High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/155/2018disposed of

Rakesh Mehra v. Radhey Sham Mehra And ORS

2024-03-15Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia4 pages

ARB-155-2018 ( O&M ) and connected matters -1-

!!" # $ %& '

"!

("! )

!!" # $

"!

("! * + %& '

",-!

"$.

/./

!!" # $

"!

("!

)

!!" # $

"!

("! !"#$%$& 01234567&8 59&&2:1;4 <8 291 5=67&8 5

!0 ) &!

<>"-!< $ ,/<>"-!< '(&.

<>"-!< !/<>"-!< ?"

!

(!!"

&)>& '<&"

>"-!<,!

2' 9$!'<>"-!< ?"

("!2"

<?"

(!!" < +

/@$' .. ,/<>"-!< ?"

("!2" < +

:

) )<>"-!< ?"

("!@-

//!

?"$ - AAAA

ARB-155-2018 ( O&M ) and connected matters -2-

$'$' ()* '

/

>, "? !

" '!" !

((/-!"< $/% $(("

!B%??>!<!

'-

<, - ?C?"

<( ("!$(!"%!/??"

.$/!!/%< ,!

!

-"!"? / -"$/ ?"

!

( !< !

>/>"< /"( (" B.!$(/".,!

?"

. ((/-!"<--"

./%<//",

((/-!" $ &-!" "? !

!" "-/!" -!< ++ ?"

"

!< D!

-!E ?/ ?"

(("!'! "? !" )$-! !

($!?? - ! !

( ! --"

- ,!

.

'! ! * C$ . . ( !!""?)"!?'/%( "( ! ( $/"?!

.

'!,"$/.""!" ",!

($! ?'/% ($! B!, % & '

", -

( !!

"$.

/./ ( !!><, - -/$ ,?@-

<'!"!

'''""?( ! "8 !/ "?!

( "( ! >B'!"!

!".

'!!/? < +

*

! "! ($! !

! % & '

?/ + - //..!

"

!F (B%>/6$. 6$"

:>"<'

->/$!2"** "? B%!

( % ?"

)"$ .!

-!//("/"?!

(!!"$ &-!""? -!, )-!( $/"?!

(/!"?!

->/$!,"$/."" !" ", !

! !

!

? ! C-$! B% % & '

ARB-155-2018 ( O&M ) and connected matters -3-

?>"$ "?

, $B)-!'!! "? - //. " !

.

"$!

!, !* / %B(

&'/ /%< < - //. , !" !

"

! F ( B% >/ 6$. 6$"

:>"< '

->/ $! B .2" & FF"? <, B%'/ ((/-!"?"

)"$ .!

( "-."--"$!"?(-%"? !"(!!",'8 ->/ $! B ?/ B%

- //.. !

;// ! * <C-$!B% %& '

<"!

.

"$ ! , "! ("!" !" C-$! !

' B. "! ( %-//% '!//% ?! "! /.//% -"'(!! !" " " !

->/ $! /"< @-

<)

!

?!

&'/ "

! F ( ->/ $! B . 2" &

F "? ?/ B%

< , B% !

G$! ?"

)"$ .!

->/$!"--"$!"?(-%"? !"(!!"

B )-!<,$ - //.

8 $!, ?"

-/ !"!

!/!* F C-$!B%?!2"H @-

<?>"$ "??!2"

H '4/,-">- "!- !%/./ .

! ?>"$

$< ?

"' !

B">< ! -/ !

($!! !

( !$- " -/"/% /!<( !?

"'"/! %-/'.!" ( >!?!H '4/8 ($!-B "/>B% ?

. ( !!"!

<!

$"? .

!"? '4/-/,%B )$-!!$BG$!("!"?!'?! !

!", -/ ? /./ .

!! !

( ! F @(. >, !

B">< !

"$ ! (("! 6$!- &B<?"

' -!. ?6$!-"?!

1'- / 1.

"$ !<

ARB-155-2018 ( O&M ) and connected matters -4- ",//-"$-!!

( "-.!!

.

!" !

4! -/ !"< G$ $ &-!" "?!

-!<B -//?"

(/-B?"

!

"$ ! &-!

'!! .".!"B)$-!B%!

!

B.

! !

( !!

%,//BB"$B%!

-""? < !

" G$ '! !" ( "- ,!

!

>/ >"< , - ?

$-!$"$< (""??--"

./%<!

->/ $! /" ?

$-!$"$ 8 "$ ! ! '

B ?"

' --"

./% +

!,//B"(!"!

!"?C!

?<(.>,!

-"'(/C!%"?$>"/>!$ "?!

( "( !%,//!

>"/$' "?!

/B"$ , - ,"$/."!"-.!

($! 2/!"%!

"$ ! "!-"''!"!

' ! "? !

- !

( ! ?

!" // !

/./ $ B?"

!

:(""?? 9&&2:1;4 8 291 5=67&8 5 - < ) ;

!

(. " I ;

!

("

!B/ 2"