Pattathil Kasim v. Tharammal Vanmari Narayanan Nambiar
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.ABRAHAM MATHEW THURSDAY, THE 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2015/7TH KARTHIKA, 1937 --------------------------- (IN CONNECTION WITH E.P.28/1982 IN O.S.37/1957 ON THE FILES OF SUB COURT, VATAKARA) PETITIONER(S)/93RD RESPONDENT:
--------------------------------------------------- PATTATHIL KASIM AGED 51 YEARS S/O.AMMATH, POOMALA PUTHIYA VEETTIL, P.O NADAPURAM VATAKARA TALUK BY ADV. SRI.P.K.SAJEEV RESPONDENT(S)/PETITIOENRS 1 TO 46 & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 92: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. THARAMMAL VANMARI NARAYANAN NAMBIAR KAKKATTUKANDIYIL, VATAYAM AMSOM DESOM
2. THARAMMAL VANMERI KALLIANI AMMA, KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
3. SON SREEDHARAN NAMBIAR RESIDING AT KALARI POYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM KARANDODE DESOM
4. SISTER PADMAVATHI KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
5. SISTER KUNHILAKSHMI KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
6. SISTER SAVITHRI KALARIPOYIL, KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM KARANDODE DESOM
7. SISTER SAROJINI KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
8. BROTHER RABHAKARAN KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
9. BROTHER GOPI KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
10. SOBHANA KALARIPOYIL, KAYAKKODI AMSOM, KARANDODE DESOM
11. LAKSHMI AMMA VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM
12. THARAMMALVENMERI KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM
13. THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMA VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
14. THARAMMAL VANMERI RAGHAVAN NAMBIAR VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, THARAMMAL PIN-673 101.
15. THARAMMAL VANMERI SREEDHARAN NAMBIAR VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, THARAMMAL PIN-673 101.
16. THARAMMAL VANMERI PRASANNA VADAKKAN PILAVIL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
17. GEETHA D/O.14TH DEFENDANT, THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMA THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMAVADAKKAN PILAVIL KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
18. THARAMMAL VANMERI KUTTIKRISHNAN THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMAVADAKKAN PILAVIL KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
19. SISTER DAKSHAYANI THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMAVADAKKAN PILAVIL KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
20. THARAMMAL VANMERI AMMUKUTTY AMMA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
21. SISTER JANU AMMA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
22. SISTER LEELA AMMA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
23. BROTHER BALAKRISHNAN NAMBIAR MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
24. VIJAYALAKSHMI MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
25. SISTER OMANA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
26. SISTER PADMAJA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
27. GEETHA MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
28. SARALA (D 25 TO 33 ARE LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED D 24).MARAVEETTIL NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
29. THARAMMAL VANMERI PARVATHI AMMA PUTHIYOTTIL, ERAMALA AMSOM, DESOM 673 101.
30. DAUGHTER SANTHA PUTHIYOTTIL ERAMALA AMSOM DESOM, -673 101.
31. BROTHER MOHAN PUTHIYOTTIL ERAMALA AMSOM DESOM -673 101.(D35 (30TH PLAINTIFF) LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED D34.
32. (SUP0PL.) EDOTHKANDY BHARATHI AMMA W/O.KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, SWASTHAM, IRINGANNOOR AMSOM KAYAPPANACHI DESO, VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
33. (SUP0PL.) EDOTHKANDY HARIDASAN S/O.KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, AGRICULTURSIT IRINGANNOOR AMSOM, KAYAPPANACHI DESO VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
34. KUNHIPARVATHI AMMA W/O.T.V.NARAYANAN NAMBIAR, KAKKATTUKANDIYIL HOUSE VATAYAM P.O., VATAKARA-673 101.
35. AMBUJAKSHI D/O.T.V.NARAYANAN NAMIAR PUKAYILENTE PARAMBATH HOUSE, VATAYAM P.O.
VATAKARA-673 101.
36. DINAKARAN S/O.T.V.NARAYANAN NAMIAR, KASKKOTT KANDIYIL HOUSE VATAYAM P.O., VATAKARA-673 101.
37. GEETHA W/O.T.V.NARAYANAN NAMIAR KAKKATTAKANDIYIL KANDIYIL HOUSE, VATAYAM P.O. VATAKARA-673 101.
38. DINESAN KAKKATTAKANDIYIL KANDIYIL HOUSE, VATAYAM P.O. VATAKARA-673 101.
39. NIRMALA K.
D/O.T.V.JANU AMMA, THERAMBATH HOUSE, AVALA P.O. MEPPAYOOR VIA, VATAKARA-673 101.
40. SALILA K.
VIKRAMAMKANDIYIL HOUSE, PERAMBRA P.O.
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
41. RAMACHANDRAN A.
B1-20, POLICE QUARTERS, PUTHUPETTA CHENNAI-2.
42. PREMAKUMAR A.
MARAVEETTIL, NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
43. RADHIKA A.
C/O.ANILKUMAR, KALLOOR HOUSE, MUPPATHADAM P.O. ALUVA VIA, ERNAKULAM-683 110.
44. SASIKUMAR A.
33/16, MYROR, CHITTY BABU STREET TRIPPIKEN CHENNAI-5.
45. MANOJKUMAR P.
MYNAKAM, THONDENTEVID, NALUTHARA P.O.
MAHE, PONDICHERY, PIN-673 310.
46. GEETHA P.
KARANGOTT HOUSE, PALERI P.O., VATAKKUMBAD KUTTADI VIA, VATAKARA TALUK.
47. THARAMMA, VANMERI KUNKAMMA AMMA CHEDAKKAL, MUNNUMMAL AMOM DESOM-673 101.
48. SON THARAMMAL VANMERI KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR CHATHOTH, CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM673 101.
49. SISTER LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
50. THARAMMAL VANMERI KUNHIMADHAVI AMMA PUTHANPURAKKAL, VELLOOR AMSOM DESOM.
51. THARAMMAL VANMERI SANKARAN NAMBIAR CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
52. SISTER THARAMMAL VANMERI SAROJINI AMMA CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
53. SISTER THARAMMAL VANMERI NARAYANI AMMA CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
54. GOVINDAN NAMBIAR @ BALAN NAMBIAR S/O.3RD PLAINTIFF-673 101
55. `SISTER THARAMMAL VANMERI KAMALAKSHI CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
56. BROTHER THARAMMAL VANMERI RAGHAVAN CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
57. BROTHER THARAMMAL VANMERI VENUGOPALAN CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
58. BROTHER THARAMMAL VANMERI SADANANDAN CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
59. BALAKRISHNAN S/O.5TH PLAINTIFF, PIN-673 101.
60. BROTHER CHANDRAN CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
61. BROTHER VIJAYAN CHEDAKKAL, KUNNUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM673 101.
62. NOT NAME
63. THILLERY GOPALAN ANAMBIAR KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
64. SISTER NARAYANI KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
65. SON THILLERY RAMAKRISHNAN KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
66. SISTER RADHA KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
67. SISTER RAMANI KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
68. SISTER RAJALAKSHMI KOCHERI, VILLIAPALLY AMSOM DESOM, PIN-673 101.
69. DR.T.V.NARAYANAN NAMBIAR VADAKARA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
70. T.V.KUNHIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR VADAKARA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
71. BROTHER -D0- GOPALAN NAMBIAR VADAKARA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
72. THARAMMAL VANAMERI KRISHNAN AMBIAR ONCHIYAM AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
73. THARAMMAL VANAMERI LAKSHMI AMMA RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
74. BORTHER THARAMMAL VANAMERI KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
75. BORTHER THARAMMAL VANAMERI NARAYANAN NAMBIAR RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
76. BORTHER THARAMMAL VANAMERI RAGHAVAN RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
77. BORTHER THARAMMAL VANAMERI BHASKARAN RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
78. SISTER PADMAVATHI RESIDING AT PALOLLATHIL NARIPPATTA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
79. SISTER NOT NAME
80. THARAMMAL VANAMERI KELAPPAN NAMBIAR RESIDING AT MANEKKANDIYIL KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
81. PUTHIYADUTH KEEZHALAN AMMALU AMMA KAYAKKODI AMSOM, AKKAL DESOM LEGAL HEIRS OF 39TH DEFENDANT.
82. SON PUTHIYADUTH KEEZHALAN BALAKRISHNAN KAYAKKODI ASMOM, AKKAL DESOM, PIN-673 101.
83. PUTHIYADUTH KEEZHALAN RADHA KAYAKKODI ASMOM, AKKAL
84. KURUNGOT KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR RESIDING AT MARAMKANDIYIL KAYAKKODI AMSOM AKKAL DESOM, PIN-673 101.
85. KRISHNAN VEETIL AMMALU AMMA RESIDING AT KUNNOTH, KADAMERI AMSOM DESOM LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED D1, PIN-673 101.
86. SON KRISHNAN VEETTIL KUNHIKRISHNAN ADIYODI RESIDING AT KUNNOTH, KADAMERI AMSOM DESOM PIN-673 101.
87. BROTHER GOPALAN ADIYODI, RESIDING AT KUNNOTH, KADAMERI AMSOM DESOM PIN-673 101.
88. BROTHER D0- BHASKARAN DIIUODI
89. ROTHER RAGHAN -DO.
90. BROTHER CHANDRAN -DO.
91. SISTER SAROJINI -DO.
92. PULLANCHERI THIRUVOTH NARAYANIKUTTY AMMA NADAKKUTHAZHA AMSOM DESOM LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED D 38 AND D 93.
93. DAUGHTER VARISYAKUNTYIL LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA RESIDING AT CHATHOTH, KUNNUMMAL DESOM LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED D49
94. MARARIKULAM NARAYANAN NAMBIAR
95. WIFE M MEENAKSHI AMMA RESIDING AT MARIVEETTIL, LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED D41
96. DAUGHTER RADHAV DEVI -DO.
97. BROTHER RAJAGOPALAN -DO.
98. SISTER SATHIDEVI -DO.
99. PREMACHANDRAN -DO.
100. BROTHER RADHAKRISHNAN -DO.
101. SISTER REMANI (DIED) -DO.
102. VIJAYAKRISHNAN RESIDING AT KODAKKATTUNI HOUSE, HAROSSIL, MARIVEETTIL
103. WIFE KOTHIYAPARAMBATH VENGOLI PERUVANKADIYIL KALLIANI AMMA, RESIDING AT MANHOLIKADIYIL KATTUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM LEGAL HEIR OF D 75.PIN-673 101.
104. DAUGHTER ANI AMMA RESIDING AT MANHOLIKADIYIL, KATTUMMAL AMSOM, DESOM LEGAL HEIR OF D 75. PIN-673 101.
105. SISTER KARTHYANI AMMA RESIDING AT KEZHANA, KADAMERI AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
106. MADATHIKANDIYIL PARKUM -DO- CHINNAKURUP KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
107. LEELA AMMA DO- DESOM
108. CHATTUVAKANDY NANU S/O.KELAPPAN, FITTER MOTOR MEECHANITE , KAKKATTIL VATAKARA AMSOM DESOM-673 101.
109. CHACHANATH RAVEENDRAN NAIR S/O.UNNI NAIR, MOTOR VEHICLE COACH FACTORY MADRAS (HUSBAND OF DECEASED E 55).
110. SON MARIVATTIL MANJOJ KOZHIKODE-673 101.
111. SISTERN NISHA
112. MAKKOTTATHIL AMMAD REP. BY P/A. HOLDER FATHER MAKKOOTTATHIL MOIDU KUNNUMMAL AMSOM DESOM, VATAKARA-673 101.
113. P.MEENAKSHI AMMA W/O.LATE T.V.KRISHNAN NAMBIAR, POYIL HOUSE ONCHIYAM P.O., VATAKARA-673 102.
114. P.P.SANTHA D/O.LATE KRISHNAN NAMBIAR C/O.T.GOPALAN KRISHNA (RTD), EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SILPAM, IV-396, JAVAR ROAD CHOVVA, KANNOR-6.
115. P.SOMAN S/O.LATE KRISHNAN NAMBIAR, INDIRA APARTMENT, NO.2 GROUND FLOOR, 25-RAMANANDAN ROAD, KILPARK MADRAS-10.
116. M.K.LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA W/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, MARAMKANDIYIL HOUSE KAKKATTIL P.O., VADAKARA-01.
117. M.K.VIJAYAN S/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR-673 101.
118. M.K.VIMALA D/O., LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, KUNIYIL HOUSE IKKATIL P.O., VATAKARA-673 101.
119. M.K.GIRIJA D/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, THAZHETHETTATHI SREENILAYAM, PUTHUPPANAM P.O., VATAKARA.
120. M.K.SYAMALA D/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, PORANDAYIL HOUSE, PONMERI KARAMON, VILLIAPPALLY, VATAKARA.
121. M.K.SASEENDRAN S/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, P.B.NO.11282 MUMBAI (UAE), PIN-673 101.
122. M.K.VINODAN S/O.LATE KUNHIRAMAN NAMBIAR, MARAMKANDIYIL HOUSE KAKKATTIL P.O., VADAKARA-01.
123. RAMAKRISHNAN K.
KOCHERI HOUSE, VILLIAPPALLY P.O.
VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
124. RAHDA K.
AMBATTUKUNNUMMEL HOSUE, MAILOTH P.O., THOTTIPPALAM VIA VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
125. REMANI VENGERI HOUSE, KAINATTY P.O., CHENNAMANGALAM CHORODE, VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
126. VENUGOPALAN KOCHERI HOUSE, VILLIAPPALLY P.O.
VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
127. PRASANNAKUMARI K.
SURABHI HOUSE, CHEMMARATHOOR, VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
128. RADHAKRISHNAN K.
KOCHERI HOUSE, VILLIAPPALLY P.O.
VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
129. CHANGAKANDYIL THAZHEKUNIYIL DAMODARAN KULANGARATH, KAKKATTIL P.O., VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
130. THAZATHARAMMAL DEVI KULANGARATH, KAKKATTIL P.O., VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
131. PUTHANPURAKKAL NARAYANI KULANGARATH, KAKKATTIL P.O., VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
132. VASU K.
THIRUVONAM HOUSE, NARASIMHAPURAM P.O., KANCHIKODE WEST PALAKKAD DISTRICT-678 621.
133. SASIDHARAN THAZHETHARAMMAL, KULANGARATH, KAKKATTIL P.O.
VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
134. SREEDHARAN M.K.
S/O.KALLIANI AMMA (LATE), MELESOOTHRAYIKKAL HOUSE RAMANATTUKARA P.O., FEROKE-673 101.
135. RAVEENDRAN M.K.
POOVARACHALIL HOUSE, KOOTHALI P.O., PERAMBRA KOYILADY TALUK-673 101.
136. SAJEEVAN M.K.
POOVARACHALIL HOUSE, KOOTHALI P.O., PERAMBRA KOYILADY TALUK-673 101.
137. SHEEJA M.K.
KOYLOTHUMTHARA HOUSE, MOILOTHUMTHARA P.O.
THOTTILPALAM, VATAKARA TALUK-673 101.
138. MOOSA S/O.ABDULLA, MAILOTH HOUSE, NADAPURAM AMSOM DESOM VATAKARA TALUK.
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 29-10-2015, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPENDIX PETITIONER(S)' EXHIBITS ------------------------------------- EXHIBIT P1 TRUE COPY OF SALE DEED NO 2129/2009 OF KAKKATTIL SRO EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY OF SALE DEED NO 2130/2009 OF KAKKATTIL SRO EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY OF SALE DEED NO 2131/2009 OF KAKKATTIL SRO EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 22-09-2015 IN E.P 28/1982 IN O.S 37/1957 OF SUB COURT, VATAKARA EXHIBIT P5 TRUE COPY OF PROCEDINGS IN E.P 28/1972 IN O.S 37/1957 OF SUB COURT, VATAKARA EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF INTIMATION NO RC-CA-1196/2015 DATED 30-09-2015 SENT BY THE SHERISTADAR OF SUB COURT, VATAKARA TO P.DIVAKARAN, ADVOCATE RESPONDENT(S)' EXHIBITS NIL --------------------------------------- R.AV //TRUE COPY// PA TO JUDGE
K.ABRAHAM MATHEW, J --------------------------------- O.P.(C).NO.2612 OF 2015 ----------------------------------- Dated this the 29th day of October 2015
J U D G M E N T
------------------ Petitioner is the 93rd respondent in EP.28 of 1982. The decree is for partition. The court has ordered delivery of the property to the petitioner in the EP. The prayer in this O.P is to set aside the delivery order and stay further proceedings in the execution petition. The ground stated is that all the documents relating to the case are missing from the court and delivery cannot be effected since the property cannot be identified.
2.
Heard.
3.
I have perused Ext.P6 intimation given by the court to the advocate concerned. In it, it is stated that the final decree application is missing. The officer concerned applied for several documents relating to the final decree. It appears that the court could not comply with the request because final decree application is missing. There is no mention that any other document is missing. So final decree is available in this court. Moreover, a copy of it will be available in the office of the Sub Registrar. The
O.P.(C).NO.2612 OF 2015 argument of the learned counsel that there is no means to identify the property sought to be delivered cannot be accepted.
4.
It was also submitted that the prayer in the EP is to execute the decree dated 17.11.1970, but there is a modified decree passed on 20.11.1971. But the court is aware of it which is seen from Ext.P6 intimation. The intimation specifically mentions the modified final decree dated 20.11.1971. So I hope that the court will ensure that it is in accordance with the modified decree the delivery will be effected.
With the above observation this O.P is disposed of. sd/- K. ABRAHAM MATHEW JUDGE R.AV //True Copy// PA to Judge