Madras High CourtCRL OP(MD)/5657/2023dismissed

V.P.Senapathy v. The Inspector Of Police

2023-04-11Honourable Mr Justice G.Ilangovan12 pages

"#$%$&#'

(

"#)* (* $#'

+ (,-. //#( +) , )(0.

(),1# #' # /12

2#3- /(/43 /(/43 /) /1#5, /(( + -( ( 6'1##5, /(( /5/( /4/( //#( -) 0( '/ 3( )1/#(7#'- /5/( #13 #2 #1

'# - 1# )/(, #1/(4)/(#7&#'7#( -'/ #'-83/1/ 4/) 62 /(/43 (93)- -)5/()#' )-,//#( /)1#(1 ( # //#(

)30 ( : # )),#(( 50/) ;( //#( 30 /1 #)13#

# (),#((

3 34)(

-/) 1 /5/( # /4/( ,//#( -) 0( '/ )</(493)-5(#'-1)/(#7&#'7#(- '/ #'-83/1/ 4/) #2 /(/43

6 -6'1#1#5, /(( #41#5, /()/(4 --/)-#=( #'-# ( <# - /(315((05(#' 2-,//#( - /(2 # ),)) /(# - # ( 1< -/) 5, #.) ( #113,() =) 1 /5/(

. /(/5/ ( )# )# ( =. )&26 ( #- ,/(/(4 5 / )2#(%%(-0)/)#'-0#;)/ 1#5, /(21)=) 4/) /( /5##'% '# -#''(1)3( )1/#()*!0"2&2 *2*2 $%!//"2&2$2727( ' 1#5, /(4 - /(;)/4/#(2 '/( ,# =) '/ ( / =) <( 1#4(/>(1 /( #7& #' 7 0. - 83/1/

4/) #2 /(/43

(/(4 - 0#; )/ / , #1))2 - ,//#( '/

"#7&#'*0'# -/) 1#3 )</(493)-5(#'-, #1/(4)4/()-/5#( -4 #3(-(#),1/'/1#; 1-)0( /03 4/()-/5?(3 /(4-1#3 )#'/(;)/4/#(2(# 5 / )-;0(1#

14/()-/5?(- =) (#1-(1'# -/5#0-1#55/))/#(#'-0#; )/1 /5?/), 1/)/(4;#135035 -,//#(=)- (/)5/))=/- -'#

#=/(4#0) ;/#()6

$%$

&'&

! $30)93(#-2-/),//#(-)0( '/ )</(4)/5/ /'2#'1#3 )20.)/(4#3 - '1) ( 1/ 135)(1) #' - 1) /( / 5(( #-/5#' 435(2/=))305/0.

-,//#( -(#5 / -)0(1#

13 /(4 - 1#3 ) #' /(;)/4/#( # /5, /1 -/5 3(

)1/#(* % ) ) 0#;2 - '/ ) ,//#( =) '/ )/(4-1/;/ /))3-)0(4/;(1 /5/(

1# #3 @1,-2(##- 435(=);(1 -/5

&/(4#'-4 #3(-/)5(/#(/( -0#;)/1 /5/( # /4/( ,//#( )##)(# /(/1 (. )30)(/ 4 #3( '# 93)-/(4 - , #1/(4) 7(4#/(4 - #34- - 1# )(- /(4 - , /)2 -/) 1#3 -) 5 - 0#; )/ #0) ;/#( # - 93)/#(2 =-/1- /)) '#

1#()/ /#(/)=-- -/)(1-1(</'' ( ;/='

#5-;/=#'-1## /((1-#'-/)1#3 *- ( 1#3() ,, /(4 '# - ,//#( =#3 .3,#(-'#

#=/(41/)/#()#'- #(A0 3, 51#3 ;/>2!"35-/+)- , 0.- (),1# #' # /12-<<(## (/ # /1/#(2 3 / ( #- ) ! 8 $%"? ( !"

3, /((( ( 550 (1 #' B4 ''/ )2 C) (4 +) #-( /(4- !

*&$ " '# - , #,#)//#( - - )1#( 93)- ,//#( /) 5/(/(0 #(/'' (4 #3()

# #30--)1#(93)-,//#( /)5/(/(0 3- /5//#(/)--4 #3()2 =-/1- -; 0( /) (#= #34- (# # -; 0( ;/ 0 -/5#''/ /(4-'/ )93)-,//#( C-(=,, .-0#;)/, /(1/, #(-. )/1< # - , )( 1)2 0)# 3 .2 '/( - #( . - '1) ( 1/ 135)(1) -; 0( ) #3 /( - ,//#( 3 (# /( - '/ ) ,//#(2

-) #3()(#=--;0( /)= ;/ 0 #- ,//#( - /5 #' '/ /(4 - '/ ) ,//#( /) '-.#5/#)#3-'13 4 #3()(#= - -; 0( /) ;(2 /' = 11, - (= #3() -; 0( 52 -) #( . - '13

),1)(1#()/ /(4-'13 ),1)2-

,//#(=)/)5/))0.-1## /((1-#'-/) 1#3 )/(4-(# 4 4 #3(-)0(5#3# 93)--, #1/(4) #2-'/ )1#((/#( /) #(-, #'-,//#( --)1#(,//#(/) ; .=

5/(/(0 /)(#

11,0 #===/

4#-4 #3()C/- 4 # - '13 ),1)2 / -) 0( ) - - , #, ./),30 #(4)##(: #-552=-#=)(

@6 /(/) =) /0 # ,. )#5 5#(. # - )1#( ),#(( #2 - 0#; )/ : #-55 @13 #= #' # (./(';#3 #'-/)5, #.# )

-, #, .#-6'1#1#5, /(( 3- )1#( ),#(( (5 . - 6'1# 1#5, /(( / 1- #= 4(#@13) /(';#3

#' - ,//#( ( -/) =/' B 2 - ,//#(

@13- #= #' # (./(';#3 #'-)1#(

),#((A)34- #= -

4/#( /) - =/-#3 - <(#= 4 #' - )1#( ),#((2 -/) ,//#(

1(1

- #= #' # (. ( ) #3 - , #, .# #2/),3 #)#; -,#))))/#(#'

- , #, . 0=( - ,//#( ( - )1#(

),#((-5 =) '

# 3( )1/#( $#' 0.- (),1# #' # /1 =)1/ /(';#3 #'-)1#( ),#((

#&7$#' =)'/ (/( /5).=)# (/(4-0#; )/ (93/ .2 - ,//#( ( -/) =/' )# - , #, .# (-/)=/' -),))(# 2#( %#-(#; -,#))))/#(#'-, #, .# -)1#( ),#(( )#/ 1#4 (,# /1

, #1/#( (-5(/52#(%%%2-, )( 1)-)0( 4/) ( .0

4/#(-)0( 5 4/() -/) ,//#( )/(4 - -/) 05(2-0#;)/#113

(1##<, 1 ' . )2 ) , - # #' - 2 (93/ . =) 3( <( 0. -

2 /(/43 4/( 4/) 1)/( /5##'%(-0)/)#'-

1#5, /(2=/-#3(., #, )#(# 93)-0#; )/ ()' #' /(;)/4/#( =) # 0. # -/))-#=)-@ # /( ./( )#'- ( /(-/)5

/)'3 - )-(#/(4 /() #')1/#(& 14/()-/),//#(

-)0()/5, .)-=/--/)05(2-/) #''(1/))/#-;0(1#55/ - ( 1#3() ,, /(4 '# - ,//#( =#3 .3,#(-1/)/#(#'-#(A0 3, 5 #3 1/ /( - 1) #'

!" #

$ % $% !" & '# - ,3 ,#) #'

435(C- /(-/)/(1/#(0=(-#''(1#'

05(3( )1/#(1 3)#')1/#(& (- #' 1 /5/( 1#(),/ 1. 3( )1/#( 6 /) 5(/#( # 1/(4 & 2 / -) 0( ) - 5 1#50/(/#( #' , )#() # 4 5( 0=( -5/)(#(#34-2031/#(5/4--;0(<(/( ,3 )3(1 #' - 1#(),/ 1. # ' ) 6 /) 1#(1 (2 5 4 5( # 1#55/ - #''(1 /) (#34- $##302- 1(0(#)1#(#,/(/#( #( - )5( #' = - (

/#( #' '1) )3''/1/((#34-#)-- =)/),30=( - 6'1# 1#5, /(( ( -/) ,//#( #; - 0#;)/, #, .C-(-0#;)//),3@/))2 - , )( #113

(1 )/ # -; 0( <( , 1 ( ./-)0()-#( .-/)/()/4/#(( 05(2-0#;)/#''(1)/#-;0(<( , 1#2=-- - =)(.05(#(-)/#'

- ,//#( # 1#55/ - #''(1 /) 5 '#

1#()/ /#( 0. - / 1#3 # - #''(1 #'

05( 1((# 0 1/2 =-/ @ 1/)/(4 - :3 /)/1/#(3( )1/#(7 -/)=-.2- 1## /( (1- #' -/) 1#3 /)5/)) -

,//#()/(4-//),3 .'13 /))3

% 0)# 3 .2 '/( -(#(=5 /

-) 0( 0 #34- #( 1# # 93)- - , #1/(4) ;/(4#0/(-# #'/)5/)) #(5 /)2/5.

(#0, #, #(-, #'-,//#( 2#(14/( ,, #1-) -/) 1#3 0. =. #' -/) ,//#( )</(4 93)-5(#'-1#5, /('# -)1#(/5 & # 6#; 2 ,/15 4 #3() )-#3 (# 0 ( /(2 =-/ /(;#</(4 - :3 /)/1/#( 3(

)1/#(7#' /15 4 #3(/)

#=# ( /(2 0)# 3 .2 - =/

0 (# ( # - /5/( / /(4 - 1#3 ) #' - / 2 - , /)5.'/(#35 / # (=4 #3(2#)

- / , #1))2- /); .,#))/0/ /.#',, #1-/(4 -/)1#3 4/((4/(2=-/1-=/

5#3(#1

03)#', #1))#'-1#3 ( =#-/))-#3 (# 0, 5/-/)=-.2/-)0(1 '3

.) --4 #3()2=-/1- (#= /)#34-(##-; 0( ;/ 0 - '/ ) /5 0)# 3 .2 '/((#(=4 #3(#-/),//#(/)1 03)#'

, #1)) #' 1#3 ( = ( - )# 4 #3(2 -/) ,//#(/) /0 #0/)5/))

7 ( - )3 2 -/) ,//#( /) # $ # #()93( .2 1#((1 /)1

(#3) //#() 1 #) %%&'(&)')*

(@D)#

( (D)#

#2 -83/1/ 4/) #2 /(/43

- (),1# #' # /12

#3-2 /(/43

- //#( 30 /1 #)13# 3 /(1-#' )/4-#3 2 3 /

"#$%$&#'

%%'()')*