← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/64/2016dismissed

M/S Krishan Chand v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-09-09Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal6 pages



     

       

 

  



! "#  

$

     

   

 & ' ( & (

  

%')*# (

 * & +

*("# ( 

,,,,       %%* 

 ./

 0

 * (%% 1  *  





     4

 





-

  &'

   *

 -

 5

    

  

  



 *

 

 *

67

4



&&

   & 3  !

 68 *

 9   :( 3  *  1

*#1 %

  ;

*

   

*

    & 4 

6 

                    

    

       

   

  

        

     !   " "    #     

 #"  $

 %            &'    "   " "

   

  "

   "   "   # (    "    (      )'    #     "     "$  % *    "

    

 "    

 +      

# 

 ("    "  "

  

 +

        , 

   

  

$  "

 #      *



 

     "   *

   $ 

  "  



  "    *

  



  $  +"       

  

  

 $  *



      "    

*



  *

--)

# #      #     

+ $.  "





 3 *  

*# ** 3   *

 7 -

 *#

  !

 68*

9  :(3  1  %  

    1   

 **3 4 %&  6 

       

%      #"   /

   ##   #     #" $ '     #"  01

2   

3$$+$

   ""   4 

# $

2 5   ##

  

  /"    

6 2 5

1  ##     ("   /  #

 #

   "   # #"  $



 "    

      

   

  

     

  (     #  

              ## #     "

        #



 #

 

       



     #    # ( $ '   ##   $% ##  "   7  

   ,    

       "    #    

              "

  



   "

  

$      8 

  

 "

 (    8     #  

    "   "        ## 

    $ 

    ""         ##   #"   /

   ##  # (  $ %       

 #"  

  ##$ %  #"     #"    ## 

01 2

   ##    #

   /

  #"   ##  

 /"  / 

!:  / 

 / 4 

# $ 2    ##   

  

92

1   ##          ("    

     

#  "

    "      # #"  $ %

#"       "

          ""

  # $    ,  /

  #"    ## #    ""

     

#"  



#  ""  $ %#"   ##  "    -'    #     ""     

 

""

  ""

"

     

   "$ %  /

 #"   ##     #"   #   #"   "        

 ;

$ % 

"

"

#      



 #     #$     "     

  # ""

     $ /#

   #"     "   /

 #"   ##

#  "        

 ;

       

""

  ""

   $ *  "

        "    #  " <=  # #     #  

++"      #

.$

    "

      +"    /#   



#  

" 

.$ 9$$#" ""2$ 7 < 

*

 ( *  3 %*

 1#



;%

  

7M/s Tibba Danasher Coop L/C Society Limited v. State of Haryana and others 3  

 

 1*4

8 %% 

   81( 3 ( 1

 & 3%  

*

4  

8  # )*# (* 



 * & +

*("#  

1#  3   &

  



& %&   !

 689  :-    & 1

 1#



;

  

1 8 



   3

  

!

 689  :1

%

   1 =

& *#%*

*   % 

& #  3 9Deleted:3 %%  * 4

* 

*

( 1 *#( 9Arbitration: 3 ** 

 *  4% 3 

 & 3 

%&  

*

 9 $

*!# 1:.$!/

3**   

 #

>1%  %*

   

 3  9any: <  

 

  3  

   

*  

 %     

 &    !

 68 *#



 %*  ?

* !

 68 9 $

*!# 1:.$!/

$!

   *

 



*1  %* 3 **  

*1



 4 

9$!: 

*1  %* (

*



 

%# 3 *

 4   %% * 4  

    

11



>1%3

!  4 11

< *1  % *

 $!   

     

  

  



 >1%3

!  4 11

3

#

> 4

-

4 %% *4 

    11



>1%3

!  4 11

-

   

>1%3

!  4 11

* %&

  %&  4

4 %% *4 

  

  >1%3

 !  4 11

 *

 A*1

3**  *# 



>1%3

!  4

11

B3

 >1%3

!  4 11

-

%

 4   

  >1%3

 !  4 11

   

-

  

11

    4 % 

     4 % 

1%*#  

 *#  

 *1

@  %&

   

 *

 1 *#  %#1   *1  %7C

 * % -

 

3

 * #%%

  

4 

%%

  

  *

   !

 68     * &   



 3# -

    

 %

 4      1 

   %%*   %% 1    

 %

 4  1

     

%

 4  *  4 & # *1  "3  3  

 &

@%

    

*

 A  & 3  

   *

     $

* !# 1

3**   

 #

" .emphasis supplied/B-  *  4

*1

*1  #% *&* 8 

3

  *1

 *1  *

    *  -  *   1 

    

  

  

    $

* !# 1 *

*1   %*

 8%%  !

 68

  @%

*#

* *

7 - ( 3 (  1# 1    * &   

 -

  *

  *  

*

 #   @%

  "3 ( 

* &  %  !

 68 %

 3

 3

AArbitration: DeletedB -  **3

 # 

 4 9 $

*!# 1:-

 # 1



  

 *1  %*

 

# 1 * 4  ** 

 *1

   

   & 3  

  $

* !# 1 

 3**      

   #

 

 8   * ( 

  *

 7 * 4  

*

 8 

 1  

(

  1

 .!DE8F$/  "8>FDG!-8 >   9&

: Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No√