M/S Samrat Forgings Ltd. And ORS v. Jassoo Singh Basi And ORS
!"#"$$%" &&'' (") *"+ $*," -& .
-/*0'1' )"% &&'' (") *"+ $*," -&
! " 2**""&"" ''3&&"!41''3 /)$!5 61" """&"""5 . 2**"*/)$!*)'1"&"*$5 " " /4+*78
"*&&'' 9 ":3'04'78
"*&&'' 9.
)*!*&"78
"*"& 9 .
;;;;
" #$%&'( 6*"" !*''& ' !"#"$$%"(+ $*," .
' -/*0'1' )"%(+ $*,"6* <) '3* "! &&'"!!7*" "*4"$*"#"=
"! 6* &" "! &&' *81 ' * !"#"$$%*"7&"!" *"*'" -/*0'1' )"%1$*1 &)"*" * *"*4"
> *" ''*'73)'1&$8 &" *!" )"$*&4 *&"$1 ",9#-7*""
> ! 1 &
6* &"8&" *""1"*))"?
!"#$
#%
&
' #%
& ( ) *
+
,$ ' ( (
+ '
& +
&
& -.
-.
/0 12,3 /4 54 6,3 787+8, 787+8,9 9&)")* "!"7 8'<)4 *" 3" '' * )" &" + *3*"47 ,) *3*"47-=*:)!"7 +4@'$"8%!6* "!''!*1&)")*"')
> A)"? 6*!"=&&$1 " ,9#- ''4 >
> A)"? 7*,9#-& * &141"8$)"?
: + ( 6,;
)
6 ))
* # /"3
# /3 <
= /!3 / 3
) > - ? > - :="% @ 7 $ & 5 - A) ;
* ; ' *-
;
#/"3 ) + )
B >
)
C;
> - 6,; 5 - A)
) ;
) 4
-5 A) & )
*
; ;
B # -.
-.
/ A
3 /, ) A 7 5 9 "$'47*"" *,9#-'"&"3 !&'3*3** 8 "!*' *&4!! #'9)8A)"?
6*"& 1$"!" *"*'"8=*/)" *!&4 %3,"14 '$&B
>)" .
7.
.
*!&7
>*!&4%3,"8 "" > >
>&"!"144$**" &" "'1*''1''7 &&"8*C0
>
> 9* "!&7$"&'$3! * "&?*" &&''?*" 3" *8$ 7> <)4 *" * ' & )& C<)4 *" &' "& !&4'&?)&<)4*"&' "&?!&4 . .
3-
.'77*" "7*"*'$! 1>
D6*!&4%3,"8"" B
14 "$**"*'$ *"&>
D8*""
> >
>6*"""*)?
571 D 0? +,6 1,< 5<10 +8
8? 6804< :" "% 5 C 1,88 &@ 7& E<70 D6E 787+8, &&8 6 58 527 ,68, 488& C &48 48,< C 1,< 5<10 +8 54 C &48 571 D 0?
+,6 F:"F & ! 7
78 C &48 571 D@ 7- 7,& C,A< A 0&6 85&< C &48 571 <8 5&@ !#F-!#=-!##
/< 5 03 6 , 2 5 )
, " , > , A
)
, !
)
, : , A 6 ,68, 1 )
& )
> > , , 1
* ,
%%"% )
, , / , ( , A .6 3
1( 51
:" "% ; 1 /
3 %#G ) > "%FF @! , ) 1 "
-. E
) 7 F:"F9 9&"*)"$*""$)!7"& !8 &&' " =$ !! * & "!7*!314*&&''@38" *!&4%3,"8""
A)"?.
7 &"!*"&3*"3*!&4&1"$B
>3*'1"4 '*!*&"!"4$") "!! 3 !&' * 8"' *" &"7 *38"7 )1/ &4! -
?&"8&" *""1" )"?
$ < , :% 50+ , )
-
) , :% &
- ) (
'
-
' ,5( , (
)) ;
(
+<C, #== "% 4 );
;
;
)
' 51;
) 2 (
/ 3
? ;
& ; ) /)3 2 (
/ 3; > &;
51
'
&
4 );
' )
-
,< )
)
)
,.
+<C, ))
' )
;
)
51 51
,$;-.
51 51;
; ;
% 5 "F=-= ) 9 6*"&*4"
7 '!&4 1"$
14 8=$ * &"8 )"
.
7.
7B 7B .B >"3* *)'E9 .
*!&7
> *" "" ""F*F9* "!&7&8")"' 7*&"!"4"' )$* 31434 *''$$"" ""!8' ""*& "& 3** "$ *!7 )' 1 ! 1 "!8 )" &"8 .
0 *7)$*1&"/14 &&'' *" "& *" 3'' * ''!
*"! >
>9* "!!&4&3** *1 ''48!&)$"" .
*1*''$14*&&''8&"&&' " /4+*7":3'04'7'")' &&"$1*'
&&''"*!)' '"$)!3**" )!!"G*"18
6*"!8' *""*&)" .
$ F* F1$& ')" .
*
6* ''! &" "' *" &)") * "*"" >
>&14*,9#-7 1*''$83 *1"8$)" >
* =9)"'!& &'"87
. 9&"8)&B
>7*"& *8!*"*"*'$6*"&1&"! &&"1"&"1*!1"**&"!**4 *8*=3'$ *''! *" >
>
B 9"*"*'$ &" "'*81 "* "&"&" )$ *!&43**3&"/)' *" **"*'"""
-/* 0'1' )" % " * 1 &)"*" **"73***81&)"*&)")* "" B
9)&&" * "!7&&''*8* /)$! 4 1
+ E + 5 1) 0 H "/:3 55 :"; 6 <) 1 0 E 1 1 H "$/3 55 %; 1 A
H E
) 1
/6
3 0, H "$/3 55 !:; & 7 0 E
1
1 < H & "=/#3 5 ""F; &
< 6) 5 0 E + <
C , /"=3 :$ 55 ": /7
3 H ' ''
E > 6 511 "=; 1H47 *""3*"$"* *""*&1 *''$*&"$)" .
F*F7''! *1 "=$"*
" *!&4 3**"4!"&"/)'*&)1'"7!)*'7 *"*'" ""7 )" * &"8 = 9)"'
!& &'"87
*" "1" ""
F 9F1$&''38??8
>!&
>9 *&"8 &'3)'8""*&"8
0"'6*"")**"3)'1*"'! *CA&" *!&4%3,"''! *" 3)') &&" )*!*&"7'")'&&"$1*'
"& )1!*1/ '!1"14* &&''*&&''&)")*""&14!&4 %3,"73*'''3$!!7&* -
? -&*8=3'$ ''! **")
>6*"" *!&4%3," "7'$'/) '1'1*="*" * "!" *"*'""" 9*8*"'")' "*&"&&"* &&"1=3**"1'
9""&&"*)1!7**"& *8*=3'$ *''! *")
>7* )" 1 "! 1'8) * "" > >
>
A)"?B 73*"14*"&**''$ *'$ C083***!&4''&" "'*"6* "!""388"" B
A)" ?. 73*"*"& *!*"*"*'$* A >
D6*)7*41&"!*''$*''! * &" "' *"*'" * &"! * *"*'$ * "1'4")7!)*'7*4"&&7*8<)7*) !483*"&**=3'$ *!$ C0 *)' "*&)"& ''! &" "'*"*'$7 *" "7 * & * ! ) 3 !1'7 *" * * &"! 3 $" 14 * !&4%3," ' "*!&4&6*"*"
& *!"*&")' *&"8&" *""7 !&4%3,"$"*&"! "!*&"! *"&*)$*!&'!4*"&"7*" "7* &&''1&"8"*&' '!8??8* !1'4 C8*"3*''! &" "'*"*'$3 !14*!&4) *"8'"!"') 1)*1 *" -*1' *!14*,9#- "" >
>7*""83 > * F 9F 1 *''$ #" * = 1"847 >
"&")*"1'3?
@.
B )
) ) > + ; ; >
' '
9 983 *& 1")" >
7 !&4%3,"7*8!&)$"""**"&' *"&3''8")*"""7*)*!! /)'"!4!)****& **&"*8''>
D *"*'$
""*&1*''$)"&"8 .
*" &""!4)"
>,*!478*"37* "&*'"$**''$* ""*&H !)" .
$
>I*=&' 341=
6*@F1' )&"!)"*"*) *!1'4 *& ""!8' *""*&)"
.
*
>*1'4*'**&" *8$)*$"8$1 "!&4%3," 983 3**11"8187*!&)$""
)1'7"$'4&&' ""$'4''3 7 -/*0'1' )"%*81!* "!" *"*'" 83 *''! *&" "'
*"*'"7*""$*3)'1<)''4&"!'"* *" "$* 1
*4 *8 1 '' *" 3**"&14*,9#- !&4%3," ) * + $ " (