The Superintending Engineer v. M Ayyammal

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 23-04-2025

CORAM

THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE S. M. SUBRAMANIAM AND THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR REV.APPL No. 262 of 2024 AND REV.APPL No.263 of 2024, REV.APPL No.264 of 2024, REV.APPL No.265 of 2024, WA No.1737 of 2021, WA No.1787 of 2021, REV.APPL No.266 of 2024, REV.APPL No.267 of 2024, REV.APPL No.268 of 2024, REV.APPL No.270 of 2024, REV.APPL No.271 of 2024, WA No.1780 of 2021, WA No.1779 of 2021, WA No.1789 of 2021, WA No.1788 of 2021, REV.APPL No.269 of 2024, WA No.1746 of 2021, WA No.1719 of 2021, WA No.1697 of 2021, REV.APPL No.296 of 2024, WA No.1725 of 2021, WA No.1724 of 2021, WA No.1726 of 2021, WA No.1747 of 2021, WA No.1730 of 2021, WA No.1729 of 2021, WA No.1722 of 2021, WA No.1723 of 2021, WA No.1736 of 2021, WA No.1716 of 2021, WA No.1734 of 2021, WA No.1731 of 2021, WA No.1727 of 2021, WA No.1696 of 2021, WA No.

1718 of 2021, WA No.1714 of 2021, WA No.1782 of 2021, WA No.1786 of 2021, WA No.1784 of 2021, REV.APPL No.278 of 2024, REV.APPL No.277 of 2024, REV.APPL No.272 of 2024, REV.APPL No.273 of 2024, REV.APPL No.274 of 2024, REV.APPL No.275 of 2024, REV.APPL No.276 of 2024, REV.APPL No.279 of 2024, REV.APPL No.282 of 2024, REV.APPL No.288 of 2024, REV.APPL No.280 of 2024, REV.APPL No.286 of 2024, REV.APPL No.284 of 2024, REV.APPL No.283 of 2024, REV.APPL No.281 of 2024, REV.APPL No.285 of 2024, REV.APPL No.

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M Ayyammal S/o. Mookan, Kadamparai Powerhouse (P.O), Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore District - 101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 265 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M.R. Ganesh 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101.

Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 263 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. B.Jagathesan C/o. B.Malathy, Kadamparai Powerhouse Post, Pollachi (Via), Coibatore Dt-642101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor Tneb Tneb Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 264 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K. Sivakumar 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor

TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1737 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Nagamani W/o.K.Kanjimalai, C/o.B.Mary, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi(via) Coimbatore District.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1787 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s)

Vs

1. M.R.Ganesh S/o Ramakrishnan, No.3 S.R.M.S.Mills Road, Pollachi, Coimbatore Dist.

2.KARUPADEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 267 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S Venugopal 2.N Babu Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 266 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil

Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S Devaraj S/o. Shanmugham, Kadamparai Powerhouse, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore, Coimbatore Dt. 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 268 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. P Moorthy 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101

The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 270 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K Ponnusamy 2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 271 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K Hanifa S/o. V.K. Kasim, 20, Aathupura Colony, Aliyar Nagar Post, Coimbatore Dt 642 101.

2.N Babu Labour Contractor, TNEB. TNEB Quarters,

Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1780 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. A.Senthil Kumar S/o Arumugham, Minparai Mugam Post, Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1779 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Gneration Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Minparai - 642 101, Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. R.Lakshmi

D/o Raman, C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam, Pollachi Via, Coimbatore District 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor , Tneb, Tneb Quarters Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbaote District Labour Court, Coimbatore District Respondent(s) WA No. 1789 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. V.Malleswaran S/o Velusamy, Kadamparai Power House Post, Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1788 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer

Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai642101, Coimbatore District. Appellant(s) Vs

1. R.Sumathi C/o Mathaiyan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Via, Coimbatore Dist.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 269 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K Deenadhayalan 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor, TNEB , TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s)

WA No. 1746 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Appellant(s) Vs

1. A.Kumaravel S/o.T.Arumugam, C/o.Civil Section, Minparai(post), Pollachi(via) 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1719 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. B.Jagathesan C/o. B. Malathy, Kadamparai Power, House Post, Pollachi (via), Coimbatore Dt.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1697 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. P.Moorthy S/o.Palanisamy, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore District.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 296 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. V.Malleswaran Paulkarar Camp, Kadamparai Power

House Post, Pollachi (Via) Coimbatore Dist- 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist. - 642 101.

Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1725 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. P.Veeranan S/o N.Palusamy, Upper Aliyar Dam (post), Valparai Tk 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1724 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil

Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S.Sakaraiappan S/o.Subban, 1/4, A.K.Radipalayam, Kodunkiyam Post, Udumalpet 2.KARUPADEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1726 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M. Ayyammal B/o. Mookan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via), Coimbatore District.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1747 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Appellant(s) Vs

1. S.Ramesh S/o.Sennan, Kadamparai Power House(p.O.) Pollachi(via), Coimbatore District.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1730 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Sivakumar S/o.K.Kanagaraj, Kadamparai Power

House Post Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1729 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101, Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M.Kannaiyan S/o.Malan, Settlement, Kadamparai Dam(via) Pollachi 642 101.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1722 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil

Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. N. Mohan Babu S/o Nagarajan, C/o. Balasundaram, 6/851, Subramani St, Kallingarajan, Palayamputhur, Bhavani 638 301.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1723 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Minparai - 642 101.

Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Mahalingam, S/o.Kanagaraj, Kadamparai Dam, Kadamparai Power House Post, Coimbatore District.

2.N. Gopinathan, Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore Dist.

3.The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1736 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Hanifa S/o.V.K.Kasim, 20, Aathupura Colony, Aliyar Nagar Post, Coimbatore District.

2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1716 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S.Devaraj S/o.Shanmugham Kadamparai Power

House Pollachi (via), Coimbatore Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1734 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Appellant(s) Vs

1. S.Venugopal S/o.Sivasankaran, Meena Nivas, Karingarapalli Post, Palakad, Kerala.

2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1731 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil

Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. A.Geetha C/o.V.Palanisamy, 161b, Sivasakthi Nagar, Thanthontrimalai Post, Karur Dist.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1727 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Ponnusamy S/o.Kittan, C/o.Arumugham (mahali) Kadamparai Power House (po) Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1696 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. M. Murugan S/o Mookan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Via, Coimbatore Dt.

2.Karupa Thaver Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1718 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Ganeration Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai - 642 101, Coimbatore Dist Appellant(s) Vs

1. C.Raja, S/o.Chinnaperumal C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam,

Pollachi(via), Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters , Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1714 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. A.Amutha W/o.Arumughan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1782 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil

Nadu Electricity Board Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. JAGATHESAN C/o.B.Malathy, Kadamparai Power House Post Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore District.

2.MOHANBABU S/o.Natarajan, No.49 Kuruvappan St, Thavuttupalayam, Andhiyur Bhavan, Bhavani.

3.P.Sumathi C/o.Mathiyan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore.

4.DEENADHAYALAN S/o.A.K.Kandasamy, 82-d, Kottur, Malayandipattinam Post, Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore.

5.KUMARAVEL S/o.T.Arumugam, C/o.Mathavan, Soolammal Devi Post, Madathukulam Tk, Udumalpet, Thiruppur District.

6.M.Kannian S/o.Malan, Settlement, Kadamparai Dam Via, Pollachi, Coimbatore.

7.The Presiding Officer Labour Court, Coimbatore.

8.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Respondent(s) WA No. 1786 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. K.Deenadhayalan S/o A.K.Kandasamy, Indira Nagar, Ariyapuram, 82-d, Kottur, Malayandipattinam Post, Pollachi 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) WA No. 1784 of 2021

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu, Electricity Board Minparai642101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. M.Selvi

W/o Palanisamy, C/o B.Mary, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.KARUPDEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 278 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. P Veeranan 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB, TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 277 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamaparai Generation Circle, TNEB, Minparai-642 101, Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M Murugan S/o. Mookan, Kadamparai, Powerhouse Post, Pllachi(Via), Coimbatore District-642 101 2.Karupa Thaver Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 272 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai- 642 101 Coimbatore District.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. A Senthil Kumar S/o. Arumugham, Minparai Mugam Post, Coimbatore District-642 101 2.N Babu N Babu Labour Contractor TNEB,TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101

The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 273 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai-642 101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. K Nagamani C/o. B.Mary, Kadamparai, Powerhouse Post, Pollachi(via), Coimbatore District-642 101 2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB ,TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore Distrct 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 274 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S Sakaraiappan 1/4 A.K.Radipalayam, Kodunkiyam Post, Udumalpet-642122 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 275 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai-642 101, Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. B Jagathesan C/o. B.Malathy, Kadamparai Power house Post, Pollachi(Via), Coimbatore-642 101 2.N Mohan Babu S/o Nagarajan C/o Balasundaram 6/851 Subramani Street Kallingarajan Palayamputhur Bhavani 638 301 3.P Sumathi C/o Mathaiyan Kadamparai Powerhouse Post Pollachi Via Coimbatore District 642 101

4.K Deenadhayalan S/o A K Kandasamy Indira nagar Ariyapuram 82-D Kottur Malayandipattinam Post Pollachi 642 114 5.A Kumaravel A Kumaravel S/o T Arumugam C/o Civil Section Minparai (Post) Pollachi(Via.) 642 101 6.M Kannaiyan M Kannaiyan S/o Malan Settlement Kadamparai Dam (Via) Pollachi 642 101 7.The Presiding Officer The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore 8.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 276 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642101 Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. N Mohan Babu

2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB, TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 279 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. S Ramesh S/o. Sennan, Kadamparai Powerhouse (PO) Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, TNEB TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 282 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s)

Vs

1. A.Amutha W/o. Arumughan, Kadamparai Powerhouse Post, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dist. 642 101 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 288 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101 Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. K Mahalingam The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101 Coimbatore District 2.N Gopinathan Labour Countractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District-642 101

The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 280 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. P.Sumathi 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 286 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. R.Lakshmi 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB

TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 284 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. C Raja C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt. 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 283 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101,

Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. A. Kumaravel S/o. T. Arumugam, C/o. Civil Section, Minparai (Post), Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt - 101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 281 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. A.Geetha 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101

The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 285 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer, Kadamparai Generation Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai - 101, Coimbatore Dt.

Appellant(s) Vs

1. M.Kannaiyan 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 295 of 2024

1. The Superintending Engineer kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Minparai 642 101 Coimbatore District Appellant(s) Vs

1. M Selvi 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk,

Coimbatore Dist. -642 101.

Labour Court, Coimbatore Respondent(s) REV.APPL No. 262 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1726 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 265 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1787 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court REV.APPL No. 263 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1719 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 264 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1730 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1737 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP.No.18098 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1787 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the WA and set aside the order in WP No. 18096/2011 dated 24/07/2019.

REV.APPL No. 267 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1734 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 266 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1716 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 268 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1697 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 270 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1727 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 271 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1736 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1780 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.18114/2011 dated 24/07/2019 WA No. 1779 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.18113/2011 dated 24/07/2019 WA No. 1789 of 2021

PRAYER To allow the WA and set aside the order in WP No. 18104/2011 dated 24/07/2019.

WA No. 1788 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the WA and set aside the order in WP No. 17936/2011 dated 24/07/2019.

REV.APPL No. 269 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1786 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1746 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP.No.17938 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1719 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.17935 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1697 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18100 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 296 of 2024 PRAYER To reveiew the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1789/2021. WA No. 1725 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.17941 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019.

WA No. 1724 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18105 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1726 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.18112 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1747 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP.No.18101 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1730 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18102 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1729 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the Writ Appeal and set aside the order in WP No.17939 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019.

WA No. 1722 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.17940 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1723 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.18095 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1736 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP.No.18107 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019.

WA No. 1716 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18106 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1734 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP.No.18103 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019. WA No. 1731 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18099 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1727 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18111 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1696 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18110 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No.

1718 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18109 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. WA No. 1714 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the writ appeal and set aside the order in WP No.18108 of 2011 dated 24.07.2019 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court.

WA No. 1782 of 2021 PRAYER To set aside the order in WP No.23526/2011 dated 24/07/2019 WA No. 1786 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the WA and set aside the order in WP No. 17937/2011 dated 24/07/2019.

WA No. 1784 of 2021 PRAYER To allow the WA and set aside the order in WP No. 18097/2011 dated 24/07/2019.

REV.APPL No. 278 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the Order dt. 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1725/2021 REV.APPL No. 277 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1696/2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Honourable Court REV.APPL No. 272 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.NO.1780/2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Honourable Court may deem fit in the interest of Justice REV.APPL No. 273 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1737/2021

REV.APPL No. 274 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the Order dt. 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1724/2021 REV.APPL No. 275 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1782/2021 REV.APPL No. 276 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the Order dt. 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1722/2021 REV.APPL No. 279 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1747 of 2021 REV.APPL No. 282 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in W.A. No. 1714 of 2021. REV.APPL No. 288 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1723/2021 REV.APPL No. 280 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in W.A. No. 1788 of 2021. REV.APPL No. 286 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the Order dated 31.10.2023 passed in W.A.No. 1779 of 2021

REV.APPL No. 284 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1718 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 283 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in WA No.1746 of 2021 and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court. REV.APPL No. 281 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the order dated 31.10.2023 passed in W.A. No. 1731 of 2021. REV.APPL No. 285 of 2024 PRAYER To Review the Order dated 31.10.2023 passed in W.A.No. 1729 of 2021 REV.APPL No. 295 of 2024 PRAYER To review the order dated 31-10-2023 passed in WA.No.1784/2021. REV.APPL No. 262 of 2024 For Petitioner:

Mr.Anand Gopalan For M/s.T.S.Gopan & Co.

For Respondent:

Mr.V.Ajoy Khose For RR1 & 2 Labour Court For R3

ORDER

(Order of the Court was made by S.M.Subramaniam J.) The Review Petitions have been instituted to review the common order dated 31.10.2023 passed in batch of writ appeals.

2. Mr. Anand Gopalan, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the review petitioner would mainly contend that few workmen not even completed minimum qualifying services of pension.

3. Service pension is granted pursuant to the order sought to be reviewed and the present review petitions sought to be considered. It is contended that a person who served 14 months have been made eligible for grant of pension and therefore the Tamil Nadu Electricity Board filed the present review petitions.

4. Several other grounds raised relating to merits cannot be adjudicated in a review petition. Grounds for an appeal cannot be considered as a ground for reviewing the order passed by the Court. Scope of review cannot be expanded for the purpose of re-adjudication or reconsideration of the issues already decided by the Courts.

5. In Review Application No.662 of 2017, paragraph Nos.8, 9, 10 reads as under:

"8.This Division Bench is of the opinion that the review applications are not maintainable either under Section 114 of CPC or under Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC for the reasons that the review application can be maintained under any of the ingredients of Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC and more importantly, only when there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record. The review applicant has not made out even a single ground for reviewing the said judgment and there is no defect or error apparent on the face of the record. The review applicant did not make out any ground so as to attract the ingredients of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC and not pointed out any error apparent on the face of the record. The Supreme Court of India in the case of Persion Devi and Ors v.

Sumithra Devi & Ors reported in [1997 (8) SCC 715], held that reviewing a judgment on error apparent on the face of the record, is distinct from erroneous decisions. An erroneous decision, even assuming to be, will not provide a cause for filing a review application. The Supreme Court has made out a distinction between the error apparent on the face of the record and erroneous decisions. But, the grounds raised in the present review application do not establish any error apparent on the face of the record and thus, the present review application deserves to be rejected.

9.Further, the Supreme Court of India held that the review jurisdiction cannot be used as an Appellate Jurisdiction. The "mistake" or "error" must exist apparent on the face of the record to seek for review. As per Order 47 Rule 1 CPC, the Judgment may be opened to review, inter alia, if there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the records. An error which is not self-evident and has to be detected by a process of

reasoning can hardly said to be an error apparent on the face of the record justifying the Court to exercise its power of review in exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. It is impermissible for an erroneous decision to be "re-heard and corrected" and there is a clear distinction between an erroneous decision and an error apparent on the face of the record. 10.The review application has a limited scope and cannot be allowed to be argued as an Appeal in disguise. In many cases across the country it is held that, where the grounds enumerated under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC is imminent and in the absence of satisfying the ingredients, no review application would lie.

The review application is not a process of re-hearing of the whole matter, which had been earlier finally disposed of and the review application filed by the present applicant herein exactly attempts to do the same. Acceptability or rejection of the review application has to be decided only with reference to the grounds on which the review is permissible and not on the merits of the claim. The Supreme Court of India in the case reported in AIR 2000 SC 1650 held that a review application is for a correction of mistake and not for substitution of views. A point which may be a ground for an appeal is certainly not a ground for review. Thus, an erroneous view of evidence or of law is no ground for a review, though, it may be a ground for an appeal.

The grounds of review application presently filed by the applicant does not make out an evidence of error apparent on the face of the order of this Court."

6. In view of the legal principles, this Court is of the considered opinion that the grounds raised on merits by the review petitioners need not be considered in the present review petitions. All such grounds are to be

adjudicated only in an appeal if any instituted and certainly not in a review proceedings. Thus, this Court is not inclined to entertain the review petitions and consequently, the review petitions stand dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

(S.M.SUBRAMANIAM J.) (K.RAJASEKAR J.) 23-04-2025 ssi Index:Yes/No Speaking/Non-speaking order Internet:Yes REV.APPL No. 262 of 2024 To 1.M Ayyammal S/o. Mookan, Kadamparai Powerhouse (P.O), Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore District - 101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 265 of 2024 To 1.M.R. Ganesh 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101.

Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 263 of 2024 To 1.B.Jagathesan C/o. B.Malathy, Kadamparai Powerhouse Post, Pollachi (Via), Coibatore Dt-642101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor Tneb Tneb Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 264 of 2024 To 1.K. Sivakumar 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk

Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

WA No. 1737 of 2021 To 1.K.Nagamani W/o.K.Kanjimalai, C/o.B.Mary, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi(via) Coimbatore District.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1787 of 2021 To 1.M.R.Ganesh S/o Ramakrishnan, No.3 S.R.M.S.Mills Road, Pollachi, Coimbatore Dist.

2.KARUPADEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore

REV.APPL No. 267 of 2024 To 1.S Venugopal 2.N Babu Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 266 of 2024 To 1.S Devaraj S/o. Shanmugham, Kadamparai Powerhouse, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore, Coimbatore Dt. 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 268 of 2024 To 1.P Moorthy 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk

Coimbatore District 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 270 of 2024 To 1.K Ponnusamy 2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 271 of 2024 To 1.K Hanifa S/o. V.K. Kasim, 20, Aathupura Colony, Aliyar Nagar Post, Coimbatore Dt 642 101.

2.N Babu Labour Contractor, TNEB. TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

WA No. 1780 of 2021 To 1.A.Senthil Kumar S/o Arumugham, Minparai Mugam

Post, Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1779 of 2021 To 1.R.Lakshmi D/o Raman, C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam, Pollachi Via, Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbaote Dist Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1789 of 2021 To 1.V.Malleswaran S/o Velusamy, Kadamparai Power House Post, Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1788 of 2021 To 1.R.Sumathi C/o Mathaiyan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Via, Cimbatore Dist.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 269 of 2024 To 1.K Deenadhayalan 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor, TNEB , TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court Coimbatore.

WA No. 1746 of 2021 To 1.A.Kumaravel S/o.T.Arumugam, C/o.Civil Section, Minparai(post), Pollachi(via) 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk,

Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1719 of 2021 To 1.B.Jagathesan C/o. B. Malathy, Kadamparai Power, House Post, Pollachi (via), Coimbatore Dt.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1697 of 2021 To 1.P.Moorthy S/o.Palanisamy, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore District.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 296 of 2024 To

1.V.Malleswaran Paulkarar Camp, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (Via) Coimbatore Dist- 642 101..

2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist. - 642 101.

Labour Court Coimbatore WA No. 1725 of 2021 To 1.P.Veeranan S/o N.Palusamy, Upper Aliyar Dam (post), Valparai Tk 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1724 of 2021 To 1.S.Sakaraiappan S/o.Subban, 1/4, A.K.Radipalayam, Kodunkiyam Post, Udumalpet 2.KARUPADEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1726 of 2021 To 1.M. Ayyammal B/o. Mookan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via), Coimbatore District.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1747 of 2021 To 1.S.Ramesh S/o.Sennan, Kadamparai Power House(p.O.) Pollachi(via), Coimbatore District.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1730 of 2021 To 1.K.Sivakumar

S/o.K.Kanagaraj, Kadamparai Power House Post Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1729 of 2021 To 1.M.Kannaiyan S/o.Malan, Settlement, Kadamparai Dam(via) Pollachi 642 101.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, , Tneb Quarters Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1722 of 2021 To 1.N. Mohan Babu S/o Nagarajan, C/o. Balasundaram, 6/851, Subramani St, Kallingarajan, Palayamputhur, Bhavani 638 301.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk,

Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1723 of 2021 To 1.K.Mahalingam, S/o.Kanagaraj, Kadamparai Dam, Kadamparai Power House Post, Coimbatore District.

2.N. Gopinathan, Labour Contractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore Dist.

3.The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1736 of 2021 To 1.K.Hanifa S/o.V.K.Kasim, 20, Aathupura Colony, Aliyar Nagar Post, Coimbatore District.

2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1716 of 2021 To 1.S.Devaraj

S/o.Shanmugham Kadamparai Power House Pollachi (via), Coimbatore Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1734 of 2021 To 1.S.Venugopal S/o.Sivasankaran, Meena Nivas, Karingarapalli Post, Palakad, Kerala.

2.N.Babu Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1731 of 2021 To 1.A.Geetha C/o.V.Palanisamy, 161b, Sivasakthi Nagar, Thanthontrimalai Post, Karur Dist.

2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb

Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1727 of 2021 To 1.K.Ponnusamy S/o.Kittan, C/o.Arumugham (mahali) Kadamparai Power House (po) Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1696 of 2021 To 1.M. Murugan S/o Mookan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Via, Coimbatore Dt.

2.Karupa Thaver Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore

WA No. 1718 of 2021 To 1.C.Raja, S/o.Chinnaperumal C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam, Pollachi(via), Coimbatore Dist 2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters , Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1714 of 2021 To 1.A.Amutha W/o.Arumughan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.N.Gopinathan Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

Labour Court, Coimbatore.

WA No. 1782 of 2021 To 1.JAGATHESAN C/o.B.Malathy, Kadamparai Power House Post Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore District.

2.MOHANBABU S/o.Natarajan, No.49 Kuruvappan St, Thavuttupalayam, Andhiyur Bhavan, Bhavani.

3.P.Sumathi C/o.Mathiyan, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore.

4.DEENADHAYALAN S/o.A.K.Kandasamy, 82-d, Kottur, Malayandipattinam Post, Pollachi Tk, Coimbatore.

5.KUMARAVEL S/o.T.Arumugam, C/o.Mathavan, Soolammal Devi Post, Madathukulam Tk, Udumalpet, Thiruppur District.

6.M.Kannian S/o.Malan, Settlement, Kadamparai Dam Via, Pollachi, Coimbatore.

7.The Presiding Officer Labour Court, Coimbatore.

8.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore District.

WA No. 1786 of 2021 To 1.K.Deenadhayalan

S/o A.K.Kandasamy, Indira Nagar, Ariyapuram, 82-d, Kottur, Malayandipattinam Post, Pollachi 2.SOUNDARARAJAN Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore WA No. 1784 of 2021 To 1.M.Selvi W/o Palanisamy, C/o B.Mary, Kadamparai Power House Post, Pollachi (via) Coimbatore Dist.

2.KARUPDEVAR Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist.

Labour Court, Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 278 of 2024 To 1.P Veeranan 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB, TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101

Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 277 of 2024 To 1.M Murugan S/o. Mookan, Kadamparai, Powerhouse Post, Pllachi(Via),Coimbatore District-642 101 2.Karupa Thaver Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 272 of 2024 To 1.A Senthil Kumar S/o. Arumugham, Minparai Mugam Post, Coimbatore District-642 101 2.N Babu N Babu Labour Contractor TNEB,TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 273 of 2024 To 1.K Nagamani C/o. B.Mary, Kadamparai, Powerhouse Post, Pollachi(via), Coimbatore District-642 101 2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB ,TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore Distrct 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 274 of 2024 To 1.S Sakaraiappan 1/4 A.K.Radipalayam, Kodunkiyam Post, Udumalpet-642122 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 275 of 2024 To 1.B Jagathesan C/o. B.Malathy, Kadamparai Power house Post, Pollachi(Via), Coimbatore-642 101

2.N Mohan Babu S/o Nagarajan C/o Balasundaram 6/851 Subramani Street Kallingarajan Palayamputhur Bhavani 638 301 3.P Sumathi C/o Mathaiyan Kadamparai Powerhouse Post Pollachi Via Coimbatore District 642 101 4.K Deenadhayalan S/o A K Kandasamy Indira nagar Ariyapuram 82-D Kottur Malayandipattinam Post Pollachi 642 114 5.A Kumaravel A Kumaravel S/o T Arumugam C/o Civil Section Minparai (Post) Pollachi(Via.) 642 101 6.M Kannaiyan M Kannaiyan S/o Malan Settlement Kadamparai Dam (Via) Pollachi 642 101 7.The Presiding Officer The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore 8.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101

REV.APPL No. 276 of 2024 To 1.N Mohan Babu 2.Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB, TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 279 of 2024 To 1.S Ramesh S/o. Sennan, Kadamparai Powerhouse (PO) Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan Labour Contractor, TNEB TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District 642 101 Labour Court, Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 282 of 2024 To 1.A.Amutha W/o. Arumughan, Kadamparai Powerhouse Post, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dist. 642 101 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB

Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court, Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 288 of 2024 To 1.K Mahalingam The Superintending Engineer Kadamparai Generation Circle Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Minparai 642 101 Coimbatore District 2.N Gopinathan Labour Countractor, TNEB, TNEB Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Taluk, Coimbatore District-642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 280 of 2024 To 1.P.Sumathi 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore

REV.APPL No. 286 of 2024 To 1.R.Lakshmi 2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore.

REV.APPL No. 284 of 2024 To 1.C Raja C/o. Rajammal, Kadamparai Dam, Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt. 642 101.

2.N Gopinathan N Gopinathan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 283 of 2024 To 1.A. Kumaravel S/o. T. Arumugam, C/o. Civil Section, Minparai (Post), Pollachi (Via), Coimbatore Dt - 101.

2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 281 of 2024 To 1.A.Geetha 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore REV.APPL No. 285 of 2024 To 1.M.Kannaiyan 2.Soundararajan Soundararajan Labour Contractor TNEB TNEB Quarters Kadamparai Valparai Taluk Coimbatore District 642 101 The Presiding Officer Labour Court Coimbatore

REV.APPL No. 295 of 2024 To 1.M Selvi 2.Karupadevar Labour Contractor, Tneb, Tneb Quarters, Kadamparai, Valparai Tk, Coimbatore Dist. -642 101.

Labour Court, Coimbatore

S.M.SUBRAMANIAM J.

AND K.RAJASEKAR J.

ssi REV.APPL No. 262 of 2024 and etc., batch 23-04-2025