Punjab Unaided Colleges Associations v. Punjab State Board Of Technical Adn Industrial Training And ORS




   
  

 

 !"#

 $ % !&'

$ ()* )+,,- 

%+).+



 

$ ()*/.).) %0 +%),$%).+ ) .0



1! 231  /
/3 4
  /
  231  /
5
6//

7777

  .!


 





 

   
!"!#

 
$

%

&  




 
'



  
 (

 
)

  #
"# (

    #

*+,-
 ....

5
6//

4

/ 0     #    #  $$12$$3    

     -      4
  (  +  ##0





     ## 0

 !5*

88 67--8 -



  0  ##0#! 4

2



*&  ## 9 

0      0  !  

    #0 

!:;# 



#2 #0!

 

  0   !  #  &!* ! #-7 -8<0   

    #  ##  '

$
$=$'  

 !! 0 

#!  <

               

##  



     

 ! 

  ##!  ! # ##! ###0 !

!   #<      !      0  !    :;# 

    

 '=

$=$'       ##0 



 !

  #    !     0   < 

    

 #! 
> $
&#!   

   # !##0  #!04#0 ! #!

0 !  0  ?1=
/

0   #    *@* 

! < 0

%0% #  !

$=$'*$)
/  !    

## 

8&8 ! #-7 ; -;8
/  #

  0  !## !## # ! 

-
  

     

  

      49&:&/&';
$

/ -  # 2  3
=3
$= A #

  0 !##0  0% #  ## %0 !  !   00        !  $=$=*$
    # 2  =A
=A
$= A     !  < 0    

#    78  "  - B  78 -  *C 0B78 2+/          0  %
    &
    7 8    #

   D=
 ##!        # 2     

# 0 ##0 0%
2&
 $= A*$=

 ## 

#! 0 #  ## 0       

  $=$=*$    < 0  

  !

  ##   !  -

2 # ! 7 8
$
$ /  00    #         (  #  :0        %#     0  !

##0#!  #  !  -0

# 0 !-  0  !$=$$*$'  

#!

88  ! -   

#
/  

  ## 
$
'

00! ( 0  - :;#

- 

#   

 ( 0 D
=A
$=$$
/( 0#     
 

     

  
  49&:&/;
$
) &!  

#  ! <  0

#! -- 

$=$'*$) 
  

  7

8  #!


 /   -  

      

#    <       
  

  7

8   ##  =1
=A
$=$'

 ##



# 
A$3$=$'


 
A=)?$= $7< *$8
$
D /    

    (       

0

   #



! < <0

### '

$
$=$'
/  !  ###   

 #   2##0

 

#

 #! ## 

 

0  #<
  

   7

8
'
+ 

 
* (&/# C -

#/0    #0

8;8

   =1
=A
$=$'7< *$8

! < 

# -  

      0  

#     0    !  -

 0!  # 

!

:0 

#  


-  $1
=$
$=$)

! !

#-   # 

 
)
%#

     0 

# 0

   0  0

0:;#

#0

0 =1
=A
$=$'7< *$8
)
/ 

  #  #  2 0



$=$'*$)%0% # ! 

      0   

         #   

  !  



 
-

     
 /     #              $1
=$
$=$)    !      #0  +     #!  0

#

! ##0   

  
/ 0  



$'7+ !8   # 



#0        

# 0


8"8 D


     $1
=$
$=$) 

 + !
$'#

    # 

!$=$'*$)

#  ###-

#/#C 7 ;- /C;8  D
=A
$=$'
/ - /C# 3
=
$=$'

 # !$=$'*$) 0 #  '
=
$=$'

 !:;#

0#!# 

<

'=
=
$=$'   - /C;

  
/

(## 3
=
$=$'7<  2)8 6 5*

     #  $=$'*$)    

  !  :;#  



>
/ #  

## * ## #0 +  2%    /#  C   7%/C8    ##   "    +  /
 /   -  #   

    2  $=
=
$=$'7<  218 " C<0  

0   ##  

  !  -  00        =1
=A
$=$'

! < 
- 

( :;#

-< 0  0#! #0  <   #  

 #  #

#

'

=
$=$'

# 2 #

##'=

$=$' !$=$'*$)
-   #   ##0

## <!

!' $
$=$'
/



8#8

#!+   ! # 

# -# (! #     #2 

!  ##0       !  

    #               

    '

=
$=$''

$
$=$'
/  # 

   ##+ !



$'
 1
 '
=D
$=$)& !:#E#!F#"-#  0  < 0  0       <    =1
=A
$=$' 

  



A$3$=$'

 
A=)?$= $# 
  

   

  

      

# #! 0

#    # 

!

< 0 
- #  

1
=D
$=$) # 

:;# 

=1
=A
$=$'!$=$'*$) < 0   3
!#0#  #   0  #  0 


$ '

-

"

(# (/#+ !G#(

(  0   (  /#  + !  &    !  

0
0#! 1
=3
$=$)   

 

   9 


$'


8'8 ?
H  #  #!



 0     <  0=1
=A
$=$'

! <   #

#!

#!   0

#  00  #  < 0

     

-  

  



#!9    

     

#  #!    ##      

0         =1
=A
$=$'
 A
#  # 

 





)

#!

  
-



  ## + !     =1
=A
$=$'

!

-# 

# 

! - (! #
-  

  

# #0 

# !  0=1
=A
$=$'# ! 

   0   < 0  



#  ## 0

 !:0

 
-  

 !  #  #  0  

:;#

!#0

 

# #=1
=A
$=$'

!  <   3
=D
$=$)
-  

 

#!  #!



# 0

8<8 # !#0 

#    
 /    



 ##!  

0    

3
=D
$=$)

 !  0H7 8 
$D1$2$=$) 

  

    =
=3
$=$)
-    

! !   

 0    

##!  0!#  #



 0##!

#- /C#0  <


=
F#  #  #0



 #

 

- !

9 

 -#!0!0#=1
=A
$=$'0  0   #   



# 0

 #



$
/



 0    # 

 #0 

#

 

! ## ! <  =1
=A
$=$'
/# 0   ! 

#   5* 6$D
! ##0&/C  ## 0
- 

F ## B

# - 0

  

88   ## #
$1
/

#   #
?D=  

#  $=$'*$=$)

  D== !

  !

#    
/ 



0       

#     

   

 5* #


 #

%70 8



#  4

#7##

  8 $
%

# 7 ! 

#

<8

D== '
-

0 $?)D )
-

  C

$?)D D
-

-   

# )== 1

 0   :;#%#:0 

D== 3
/# -    

# 0 ?D= $3
/

#2! #-  

#   ## 

0   

#    

    ##  0##



##!



# #!  :;#%#:0  :;# ##:0 H  &## 

F    #  0            &/C  

#       

 

<  )D=  

#    ##     

#  ##                '=
=?
$=$'      

#   '=
=A
$=$'  
  

     

  

      !"#$ # %

#&' 

88 $?
/  0<0! <!       

#2!  #   -

 

#2! #- ! 0

# 0 !

<0 *'=
=?
$=$''

=
$=$'

#      

#2 #    '=
=A
$=$'   '=

$=$'        !  $=$'*$=$)
 /

#2! #-

 #?D=

#             !

7# 0)D=

#   !

+&/#C 

##

,



9  0!:;#:0

 8 !$=$'*$=$)

!!



 

! :;# #!  ! ##


$A
/ #!

    #        

! # <   (

##  

#  0# #!    #0#   (





-    

 ##! ! :;# ! #  78 "<  #

#

   ,  '

 $=$'    

#  #

 ##   '= $=$'     

#2! #- !$=$'*$=$)B 78

7 8  :;#  

        
 %E, /:- /,E- % C/:CH-  / - %+/I&,+ %:HHC C  I>

88

'

 0   !#

J78K#0                  ##

 

#    

##  

#7 8=1
=A
$=$'

7< *$8
/  

5* :

#!"# -
/

##"#- 



 %
  0#

  #
: !#  #
$
/ 0  ##!     #        

#    <          0      #    

! !# 

 ! ### 

#  !#

678>##

#  <# 5* 

 
A$32$=$'

 
A=)?2$= $ 678  "  <            #  

# 

   ,  '

 $=$'  

# 2 #

## '= $=$' 

#2! #- !$=$'*$=$)B>  A$?2$=$'

 
A=)?2$= $ 678< *0#



D
=A
$=$'    

    

#  /# - 2

!- /C 

$=$'*$)
>  A$A2$=$'

 
?=)?2$= $ 678C<2#< *


$)
='
$=$'# #

!

#+ !- /C ,

   2  !     #    

 $  

#
>

8&8 '

#

    #0 ##  <!
)
/

# 0#!


>

)
 

# !

#7 #   

##!0<   #

#

'

=
$=$'

# 2 #

##'=

$=$' -!$=$'*$=$)
/ =1
=A
$=$'#  H   <   ### 

#  !#

J78K##

#      #
 

#

# ! <  0! -    0 #

#

  9 #  #
/=1
=A
$=$'     ! 


D
-    



!

:0  

0

# 0  
/  #   ## < 0
- # 

1
=D
$=$)#!+*! !:#E#!

F#"-0<   #

#

  < 0  / 

  ##

#  ! -     

#

 #

88  #!0##! 

#

 <

 !0<  #

#

 
/   ! #

  <

  

#

   0   



1

0    

3
-#0 

          !


/

0  ###

?

##!    



A
0

# !#  


9/3 :

95
6//

:


  /
   $-$ .&4   F

02  I F # I