M/S Ist Finvest Llp v. M/S Unitech Ltd
!"#$ %&&' ' ( % ) *&+ , !"# $"%&'(#!")'"
* !"#
'( (+ ," -*.%. (*, ( (*(,
$"%&'(#!")'"
* !"#
#*, */ 01 (
*(/(
2 0 . 3 0(/(( (+
(/( 01 4 * -(+
51(' ' ( ++1 *(, 63
0 (/(( (/(( * / ,, ,( (/( 01 * -(+ 2( ,1 *% ( /7 * ,( ,*(, / -(%.*( (,(
/*0 #*( &(*, 8 9/0 * "1,(+ 21(
%
.
"226 *%*0* (/(( ,, ,(-(,(1( 7* ,10+.(-* ,(: ,, (/((
#*(&(*,*%*01
;
"1/ . 6 "
*% ,,0 *,( *,(*%-( ,(1( -*(/(( 201
"1/ ,(%*1/<1/ 3.
*,(( (-( ,(1( - * (/(( ( (/(( "1/ 3 += ,(% (+= - ,,0 *2* >1 ( ,, (/(( *( (1+ ?,(: 0(@1(1 * -( ,(1(. ( / * ,( ( * 7 ,, (/(( 0(* -(+ 5, *+1 (*,(1(.(,( . 01 - 1 . 0,( (+ : (1 *+ ( 1 ( * ,(1( !
* *( (1+ .*2* >1+:5( *<1( % *+1
3 ,, *(/((!
* ,( .*0( +%*2* >1 *00*/8-*21( ( "
3 ( ,,
(/((*2(,( 0(@1( (201
#**(/ ( ,1. +0:.
.*0(001, /:
7( ,, (/(( ( 7**(+ 201 *-(+ ?* 0( + ,,0 1 ( "
3 ,, *(/(( 3
? * ,, *0(/((
(*,,0
370(:
+/:*0(
3 !
'1 <&0:A'1 <&0:&%'( 8 &A
3 "223 BB.*-(+ ( /7 * ,( (/( 01 #* ,1
( (/7 *,('1 < &0: ,,00 (% '( (, + -,, (/(( ( ( ,1*+'( 0
5,(: *(::.'1 <&0:+%*2* >1 *8-*21( *(/((1 "
3'( * +,, 00* +% - * ,,0 #* - >1- ( 1,, *(/((*0 -**(+:
%0/0 7 +% ( 7* * -(+ --(%/:*((.7(,
7 07**7+ *+((* *21(*(>1- * *21(( (( ("7*-(C *0**+(7 %(@1(0:/:*<1-+ *%7= /:
*- >1- 0 -7**,,0 "
3 *% *7 (-*#* 21(((*,,0
3/ ( * 2* >1 * 8-* 21( ( (* ( ,, * (/((
( 7*"
3
4 D( 100-(+ 7**0-0,
/: * 21( ( "7*-(A( "7*-( & % # $ & *(
A
"22 BB7***0/ 007
'1 < &0:A'1 < &0: & % '( 8 &
A
3 "223 BB
"
,(%*2* >1(* - ,( ( 1 . ,, -
(/((. *00 *% 1 (-( 7 ,? @10 (@1( *(/((/:*-(+ *,(? /*( ( (0=0: 1(*,, , +,(0 (/((!
(*( 07:+ ( A(*(
07:+ ( . (: 07:.70* %'0E - ( -2+, :&+ A
"22
BB.*(>1- * *21( (* *+ "
!
( "
. * 21( * ,, *
(/(( ( (/(( + * (/(
-(+ +1. /1 7*0 += - * ,, * 7 (@1(+ + *(
*%/=, %7
!
7,,0:*0-0, 5,/:* 21( ("7*-(A("7*-(&% #$ & *( A
"22 BB *+ .700/ **2(,( *
(-*,, *(/((! (* ( *
.*0(001, ,, *(/(( ( 7* (+ 201 * -(+ /1*7 00*0(*+,,0
3*2* >1 *00*/8-*21(
*(/((#*,, 7 +/:*2(,( 0:1( -*, : ,( -1
3"1*,, /:
* 2(,( ( 1( (-* @1 * 0*0(= ,, *(/((/:*2* >11 "
3 D 7( * /% @1 ( -0:
"
*0,*2(,( 00 * 1 $(0:.*( @10 *(/((,((/ *-(+ " 0:. 1(*,, , +,(0 (/((.(*( (:*+ *(*
( ,, (/(( *2(,( * (-*,, * (/((1 (201 *-(+
&( ( 1 0 ( * 2(,( .
*7%(.( (( (,((( *21(
7 E - ( -A 7 E - ( - 2*+&%!
02(,( &(
6
"22
#*(/( 01 *7+0( * (/( 01 * ,( #* ((*7( *2(,( ,, E 0(/((,(*-(+ 1* 7(/=* ((*
E * 5 1 ( 0 ( (- #*2(,(
(* (( 1/1E7*(((= -7** (( -(#*2(,( ,, (((= -(/((#* ((+ ,,0
3(7*"
6 * 3 (( >1-*0(/((#*" -0>1-+ *, 0/:* ((- *((.* ,00%, 7 0/:* ((#* 21( ,(-(,*4 *(( 007
;4 8% - (-( * 5,(. 0( @1%0(/( 01/7 *,( **,1/7 *+*00/( (( * 0 (/( * E * . E 7 1 /0 ( 700 -*0(/((.*+( *00/( ((*,( - /:1* E *,07*7700 -0 (/(( . *+/0
(/((. *(,( *10(/((.
* ,, (( (= - ( *
+ 0(/((/:*2(,(
/ 1 !
*
E 5 *,( 7(1 /0(* :-(01 .* (/( 01 1(%% */ (*% -7(=1(( - * (/( 01. 0 (/(( 710 / E(* + 0!
3 (1+ .7 , *( ,( 1 0(00:,, :(/(( (01 *,1"
3. 6 * 3*% ,,0 0-* *( /%F D( (*7**/ /%*
,,0 *,( 1 !
7
- ( -. * 21( 7 7* * @1 1( (-* ,, (/(( 1* (-1+ 7 ( * #* @1 ( 7
- ( -7 (0:
( !
*,( .
*2(,( * 0 (@1(1 (* ,(1(-(1, /:*,( 201 ,*+ /:*0(,, *(/((.
* 2(,( += ,, 1 0 * ,,0 7+1 ( "
3#*1.* * (-* ,,
(/((!
*%7 *+(.*2* >1 1-**%5(*<1(
3 * +( ( ,, (/(( ,,(,(0:#*,, *(/((/:* 1( -*, : ,( -1 "
37 @1 F
( -0:.!+ *00*(@1(+ (/( 2 0 . 3*%/ 00/:*, ( *"0(/(((@1(/,, (0%00*,1 7***%( /7 *,( 6 ( -0:.("G(=.(" >1- ,, 0(/((#*0(/(((@1 ( ( ( 7* ,( 77= (+* (, *,:
*((#*( (.*, (( 00+,
7* ,( *(7=,0:/ 0/:*(, 7*
4
1(*( ,( *( 7= #* ,0 -. 01 -. (< ( 1 (0+.*000/+,0/:*,(7* ,(
-*7= ( ( - ( ( /:*0(/((!*00/ , *(/(((+ *7 ,(1(7**
*,(#*7(*00/+(0:,(*,(% (/( 2 0 . 37* 5+ *0 **(/((*00,,= -((#*-(: *21( (++0:
(+("G(=.(" >1- /1*, - *((/: -,: *((*+ 3 !
%7 *.*, ,
<%"*(+ % -2* >1 D**(,= - ( H D**(,(/0 H