G S Developers & Contractors Pvt Ltd v. Concepts International India Llp
!"#$ %& '( !) !"# * ,- ' + ./
1 '
- ,/..
( % %221/234/+' / % 51,*'2/ +4/+' 4 2 % *6
+*74% 52/86/ % *12 ,4/+' 4 2 9999 2--,' , /1/ '"" 2 ', '4 "::# $ 2 ;2 '<& 2 --=
+ / '+, '1' 8> ,1 , /-1 383 ,1
? , + /1/ (@
! "
##$ %
%
& %
" '
% (
) ?
< 8''
- //2 - 7
/ / ?!
"!
!"!
-1 / / '
8
2 - 3, / /!
!A !"A',= 2 =1 1 B ) ' 8 /1 / -3, 3 2 /+> /2 / ',1 ,',1 ?
C1 2 '/ 82 2 2 7
1++ + 8 82 - / 8
2 - 2 , / /"!
!"A8// /32 2 822 '-DFinal Settlement of ClaimsE 16 ' 2 , ;Full and final settlement of claim for the execution of the said contract"
+1 =
7 2 ,/ 8
2 - ,+ 2 1 ,7 2 < ',= / "the payment finally agreed to be payableE , 12 1/ (@
*+ '
%
,-
! " # ! $
. / 0. ! .1 2+ $232 433 3332 333$$ 3+
5 ( !
5 ( 4# 2 4# 22 4+ 3333+ 2 6
33 333 333 ---- 333
4 "- (
( &789 0: ( ; 2$2$2<- '
: (1 #3 +3 +3 333$2 333 6 !
(
0 1 =
= +34 +33 +33 333$+ 333 $ *
2# 2#3 2#3 333$# 333 2
42 333 333 ---- 333 + " #
433 333 333 ---- 333 # > 33
330
%8
1 ! ?
5 $# 33 33 33 33 ---- 333 + # 3
"
>
> ?
0 *+ 1
@
( ,- @
#3#34 AAA @ < (
4 AAA AAAA $ AAAA 2 AAAA + AAAA >
'
(
)
1 // / , , / "!
!"A 82'2 F- ,3
2 < , / "!
!"A ',, / 1- 2 '>8, /7 2 '
- 2 '2 C1 = Dagainst the full and final settlement claim for execution of ..the work". 2
/ '
- 2 '2 C1 2 2 * '2 C1 / /"?
""
!"A/ '2 C1 / /!
!:
!"A / 2 '2 C1 4 2 4 2 / 2 / , / /"!
!"A 2-,3 '1 '2 C1 8 - - / '- 2 + / # /'2 C1 8 /21 /1-- ) / '1 , -- 7 2, 2 ' / 2 2 2 7
/ 1 / ''1 2 '2 C1 2+7
/21 < ' 2 2 2/ 2 8 7
/ 8
2 - 2 2 -3= 81,/ =/ 3?"
!?
!"
/22 8 , / - 2 '2 C1 2/
2 7/=- 2--3= 8 =/ "# !"A4 !
!"
!"
4 !:
!"
!"
4 "# !"
!"
4 :
!"
!"
/"# !
!"
2 1= A
"",'4 !,'4"!,'4"!,'4"!
! ,'/"!
!!,' - '+ ,377 77"!
?",'1 2 ,=1 4"B4"
4!!!G@-3, 1/ 2 27
- ''
- = 1'/,,3 + 1=7 2 2 - <' 22 -3= 8 =/ == / ,31-2
'1 2 / / "!
!
!"A ' ' / 2 2 = -3= 8 2 '
2 '''
/ ''1 2 2+7 ''
- - -3= 1'/,,3 2 =, 7 2 < ' 2 -3= 8 =/ == / ,3 :
"# !
!"
4 2 // / , 2 722 '2 C1 2/
/21 /"
!"A /7"!
!
!"
2 22 1/8 1 ' /2- 2 , ":
"?,'8
, /== / ,3/2 ,'
=1 ?
! ,'8 , / 82 8
> 12 / 2 2 = 1 7
7 1,, / +/ =- 2 2 2 , C1 D , = 2 / ,'
=1 "4"?4!?4B#"G@D = -3= 3 !
!
!"
'',1/ /372 2 , /=> -3= 81,/2+ -1/---- = 1 71/ "!
2143 42 = => -3= /= /,3 / F /, !
!
!"
8,,8/ = -3= 8 /3?"
!?
!"
""
2 + 3 F/3
") !
!"
inter alia /22 - 2/7
/22 -3= 1/ 2 8 =/ ?"
!?
!"
?!
!?
!"
42 -/ 12 =1 ?) "#,' 12 43, / /""
!# !"
// / 2 4 2
/ 2 , -2' /'12 ,//2 @=, 32 ?!
!?
!"
4 !"
!A !"
4 "!
!
!"
/ !:
!# !"
- '+ ,3 C1 7 ',, ' 2 / =/ / 2 ,'
1= !
#B ,' 2/ '7 /2 / =// / /?!
!?
!"
@=, 2+
/ ' 2 2 / =/ / / ?!
!?
!"
81 //= 22 //''
-2 =/ / 2 '2 C1 1 / , 1 2 ) !) !"
, + =1 1/ 2 8 -/ / 3
/3?"
!?
!"
+ 1=7 2 2 < ' 2 2 -3= 8 =/ == / ,3 1- '1 2 2 7
''
- / 81,/ => / '
2 --,' --= ''
7, 7
/ 11 //2 72 2 - /'3,,H / = 2 2 ' /2 <, / /"!
!"A 214 2 8 / ,3 -3= 4 2 < 724 34 81,/ 1/ 2 2 7
82'2 / ' 7
7
' /2 7,7
8--,', 2 27
"?
' 2 2 2 7
8 / 1/1, ,3,,311, / 2172 ' / 2 -3= 2+7
=/ == / ,3 1- 2
'1 2 7
/ / "!
!"A 2+ , /3 /42 3 ''
- /1,-3=
2 2782 = ,3/' 2 2 7
8 / 1/1, ,3 1/1, = - 2 7
'4 2 4 / +/ + 1=7 2 8 1/1, 4 81,/ +/, 2 '
2 2 ,3 // +/ 2 7
1' /3''
-7-3= /'+ 2 ,, / 1/ "A 2 ,/32 *1- 1National Insurance Company Limited v. Boghara Polyfab Private Limited 2009(1) Supreme Court Cases 267 82 2 2 - 2+ '',1/ ''G' 3 '/7 ' 2 = ,72/,73 '
+7 , -3= 821 6 ' 1 82'2 =3 / '/ / --,'1/ '"" 2 ' 21 2172
'
2C1 =3 =/ ,1,42 1 ', / '/ /--,'1/ '"" 2 '
2 /'1= /= / ' 2 1 '2 / '/ 1 2--,'1/ '"" 2 ' "# 2 ''1='
42 /= $* 0I &
* J+/ J
√