High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/318/2018disposed of

M/S Lubetech India Private Limited v. M/S Unitech Ltd

2019-10-04Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma7 pages

!"#$ %&'!( % & ' ) *!( + !"# $"%&'(#!")'"

* !"#

%& &( +, -*.'. &*+ & &*&+

$"%&'(#!")'"

* !"#

/*+ *# 0"

& *&#&

1 0 . 2 0&#&& &(

&#& 0" 3 * -&(

4"&% % & (("

*&+ 32

0 &#&& &#&& * # ++ +& &#& 0" * -&( 1& +" *' & #5 * +&

+*&+ # -&'.*& &+&

#*0 /*& !&*+ 6 7#0 * ,"+&( 1"&

,113 *'*0* &#&& ++ +&-&+&"& 5* +"0(.&-* +&8 ++ &#&&

/*&!&*+*'*0"

9 ,"# . 3 , *' ++0 *+& *+&*'-&

+&"& -*&#&& 10" ,"# +&'*"#:"# 2.

*+&& &-& +&"& - * &#&& & &#&& ,"# 2 (; +&' &(; - ++0 *1* <" & ++ &#&& *& &"( =+&8 0&>"&"

* -& +&"&. & # * +& & * 5 ++ &#&& 0&* -&( 4+ *("

&*+&"&.&+& . 0" - " . 0+& &( 8 "

&" *( & "

& * +&"& $ * *& &"( .*1* <"(84& *:"& ' *("

2 ++ *&#&&$ * +& .*0& ('*1* <" *00*#6-*1"& "

& , 2 & ++

&#&&*1&+& 0&>"& "

&10"

/**&# & +". (08.

.*0&00"+ #8 5& ++ &#&& & 5**&( 10" *-&( =* 0& ( ++0 "

& , 2 ++ *&#&& 2

= * ++ *0&#&&

&*++0 250&8 (#8*0& 2 $ %"

:!08?%"

:!08!'%& 6 !?

2 ,112 @@.*-&( & #5 * +& &#& 0" /* +"

&#5 *+&%"

!08 ++00 &' %& &+ ( -++ &#&&

& +"*(%& 0

4+&8 *&88.%"

:!08('*1* <" *6-*1"& *&#&&"

, 2%& * (++ 00* (' - * ++0 /* - <"- & "++ *&#&&*0 -**&(8 '0#0 5 (' & 5* * -&( --&'#8*&&.5&+

5 05**5( *(&&* *1"&*&<"- * *1"&& && &,5*-&A *0**(&5 '&>"&08#8*:"-( *'5; #8 *- <"- 0 -5**++0 , 2 *' *5 &-*/* 1"&&&*++0 2# & * 1* <" * 6-* 1"& & &* & ++ * &#&&

& 5*, 2 B C& "00-&( 5**0-0+

#8 * 1"& & ,5*-&?& ,5*-& ! ' / D ! *&

,11 3 @@5***0# 005

: !08?%"

: !08 ! ' %& 6 !

2 ,112 @@

, +&'*1* <"&* - +& & " . ++ -

&#&&. *00 *' " &-& 5 += >"0 &>"& *&#&&#8*-&( *+&= #*& & &0;08 "&*++ + (+&0 &#&&$ &*& 058( & ?&*&

058( & . &8 058.50* '%0E - & -1(+ 8!( ?

,11

@@.*&<"- * *1"& &* *( , $ & ,

. * 1"& * ++ * &#&& & &#&& ( * &#&

-&( (". #" 5*0 (; - * ++ * 5 &>"&( ( *&

*'#;+ '5 $ 5++08*0-0+ 4+#8* 1"& &,5*-&?&,5*-&!' /D ! *& ?

,11 3 @@ *( .500# **1&+& *

&-*++ *&#&&$ &* & *

.*0&00"+ ++ *&#&& & 5* &( 10" * -&( #"*5 00*0&*(++0

2*1* <" *00*#6-*1"&

*&#&&/*++ 5 (#8*1&+& 08"& -*+ 8 +& -"

2,"*++ #8 * 1&+& & "& &-* >" * 0*0&;

++ *&#&&#8*1* <""

, 2 C 5& * #' >" & -08

, *0+*1&+& 00 * " D&08.*& >"0 *&#&&+&&# *-&( , 08. "&*++ + (+&0 &#&&.&*& &8*( *&*

& ++ &#&& *1&+& * &-*++ * &#&&"

&10" *-&(

!& & "

0 & * 1&+& .

*5'&.& && &+&&& *1"&

5 E - & -? 5 E - & -

3 1*(!'$ 01&+& !&

,11

/*&#& 0" *5(0& * &#& 0" * +& /* &&*5& *1&+& ++ E 0&#&&+&*-&( "* 5&#;* &&*

E * 4 " & 0 & &- /*1&+&

&* && "#"E5*&&&; -5** && -&/*1&+& ++ &&&; -&#&&/* &&( ++0 2&5*, 3 * 2 && <"-*0&#&&/*, -0<"-( *+ 0#8* &&- *&&.* +00'+ 5 0#8* &&/* 1"& +&-&+*B *&& 005

9B 6' - &-& * 4+&. 0& "

>"'0&#& 0"#5 *+& **+"#5 *(*00#& && * 0 &#& * E * . E 5 "

#0 & "

500 -*0&#&&.*(& *00#& &&*+& - #8"* E *+05*5500 -0 &#&& . *(#0

&#&&. *&+& *"0&#&&.

* ++ && &; - & *

( 0&#&&#8*1&+&

# " $ *

E 4 *+& 5&"

#0&* 8-&0" .* &#& 0" "&'' *# &*' -5&;"&& - * &#& 0". 0 &#&& 5"0 #

2 E&* ( 0$ &"( .5 + *& +& "

0&008++ 8&#&& &0" *+", 2. 3 * 2*' ++0 0-* *& #'F

C& &*5**# #'*

++0 *+& " $ 5

- & -. * 1"& 5 5* * >" "& &-* ++ &#&& "* &-"( 5 & * /* >" & 5

- & -5 &08

$ *+& .

*1&+& * 0 &>"&"

&* +&"&-&"+ #8*+& 10" +*( #8*0&++ *&#&&.

* 1&+& (; ++ "

0 * ++0 5("

& , 2/*".* * &-* ++

&#&&$ *'5 *(&.*1* <" "-**'4&*:"&

2 * (& & ++ &#&& ++&+&08/*++ *&#&&#8* "& -*+ 8 +& -"

, 25 >" F

& -08.$( *00*&>"&( &#& 1 0 . 2*'# "0 00#8*+ & *,0&#&&&>"&#++ &0'00*+" 5***'& #5 *+& 3 & -08.&,G&;.&, <"- ++ 0&#&&/*0&#&&&>" & & 5* +& 55; &(* &+ *+8 *&&/*& &.*+ && 00(+

B 5* +& *&5;+08# 0#8*&+ 5*

"&*& +& *& 5; /* +0 -. 0" -. &: & "

&0(.*000#(+0#8*+&5* +&

-*5; & & - & #8*0&#&&$*00# + *&#&&&( *5 +&"&5**

*+&/*5&*00#(&08+&*+&' &#& 1 0 . 25* 4( *0 **&#&&*00++; -&&/*-&8 *1"& &((08

&(&,G&;.&, <"- #"*+ - *&&#8 -+8 *&&*( 2 $ '5 *.*+ +

:',*&( ' -1* <" C**&+; - & H C**&+&#0 H