Madras High CourtWP/32343/2019disposed of

M.Santhanameenakshi v. The Director Of School Education,

2019-11-19Honourable Mr Justice M.Dhandapani43 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 19.11.2019

CORAM:

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE M.DHANDAPANI W.P.Nos. 32343, 32401, 31417, 31475, 31480, 31482, 31483, 31484, 31487, 31488, 31489, 31493, 31572, 31609, 31728, 31760, 31838, 31517, 31523, 31527, 31531, 31550, 31812, 31860, 31329, 31352, 31414, 31439, 31449, 31472 of 2019 and WMP.Nos.32640, 32642, 32717, 31586, 31475, 31652, 31653, 31656, 31655, 31657, 31659, 31660, 31663, 31664, 31665, 31667, 31668, 31671, 31780, 31782, 31814, 31815, 31817, 31933, 31979, 31981, 32079, 32081, 31711, 31714, 31719, 31720, 31724, 31725, 31729, 31731, 31744, 32049, 32050, 32051, 32106, 31491, 31530, 31531, 31584, 31612, 31623, 31641 of 2019 M.SANTHANAMEENAKSHI ... PETITIONER in WP No.32343 of 2019 S.SHENBAGA BRINTHA M.A. B.E... PETITIONER in WP No.32401 of M.SANGEETHAVALLI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31417 of 2019 P.EKAMBARAM ... PETITIONER in WP No.31475 of 2019 M.

MUTHUKUMAR ... PETITIONER in WP No.31480 of 2019 M.KIRUBAHARAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31482 of 2019 M.ARIKRISHNAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31483 of 2019 R.V.RAJMOHAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31484 of 2019 T.MANIKANDAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31487 of 2019 S.JAYASANKAR ... PETITIONER in WP No.31488 of 2019 M.THILAGAM ... PETITIONER in WP No.31489 of 2019 S.SUDHA ... PETITIONER in WP No.31493 of 2019 P.THANGANAYAKAM ... PETITIONER in WP No.31572 of 2019 V.SIMSONRAJKUMAR ... PETITIONER in WP No.31609 of 2019 MRS.V.ARUL SELVI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31728 of 2019 J.VEDAVALLI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31760 of 2019 M.PASUVARAJ ... PETITIONER in WP No.

S.BABU ... PETITIONER in WP No.31517 of 2019 K.RAMALINGAM ... PETITIONER in WP No.31523 of 2019 D.JEYALAKSHMI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31527 of 2019 C.P.SHOBANA ... PETITIONER in WP No.31531 of 2019 P.RAMAKRISHNAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31550 of 2019 A.MURALI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31812 of 2019 S.SAMBARAJ ... PETITIONER in WP No.31860 of 2019 DAVID LIVINGSTON ... PETITIONER in WP No.31329 of 2019 K.DHANALAKSHMI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31352 of 2019 R.TAMIZHARASAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31414 of 2019 P.THAMIZHSELVI ... PETITIONER in WP No.31439 of 2019 T.STEPHAN ... PETITIONER in WP No.31449 of 2019 J.SIMIYON ... PETITIONER in WP No.31472 of 2019

Versus

1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

.. RESPONDENT in WP No.32343 of 2019 2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REPRESENTED BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

1 THE SECRETARY ... RESPONDENT in WP No.32401 of 2019 SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (TRB) GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU SECRETARIAT FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 4 THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HIGHER SECONDARY DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2/43

1 THE DIRECTOR ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31417 of 2019 SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 2 THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOA RD REP. BY ITS MEMBER SECRETARY DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 600 009 .. RESPONDENT in WP No.31475 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006.

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31480 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO... RESPONDENT in WP No.31482 of GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 600 009 3/43

2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006.

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31483 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31484 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31487 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 4/43

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI 600 ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31488 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT.

OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31489 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI 600 ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31493 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 5/43

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT.

OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31572 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31609 of 2019 REP.BY THE SECRETARY SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE TEACHER RECRUITMENT BOAR D REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR E.V.R.

SAMPATH MALIGAI D.P.I. COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU .. RESPONDENT in WP No.31728 of 2019 REP BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOLS EDUCATION SECRETARIATE FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DPI CAMPUS 17 COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI 8 3 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS NO.52 COLLEGE ROAD THOUSAND LIGHTS CHENNAI 6 6/43

1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECURI ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31760 of 2019 TMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 2 THE MEMBER SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K.

SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 .. RESPONDENT in WP No.31838 of 2019 2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31517 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31523 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 7/43

1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31527 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31531 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WP No.

31550 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 2 THE MEMBER/ SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 1 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006 2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION O/O.

1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT EDUCATION DEPARTMENT FORT ST.GEORGE CHENNAI -9.

... RESPONDENT in WP No.31860 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TAMIL NADU TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI -6.

1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI-6 2 THE MEMBER / SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI-6 ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31329 of 2019 1 THE SECRETARY ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31352 of 2019 DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ST. GEORGE FORT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI - 600009 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT ST. GEORGE FORT CHENNAI 01 ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31414 of 2019 2 THE DIRECTOR TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600015 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP. BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION SECRETARIATE FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 600 009. ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31439 of 2019 9/43

2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DPI CAMPUS 17 COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMPAKKAM CHENNAI 600 008 3 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS NO. 52 COLLEGE ROAD THOUSAND LIGHTS CHENNAI 600 006.

1 THE CHAIRMAN THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 ... RESPONDENT in WP No.31449 of 2019 2 THE DIRECTOR THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR 33 EVK SAMPATH COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 007 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI.

... RESPONDENT in WP No.31472 of 2019 1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32640 of 2019 2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REPRESENTED BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

10/43

2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REPRESENTED BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006.

... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32642 of 2019 1 THE SECRETARY ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32717 of 2019 SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (TRB) GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU SECRETARIAT FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 4 THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HIGHER SECONDARY DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 1 THE DIRECTOR ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31586 of 2019 SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 2 THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOA RD REP. BY ITS MEMBER SECRETARY DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE MANAGEMENT ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31475 of 2019 STATE HEAD OPERATIONS GVK EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AND RESEARCH INSTITUTE BEHIND LABOUR COMMISSIONER OFFICE DMS COMPOUND TEYNAMPET CHENNAI - 600 00 2 THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF LABOUR (HEAD QUARTER) DMS CAMPUS TEYNAMPET CHENNAI - 600 006.

11/43

1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31652 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31653 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 600 009 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006.

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31656 of 2019 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31655 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 12/43

2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31657 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31659 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.

31660 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.

2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31664 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI 600 ...

RESPONDENT in WMP No.31665 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT.

OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31667 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 14/43

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31668 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST GEORGE CHENNAI 600 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31671 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD GOVT. OF TAMILNADU 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION GOVT.

OF TAMIL NADU DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31780 of 2019 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31782 of 2019 15/43

2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION CHENNAI 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP.BY THE SECRETARY SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31814 of 2 THE TEACHER RECRUITMENT BOAR D REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR E.V.R.

SAMPATH MALIGAI D.P.I. COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP.BY THE SECRETARY SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9...

RESPONDENT in WMP No.31815 of 2019 2 THE TEACHER RECRUITMENT BOAR D REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR E.V.R.

SAMPATH MALIGAI D.P.I. COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP.BY THE SECRETARY SCHOOL EDUCATION FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 2 THE TEACHER RECRUITMENT BOAR D REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR E.V.R.

SAMPATH MALIGAI D.P.I. COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31817 of 2019 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOLS EDUCATION SECRETARIATE FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 9 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31933 of 16/43

2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DPI CAMPUS 17 COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI 8 3 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS NO.52 COLLEGE ROAD THOUSAND LIGHTS CHENNAI 6 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECURI TMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 2 THE MEMBER SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K.

SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31979 of 2019 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECURI TMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31981 of 2019 2 THE MEMBER SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K.

SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI-6 1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32079 of 2019 2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 1 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32081 of 2019 17/43

2 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31711 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31714 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.

31719 of 2019 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.

3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31724 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31725 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31729 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31731 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 6 19/43

2 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU HIGHER EDUCATION EDPARTMENT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI 3 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION CHENNAI 1 THE CHAIRMAN ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31744 of 2019 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 2 THE MEMBER/ SECRETARY TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD (TRB) COLLEGE ROAD NEAR SANKARA NETHRALAYA SUBBA ROAD AVENUE NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600006 1 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32049 of 2019 2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION O/O. THE DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 6 1 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006 2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION O/O. THE DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 6 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32050 of 2019 20/43

1 TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600 006 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32051 of 2019 2 THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCA TION O/O. THE DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION COLLEGE ROAD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 6 1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT EDUCATION DEPARTMENT FORT ST.GEORGE CHENNAI -9.

... RESPONDENT in WMP No.32106 of 2019 2 THE CHAIRMAN TAMIL NADU TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI -6.

1 THE SECRETARY ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31531 of 2019 DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ST. GEORGE FORT SECRETARIAT CHENNAI - 600009 2 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR E.V.K. SAMPATH MALIGAI DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI - 600006 1 THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT SCHOOL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT ST. GEORGE FORT CHENNAI 01 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31584 of 2019 2 THE DIRECTOR TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD NUNGAMBAKKAM CHENNAI - 600015 1 THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP. BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION SECRETARIATE FORT ST. GEORGE CHENNAI 600 009.

... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31612 of 2019 1 THE CHAIRMAN THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD DPI CAMPUS COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 006 2 THE DIRECTOR THE TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR 33 EVK SAMPATH COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI 600 007 ... RESPONDENT in WMP No.31623 of 2019 22/43

1 THE CHAIRMAN TEACHERS RECRUITMENT BOARD 4TH FLOOR EVK SAMPATH MAALIGAI DPI COMPOUND COLLEGE ROAD CHENNAI.

RESPONDENT in WMP No.31641 of 2019 WP No.32343 of 2019 directing the 2nd Respondent to revise the Key answers to questions No. 88 and 139 in the subject Economics and award additional 2 marks to the Petitioner having Roll No. 19PG101209873 and Registration No. TRBPG702684 in the written test conducted by the 2nd Respondent for the post of PG Assistant in Economics pursuant to Notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 inviting applications from eligible candidates upto 15.07.2019 for the direct recruitment for the post of PG Assistant for the year 2018-2019 and consequently direct the Respondents to appoint the Petitioner in the post of Post Graduate Assistant in Economics in School Education for the year 2018-2019 taking the marks of the Petitioner as 75 WP No.

32401 of 2019 directing the 2nd respondent to award three marks to the Question Nos.8, 110 and 144 (Booklet Series) in the examination for direct recruitment for the post of PG Assistant for the year 2018-2019 and further direct the respondents to provide appointment to the petitioner within the time frame that may be stipulated by this Honourable Court WP No.31417 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent to declare the petitioner as qualified in the selection for the direct recruitment to the Post Graduate Assistant in Economics by awarding 6 marks to her, and consequently direct the 1st respondent to appoint the petitioner as Post Graduate Assistant in Economics as per the recruitment notification dated 12.06.2019 WP No.

31475 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent which had published the result of online examination conducted in pursuance to the notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 for Recruitment of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I, to awad 6 marks for question Nos.

(Subject Economics) in any departmen WP No.31480 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19PG101301629) in respect of the questions with question numbers 32, 112, 56, 61, 125, 71, 26, 77, 62, 45, 40, 19, 102, 150, 24 and 100 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant (Economics) WP No.31482 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent which had published the result of online examination conducted in pursuance to the notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 for Recruitment of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I, to awad 6 marks for question Nos.

24, 47, 86, 120, 125 and 142, that, that were erroneously given wrong key answers thereby denying 6 marks to the petitioner who had actually secured 73 marks, thereby enabling the petitioner to come within the zone of selection for appointment as Post Graduate Assistant Grade I (Subject Economics) in MBC / DNC - 1 category which is 75 marks and above and consequently to appoint the petitioner herein as Post Graduate Assistant Grade I (Subject Economics) in any depart WP No.31483 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19PG103202643) in respect of the questions with question numbers 69, 13, 30, 47, 85, 126, 74, 53, 114, 23, 145, 131, 25, 20, 9 and 33 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant (Economics) WP No.31484 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19PG101801106) in respect of the questions with question numbers 105, 31, 53, 144, 145, 9, 131, 107, 125, 93, 78, 47 and 5 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

WP No.31487 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19PG101401359) in respect of the questions with question numbers 7, 11, 138, 49, 137, 100, 12, 118, 129, 54, 26 and 108 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant (Economics) WP No.31488 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent which had published the result of online examination conducted in pursuance to the notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 for Recruitment of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I, to award 6 marks for 6 question Nos.

12, 39, 89, 96, 125 and 143 that, were erroneously given wrong key answers thereby denying 6 marks to the petitioner who had actually secured 67 marks, thereby enabling the petitioner to come within the zone of selection for appointment as Post Graduate Assistant Grade I (Subject Economics) in SC category which is 68 marks and above and consequently to appoint the petitioner herein as Post Graduate Assistant Grade I (Subject Economics) in any department including WP No.31489 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19PG101500260) in respect of the questions with question numbers 29, 92, 79, 51, 76, 20, 110, 13, 50 and 31 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant (Economics) WP No.31493 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent which had published the result of online examination conducted in pursuance to the notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 for Recruitment of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I, to award 6 marks for 6 question Nos.

WP No.31572 of 2019 directing the respondents to award marks to the petitioner (Roll No. 19PG101408931) in respect of the questions with question numbers 71, 11, 15, 83, 139, 26, 2, 125 and 60 in the online examination conducted by the 1st respondent on 27.9.2019 and further directing the respondents to consider the petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant (Economics) WP No.31609 of 2019 Calling for entire records pertaining to the Certificate Verification Intimation of Selected Candidates dated 25.10.

2019 Published by the 2nd Respondent for the Direct Recruitment for the post of Post Graduate Assistants/ Physical Education Directors Grade - I in School Education for the year 2018-2019 and quash the Selection process and consequently directing 2nd Respondent to conduct the re-examination in a fair and transparent manner WP No.

31728 of 2019 to direct the respondents to award appropriate mark for the questions bearing numbers 33, 34, 55, 68, 71, 97 and 116 (as per the Tentative Answer Key) and question numbers 113, 63, 35, 21, 81, 10 and 102 as per the online question paper which was assigned to the petitoiner by accepting her answers marked by her in the respective options as correct key answer based on the Text Book materials approved by the Government of Tamil Nadu and National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) and to call for the petitioner for certificate verification for the Post of P.G. Asst (History) WP No.31760 of 2019 Directing the 2nd Respondent to pass appropriate orders on my representations dated 21.10.2019 and 30.10.

2019 and to award 2 marks for not granting correct answers given by the Petitoner to the Question No 133 and 138 and to direct the Respondens to include Petitoners name and roll number in the selection List for the Post of P.G.Assistant Teacher in the subject of Tamil for Direct Recruitment of Post Graduate Assistants/ Physical Education Driectors Grade-1- 2018-2019.

WP No.31838 of 2019 directing the 2nd respondent to revise the Key Answers to questions No. 82,98,124 and 137 and award additional 4 marks to the petitioner having Roll No. 19PG071800276 and Registration No. TRBPG325539 in the written test conducted by the 2nd 26/43

respondent for the post of PG Assistant in Zoology pursuant to Notification No.10/2019 dated 12.6.2019 inviting applications from eligible candidates upto 15.7.2019 for the direct recruitment for the post of PG Assistant for the year 2018-2019 and consequently direct the respondents to appoint the petitioner in the post of Post Graduate Assistant in Zoology in School Education for the year 2018-2019 taking the marks of the petitioner as 85 in the written test WP No.31517 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19 PG101415252) in respect of the questions with question numbers 145, 13, 88, 22, 48, 33, 31, 133, 93, 37, 98, 23, 24, 44, 40, 102, 101 and 149 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant Economics WP No.31523 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19 PG101401488) in respect of the questions with question numbers 135, 138, 136, 49, 117, 29, 105, 8, 84, 97 and 103 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant Economics WP No.31527 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19 PG101650774) in respect of the questions with question numbers 31, 80, 19, 95, 43 and 85 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

2019 and further directing the Respondents to consider the Petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of PG Assistant Economics WP No.31531 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to award marks to the Petitioner (Roll No. 19 PG101408916) in respect of the questions with question numbers 41, 10, 122, 87, 25, 105, 43, 110, 39, 131 and 55 in the online examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

WP No.31550 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to revalue the Petitioners answer sheet vide his Enrolment No. TRBPG799155 relating to the examination conducted by the Respondents in Teachers Recruitment Board (TRB) vide Notification No. 10/ 2019 dated 12.06.2019 for which the examination was conducted on 27.09.2019 and consequently add 3 marks including grace marks to the Petitioner and verify the certificate verification accordingly WP No.31812 of 2019 to call for the records pertaining to the impugned Provisional Certificate Verification List dated 25.10.2019 and Final answer key dated 21.10.2019 for the appointment to the post of Post Graduate Assistants / Physical Education Directors Grade-I-20182019 on the file fo the Respondent No.1 and quash the same as illegal to the extent non-inclusion of the petitioner and consequently to direct the Respondent No.1 to allot prescribed marks and if deems meritorious include the petitioner for Provisional Certificate Verification List within the time stipulated by this Honble Court.

WP No.31860 of 2019 Directing the respondents to award marks in the Question Nos. 2,10.19,20,23,29,81,133, 138 and 141 of Booklet of the written Examination TRB -2019 in Tamil conducted on 18/08/2013 and to proceed with selection for the post of PG Assistant (Tamil) based on the revaluation with correct key answer and consequently direct the respondents to award marks in the answer book of the petitioner (Roll No.19PG 011316851) and to select the petitioner to the PG Assistant (Tamil ) based on such revaluation, within a time frame to be fixed by this Honourable Court.

WP No.31329 of 2019 Directing the Respondents to revalue the Petitoners answer sheets vide his Enrolment No TRBPG956216 relating to the examination conducted by the Respondents in Teachers Recuritment Board (TRB) VIDE notification No 10/2019 DATED 12.6.2019 for which the examination was conducted on 27.9.2019 and consequently add 6 marks including grace marks to the Petitioner and to allow the Petitoner in the certificate vertification as per the list scheduled on 8.11.2019 .

28/43

WP No.31352 of 2019 Directing the 2nd respondent to provide 3 marks for the question Nos. 33,55 and 116 to the petitioner and also permit the petitioner to participate the provisional certificate verification in Notification No. 10/ 2019 dated 12.06.2019 based on the representation of the petitioner dated 30.10.2019 WP No.31414 of 2019 Directing the Respondent to consider the petitioner representation dated 02.11.2019 and consequently to round off the petitioner percentage mark as 45 percent and to include the petitioner name in the provisional selection list of passed candidates and consequently permit the petitioner to participate in the selection process as per the notification dated 12.06.2019 to the post of Post Graduate Assistant (Economics) in School Education and other departments for the year 2018-2019 WP No.

31439 of 2019 Direct the Respondents to award appropriate mark for the question numbers 30, 50, 55, 35, 101, 130, 16 and 44 by accepting her answers marked by the petitioner in the respective options as correct key answer based on the Text Book materials approved by the Government of Tamil Nadu and National Council of Educational Research and training (NCERT) and thereby declare the petitioner WP No.31449 of 2019 To direct the respondents to recruit him for the post of post Graduate Assistant / Physiclal Education Directors Grade I (subject-Economics) in examination conducted by the respondents for the year of 2018 to 2019 WP No.

31472 of 2019 Directing the respondent to revalue the petitioners answer sheet for the exams held for the direct recruitment for the post of Post Graduate Assistants / Physical Education Directors Grad -I, on 28/09/2019 in notification No.10 of 2019 and award the marks in the manner known to the law.

WMP No.32640 of 2019 to issue an order of Interim Direction, directing the 2nd Respondent to appoint a team of experts to scrutinize the key answers as published by the 2nd Respondent to questions No. 88 and 139 relating to the subject Economics in the written test conducted by the 2nd Respondent for the post of PG Assistant in Economics pursuant to Notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 inviting applications from eligible candidates upto 15.07.2019 for the direct recruitment for the post of PG Assistant for the 29/43

year 2018-2019 and submit a report pending disposal of the Writ Petition.

WMP No.32642 of 2019 to issue an order of interim direction, directing the Respondents to reserve one post of Post Graduate Assistant in Economics pursuant to Notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 issued by the 2nd Respondent pending disposal of the above Writ Petiiton.

WMP No.32717 of 2019 To direct the 2nd respondent to keep one post vacant for post of Post Graduate Assistants notified for the year 2018-2019 till the disposal of the pending writ petition WMP No.31586 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the respondents to permit the petitioner to attend the forthwith certificate verification to the post of Post Graduate Teacher in Economics pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31475 of 2019 To direct the Writ Petitioner/ Management either to reinstate him or pay him the 17B/ last drawn wages every month from the date of filing of the writ petition till the disposal of the Writ Petiyion WMP No.

31652 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31653 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the Petitioner in Roll No. 19PG101301629 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31656 of 2019 To pass an order of ad-interim direction directing the respondents to reserve one post of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I Economics subject as far as this petitioner is concerned in the ongoing recruitment process being undertaken by the 2nd respondent in pursuance to its notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.

Physical Education Director Grade I for the year 2018-2019 in MBC /DNC-1 category, pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31655 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31657 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the Petitioner in Roll No. 19PG103202643 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31659 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31660 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the Petitioner in Roll No. 19PG101801106 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31663 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.

31664 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the Petitioner in Roll No. 19PG101401359 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

I Economics subject as far as this petitioner is concerned in the ongoing recruitment process being undertaken by the 2nd respondent in pursuance to its notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 to fill-up the posts of Post Graduate Assistant / Physical Education Director Grade I for the year 2018-2019 in the SC category, pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31667 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31668 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the Petitioner in Roll No.

19PG101500260 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31671 of 2019 To pass an order of ad-interim direction directing the respondents to reserve one post of Post Graduate Assistant Grade I Economics subject as far as this petitioner is concerned in the ongoing recruitment process being undertaken by the 2nd respondent in pursuance to its notification No. 10/2019 dated 12.06.2019 to fill-up the posts of Post Graduate Assistant / Physical Education Director Grade I for the year 2018-2019 in MBC /DNC-1 category, pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31780 of 2019 to pass an order of interim injunction restraining the respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st respondent on 27.9.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31782 of 2019 to pass an order of interim direction directing the 1st respondent to permit the petitioner in Roll No. 19PG101408931 to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 6.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31814 of 2019 To Dispense with the production of Certificate Verification Intimation of Selected Candidates dated 25.10.

Graduate Assistants/ Physical Education Directors Grade - I 2018-2019 WMP No.31815 of 2019 To pass an Interim Stay of all further proceedings in respect to the Certificate Verification Intimation of Selected Candidates dated 25.10.2019 Published by the 2nd Respondent for the Direct Recruitment for the post of Post Graduate Assistants/ Physical Education Directors Grade - I in School Education for the year 2018-2019, pending disposal of the main writ petition WMP No.31817 of 2019 To direct the 2nd Respondent to furnish the Caste/ Community based Quota wise marks awarded by the Respondents in the Examination conducted by the 2nd Respondent on 20.09.

2019 for the Selection of Direct Recruitment for the post of Post Graduate Assistants/ Physical Education Directors Grade - I in School Education for the year 2018-2019 pending disposal of the main writ petition WMP No.31933 of 2019 direct the 3RD respondent to keep one post in P.G. Asst (History) for the petitioner in filling up the post of P.G. Assistant (History) to be held on 8.11.2019 and 9.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31979 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim stay of conducting certificate verifications on 8.11.2019 and 9.11.2019 for the tamil Subject in all 11 Districts pending final disposal of the main Writ Petition.

WMP No.31981 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction directing the Respondents herein to keep one Seat vacant in the subject of Tamil of P.G.Assistant Teacher, Pending final disposal of the Main Writ petition.

WMP No.32079 of 2019 to issue an order of interim direction, directing the 2nd respondent to appoint a team of experts to scrutize the key answers as published by the 2nd respondent to Questions No. 82,98,124 and 137 relating to the subject Zoology in the written test conducted by the 2nd respondent for the post of PG Assistant in Zoology pursuant to Notification No.10/2019 dated 12.6.2019 inviting applications from eligible candidates upto 33/43

15.7.2019 for the direct recruitment for the post of PG Assistant for the year 2018-2019 and submit a report before this Honourable Court pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.32081 of 2019 to issue an order of interim direction, directing the respondents to reserve one post of Post Graduate Assistant in Zoology pursuant to Notification No.10/2019 dated 12.6.2019 issued by the 2nd respondent pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31711 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.

31714 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the petitioner in (Roll No. 19 PG101415252) to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31719 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31720 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the petitioner in (Roll No. 19 PG10140188) to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31724 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.

WMP No.31725 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the petitioner in (Roll No. 19 PG101650774) to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31729 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the Respondents from making any appointments in the post of PG Assistant (Economics) in furtherance to the Online Examination conducted by the 1st Respondent on 27.09.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31731 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim direction directing the 1st Respondent to permit the petitioner in (Roll No. 19 PG101408916) to participate in the certificate verification process to be held from 06.11.2019 to 08.11.

2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31744 of 2019 To issue direction to the 1 and 2 Respondents to reserve one post in pursuant to the notification vide Notification No. 10/ 2019 dated 12.06.2019 for the recruitment of Post Graduate Assistant in the Science (Physics) Faculty pending disposal of this writ petition WMP No.32049 of 2019 to dispense with production of the Original Provisional, Certificate dated 25.10.2019 Verification list for appointments post of Post Graduate Assistants Physical Education Directors Grade-I-2018-2019 and thus render justice.

WMP No.32050 of 2019 to pass an order of Interim Injunction, restraining the Respondents from conducting the counseling based on the Provisional Certificate Verification List for appointments post of Post Graduate Assistants / Physical Education Directors Grade-I-2018-2019 pending disposal of the Writ Petition. WMP No.32051 of 2019 to pass an order of Interim Direction, directing the Respondents to keep one post vacant for appointments post of Post Graduate Assistants / Physical Education Directors Grade-I-2018-2019 35/43

pending disposal of the Writ Petition.

WMP No.32106 of 2019 To issue an interim direction, directing the respondents to permit the petitioner to the participate the certificate verification and reserve one PG Assistant (Tamil ) Post vacancy, pending disposal of the above writ petition. WMP No.31491 of 2019 To issue direction to the 1 and 2 Respondents to reserve one post in Pursuant to the notification vide notification No 10/2019 DATED 12.6.2019 for the recruitment of post Graduate Assistant in the Science (physics) Faculty pending disposal of this Writ Petition WMP No.31530 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Injunction restraining the 2nd respondent from all further proceedings in Notification No. 10/ 2019 dated 12.06.2019 of the 2nd respondent till the pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31531 of 2019 To pass an order of Interim Direction thereby directing the 2nd respondent to keep one post vacant in Notification No. 10/ 2019 dated 12.06.2019 till the pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.31584 of 2019 To pass an Interim Direction directing the respondents to permit the petitioner in the Certificate Verification to be held on and after 08.11.2019 pending disposal of the writ petition WMP No.31612 of 2019 To direct the 3rd Respondent to call for the Petitioner for certificate verification for the post of P.G. Assistant (Economics) to be held on 08.11.2019 and 09.11.2019 pending disposal of the above writ petition WMP No.

31623 of 2019 To grant an order of ad-interim direction, to direct the respondents to keep a post of post Graduate Assistant / Physical Education Directors Grade-I (Subject Economics) pending disposal of the present writ petition WMP No.

direct recruitment for the post of Post Graduate Assistants / Physical Education Directors Grad -I, in notification No.10 of 2019 and permit the petitioner participate in the certificate verification pending disposal of the writ petition. In WP.No.32343 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mrs.Nalini Chidambaram, Senior Counsel for Ms.C.Uma For Respondents: Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.32401 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.Krishna Prasad For Respondents: Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1, R3 & R4) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31417 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.K.Balu For Respondents: Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31517 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.G.Prabhu Rajadurai For Respondents: Mr.V.Kadirvelu, (for R2) Special Government Pleader : Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R1 & R3) Special Government Pleader.

37/43

In WP.No.31550 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.R.Balaguruswamy For Respondents : Mr.C.Munusamy, Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31812 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.S.Leninprabhu For Respondents : Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R1) Special Government Pleader.

: Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R2) Government Advocate.

In WP.No.31860 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.D.Lakshmipathy For Respondents : Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31329 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.R.Balaguruswamy For Respondents : Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R1 & R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31352 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.K.Murugesan For Respondents : Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31414 of 2019:

For petitioner : M/s.T.Fenn Walter Associates 38/43

For Respondents : Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31439 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.V.R.Appaswamee For Respondents : Ms.P.Kavitha, (for R1 & R2) Government Advocate.

: Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R3) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31449 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.C.Girish Babu For Respondents : Mr.C.Munusamy, (for R1 & R2) Special Government Pleader.

In WP.No.31472 of 2019:

For petitioner : Mr.M.Sathish Kumar For Respondent : Mr.C.Munusamy, Special Government Pleader.

ORDER

Since the issues involved in these Writ Petitions are one and the same, these Writ Petitions are heard together and disposed of by way of this common order.

2.These Writ petitions have been filed seeking a direction to the respondents to award additional marks in the on-line examination conducted by the first respondent on 27.09.2019 and further direct the respondents to consider the petitioners candidature for appointment to the post of P.G. Assistant in various subjects.

3.The petitioners participated in the selection process conducted by the Teachers Recruitment Board for appointment to the post of P.G. Assistant in various subjects. The selection was conducted through on-line examination by objective type 39/43

questions for 150 marks. The minimum marks for being considered for appointment for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes is 68 marks and for others is 75 marks. The Teachers Recruitment Board published the key answer on 03.10.2019. The petitioners have written the correct answer as per the standard books in the relevant subjects, however, they were not awarded any marks for such questions. The petitioners are entitled to marks for the said questions and if such marks are awarded to them, they will be eligible for being considered for appointment to the post of P.G. Assistant. The Teachers Recruitment Board has not selected the candidates for entire vacancies published by them and still there are some vacancies. Under such circumstances, the petitioners have come up with these Writ Petitions for the relief stated above.

4.The learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the respondents/TRB would contend that the notification was issued on 12.06.2019, fixing the last date for submitting the applications on 15.07.2019, and written examination was conducted on 27.09.2019. The Teachers Recruitment Board published the tentative key answer on 03.09.2019 inter alia inviting objections on or before 07.10.2019. The Teachers Recruitment Board received 11,000 objections from the candidates. The Teachers Recruitment Board constituted an Expert Committee to consider the objections received from the various candidates. The Expert Committee scrutinized all the objections received on 21.10.2019 by following the procedure, without any discrimination. Some of the petitioners have also given objections within the time stipulated by the Teachers Recruitment Board.

The Special Government Pleader further contended that the key answer to the questions were prepared in consultation with the experts in the subject. The objections received from the candidates will be examined and appropriate orders will be passed by the expert. While so, this Court need not interfere with the claim of the petitioners for awarding additional marks purportedly on the basis that there is a mistake in the key answer given by the expert. In support of his contention, he relied on the following Judgments:- "1.In Ram Vijay Singh and others Vs.

2.In Kanpur University and others Vs. Samir Gupta and others reported in AIR 1983 SC 1230 : (1989) 2 SCALE 89 : (1983) 4 SCC 309 : (1984) 1 SCR 73;

3.In Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission through its Chairman and another Vs. Rahul Singh and another reported in (2018) 7 SCC 254;

4.In A.Arthi Vs. The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission in W.P.Nos.19276 and 19281 of 2018"

40/43

5.Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and the learned Special Government Pleader and the learned Government Advocate appearing for the respondents. 6.From the materials on record and rival submissions of the parties, it is clear that there were disputes with the regard to correctness of the key answer given by the Teachers Recruitment Board. According to the petitioners, the key answer to the questions mentioned are wrong as per standard books published in the relevant subjects. The said contentions are disputed by the learned Special Government Pleader and the learned Government Advocate. It is no doubt true that for ascertaining the correctness or otherwise of the marks awarded to certain questions, the respondents, constituted an Expert committee.

The expert committee has also received objections are those objections will be considered. While so, this Court, in exercise of the power conferred under Article 226 of The Constitution of India, cannot decide the disputed question of facts in the Writ proceedings, especially, the key answers were prepared by the expert in the relevant subjects. However, in order to render substantial justice, this Court is of the view that the petitioners must be given an opportunity to substantiate their case, so that, in the event of their succeeding in getting awarded additional marks, they will become eligible for appointment.

7.For the above reason, the Teachers Recruitment Board is directed to constitute an Expert Committee in the subjects, which are under challenge in the present Writ petitions on or before 25.11.2019, consisting of the members, who are not in the earlier committee. The petitioners are directed to submit their objections on or before 21.11.2019 along with materials, which they relied on in respect of their claims that the key answers not correct. On receiving such objections, the Expert Committee is directed to consider the objections and take a decision on or before 28.11.2019.

8.With the above directions, all the Writ Petitions are disposed of. No costs. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

-s/d- Assistant Registrar True Copy Sub-Assistant Registrar klt 41/43

To 1.The Director of School Education, Directorate of School Education, DPI Campus, College Road, Chennai - 600 006.

2.The Chairman, Teachers Recruitment Board 4th Floor, EVK Sampath Maaligai, College Road, Chennai - 600 006.

3. The Secretary to Government Government of TamilNadu Higher Education Department secretariat Chennai 4.The Secretary School Education fort The State of Tamil Nadu St.George Chennai-9 5.The Director of School Education DPI Campus 17 college Road Nungambakkam Chennai-8 6.The Member Secretary Teachers Recruitment Board 4th floor E.V.K Sampath Maaligai DPI Campus College road, Chennai-6 7.The Chairman Teachers Recruitment Board (TRB) College Road Near Sankara Nethralaya -Subba Road Avenue Nungambakkam Chennai-600 006 8.The Joint Director of School Education Higher Secondary, DPI Campus, College road, Chennai-6 9.The Principal Secretary to government of Tamil Nadu Department of School Education St.Fort George chennai-6 42/43

+4 ccs to M/s.M.Purushothaman Advoccate sr95892 +1 cc to M/s.K.Balu advocate sr97207 +2 ccs to M/s.M.Dharani Dharan Advocate sr95943 +1 cc to M/s.A.Prakash advocate sr95872 +3 cc to M/sG.Prabhu Rajadurai Advocate sr96007,96008,96009 +2 ccs to M/s.C.Uma Advocate sr95935,95934 +1 cc to M/s.B.Krishna prasad Advocte sr95871 +1 cc to M/s.M.Sathish Kumar Advocate sr96665 +1 cc to M/s.D.Lakshmipathy Advocate sr96763 +7 cc to Government pleader sr97095,97051, 97050,97094,97089,97052,97092 W.P.Nos. 32343, 32401, 31417, 31475, 31480, 31482, 31483, 31484, 31487, 31488, 31489, 31493, 31572, 31609, 31728, 31760, 31838, 31517, 31523, 31527, 31531, 31550, 31812, 31860, 31329, 31352, 31414, 31439, 31449, 31472 of 2019 and WMP.Nos.32640, 32642, 32717, 31586, 31475, 31652, 31653, 31656, 31655, 31657, 31659, 31660, 31663, 31664, 31665, 31667, 31668, 31671, 31780, 31782, 31814, 31815, 31817, 31933, 31979, 31981, 32079, 32081, 31711, 31714, 31719, 31720, 31724, 31725, 31729, 31731, 31744, 32049, 32050, 32051, 32106, 31491, 31530, 31531, 31584, 31612, 31623, 31641 of 2019 aa22/11/2019 43/43