← Library
High Court of KeralaOP(C)/1208/2015allowed

Muhammed Haji v. Salim

2015-07-09Honourable Mr. Justice B.Kemal Pasha5 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

PRESENT:

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE B.KEMAL PASHA THURSDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF JULY 2015/18TH ASHADHA, 1937 --------------------------- I.A.NO.1076/2014 IN O.S.NO.97/2011 OF SUB COURT, MANJERI. ..........

PETITIONER:

------------------- MUHAMMED HAJI, S/O. ALASAN HAJI, PALAYAKKODAN HOUSE, MALAPPURAM AMSOM, KEEZHMURI DESOM, HAJIYARPALLI PO, ERANAD TALUK.

BY ADV. SRI.DINESH MATHEW J.MURICKEN RESPONDENT(S):

-------------------------

1. SALIM, S/O. ALASAN KUTTY, PALAYAKKODAN HOUSE, MALAPPURAM AMSOM, KEEZHMURI DESOM, HAJIYARPALLI P.O, ERANAD TALUK, PIN-676 519.

2. ABDUL RASAK, S/O. ALASAN KUTTY, MALAPPURAM AMSOM, KEEZHMURI DESOM, HAJIYARPALLI P.O, ERANAD TALUK, PIN-676 519.

3. ABDUL MUNEER, S/O. ALASAN KUTTY, MALAPPURAM AMSOM, KEEZHMURI DESOM, HAJIYARPALLI P.O, ERANAD TALUK, PIN-676 519.

4. KHADEEJA, W/O. ALASAN KUTTY, MALAPPURAM AMSOM, KEEZHMURI DESOM, HAJIYARPALLI P.O, ERANAD TALUK, PIN-676 519.

5. ABOOBACKER, S/O. ALASAN, PALAYAKODDAN HOUSE, KODOOR AMSOM, MANGATTUPULAM DESOM, PERINTHALMANNA TALUK, PIN-676 519.

6. PALAYAKKODAN KUNJARAMMU, KODOOR AMSOM, MANGATTUPULAM DESOM, PERINTHALMANNA TALUK, PIN-679 321.

7. MAIMUM, W/O. LATE PALAYAKKODAN AALI, CHUNGATHARA AMSOM DESOM, P.O CHUNGATHARA, NILAMBUR TALUK, PIN-679 334. --2--

--2-- --------------------------------------

8. RAHOOF (MINOR), CHUNGATHARA AMSOM DESOM, P.O CHUNGATHARA, NILAMBUR TALUK, PIN-679 334, REPRESENTED BY HER GUARDIAN AND MOTHER MAIMUNA, (7TH RESPONDENT HEREIN)

9. SAFA (MINOR), CHUNGATHARA AMSOM DESOM, P.O CHUNGATHARA, NILAMBUR TALUK, PIN-679 334, REPRESENTED BY HER GUARDIAN AND MOTHER MAIMUNA, (7TH RESPONDENT HEREIN)

10. PATHUMMA, D/O.ALASAN & W/O. MALAYIL CHEKKU, NILAMBUR TALUK, CHUNGATHARA AMSOM, PALUNDA DESOM, P.O PALUNDA, PIN-676121.

11. KHADEEJA, D/O. ALASAN HAJI & W/O. CHALATTIL KALLADI KUNJU MUHAMMED, MUTTIPPADI, ERANAD TALUK, MELMURI AMSOM DESOM, P.O MELMURI, PIN-676517. R1 TO R4 BY ADVS. SRI.P.A.MOHAMMED SHAH SRI.SOORAJ T.ELENJICKAL SMT.UMA SMT.P.M.MAZNA MANSOOR R5 & R 6 BY ADV. SRI.D.G.VIPIN THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 09-07-2015, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: mbr/

-------------------------------------- APPENDIX PETITIONER(S)' EXHIBITS:

------------------------------------- EXHIBIT P1:

TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN OS NO. 97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 26.3.2011.

EXHIBIT P2: TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT FILED BY THE DEFENDANTS 1 TO 4 IN OS NO. 97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 26.5.2011.

EXHIBIT P3:

TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT FILED BY THE DEFENDANTS 5 & 6 IN OS NO. 97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 26.5.2011.

EXHIBIT P4:

TRUE COPY OF THE IA NO 859/2011 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI.

EXHIBIT P5:

TRUE COPY OF THE COMMISSION REPORT FILED BY THE COMMISSIONER ALONG WITH PLAN IN IA NO.859/2011 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 17.7.2012. EXHIBIT P6:

TRUE COPY OF THE IA NO.1772/2012 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI.

EXHIBIT P7:

TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION IN IA NO 1772/2012 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI DATED 29.10.2012. EXHIBIT P8:

TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION OF THE COMMISSIONER RECORDED

IN THE ENQUIRY IN IA NO.1772/2012 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE

SUB COURT, MANJERI DATED 23.1.2013.

EXHIBIT P9:

TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN IA NO.1772/2012 IN OS NO. 97/2011 PASSED BY THE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 23.1.2013. EXHIBIT P10: TRUE COPY OF THE COMMISSION REPORT ALONG WITH PLAN FILED BY THE COMMISSIONER PURSUANT TO THE ORDER IN IA NO. 1772/2012 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 18.6.2014.

EXHIBIT P11: TRUE COPY OF THE AFFIDAVIT IN IA NO.1076/2014 IN OS 97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 25.9.2014. EXHIBIT P12: TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION IN IA NO.1076/2014 IN OS NO.97/2011 ON THE FILE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 14.10.2014. EXHIBIT P13: TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN IA NO.1076/2014 IN OS NO.97/2011 PASSED BY THE SUB COURT, MANJERI, DATED 28.2.2015. RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS:

NIL.

//TRUE COPY// P.S. TO JUDGE mbr/

B. KEMAL PASHA, J.

................................................................ O.P.(C) No.1208 of 2015 ............................................................... Dated this the 9th day of July, 2015

J U D G M E N T

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner. Notice to respondents 6 to 10 are dispensed with and heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and other respondents. 2.

Ext.P13 order is under challenge. Respondents 1 to 4 had filed I.A.No.1076 of 2014 for getting the Commissioner's report and plan set aside. By way of Ext.P13 order the court below has passed the following order: "Heard. Commission Report is set aside as the plan and report are not sufficient to adjudicate the matter. A fresh Commissioner is appointed." No doubt, the said order is not a speaking order. The court below has not made it clear as to

O.P.(C) 1208 of 2015 -: 2 :- why the plan and report were not acceptable and not sufficient to adjudicate the matters in controversy. The court below has to pass a speaking order. Ext.P13 is liable to be set aside.

In the result, this Original Petition is allowed. Ext.P13 order is set aside. The court below is directed to pass a speaking order on IA 1076/2014, after adverting to the contentions of either side.

Sd/- B.KEMAL PASHA, JUDGE ul/- [True copy] P.S. to Judge