Dr.K.Aravindan, v. The Government Of Tamil Nadu

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 18.01.2024

CORAM:

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE G.K.ILANTHIRAIYAN and WMP.Nos.35891 of 2023 & 1059 of 2024 1.Dr.K.Aravindan 2.Dr.V.P.Suthakar 3.Dr.P.Senapathi 4.Dr.S.Ayyappan 5.Dr.N.Sugavanam 6.Dr.V.Natarajan 7.Dr.P.Alamalarathan 8.Dr.P.Karthik 9.Dr.K.Jayaraju 10.Dr.K.Vijayakumar 11.Dr.T.Ponraj 12.Dr.K.Sureshkumar 13.Dr.V.Sathiyaraj 14.Dr.P.Sankarganesh 15.Dr.M.Senthilkumar 16.Dr.M.Thirumurthi 17.Dr.P.Arulmurgan 19.Dr.B.Anandaraj 19.Dr.K.Anbalagan ... Petitioners Vs.

1.The Government of Tamilnadu, Represented by the Principal Secretary to Government, Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries Department, Secretariat, Chennai 600 009

2.The Director, The Office of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services, No.571, Anna Salai, Nandanam, Chennai 600 035 3.The Secretary, TNPSC, Flower Bazaar Road, Parrys, Chennai-104 4.DR.A.R.ABBAS 5.DR.I.AADIL 6.DR.C.RAVIKUMAR 7.DR.K.DHANUSAADIITYAA 8.DR.S.RAMESH 9.DR.M.SUGUMAR 10.DR.M.THAMARAISELVI 11.DR.S.SANGAVAI 12.DR.K.SELVALAKSHMI 13.DR.M.S.ASWATH 14.DR.V.MOZHIARASI 15.DR.M. VIMALKUMAR 16.DR.E. EBEN TITUS 17.DR.G. DHAARANI 18.DR.S.R.DHAYASUNDHAR 19.DR.M.SHANMUGASUNDARAM 20.DR.M.ARUN KUMAR 21.DR.N.NEELADEVI 22.DR.P.ESAIVANI 23.DR.R.DINESHKUMAR 24.DR.R.NAGULSAMY 25.DR.M.SUNILVARMA 26.DR.S.MUTHU MARI 27.DR.P.KOWSHALYA 28.DR.M.SIVARANJANI 29.R.M.AJAY ESWARR 30.DR. S. MANISHDA 31.DR.V.RAVI KUMAR 32.DR.S.GOKUL PRASATH 33.DR.S.DHIVIYA

34.DR.R.SHANKAR 35.DR.S.MEHARAJ 36.DR.R.B.VENGHATESH 37.DR.J.PARTHIBAN 38.DR.M.PRIYA 39.DR.M.PRAKASH 40.DR.M.TAMILARASAN 41.DR.ABRAR BASHA MHS 42.DR.S.ASMITHA 43.DR.S.GEORGE IMMANUEL 44.DR.A.GOWSALYA 45.DR.K.HARI PRASAD 46.DR.R.ISHWARYA 47.DR.R.KARTHICK 48.DR.P.KARUPPAIYA 49.DR.S.KATHIRAVAN 50.DR.M.MARUTHA MUTHU 51.DR.G.NITHYA 52.DR.S.R.PRASHANTHINI 53.DR.K.RAJESH KUMAR 54.DR.K. RAJESHWARI 55.DR.M.RAJKUMAR 56.DR.T.RAMACHANDHRAN 57.DR.K.RAVIPRATHAP 58.DR.T.SABARI 59.DR.K.SELVAKUMAR 60.DR.SENTHAMILSELVI 61.DR.S.SIVA 62.DR.K.SIVASANKAR 63.DR.V.SUNDAR 64.DR.A.THAMIZHARASI 65.DR.V.UMANATH 66.DR.P. VALAVAN 67.DR.VANJIKODI 68.DR.R.VISHNU PRABHU 69.DR.V.KAVIVENDAN 70.DR.M.BABU 71.DR.K.A.SHOBIKA

72.DR.R.POWNKUMAR 73.DR.S.ABINAYA 74.DR.V.R.SANTHOSH 75.DR.K.KIRUBANANDHAN 76.DR.K. A T. RAJARAJAN 77.DR.R.AJAYLAKSHMAN 78.DR.K.R.PONSIVASHANKARI 79.DR.B.RAGUPATHI 80.DR.G.SATHISHKUMAR 81.DR.T.S.LOGASRI 82.DR.R.NARMATHA 83.DR.R. SIVARANJANI 84.DR.I.SHARMILA 85.DR.K. K. NIVETHITHA 86.DR.S.SONIA 87.DR.M.ARAVIND 88.DR.S.SANTHOSHKUMAR 89.DR.R.PRADEEPA 90.DR.K.KALAIYARASI 91.DR.S.SARAN 92.DR.A.MOHAMED ANAS 93.DR. L. MAYAVAN 94.DR.V.PRIYANKA 95.DR.S.SANKAVI 96.DR.P. SARANYADEVI 97.DR.R.SUBHA 98.DR.N.ELANGIA 99.DR.S.SUREKA 100.DR.A.AJITH KUMAR 101.DR.R.INDUMATHI 102.DR.MAHALAKSHMI 103.DR.THIRUNAVUKARASU 104.DR.R.KANAGARAJ 105.DR.P.TAMILVANI 106.DR.R.ARAVIND 107.DR.V.ARVIND 108.DR.K.ELAIYANELAVAN 109.DR.M.PRINCE

110.DR.R.KOKILA 111.DR.G.SILAMBARASAN 112.DR.A. MUTHAMILSELVI 113.DR.PRATICKSHAA. P 114.DR.M.NIVETHA 115.DR.KISHOREKUMAR 116.DR.K.ISAIVANI 117.DR.M.AJITH 118.DR.R.AMIRDHAVALLI 119.DR.S.ANITHA 120.DR.R.ARUNESH KUMAR 121.DR.S.J.ARUNKUMAR

122. DR.R.ARUNTHATHI

123. DR.M.AYESHA 124.DR.BOSEGANDHI 125.DR.D.DHIVYABHARATHI 126.DR.D.DINESH 127.DR.DIVYARAJASELVI 128.DR.M.ELAVARASAN 129.DR.S.GIRIDHARAN 130.DR.R.GOKUL 131.DR.T.GOKUL 132.DR.T.V.HARI PRASAD 133.DR.K.HARSHA 134.DR.N.INDUMATHI 135.DR.J.JAYALAKSHMI 136.DR.J.KARTHIKEYAN 137.DR.S.MANORANJITHA 138.DR.C.MOUNIKA 139.DR.M.MUHAMMED NAWAZ 140.DR.S.MUKESH 141.DR.A.OVIYA 142.DR.K.PRADEEP 143.DR.M.POOVARASAN 144.DR.R.SASIREKA 145.DR.D.SIVA 146.DR.N.SONALI 147.DR.K.SRINIVASAN

148.DR.S.SUBHALAKSHMI 149.DR.M.THIRUMENI 150.DR.K.VIGNESHKUMAR 151.DR.V.A.VIJITHRA 152.DR.K.VIMALKUMAR 153.DR.S.YUVABALAKUMAR 154.DR.K.AJITHKUMAR 155.DR.R.ARUNKUMAR 156.DR.P.BALAJI 157.DR.U.N.DEVARAJ 158.DR.S.GOKUL 159.DR.S.KANDASAMY 160.DR.T.KANIMOZHI 161.DR.D.KARTHIKA 162.DR.M.KAVITHA 163.DR.M.KRISHNAN 164.DR.B.LOKESH SHARMA 165.DR.N.MADHANRAJ 166.DR.N.MANIMARAN 167.DR.S.MOHAMMED ZUBAIR 168.DR.K.PRATHAP 169.DR.V.PRATHAP 170.DR.R.PRAVEEN PRATHAP 171.DR.K.RAGUL 172.DR.R.RUTHRAKUMAR 173.DR.G.SATHRIYAN 174.DR.S.SENTHAMIZHAN 175.O. T.M.KOMARASAMY 4/48 THOTTIYAPALAYAM 176.DR.L.SOWMIYA 177.DR.M.SOWMYA 178.DR.G.OVIYA 179.DR.M.PAVITHRA 180.DR.B.PRIYADHARSHINI 181.DR.K ARUN 182.DR.S BRINDHA 183.DR.S DHINOSUDARSAN 184.DR.M.ENIYAMATHI 185.DR.G.GANESHAN

186.DR.M.GULSAN 187.DR.K M HARIMAGESH 188.DR.S JONES DENISON 189.DR. A. KABILESH 190.DR.V.KIRUBHAKARAN 191.DR.P.KOWSALYA 192.DR.R.KOWSALYA 193.DR.N.MALINI 194.DR.U.MANIKANDAN 195.DR.S.MANJUBASINI 196.DR.T.S. MUKILARASU 197.DR.D. NANTHAKUMAR 198.DR.S.PARAMESHWARI 199.DR.N.POOVITHA 200.DR.N.PRADHEEP 201.DR.N.P.PRADHEEP 202.DR.V.PREMKUMARI 203.DR.G.PRIYADHARSHINI 204.DR.V.PUSHPALATHA 205.DR.M.RAASIKA 206.DR.T.RAGAVAN 207.DR.D.RAMKUMAR 208.DR. G. RAMYA BHARATHI 209.DR.P.SARANYA 210.DR.T.SARANYA 211.DR.M.SEENU 212.DR.D.SETHU PATHI 213.DR.S.SHANMATHI 214.DR.M.SILAMBARASAN 215.DR.G.SONIYA 216.DR.M.SRI SHALINI 217.DR.G.SUBHAPRATHA 218.DR.M.SURESHKUMAR 219.DR.K.THARANI 220.DR.G.VEDHAVALLI 221.DR.S.R.VENKATESH 222.DR.K.VIGNESH 223.DR.N.YASEEN NAWAZ

224.DR.M.SIVA 225.DR.S.SIRAJUDEEN 226.DR.A.SOWNDHARYA 227.DR.S.R.SUNDHARESAN 228.DR.M.THANGAPANDI 229.DR.C.VINUKA 230.DR.C.TAMILSELVAN 231.DR.C.VAITHEESWARAN 232.DR.C.SHANTHALAKSHMI 233.DR.V.VIDHULA 234.DR.S.SELVARAJ 235.DR.P.SINDHU 236.DR.M.SRIVIDHYA 237.DR.P.VINOTH 238.DR.E.VINEETH KUMAR 239.DR.E.LOGESHWARI 240.DR.K.SATHISH 241.DR.A.PRETHIVERAJ 242.DR.E.NANDITHAA 243.DR.C.PAVITHRA 244.DR.M.OMSIVAPRAKASAM 245.DR.B.VARSHA 246.DR.O.NANDHINI 247.DR.J.THARANI 248.DR.PTHIRUMURUGAN 249.DR.K.KARTHIKA 250.DR.T.MALATHI 251.DR.R.KAMALESH 252.DR.J.LOGANATHAN 253.DR.T.MANIKANDAN 254.DR.S.MAHI BALAN 255.DR.S.KARTHICK 256.DR.S.J.KOMATHI 257.DR.S.KARTHIKEYAN 258.DR.P.KALPANA 259.DR.L.KISHORE 260.DR.S.KOWSALYA 261.DR.S.KARTHIKEYAN

262.DR.M.J.MOHAMMED ABRAR YACOOB 263.DR.D.LEELAVATHI 264.DR.R.BHARATH 265.DR.M.ARUN 266.DR.S.NAVEEN KUMAR 267.DR.P.SRINESH 268.DR.S.MANIKANDAN 269.DR.M.PARTHEBAN 270.DR.A.KRISHNAPRIYA A 271.DR.S.BALAMURALI 272.DR.R.RAM PRASATH 273.DR.E.KARTHIK 274.DR.S.SANDHANA KRISHNAN 275.DR.D.ABARNA 276.DR.D.ABIRAMI 277.DR.S.KALAIPRIYA 278.DR.P.GAYATHRI 279.DR.L.HARITHA 280.DR.D.BHARATHIRAJA 281.DR.G.MOHANAVASAN 282.DR.S.R.CAROLINE ZIPPORAH 283.DR.N.PRASANTH 284.DR.C.PRIYA 285.DR.E.DEEPA 286.DR.R.HARANI 287.DR.A.GOBIKA 288.DR.S.SABEEHA 289.DR.D.VETRIVEL 290.DR.E.AASTHIKA 291.DR.M.SELVAKKUMAR 292.DR.P.BHUVANESHWARI 293.DR.S.ASHOK KUMAR 294.DR.A.FIYASBASHA 295.DR.P.H.MOHAMMED YAHIYA 296.DR.R.KATHIRAVAN 297.DR.S.KAMALI 298.DR.R.SRI PRAVEEN 299.DR.S.K. MOHAMED ZUBAIR

300.DR. N. HARITHA 301.DR. T. PAVITHRAN 302.DR. S. ABINASH 303.DR. S. GOKUL 304.DR. S. GUNASEELAN 305.P. JAGADISH S/O. PERIYASAMY 306.DR. P. VIJAYKUMAR 307.DR. N. MADHUMATHI 308.DR. M. R. RUSHITHA BANU 309.DR. M. KALAISELVI 310.DR.M. HARIKARAN 311.DR. V. DURAIRAJ 312.DR.M. PRAVEENKUMAR 313.DR.R. KAVIN KISHORE 314.DR. S. GURUSAMY 315.DR. A. SURENDER 316.DR. N. SELVAMUTHU 317.DR. P. NIVETHA 318.DR. S. JANANI 319.DR. S. LOKESWARI 320.DR. B. MADHUMITHA 321.DR.C. GAKALAKHSMI 322.DR. P. ELAVARASI 323.DR. P. PADMANABHAN 324.DR. S. PRIYADHARSHINI 325.DR. E. SHALINI 326.DR.A.SOMASUNDARAM 327.DR. K. VIMALKUMAR 328.DR. G. KARTHI 329.DR. S. PIRADEEP 330.DR. S. DHARANITHARAN 331.DR. M. NAFEETHA 332.DR. N. CHINRASU 333.DR.S.ANANDHARAMAN 334.DR.N.AZHAGULAKSHMI 335.DR.P.BHAKYALAKSHMI 336.DR.M.BHUVANESHWARI 337.DR.K.DEEPAN CHAKRAVARTHY

338.DR.S.GEETHA 339.DR.S.GOBI 340.DR.P.GOKUL 341.DR.K.GOKULKRISHNAN 342.DR.V.GOKULRAJ 343.DR.M.GRACE JENIFER 344.DR.R.HAREESH 345.DR.T.JOTHIGA 346.DR.S.KAMADHENU 347.DR.E.KANAGARAJ 348.DR.G.KANIGA 349.DR.S.KARTHICK 350.DR.K.KASTHURI 351.DR.M.KAVIPRIYA 352.DR.P. KUPPUSAMY 353.DR.P.MADHUMITHA 354.DR.A. MAHABOOJOHN 355.DR.K.MAHALAKSHMI 356.DR.N.MOUNIGHA 357.DR.M. MUBARAK 358.DR.M.MUTHUKUMAR 359.DR.D.NIVETHA 360.DR.A.S.OVIYAJEETHA 361.DR.C.PRABHAKARAN 362.DR.A.S.PRAVEENA 363.DR.G.RAHUL 364.DR.K.RAJASEKAR 365.DR.S.RAVIVARMAN 366.DR.P.SAIKUMAR 367.DR.A.SANDHIYA 368.DR.S.SANGAVI 369.DR.M.E.SARAN 370.DR.G.M.SHANMUGAPRIYA 371.DR.N.SIVAPRAKASAM 372.DR.M.SIVARAJ 373.DR.G.SOWMIYA 374.DR.S.SUDHARSAN 375.DR.R.SURYA

376.DR.D.TAMILSELVAM 377.DR.M.TAMILSELVAN 378.DR.V.VASANTH 379.DR.S.VIGNESHWARAN 380.DR.A.P.JANANI 381.DR.R.ARUN PRASATH 382.DR.S.SANJAY 383.DR.M. TAMILMANI 384.DR.B. SAKTHISIVAPRIYA 385.DR.D.P. VIJAYRAGHAVAN 386.DR A.VEDHIKA 387.DR.T.HEMALATHA 388.DR.N. VINOTHA 389.DR.M.MANISHA 390.DR.R.AMUTHAN 391.DR.R.KARTHIK 392.DR.M. VETRIVEL 393.DR.E.SIVAPRIYA 394.DR.P. RAMYA 395.DR.M.GOWTHAM 396.DR.R.R.RUBIGA 397.DR.M. NIVETHA 398.DR.A.RUBESH KUMAR (Respondents 4 to 398 impleaded vide order dated 08.01.2024 made in WMP.No.387 of 2024 in WP.No.35891 of 2023) ... Respondents PRAYER: Writ petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to issue a writ of mandamus directing the Respondents herein to consider the claim of the Petitioners for allowing them to continue in the post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon with pay protection (regular time scale of pay) alone till the date of their retirement on attaining the age of superannuation without even retirement or pensionary benefits

For Petitioners : Mr.L.Chandrakumar for Mr.D.Senthilkumar For Respondents For R1 & 2 : Mr.S.Silambanan, Additional Advocate General Assisted by Dr.T.Seenivasan, Special Government Pleader For R3 : Mrs.G.Hema, Standing Counsel For R4 to 398 : Mr.M.Santhanaraman

ORDER

This writ petition has been filed for direction to the respondents to consider for allowing the petitioners to continue in the post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon with pay protection till the date of their retirment. 2.

The petitioners had acquired their B.V.Sc. degree qualification and they registered their names in the Professional Executive Employment Exchange. During the year 2011, the Government had appointed 843 persons as Veterinary Assistant Surgeon through employment exchange in order to utilise their services under Rule 10(a)(i) of State and Subordinate Services Rules on 17.05.2012 as per GO.Ms.No.137 dated 14.11.2011. Thereafter, it

was decided to subject all of them to appear in the Special Qualifying Examination to be conducted by Tamilnadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC) so as to enable them to get their services in the said post regularised with the concurrence of TNPSC subject to their clearance in the examination. Notification was proposed to be issued for competetive exam for all the candidates in the open market. In the meanwhile, notification was issued on 18.11.2022 calling for applications from eligible candidates for selection and appointment to the post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon as directed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in order to fill the vacancies by the notification No.34 of 2022. The Tamilnadu Public Service Commission prescribed minimum marks required as 171 and other categories 228.

The petitioners have scored minimum qualifiying marks. Therefore, the petitioners submitted representation to permit them to continue their post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon till their retirement without even retirement or pensionary benefits. While pending the writ petition, those who applied for the post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon as per the notification No.34 of 2022 dated 18.11.2022 filed petition to implead themselves as respondents and it was allowed and they have been impleaded as respondents 4 to 398 in this writ petition.

3.

Heard, the learned counsel appearing on either side. 4.

On perusal of records, revealed that the petitioners are unsuccessful participants in the selection process as per the notification. As directed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the selection process to be completed on or before 31.03.2023. The petitioners were originally appointed in the year 2012 as temporary Veterinary Assistant Surgeon for the period of one year from the date of appointment under Rule 10(a)(i) of Tamilnadu State and Subordinate Services Rules. The post of Veterinary Assistant Surgeon is coming under the purview of Tamilnadu Public Service Commission. The persons who are appointed under 10(a)(i) approached this Court to regularise their services by conducting Special Test and the same was rejected. Aggrieved by the same, they approached the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.

4351 of 2016 and batch, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India by an order dated 07.04.2022 passed the following orders: (ii) As far as 573 appointees under Rule 10A (many of whom are appellants before this Court) are concerned, we are of the view that they should not be permitted to be regularised in the manner proposed by the State.

relief in the following manner:

(a) the appellant-State in Civil Appeal Nos. 435354/2016 will proceed to notify vacancies including the vacancies held by the appellants before us as also all the Rule 10A appointees.

(b) The appointees under Rule 10A will be granted the benefit of upper age relaxation so that they are entitled to apply and be considered with anybody else who is eligible to apply and applies.

(c) The appointees under Rule 10A including the appellants before us will be afforded weightage of marks towards weightage of experience in the selection process. The weightage will consist of marks at the rate of 5 marks for every year, which is subject to a maximum of 50 marks. This, we are ordering on the basis of the submissions of Mr. Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel, that as far as the scheme of recruitment process is concerned, the selection is made on the basis of written examination which consists of a total of 500 marks, split up into two papers, of which, in one paper, the maximum marks is 300 and for the second paper, the maximum marks is 200. The recruitment procedure, according to Mr. Jaideep Gupta, also entails a viva voce for which the maximum marks is 70. Therefore, we proceed on the basis that the total marks on the basis of which selection is to be made is 570.

"......the appellants (the appointees under Rule 10(a)(i) shall

be permitted to continue. The recruitment process should be concluded by The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission on or before 31.12.2022. The Public Service Commission will issue the advertisement within one month thereafter. In the notification inviting applications, the Public Service Commission shall specifically indicate that Rule 10A appointees (573 in number) will be granted the benefit of relaxation from age and also the addition of weightage of marks towards their experience in terms of the order passed by this Court.

The appellants/Rule 10A appointees shall be permitted to continue.

In this regard, all the concerned departments working under the appellant (State) will report the vacancies including the 573 vacancies held by appointees under Rule 10A and any other vacancies available as per law, within a period of four weeks to the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission. Though all the Rule 10A appointees have not filed appeals, in facts, we do think that this order of benefit of continuance of all appointees of Rule 10A can be extended to all persons appointed (573 appointees under Rule 10(a)(i)). Therefore, the benefit of continuance till the selection is complete will extend to even those who have not filed appeals but who are part of 573 persons appointed under Rule 10A.

The appellants/10A appointees shall be allowed to continue till the process of selection is completed.

5.

In pursuant to the directions issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the Tamilnadu Public Service Commission issued notification No.34 of 2022. Accordingly, the maximum age relaxed and given weigtage marks of 5 for every year subject to maximum of 50 marks for the temporary Veterinary Assistant Surgeon i.e. the petitioners and others who were appointed under Rule 10 (a) (i). As per the notification, the petitioners had applied and availed the age relaxation and also marks on concession granted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Indian. Even then, they did not qualify in the selection. While pending the writ petition, the selection list has been published by the third respondent.

6.

The learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that similarly placed persons approached Madurai Bench of this Court in WP(MD).No.11599 of 2023 dated 02.06.2023, wherein directed the petitioners to submit an application along with affidavit to give up the retirement and terminal benefits before this Court as well as the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India to continue their services until their retirement with only time scale of pay without any retirement and terminal benefits. Until the outcome of the

results from the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, they may be allowed to continue in service.

7.

It is seen that no petition is pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. By an order dated 07.04.2022 the directions were issued as stated supra. That apart, respondents 4 to 398 are provisionally selected. The petitioners in the said writ petition misrepresented before this Court and obtained such direction since no petition is pending before the Hon'ble Supreme court of India in respect of the subject issue. Only contempt petition is pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India for non compliance of the directions. However, the said contempt petition is nothing to do with the present petition.

That apart, out of 573 persons who were appointed under Rule 10(a)(i), 118 got selected in the recruitment process held during the year 2019, 118 got selected in the current recruitment process during the year 2022 and the remaining 270 who were unsuccessful in both selection process have now filed this writ petition. Therefore, the directions sought for in this writ petition is against the directions issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India as their request was already denied by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. As such, the writ petition is devoid of merits and liable to be dismissed.

8.

Accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. There shall be no order as to costs.

18.01.2024 Index :Yes/No Internet : Yes/No Speaking order/non-speaking order lok

To 1.Principal Secretary to Government, The Government of Tamilnadu, Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries Department, Secretariat, Chennai 600 009 2.The Director, The Office of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services, No.571, Anna Salai, Nandanam, Chennai 600 035 3.The Secretary, TNPSC, Flower Bazaar Road, Parrys, Chennai-104

G.K.ILANTHIRAIYAN, J.

lok 18.01.2024