN W/O. S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS (GROUND FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI - 600 017.
2.UDAYARANI PLOT NO. 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARANI CHENNAI -41 3.SIVARAMAKRISHNAN PLOT NO. 28 29 SINGARAVELAN SALAI NEELANGARANI CHENNAI -41 4.KOMALA W/O SUNDARAPANDIAN 23/1 TONDIAR NAGAR MAIN ST TONDIARPET CHENNAI -81
...Respondents 1 to 4 in
OSA.83 & 84 of 2016
1.LAKSHMI D/O. A. GANESAN. W/O. S.D.SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APPARTMENTS GROUND FLOOR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
2.A. GANESAN NO.13 MELONY ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
3.KUPPAQMMAL 30/2 NU TECH PADMAM APARTMENTS 3RD FLOOR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
4.SARASWATHI NO.32 AQDAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 13.
5.G.SHANKAR NO. 30/2 NU TECH PADMAM APPARTMENTS 3RD FLOOR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
6.SRK EXPORTS PVT.LTD.
REP BY ITS DIRECTOR A.GANESAN NO.13 MELONY ROAD T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
7.GRANT ENTERPRISES REP BY ITS PARTNER K.SARASWATHI NO.32 ADAM SAHIB ST ROYAPURAM CHENNAI 600 013.
8.SBI OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY ITS CHIEF MANAGER NO. 86 RAJAJI SALAI CHENNAI 600 001.
9.SMALL I9NDUSTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK OF INDIA LTD.
REP BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER NO. 480 ANNA SALAI NANDANAM CHENNAI 600 035.
10.UCO BANK OVERSEAS BRANCH REP BY ITS SENIOR MANAGER THAMBU CHETTY ST CHENNAI 600 001.
11.G. KANTHILAL NO. 11 SHANMUGAROYAN ST OLD WASHERMANPET CHENNAI 600 031.
12.KOMALA W/O. SUNDARAPANDIAN NO. 23/1 TONDIAR NAGAR MAIN ST TONDIARPET CHENNAI 600 081.
13.GIRIJA NO.23 SRIP0URAM IST ST ROYAPETTAH CHENNAI 600 014.
14.MR. P. SUBBA REDDY NO. 30/2 GOPALA KRISHNA ROAD FIRST FLOOR T.NAGAR CHENNAI 600 017.
15.G. DHAYALAN OLD NO 78 NEW NO 104 ARAPERUNCHELVI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
16.R. RAJASEKAR NO. 3/23 VIJAYALAKSHMI NAGAR CANTONMENT POONAMALLEE CHENNAI 600 036.
17.N. KARPUKKARASI NO. 27 THIRUPARUTHIKUNDREM VILL SEVILIMEDU PO KANCHIPURAM.
18.S. NIRMALA NO. 386 A OTTAKUTHAR ST MAMALLAN NAGAR ARAPANCHERI KANCHIPURAM.
19.A. JEYANTHY NO. 93/ 35B EKAMBARANATHAR SANNITHI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
20.S. SARAVANAN NO. 12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
21.A. PUNNIAKOTI NO. 2/352 2ND ST PANDIAN ROAD SARASWATHI NAGAR NEELANGARAI CHENNAI 600 041. 22.S. RAMESH D.NO. 112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
23.R. JAYACHITRA D.NO. 112/75B SALAI ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
24.S. MAYILSAMI D.NO. 38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR TIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI.
25.M. MERCY D.NO. 38/34 2ND ST SOMASUNDARAM NAGAR THIRUVOTTRIYUR CHENNAI.
26.D.G. RAVICHANDRAN NO. 36 CO.OP B COLONY K.K.PUTHUR COIMBATORE 641 038.
27.G. SHANMUGASUNDARAM OLD NO 5A NEW D.NO3/2 SENTHIVELAN NAGAR M.K.P.COLONY GANAPATHY COIMBATORE 641 006.
28.K.SUMATHI NO. 37BM THIRUVALLUVAR ST RAMAPURAM AMBATTUR CHENNAI 600 058.
29.D. PALANI NO. 44 3RD MAIN ROAD LAKSHMI NAGAR PORUR CHENNAI 600 116.
30.M.RAJALAKSHMI OLD D.NO 9A NEW D.NO.19 KUPPU ST BIG KANCHIPURAM.
31.R.V.INDRAJITH OLD D.NO. 9A NEW D.NO19 KUPPU ST BIG KANCHIPURAM.
32.S.JOTHILAKSHMI NO.12 SOUTH KRISHNAN ST 4TH KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
33.G. GAYATHRI NO. 208 VALLALAR ST NASARTHPETTAI CHINNA KANCHIPURAM.
34.T. JAYANTHI NO. 26E/109 SOUTH ST SEKKUPETTAI 2ND DIVISION KANCHIPURAM TOWN.
35.S. SURIYAKUMAR OLD D.NO.5/1 NEW D.NO.25 JAGANATHA SWAMI KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DT.
36.KALAIVANI OLD D.NO.5/1 NEW D.NO.25 JAGANATHA SWAMI KOIL ST ARCOT VELLORE DT.
37.S. VIVEKANANDAN NO.5A SEKKUPETTAI KAVARAI ST 3RD KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
38.M.S.VARADHARAJAN NO. 90/38 THUMBAVANAM ST 2ND KOTTAM KANCHIPURAM.
39.S.KANCHANA PAPATHIAMMAN KOIL ST SATHUVACHARI VELLORE 632 009.
40.P.SULOCHANAN NO.7 ANGAMUTHU ST ROYAPETTAH CHENNAI 600 014.
41.S. PREMA NO. 8 KOSA ST KOSAPETTAI VELLORE 42.THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER NO. 97 ENNATHUR PANCHAYAT WALAJAPET TK KANCHIPURAM DT KANCHIPURAM. ...Respondents 1 to 42 in OSA.85 & 86 of 2016 1.LAKSHMI D/O A. GANESAN W/O S.D. SARAVANAN 30/2 GOPALAKRISHNA ROAD NU TECH PADMAM APPARTMENTS (GROUNDS FLOOR) T. NAGAR CHENNAI-600 017.
2.A. GANESAN NO.13 MELONY ROAD T. NAGAR CHENNAI-600 017.
3.SARASWATHI NO.32 ADAM SAHIB STREET ROYAPURAM CHENNAI-13.
4.KOMALA W/O SUNDARAPANDIAN NO.23/1 TONDIAR NAGAR MAIN STREET TONDIARPET CHENNAI-600 081. ...Respondents 1 to 4 in OSA.87 of 2016
Original Side Appeals filed under Order XXXVI, Rule 9 of Original Side Rules read with Clause 15 of Letters Patent against the common order made in A.No.5373/13 in A.No.3029/13 in CS.78/11 (OSA.51/16); A.No.6377/15 in A.No.5330/13 in CS.78/11 (OSA.No.52/16, 72/16); A.No.6378/15 in A.No.5331/13 in CS.78/11, (OSA.53, 73/16; A.No.6379/15, in A.No.5332/13 in CS.78/11, (OSA.No.54,75/16; A.No.6380/15 in A.No.5333/13 in CS.78/11 (OSA.55,74/16); A.No.6381/15 in A.No.5334/13 in CS.78/11 (OSA.No.56,76/16); A.No.7015/15 in CS.78/11, (OSA 57,77/16); A.No.7016/15 in CS.301/12 (OSA.58,78/16); A.No.7017/15 in CS.78/11, (OSA.59/16, 79/16); A.N.7018/15 in CS.78/11 (OSA.60/16, 80/16); A.No.229/14 in CSD No.39780/13 in (OSA.61, 81, 85/16); A.No.4170/14 in CSD.39780/13 (OSA.62/16; A.No.5371/13 in CS.78/11, (OSA.70/16); A.No.5372/13 in CS.78/11, (OSA.
71/16); A.No.1764/14 in A.No.229/14 in CSD NO.39780/13 (OSA.82,86/16); A.No.3546/14 in CSD.NO.39780/13 (OSA.83/16); A.No.3726/14 in CSD No.39780/13 (OSA.84/16); A.No.4169/14 in CSD.39780/13 (OSA.87/16); respectively dated 09.02.2016. For Appellants in : Ms.K.Aparna Devi OSA.51 to 62/2016 For Appellants in : Mr.T.Audiseshan OSA.70 to 84/2016 For Appellants in : Mr.K.Govindan OSA.85 to 87/2016 COMMON JUDGMENT (Judgment of the Court was delivered by The Hon'ble Chief Justice) The grievance in all these appeals arising from the impugned order is that various Interlocutory Applications have been ordered predicated on the consent of the parties.
The submission of the appellants is that they actually urged the plea on merits opposing the applications/ or they never granted consent and thus, there appears to be some communication gap between what transpired in Court and what is recorded in the order.
2. After some arguments, it is conceded that this aspect has not been brought to the notice of the learned Single Judge. It is trite to say that this Court cannot look into the issue when the order of consent is there and it must be presumed that what is recorded is correct (AIR 1982 SC 1248 - Smt.Kamalesh Kumari
v. State of U.P. and others). The learned counsels for the appellants, faced with the aforesaid position, state that they will withdraw the appeals and move the learned Single Judge for recall of the impugned order based on the pleas which they may raise in the applications explaining as to what they had canvassed and what was their intent. It is, however, stated that in view of the appellants having exercised the right of appeal, the period for moving such an application has expired. Endorsement has been made by the learned counsels for appellants.
3. We are of the view that if the aforesaid be the position, the appellants may prefer an application within one week from today and on such application being preferred, it will be considered on merits.
4. The appeals are dismissed as withdrawn in terms aforesaid. No costs. Consequently, all connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
Sd/- Assistant Registrar(CS VI) //True Copy// Sub Assistant Registrar bbr To The Sub Assistant Registrar, Original Side, High Court, Madras.
+1cc to Mr.K.Govindan, Advocate, S.R.No.17447 +3cc's to Mr.T.Audiseshan, Advocate, S.R.Nos.17448 & 17378 +2cc's to Ms.K.Aparna Devi, Advocate, S.R.No.17446 O.S.A.Nos.51 to 62, 70 to 84 & 85 to 87 of 2016 RSI(CO) CA(24/03/2016)