← Library
Madras High CourtCRL A(MD)/86/2021partly allowed

Tirupathi v. The Inspector Of Police

2024-09-02Honourable Mr Justice C.V. Karthikeyan,Honourable Mr Justice J.Sathya Narayana Prasad36 pages







   

  

    



    





  !

"#$%#&'





                 

  

!"

# $%&  &'$'

 

  ()* !"

 



   +,%-&.   !" 

 !

   "   

    

  

/  

&$ $$ &'$0   !

# &$  &'$$   

       1

 

   

"

 2  

 

3  !"



4 

 * 5  5 " 4  

 * 5  

     66666 $7+8



 

    9" 3 





 ""   



  +'& !        !     

  

 

 : ""

 

   $''''7; 

     "

""

   !

# &$  &'$$  /  

&$ $$ &'$0  

  !"



& 

7

 3  ,75

3 3

    "          

    

  

 3 75

3 - ,.  

 

 3 5  

& $            3  

   2  2

  3

 

 3 75

3 - ,.

&7+8

& &    

 

 

"   



 " 

         0 ''   

 

5  "    



  2

3 

5 

& +     

  &0 '8 &'$'   $$ %=   3  

   



 

 5  "

 

"     

 

  3

    & > 

 

 

5    "       

5  

3 

   

3 

3 ""   



   +'& !

& %



 "

  

      ?"

 $   <$, 3   

"

)? )?

 $  )?

$8 "

      

@ $  5 @ 8 "  / 

+7+8

& = @      

3 2 



  +$+ !  !

   3 



 1

7      1

     

     

 





    



  





   +'& !  

"  

 :

""

     $''''7; 

  "

""

         A          

 

+       

?"



$7      

     

 "

       ''     5  3

"

"

      &0 '8 &'$' 

 "

 

      - 3 .   3  & 3     3      5 

%

  "

        3     3   %7+8

      3 

7  5     3   

 -3

  .

 3   



3   

      

3 

7    

      3     3 

 

   7 & 3       

 

5 

=         

7 $ 

   "           $ +' 

   "  3 "

 )  $    "

 $ +'   3   ?"

  3 

  

"    9 "

 B

 3         3   



 3  3   ;

?"

 ;

?"  

  ''        

3            3 

  



  3  

 

  3

    3 

   ?   

   "  

=7+8

  

     

 3  3  

 

 

?"

    @      

  

,    ?"

 & 9 3     

     $ 

  &0 '8 &'$'     $$ %=     $  "  

  "   5 3



 

  "

       

   3   3  

  3    

 3 

5   3        " 

 "

   

   3 

 5   

  

      

     



 5  

3 

 3   3  

        "         3   ?"

  

  

 ;

?" 



     "

  3  

87+8

3  

3 3   3 "

3   3 

?"

        

 



3  3

      

 

 

 3  



3  

   3  

 



$'

    ?"

"   5  "  

   +   %  

  

 "



  &   3 



B3             





$$    "  )?

 $     $   & 3 

      $87"

 ;      3 

4   

  

  +'

'8 &'$' 

3            

  "   $ +'     - $. "

       

, 7+8



" 

$& @     "   $8  

4  !"

# $%&  &'$' 

   +'& !

  3

4 "    "    1  5 # $ 

  B !

5   ?  

3   $8 



4 "    )?

 $%

$+       3 

    

$,7"" 3 3        

 

  

?"

4 "    !"

# $%&  &'$'  



   +'& !

       "

    3     

"

@    

   "  & +'   

 3 3  

  

  "D     

  

 3 "

 )?

 $=

$%     

2    

       3

 + ''  = ''  2  C7+8

 3 "

 )?

 $8         

 " "  B !

# $8%,   

    3     - $.  9 - &. 

   - =.

  

    +  

% 3   

" - 



.    - 0.

  

   5

37 , -





. -3  

.

  

    

" @  - ?"

.   

 - 0.

  

   3   5 - ?"

. 5 - $$. 5 "   "" - 

?"

.

$= @ +'

'8 &'$'   "  = ''    



 

 -5 @ +. "    "

  

3    -5 @ %.

    

 +'

'8 &'$'  

   % ''         

" @    

 - 0.



     -)?

 8.

      -)?

 8.  

3 

 

  07+8

   & > 

 3

  3  

 

""   

 3    

    

3   

3

  3 "

 5 @ $    3 3     

3 "

 5 @ =

$8  $,  D

"  /  

 4" E 0$ 

3

"

  /  5 !  3

 

3

  -5 @ $.   

 -5 @ =. 3  

   ?"   



        

 " " 

?"

9  F - $=. 3  

"

$, @ &C ', &'$'  

 "  

   ?"

  

?  " -

$&.

@ $8 'C &'$'  

    - C. "

)

 "

 3 

 

  3  

 3  

  "

  

 @ '8 $'

&'$'  $, "



   

   

3 $' 7+8

""   



   +'& !

$C



1  5 #  

 



 D        !

# +8  &'$'  

   

   &', !  !



   

$0     3   



  +'& ! 3 3 

? 

   !    

""

        !

    

 "

3 

     !

# &$  &'$$

&'

 " 3     

 2  "  $   &        

  

    ?"

  - 0. 3 3 3         "D  

     ?"

 , "  

  3       "

   

 

  " 3  

 "  /   

   

$$7+8

 



  1

 5 @ 8 -0 .

&$     ?"

 $$ 5 " 

5 !     3  

    

?"   "  /      "   

"

 - $&. 3   ?"

  3 "

)?

 0  $'   $$

&&

 

       3 3 "

 

3 

   +'& !



   "

  

  

3 3  

    

 





  1

    



 

 

  &0 '8 &'$' 

5   "

"

    $  &       

  $$ %=        3    3          3 

5   3     

" 

 " 3 5 @ $ E 3

 





 3 

 

    

$&7+8

 

3    



  

 



&+



  1

   

 

$   & 

   3 

   





  1

 

       "  )?

 $



            3  4 "   

  

3 

   $ +'  4 "    "  

 3

  /  5  3    

  

  "  + +'    



  1

3  

   2          ""



       "  -)?

 $. 



 4 -)?

 $%. 

  

 3

 

/  5

&%



  1

 

  / 

  9  F - $=. 3   

" 

" "   -)?

 $+.

   )?

 $+ $+7+8

3

3   ? / G  

 

 

   

   

        

   

      

   !     

   !  

 !  "

&=           

 



        ! 3 

 

 3  3  

@     &0 '8 &'$' 

"

    $$ +'   

 



 



  3     

  

 



3   

 

"  /   

 "

 3  

 "   /  3    

      

 3     

 3 

  

 

  

   

 

 

 

B3   



  1

 

   $%7+8

?   

  

  



  +'& !

&8  "

  

 5  5 " 



!

    

  5  



         



&, 5  5 " 



!

  

 

 

?    3 3 

 



     $$ %=     

     

    3   3 - 3

 

. 3   

 

 



!

  ?  

 

     3 3    "

 & > 

   

       



!

 3

 



      

 /       

 3     

    



!



 

 

/  3



 



!

    

  ! 

$=7+8



     

"

  "  "

 

       

  

"

  3 



 3 3  

 

  

3     

            

    

 

  ! 

 3 



  

&C



!

  

    



  /   

 

 

 





 ! "  3   BH

 ! 

?"

"



 

       ""

  3 3  



      3 

  BH

 !    



   

   +'%   !       



   

  +'& !  



     



   +'%   !   ""

    

&0 5  



     3 





  

     



$87+8



     

    

  /       

3 

 



  " 

         

   /  

 

   3 

  

  /  

  

 

      3   

     

      3     ""    3 

 

+'



       

    3    

 "    

     

3       

 

 



  $   & 3 

   

   3 



 

   3     3        

  " "

     0 ''  



 "

       "      

        3 

 

 "          3 



3

$, 7+8

+$



       

     

?"

 ,  " 

  )

 F 3 

  3  3         

3             



     3   

      

     

 

 

 3  3

 

3      

  "     

 "   "

 

 

    3

  3    -5 @ $.      



 3  

-5 @ =.  

  3

     3 

 

     

    B3    

     3  

 



 "

3     

+&



     

 

  

  2  

 "  "

3  



 

     $$ %=      &0 '8 &'$' 

 3 3   

 " 3 

   $   & 3    

 3 3  

 

$C7+8

 

    



 3

    

  

  ""



    

"  



 4 "   

  

"

 3

 



1  5 #  



++  3   

 



       2 3  3   

 

 

 "

3        "

3 

   



  /  3

 

   

   3   

    

 

 

    

     

  +'%   ! 



  1



   

  

  



   +'& !

+%   

 

"

  

 

"  

$07+8

+=

 "

  , -5

3.

  

          

  5

3 -

,. 

   

 

 

 3 

75  3    

   "



 "

   

  "    

"   



 

3 

 "      

 ''  3  3  2

3

 

+8 @ &0 '8 &'$'   $$ %=     3  

"

   



 

 

  3              3 

  "

  3 

    

   "

      

  3  3

 

?

 

3

    "    3



     

"

  

  "

3    5

3 - ,.

 3    

4"    $$ %=   

  3     

      

 

       3       



&'7+8

 ?       " 3   

/ 

 

"  /  3 5 @ $  3

   & > 



+,           $   & 3

 

 "   



 3 

    

3       ?    "

   

     

 3  3  

<    3             3

 

 "         " 



 "  

 

  



3   2    3

   3  

3    

   /  3 3  

/    /  3 3

 " "        3



  "     

  

3   

3  "

#

   3 3     3    3

  3      3"   "

      

4   " 

" 

 " 

  

 

&$7+8

  "   3   3  3  

+C )?      +'' !   

3*;

#$  "%&     "%'       (      %   !

 

  

(

    !

  

 



     ) 

"

* +0   +'% !    

3*;

I +     

!  " ,-"+     

!  "%% &   

   

!

       (            

  (     &&7+8

(

   

  



! " 

!     )

 .            

     

  (   (  (

   )  ! )

 ( 



 ( 

     )

 "

J %'

 2   



   3  

  

3  "

 3 

  

   K %$



  $ "

 "    

 $      



 "

   

3   







3  

 

3

"

"

     ''    

 @   &0 '8 &'$' 

 "

"



    3     

 &    &+7+8





  &  3        

  7 &     $   +   %   3"  

" 3 

         $$ %= 

 

3  

      " 3  3  

 3 

    3     "

 " 3  3

   "   

 $ 

"

      



3 

         

4      / 

  

 "  " "    

 / ? 



 

 "



%&    ?  

?"

3  

 3 



K %+ 4" 



  $   &   

  

    3 

/  

3 

@ 

     5 @ $ 3

 

  

 3   

      

   2            

 3  " 3    

&%7+8

  

 5 @ =     "    

 "       3  



  

?   

# ?  

    

)     

     " 3     

  "    

          

   3

  3

3    3  3

 3

?

    

   "  "    

  B3      

  

 ?    3    "

 

  3 

  "

 

3 

 



%% ?    

?"

 3   3 

3    

  3 3

  3 3 

     3



   

3

  3      3K %=      

?  3

  

 

 

       "

    $$ %=       3  

&=7+8



    " 3 

3



3    3  /  

  3

  3 7 ,

   

  3



         3

  "   3  

   3         

 

   

%8   ;

?"   &  



3*;

I                J

      &  "

      -

. 3     3  3  

%,     

 3  "

73  

 

  3   

 

  "          

 

 

"    

 

 

"        0 ''  3  2

&87+8

3

  3    3 3 

 

3 

   

   

"

 

 "    3  

)      

  " 3 

       "

  3

  3 

  "    

?   

   "

    

3     3     "   

 

3 

  ? 

    "       ""

 

  

%C   /  

 



!

 



  

 

 -  

. -

  .    3    

     

3     ! !  "  3 

 3           

     "

3  "     

"  

 3 

3         

   "

 

   

  "

      3  &,7+8

H/ 0/ H  3  

   

       3 

3      3    

       3  3 77

BH

 !  

  

   3 



  3       

 

   +'& !  "    

  +'%   !

%0      

3

   & > 

  3  

3 3       

 "   



3

   

3

  3 3



  

 

3   3  

"  $ 

 &  



  /     "  $  &   

 

    3    + 

 % " "        3       3  / 

 

  

 3 3

    3 

    / 

 

  3       

   

&C7+8

   

   3 

  

/  



  3     

 

3  3

  3 3



   3   3 

   

   "

  

  

 3      



='

BH

 !   /  

   -

. 3

 3  

   

    "  



   +'& !   



   +'%   !  

 

3*;

1"  2               

    

   (   ( 

    (         

   3 , 4+'        3  ,-     44 4+'      

      

"  2!            %  !  )!

 !

    

 &07+8

    

 

)!  

  %  

    !

      !5! '  !



     "

6    

! !



  

    )                        

    

!  

!       )  !



 )

        "  4               %!

    (  

 

   

  

  7        

 !        ( 

  



   ) )  

  



     

 

   

+' 7+8

  "4 



   ) )   

         

    

 

      

!(   

               (   

       

(        

  "2     

              

  

   "2  (             5!  '  

    !  

!                  3 , 4+'"4      (   

            

   

          

          3  ,-  444+'      

         3 , 4+' 

     3  ,-  444+' "

+$7+8

=$    

3   2

       

 

 3  "

   3    "  3   3  3

3  3      2

 

 

 3

 

 3

@   

  3       "  

    3  3   3

3   

  ?  

    

  



   +'& !   

 

3      

 

"



 

  



   +'%   !

=&       

     /    BH

 !    

  -

.  BH

 !  



        ""



=+   

  

    

   





  

   , 3  

+&7+8





 "            

  

 3  ,   

 



   3"      3 3

 "  "

      ""

 3

3         /  "

  $''''7; 

     "

""

  "

   " 

 

=% 

    !  

      "     

    

  

  "     

   %&C !  !

==      !"

    

3

 

   



   +'& !   

  



   +'% ; !

  "  

  ""

      ""

 3    

   %&C !  !

    ""

   



( )*+ ( )* ++7+8

    *( 

?

*( #!!

*( # +%7+8

 $           

  

&

     5  F   5  B ! 5 

+   @  )7    5  F   5  B ! 5 

+=7+8





)







 # 1  "

 !

-5 .# C8  &'&$ '& '0 &'&% +87+8