Madras High CourtWP(MD)/24168/2023dismissed

Ganesamurthy .A v. The Deputy Director

2023-10-05Honourable Mr Justice S.M. Subramaniam,Honourable Mr Justice V. Lakshminarayanan12 pages

! "

# $

%&' ( ) ( ) *%&'

" %&+ %, - ./ 0( . 1.2+ .( 3 " %.- ' % &42&++.2&4( 5 " %' / %.

( 6 *( %+( +%. / - 7%8- ' 2 - ! %&' ( / - 7%8- ' 2( .29/ 0: +22 &+.

;< ;

/ + +1- 0 2.+9 .( 2&2 .0 2&%&9+( " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( +1%., +& 2&%&92%6! +.729+ .' 6 .(=++7%& ++1 - 26' 2&4( %.62%, +&! .++( +> +6/ 2

/ +! +9.+%.0( 2&2 .0 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( ' 0 4 / %> %&( %2 %.4( +> +6/ 2:

/ + 2 .29 66+9 .( .29/ 0 2 .29( .29/ 0

/ +" +&+.%6 %&%4+.( 2.96+ 29+(! %+ %&8 &' 2%( * ( &&%! %6%2( +0&%, 1+( / +&&%2: * / + .%&9/ %&%4+.( ! %+ %&8 &' 2%(

&%6'

%' ( .29/ 0: / + - / .2?+' 29+.( ! %+ %&8 &' 2%( ! .+

+ +9 7+.0 .%&9/ !

.%&9/ ( <2&%0%4% %4%. .%&9/ %2.

( ( , @+' 8%. %' ( %' - .%2: * + 1 &' +&

5 #; .2 +22 &26+' - &' +. .296+

& 2- 2 & &' 2%( 1.%02&4 .2

- %&9+ % .2 %&' %, - (' 2.+92&4/ + + 1 &' +& : & 1. 9++' % %4%2& / +1+22 &+.A - &2%&' 1. 1+.2+ > / 29/ / % @++&427+&% +9- .22+ - &' +. !

! 9266/ + +727%6%&' +/ %@262%2 &1. 9+

9 , 16++' @0/ + + 1 &' +& %&' . +22 &+.

# . %6%8.2 / &%& . .' + 1 &' +& # . ! %/ ++ / B- , %.

' ' 22 &%6" 7+.&, +& 6+%' +.

. ++1%8( ! %&' 2&4 - & +6 .

# <% - 42( %&%42&4 %.&+.( 3 2&&+. &42&++.2&4 .8 5 " %' / %. ;

; (

3 ( / 2.- &+' - &8- 6%, ( / 2.- 7+.- , @- .( .29/ 0: * +22 &+.

;< ;

/ + +1- 0 2.+9 .( 2&2 .0 2&%&9+( " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( +1%., +& 2&%&92%6! +.729+ .' 6 .(=++7%& ++1 - 26' 2&4( %.62%, +&! .++( +> +6/ 2

/ +! +9.+%.0( 2&2 .0 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( ' 0 4 / %> %&( %2 %.4( +> +6/ 2:

/ + 2 .29 66+9 .( .29/ 0 2 .29( .29/ 0

/ +" +&+.%6 %&%4+.( 2.96+ 29+(! %+ %&8 &' 2%( * ( &&%! %6%2( +0&%, 1+( / +&&%2:

* / + .%&9/ %&%4+.( %&%.% %&8( ! .%&9/ ( .29/ 0 / + - / .2?+' 29+.( %&%.% %&8(

+ +9 7+.0 %&%4+, +& .%&9/ (

6 .( +42 &%6 29+( - / 2%/ > +.

( 2662%, %' ( .29/ 0: + 1 &' +&

5 #; .2 +22 &26+' - &' +. .296+

& 2- 2 & &' 2%( 1.%02&4 .2

- %&9+ % .2 +.2 .%.22+' %&' %, - (9%662&4 ./ + .+9 .'

1+.%2&2&4 / +2, 1- 4&+' ! +92 &

2 & 29+.+%' > 2/ ! %6+ 29+' %+' 2

- +' @0*/ + 1 &' +&%&' C- % / / + %, +%&' 9 & +C- +&60( ' 2.+9 / + + 1 &' +& : &

1. 9++' % %4%2& / +1+22 &+.A - &2%&' 1. 1+.2+ > / 29/ / % @++& 427+& % +9- .22+ - &' +. !

! 9 266 / + +727%6 %&' +/ %@262%2 &1. 9+

9 , 16++' @0/ + + 1 &' +& %&' . +22 &+.

# . %6%8.2 / &%& . .' + 1 &' +& # . ! %/ ++ / B- , %.

' ' 22 &%6" 7+.&, +& 6+%' +. . ++1%8( ! %&' 2&4 - & +6 .

# B &4 ' 2( . 1.2+ .( 3 ! - @+ / &' - .2+

5 " %' / %. ;

;

* ( *(D/ .

( %6%E2 %4%.( B%- .( .29/ 0: D +22 &+.

;< ;

/ + +1- 0 2.+9 .( 2&2 .0 2&%&9+( " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( +1%., +& 2&%&92%6! +.729+ .' 6 .(=++7%& ++1 - 26' 2&4( %.62%, +&! .++( +> +6/ 2

/ +! +9.+%.0( 2&2 .0 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( ' 0 4 / %> %&( %2 %.4( +> +6/ 2:

/ + 2 .29 66+9 .( .29/ 0 2 .29( .29/ 0

/ +" +&+.%6 %&%4+.( 2.96+ 29+(! %+ %&8 &' 2%( * ( &&%! %6%2( +0&%, 1+( / +&&%2: * / + .%&9/ %&%4+.( %&%.% %&8( %& &, +& .%&9/ (

( %' - .%2 %' ( .29/ 0: / + - / .2?+' 29+.( %&%.% %&8(

+ +9 7+.0 %&%4+, +& .%&9/ (

6 .( +42 &%6 29+( - / 2%/ > +.

( 2662%, %' ( .29/ 0: + 1 &' +&

5 #; .2 +22 &26+' - &' +. .296+

& 2- 2 & &' 2%( 1.%02&4 .2

- %&9+ % .2 +.2 .%.22+' %&' %, - (9%662&4 ./ + .+9 .'

1+.%2&2&4 / +2, 1- 4&+' ! +92 &

2 & 29+.+%' > 2/ ! %6+ 29+' %+' * 2

- +' @0 / + 1 &' +&%&' C- % / / + %, +%&' 9 & +C- +&60( ' 2.+9 / + + 1 &' +& : &

1. 9++' % %4%2& / +1+22 &+.A - &2%&' 1. 1+.2+ > / 29/ / % @++& 427+& % +9- .22+ - &' +. !

! 9 266 / + +727%6 %&' +/ %@262%2 &1. 9+

9 , 16++' @0/ + + 1 &' +& %&' . +22 &+.

# . %6%8.2 / &%& . .' + 1 &' +& # . ! %/ ++ / B- , %.

' ' 22 &%6" 7+.&, +& 6+%' +.

. ++1%8( ! %&' 2&4 - & +6 .

# ! / %&%@%6%&( %&%42&4 %.&+.( 3 %72! .- 9- .%6 5 " %' / %. ;

; D* ( 3 ( ( +7+6 1, +& 6 %+( / - 7%8- ' 2( .29/ 0: * +22 &+.

;< ;

/ + +1- 0 2.+9 .( 2&2 .0 2&%&9+( " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( +1%., +& 2&%&92%6! +.729+ .' 6 .(=++7%& ++1 - 26' 2&4( %.62%, +&! .++( +> +6/ 2

/ +! +9.+%.0( 2&2 .0 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( ' 0 4 / %> %&( %2 %.4( +> +6/ 2:

/ + 2 .29 66+9 .( .29/ 0 2 .29( .29/ 0

/ +" +&+.%6 %&%4+.( 2.96+ 29+(! %+ %&8 &' 2%( * ( &&%! %6%2( +0&%, 1+( / +&&%2: * / + .%&9/ %&%4+.( %&%.% %&8( / - 7%8- ' 2 .%&9/ ( .29/ 0 / + - / .2?+' 29+.( %&%.% %&8(

+ +9 7+.0 %&%4+, +& .%&9/ (

6 .( +42 &%6 29+( - / 2%/ > +.

( 2662%, %' ( .29/ 0: + 1 &' +&

5 #; .2 +22 &26+' - &' +. .296+

& 2- 2 & &' 2%( 1.%02&4 .2

- %&9+ % .2 %&' %, - ( ' 2.+9/ + + 1 &' +&

: & 1. 9++' % %4%2& / +1+22 &+.A - &2%&' 1. 1+.2+ > / 29/ / % @++&427+&% +9- .22+ - &' +. !

! 9266/ + +727%6%&' +/ %@262%2 &1. 9+

9 , 16++' @0/ + + 1 &' +& %&' . +22 &+.

# . %6%8.2 / &%& . .' + 1 &' +& # . ! %/ ++ / B- , %.

' ' 22 &%6" 7+.&, +& 6+%' +.

. ++1%8( ! %&' 2&4 - & +6 . FFFF .' +. / + - .> % , %' +@0

/ +.+62+ - 4/ .2&/ +1.+ +& .2 +22 & %.+ ' 2.+9 / +.+ 1 &' +& & 1. 9++' % %4%2& / +1+22 &+.

A- &2%&'

1. 1+.2+ > / 29/ / %7+@++&427+&% +9- .22+ - &' +./ +!

! 9 266/ + +727%6%&' +/ %@262%2 &1. 9+

9 , 16++' @0/ + + 1 &' +&

%&'

/ +&+4%27+1.%0+. % - 9/ - 4/ .(2 4.%&+' (> - 6' 9%- +1.+E- ' 29+ / +2&%&92%62& 2- 2 & 3@%&8 &' - @+' 60(/ + @%&8 %.+ @ - &' 66 > / + 1. 9+' - .+ % 9 &+, 16%+' . / + 1- .1 + .+9 7+.2&4/ +6 %&' - +

$+%.&+' 9 - & +6 . / + 1+22 &+.

.+2+.%+' / % %11629%2 & %.+ - @, 2+' @0/ +1+22 &+.

%&' 2, 26%.6016%9+' 1+.

& @+ .+/ + 2&2 .0 4.%&9+.%2&@+&+2 / +%11629%2 & - @, 2+' %.+- &' +.1. 9+

$+%.&+' 9 - & +6 ./ +1+22 &+.

- ./ +. %+ / %

%- .04- 2' +62&+ 2

- +' - &' +. 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 +7+6 1, +& 9( 2 @+ 66 > +' 9.- 1- 6 - 60

+9%&& 1.+ - , +%&0 - 9/ 72 6%2 &%/ 2 1 2& 2, + %&' 22 &++' 6+

%+/ %/ +%- / .22+ 9 , 1++&%.+@ - &' 66 > / +, %&' % .01. 9+' - .+ % 9 &+, 16%+' - &' +. / + 9 %&' - 6+ 2& .9+ * > +. E- ' 292%6.+72+> - &' +./ + & 2- 2 &&++' & @+ +G+.92 +' 2& 9 &.%9- %6 , %+.

+G9+1 2& +G9+12 &%6 92.9- , %&9+ > / +.+4.

2&E- 29+/ % @++&+ %@62 / +' / 982&4/ +9 & 92+&9+ / + - .&& ., %692.9- , %&9+ (/ +9 &.%9- %6 @624%2 & %.+ @+ +& .9+' 2&/ +, %&&+. 9 &+, 16%+' - &' +. / +! %- + %&' - 6+ 2& .9+ &7+.

2 & 9 &.%9- %6, %+.

2& .2 +22 & > 266 +%@%' 1.+9+' +&%&' / +@%&8%&' 2&%&92%62& 2- 2 & , %0& @+2&%1 22 & 1. +9/ +1- @629, &+02&/ ++7+& 2&+.+.+&9+@0/ + - .

/ +.+ .+(%44.2+7+' 1+.

& , %0%11. %9/ / +9 , 1++&%- / .22+ . / +@%&8 ./ + +@ +9 7+.0 .2@- &%6% / +9% +@+ ./ +1- .1 + .+' .+

2&4/ +2.4.2+7%&9+ ( %6 (2&/ +1.+ +&9% +/ +1+22 &+.

%.+ %62@+.0 ' 2&/ +, %&&+.9 &+, 16%+' 2/ / +62@+.0(/ + + .2 +22 & %.+' 2 , 2

+' 9 & +C- +&60(9 &&+9+' .2 2 9+66%&+ - +22 & %.+96 +'

#5+ 3 &' +G #5+ 3 &+.&+ #5+ 3 ! =

/ + +1- 0 2.+9 .( 2&2 .0 2&%&9+( " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( +1%., +& 2&%&92%6! +.729+ .' 6 .(=++7%& ++1 - 26' 2&4( %.62%, +&! .++( +> +6/ 2

/ +! +9.+%.0( 2&2 .0 29. (! , %66%&' +' 2- , &+.1.2 " 7+.&, +& &' 2%( ' 0 4 / %> %&( %2 %.4( +> +6/ 2:

/ + 2 .29 66+9 .( .29/ 0 2 .29( .29/ 0

! =