Antson Joseph v. The Union Of India

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED : 13.09.2024

CORAM

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MUMMINENI SUDHEER KUMAR Review Application Nos.146 and 147 of 2019 and W.M.P. Nos.20931 and 20932 of 2019 Rev.Aplw. No.146 of 2019:

1. Antson Joseph

2. M.Kanagaraj

3. K.Tamilselvan

4. R.Raj

5. N.Ravi

6. K.Panneerselvam

7. N.Thambiran

8. R.Sivavannam

9. S.Ganesan

10. P.Masanam

11. C.S.Balaji

12. K.Devendaran

13. G.S.Venkatesan

14. G.D.Dominic Pulavendhan

15. K.Shankar

16. S.Jayaseelan

17. M.Anbazhagan

18. J.Panneerselvam

19. J.Gopu

20. M.Kumar

21. M.Sivasankar

22. G.Dhandapani

23. S.Saravana Subash

24. S.Vijayakumar

25. S.Lenin 1/10

26. V.Rukumangathan

27. R.Chandrasekar

28. R.Babu

29. S.George

30. N.Vijayakumar

31. M.Varadharajan

32. T.Chinnathambi

33. D.Stalin

34. S.Sukumar

35. G.Kumar

36. M.Stephen Joseph

37. A.Dilli Babu

38. R.Nallathambi

39. M.C.Nithyanandan

40. V.S.Saravanan

41. D.Thiruvalluvan

42. S.Kumar

43. S.Marimuthu

44. V.Devaraj

45. D.Sagadevan

46. N.Venkatesan

47. N.Venkatesan

48. N.Sankar

49. S.Chellaiah

50. S.Chandrasekar

51. S.Venkataswamy

52. D.Babu

53. B.Ranganathan

54. R.Ramadoss

55. A.K.Hidhyathulla Khan

56. R.Venkatesan

57. K.M.Abdul Syed

58. S.Alexander

59. R.Jaganathan

60. K.R.Senthilnathan

61. V.Aruldoss ... Applicants/ Petitioners Vs.

2/10

1.The Union of India Rep. by the Secretary, Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India, New Delhi.

2.The Executive Director, Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company of India Ltd., NACIL-(I), Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

3.General Manager - Personnel Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company, of India Ltd., Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

4.The Regional Director, Airports Authority of India, Chennai Airport, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

5.The President and CEO, AISATS, C/o.Air India, Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 011.

6.The General Manager - Ground Handling, AISATS, C/o.Air India, Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 011.

7.The Nodal Officer, Air India, Air Transport Services, Air India Unity Complex, Pallavaram, Contonment,Chennai-600 043.

3/10

8. K.Munusamy

9. S.Murugan

10. K.Arumugam

11. J.Barnabas

12. K.Irudhayaran

13. M.Anbazhagan

14. A.Christy Raja

15. A.Vincent

16. M.Nayagan

17. R.Ethiraj

18. K.Nandakumar

19. T.Thompson Joseph

20. B.Devarajan

21. S.Bobby Derrin

22. T.Shanmugam

23. V.Thirumaran

24. K.Padmanabhan

25. C.Balaji

26. R.Kumar

27. K.Gajagopi

28. R.Jagadeesan

29. S.Venkatesan

30. B.Bernat @ B.Vasanth

31. A.Moses D'Silva

32. M.Pandian

33. P.Sekar

34. N.Palraj

35. S.Selvakumar

36. C.Ellappan

37. R.Ravi

38. P.Ravikumar

39. S.Kumaran

40. G.Viswanathan

41. V.M.Natarajan

42. R.Palaniswamy

43. B.C.Giri

44. N.Sivasankar

45. R.Thirumal

46. V.John 4/10

47. R.Ranjith Raman

48. V.K.Prakash Kumar

49. S.J.Harris

50. S.Babu

51. K.Prakalathan

52. S.Thamizh Selvan

53. D.Suresh Kumar

54. S.Manickam

55. Joseph Rajini

56. N.Ramachandran

57. K.Prakash Babu

58. E.Veeramuthu

59. J.Kumaran

60. G.Natarajan

61. N.Kuppuswamy

62. C.Prabhakar

63. M.Sadasivam

64. S.Salomon

65. M.Murali Kannan

66. G.Santhanam

67. T.Rathish Kumar

68. G.Muthu

69. R.Rajendran

70. R.Chandramohan

71. M.Moses

72. P.Balasubramanyam

73. R.Subbarayadu

74. P.Moses

75. Stephen Paul Arokyaraj

76. S.Zackiyar's Jayakumar

77. S.Parthasarathy

78. I.Ramesh Babu

79. M.Senthil Kumar

80. A.Swarup Kumar

81. D.Rajinikanth

82. K.Selvaraj

83. G.Suresh

84. S.Amal Raj

85. S.Krishnan 5/10

86. A.Arul Murugan

87. S.Ragunathan

88. R.Ranjan

89. L.Vasanth Kumar

90. R.Sundaram (As no relief sought for from Respondents 8 to 90 may be given up) Rev.Aplw.No.147 of 2019:

1.P.Jagan 2.V.Bakthavatsalu 3.P.Dillibabu 4.V.Kanniyappan ...Applicants / Petitioners Vs.

1.The Union of India, Rep.by the Secretary, Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India, New Delhi.

2.The Executive Director, Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company of India Ltd., NACIL-(I), Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

3.General Manager-Personnel, Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company of India Ltd., Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

4.The Regional Director, Airports Authority of India, Chennai Airport, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

5.The President and CEO, AISATS, C/o,Air India, 6/10

Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 001.

6.The General Manager-Ground Handling, AISATS, C/o.Air India, Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 001.

7.M.Ramesh Babu 8.M.Mohammed Usama 9.C.R.Dharanivasu

...Respondents

(As no relief sought for from the Respondents 7 to 9 and may be given up) PRAYER in Rev.Aplw.No.146 of 2019: Review Application filed under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 of Civil Procedure Code, to review the order dated 28.03.2018 in W.P.No.17513 of 2010.

PRAYER in Rev.Aplw.No.147 of 2019: Review Application filed under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 of Civil Procedure Code, to review the order dated 28.03.2018 in W.P.No.22212 of 2010.

For Applicants : Mr.M.Ravi (in both Applications) For Respondents : Mr.K.Srinivasa Reddy 2 to 6 (in both Applications) COMMON ORDER These two Review Applications are filed seeking review of the orders passed in W.P.Nos.17513 and 22212 of 2010 dated 28.03.2018 contending that the said orders were passed based upon the contentions made by one of the 7/10

petitioners who were not similarly placed as the applicants/petitioners in these Review Applications. Therefore, the rights of the applicants/petitioners are affected whereby the services of the persons recruited subsequent to the services of the applicants/ petitioners are preferred and also on the ground that the case was decided based on the representation made by one of the petitioner therefore the rights that were accrued to the applicants herein are being taken away.

2. In the considered view of this Court none of the grounds raised require consideration in these Review Applications. In case the applicants/ petitioners have secured any rights by any scheme or otherwise that are introduced by the Respondent organization, such rights cannot said to have been taken away by the order passed by this Court. Then coming to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the services of the petitioner herein who are seniors in service are not being preferred is concerned, the same cannot be the ground for review of the orders passed by this Court. In case the applicants/petitioners have got any such right of preference, the same may be worked out strictly in accordance with law independently subject to the above observations.

8/10

3. Accordingly, the Review Applications are disposed of. No costs. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. 13.09.2024 Speaking (or) Non Speaking Order Index : Yes/ No mka To:

1.The Secretary,Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India, New Delhi.

2.The Executive Director, Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company of India Ltd., NACIL-(I), Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027.

3.General Manager - Personnel Air India Ltd., National Aviation Company of India Ltd., Airlines House, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027. 4.The Regional Director,Airports Authority of India, Chennai Airport, Meenambakkam, Chennai-600 027. 5.The President and CEO,AISATS, C/o.Air India, Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 011.

6.The General Manager - Ground Handling, AISATS, C/o.Air India, Airlines House, 113, Gurudwara Rakabganj Road, New Delhi-110 011.

7.The Nodal Officer, Air India, Air Transport Services, Air India Unity Complex, Pallavaram, Contonment, Chennai-600 043.

9/10

MUMMINENI SUDHEER KUMAR, J.

mka Rev.Aplw.Nos.146 and 147 of 2019 13.09.2024 10/10