High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCAPP/22/2014allowed

Idbi Trusteeship Services Ltd. v. M/S Chattar Industries Ltd. And ORS.

2015-05-19Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal9 pages

!"#$% &!!'( )%&*+ ,# -.(&!!(* /!-0'!(1&2

0!-(.( +3(*&&- 2.(&-!(1&2 2&*!-( !( &(

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.J.VAZIFDAR, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE. HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.S.SANDHAWALIA.

4*!&*!- -&!-("'"

!-( 5!""6!2&(!!&*!7.28 &9 4*!&*!-&5!-!!--!2&&*! -&!-(- &9 :4*!&*!-&*!7.28 &(*."25!-!

-&!2 &*!8!(&9 -!(!

&) +-/ (-'*,20'&!,-&*!

& +-& ,20'&!--!( &; 1 +-+ (* ,20'&!,--!( &( 2: +-< "/!*8",20'&!,--!( & ==== S.J.VAZIFDAR, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE *((

!"8 (&&*!-2!- 27.28 &&*!"!- !2

.28!-!7!'& 8&*!

&>(

"'& &5!&-!&!2(-(& '*-8! *"2!-3(!'.-!2 '-!2&- ((. 6&* -!( & ; 2.(&-" !0!"

? 2, :; 2.(&-"

- -& 2 1&2 2 -!( & ;-

'" - -& *!"!- !2.28!2( ((!2&*!

"'& &*!8-.

2&*& &*!

&>( '*-8! *2 & 5!!

-!8(&!-!2 .

2!- (!'& # &*!

!('&,%#@A-(*-&B&*!'&>C

-&*! .- (!&*(

!",6!6"" -'!!2 &*!5((&*& &*!!0!

&'*-8! &5! 8-!8(&!-!2.

2!-(!'& #&*!'&,& 6."25!028 (&&*!"D.2&- 2&*!-'-!2&-(4!*0!' !& &*!' '".( &*&&*!

&>('*-8!6( '&-!8(&!-!2.

2!-(!'& #&*!'& : *!

&;-.(&!!(* /!-0'!(1&2(-!!--!2& &*! -'!!2 8( 2 &*!

.8 !2 -2!- ( /1 *!

& (

!5!

&.-!-.(&!!6*'*&*!5!

!'-!(-!.- & "E!2 (.-

!(,

!" ,1! (.- '!- -& 2F!

!-" (.- - -& 2F!6 2((.- '!1&2 2 -!

&" (.-

1&2 -.(&!! 8-!!

& 2&!2 :%%# 6( !

&!-!2 & 5!&6!!

&*! -(& -!( & 6*'* ( '

"D.2& 2 & ; *!

& ( &*! (.''!((-; ; &!-!(& &!-;" &&*!5!

!&&*!&-.(&!!8-!!

&" , 0!6(!'& : &*! / A!5!

&.-! -.(&!!(C A &C !8."& (, , &6( -*5&!2- '& 8(-.(&!!( 2&*!!5!

&.-! &-.(&!! 5.( !(( -!( & 6(, &*!-!-!, &- (!--!2 & &*!

2!- &*! -.(&!!( 8-!!

&, -!( & 8-!!2 & (.5('-5! & G#H (!'.-!2 -!2!!

5"! ;' 0!-&5"! 2!5!

&.-!( & 88-!8&! "0".!"'(-&'"!; &*!8-!!

&-!2((.

2!-);

$ %

' ( "'(

) *+,*,- !

) *.+ * / &#

/"/&/

) *0-- !

) *.-- ! (

) *+-- *

# #

*2 # & (

-& & & &! &6 "!&&!-( 22-!((!2 5 -!( ( 2 &*& -!'!2!2 &*( 8-!!

& !( & ;-

'" - -& *2 5 "!&&!- 2&!2 G$%% 22-!((!2 & & (&&!2 &*& &*! *2 57!'& -!( & !- 8 - ((. '*-8! & &*! (2 .- (.- '! '

!( ! 5!

!'-!(&*!&-.(&&(!'.-!&*!(22!5! &.-!("'((.57!'& &-!( &5& 8( "-B 57!'& !-&'&!>- "" &*!!I(& 8 -&' & 8

'" (&&.& ( !( &5 "!&&!- 2&!2G#%%#(&&!2&*&&*! *2 57!'& &&*!-(&-!( &>(

- (" - '-!& ((. '*-8! 0.- &*! .- (.-

!( -!( !'& 2!5!

&.-!( 88-!8&! 0".! "'( 50.(" , &*!-!&!- &*! -- 8!

& 6( !

&!-!2 & 5!&6!!

&*!

2 -!( & ( 2!5!

&.-! &-.(&!! 5!*" .- (.- '!'

!( :%%#

!( & :; 'D.-!2 '*-8! -!( !'& &*!

- !-& &*! !-%%@(&*2'D.-!2&*!'*-8!(.5(!D.! &" ,&*!-! 6( D.!(& ;-!( &:8-!! 8&&*!'-!&

((.'*-8! 0.--!( &

@ *!-! (, &*!-!-!, 2.5& 6*&(!0!- 2 2!!2 & ( 0-&."" 2 &&!2 &*& &*!

&>( 2.!( -! (!'.-!2 ( -!(2 *!

&( 2.!( -! "( 2 &&!2 *! " ' &!

& 5!*" &*! &( ( &*& &*! '*-8! 0.- &*!

& *2 & 5!!

-!8(&!-!2.

2!-(!'& #&*!'& $ *(('.-.( 2 .

-' &!

& &"!(& (-( &*!-!( &(-!' '!- !2(6! &!2!-"!--!( &( 2: !I -!((" 8-!!2 & &*!

& 5! 8 8- &!2 ((. '*-8! +-!0!-,&*! !02!

'! 6*'* 6! 6""(*-&" -!!- & !(&5"(*!(5! 2 2.5&&*&&*!'*-8!6( '&'-!&!2(6! &!2!-"!-,&*!

(&*!(.''!((-; ; &!-!(&&*!5!

!&&*!&-.(&!!8-!!

.-(.

&& 6*'*&*!'*-8!6('-!&!2*!'*-8!6(-8 "" '-!&!2 0.- & ! &*!

&>( -!2!'!((-; ; &!-!(& !( 2 2!!2 -!( & ! &*! -&88-, &*!-!-!, *0!

!-( "?

6"!28!&*!'&(&*!'(! !( &( 2*0! -50.(-!( ("!2&2('"(!&*! &!-" -&'."-(&*!'*-8!

2&*!-!8(&-& &*!-!"&*.8*&*! 5! 8&*!-8 " -&!(&&*! &-.(&!!8-!!

&*0!?

6"!28!""&*!'&( 2D.&! ((5" -!

((!(( &*! -8 " -!'-2 -&.

&!" , !0!

&*! " &!2 -!'-2 0"5"!!(&5"(*!(&*!-!8(&-& &*!'*-8! 2&*!-!5 !

5"!( .(& 27.(&'! G * &*!'& 8-!!

& 6( "( !I!'.&!2 :%%# !&*!2 6*'*&*!&-.(&!!>(8-!!

&6(!I!'.&!2 - ( 2: *2 50.(" 5!!

"!2 *! ( ! ( !02!

'!2 5 -!'! & 2&!2 %%# ((.!2 5 &*! J!

-& &

-(, !8(&--

!( (* .

&!- -!'! &, '! &*! !8(&--

!(K '?

6"!28 8-!'! &(.

:3; -!( !'&&*!(2 - (

2: - ;,*6!0!-,(""!8!2" &&-'!5"! &*!-!'-2(&*! -(&;-!( & '

!( & *( & -2.'!2 &*! ( ! !&*!- ''.

&&*!-!'! &((.!25 &*! !8(&--

!(,&

.(&5! -!(.

!2&*&5&*&*! - (6!-!"!2!&*!--!( &

- -!( & ' &!

2!2 &*& &*! 6!-! & "!2 - ;: (, *6!0!-, 2&!2 G%%# ! &!- &*! 2&! &*! -!'! & *& - , *6!0!-, *0!5!!

2!-!

&- &*! !6*'*( -!'-2*!'& &*! &&!-, *6!0!-, ( &*& &*! 5(( &*! -!'! &, & .(& 5!

-!(.

!2&*& - ( 2:*25!!

"!2-&*!-6(!&*! !8(&--

!(6."2 &*0!((.!2&*!-!'! & % *! '-!& &*! !D.&5"! -&88! ( 2 &&!2 *! + 8 8 -!'&- -!( & *2 !I!'.&!2 2!'"-& 2 .

2!-&? 8 2&!2 %%# *! 2!'"-& (&&!2 &*& &*!

05"!

- !-&!(-!( &5&* -!(!

2.&.-!J-! 6 - (!2& 5! -&88!2 2 '*-8!2 & ( &-.(&!!( A-!( & C - &*! *"2!-( ;' 0!-&5"!!5!

&.-!(&&*!!I&!

&"'((.5('-5!2 5 1,, 2 K *&&*!2!'"-& (&&!(&*&&*! -&88!6( - (!2&5! '-!&!2 ?! 2!-!

'!&6(2 &&!2" '-!&!2*((!02!

- ;G6*'*6("!2 G%%# 26*'*6!6""-!!-& !I& -!'! &2&!2%%%#6("(((.!25 &*! !8(&--

!(&-!( &'?

6"!28 8-!'! &:3; -!( !'& - (G 2:

- ;G -!!-( & &*! (2 2!!2 * &*!'& 8 (& /- & (, *6!0!-, 0&"

-& '! & &! &*! -&'."-( & /- $6*'*-!(""6();

/&/

) * 0--

/&/

' -+*55*5,,6

-5*50*5,,6

/&/

* " * *.(&*! - !I -!((" -!!-(&&*!'-!& &*!!D.&5"!

-&88!*&&*!-!6( 2'.

&(--!"!0 & !D.&5"! -&88! '

5!'-!&!25 &*!2!

(&&&"!2!!2" !&( & !'!((- -&*!

-&!( & !I!'.&! - " 2'.

& -!( !'& &*!-! *! - ( !02!

'! &*! -&88! *0 8 5!!

'-!&!2 *!-! ( &*.( !I -!(( (( &*&&*!2.!(-!( &( 2:6!-!"((!'.-!25 &*! (2 -&88! 5 2!

(& &&"! 2!!2( '-!&!2 5 &*! '

%%#*!-8*&( 6(& 20!(&!2 &*!

& &(

-& && &!&*&&*!(((& &!

!-"+ 8!-&*! (& -!( & "!&&!- 2&!2 $#%%% 22-!((!2 & &*! '" 1D.2&-(&&!2&*&-!( &(&(6!""(&*!.- (.-

!( *2 ((. -(&3!I'".(0! '*-8! &*! '

>( I!2 ((!&( *! "!&&!- 2 &&!2 &*& &*! 88-!8&! - ' " .

& 2.! & &*!

.- (.- '!'

!(("'(*(2 (( (& 2(&*( !0!- 5!!

' &!

2!2&*&&6( (&?!- 2!.

2!- (&?!

-!(( (6! & !2!-"!-,-!( &( 22 &(&&! &*&&*!'*-8!*2 &5!!

-!8(&!-!2*! !-!" (&&!&*&&*!

*( & 5!!

5"! & !(&5"(* &*& &*! '*-8! 6( -!8(&!-!2 5(! 2'& &&*!' &-- , 2&*!-!( !,& .(&5! -!(.

!2&*&&*! '*-8!6(-!8(&!-!22 &&!2" ,&*!'*-8!6('-!&!2 !0!

&,&( '"!-5! 22.5&- &*!50!'&(&*&&6(4!*0!-!!--!2&&*! 2'.

&( 2 ( !''"" - G 6*'* !(&5"(*!( &*& -!( *2(.5 &&!2&*! !'!((- 2'.

&(--!8(&-& ''-2 6&*/!'& #&*!'&4!-! '" !2& -!(.

!&*&&*!.&*-&!( '!- !2 &*! !8(&--

!(."""!2&*!(&&.&- 5"8& -!8(&!- 8&*!'*-8!*!-!6( "!8"5-&&*!'*-8!5! 8-!8(&!-!2 :

'!26&*&*(,&*!"!- !2'.

(!"

!- 8 5!*"&*! &(' &!

2!2&*&&*!2'.

&(6!-!(.5 &&!25! 2&*! !-2

-!('-5!2 .

2!- (!'& # &*!

!( '& 2 &*& ( 6* & (

((5"!&*&&*!'*-8!6( &-!8(&!-!2 *( (.5 (( 5 -!( & ( 2 ( &&"" .

''!

&5"!*! -0(&(!'& #&*!'&8- &( 22& "& ! :2 (*!-!( &* 8&(*6&*&&*!5!

!&&*! -0(6( & !I&!

2!2 & -!( & ( 2 ( 6! *0! -!

!&!2" & !2, & ( 2 *0! '

"!&! ?

6"!28! &*! '&( 2 &*! 2'.

&& *! *0! &(&&!2&*&&*! !8(&--

!(*2 -!.(!2&-!8(&!-&*!'*-8!*!-!( (.'*-!.(" -!'-24!-! & '" !2 & ( !'."&! 8 (& &*!

& 6*'* &*!-6(! *( .

(6!-5"! 27.(&'"

# 4!6!-! - !25 &*! '"1D.2&-&*&&*!

2&*!-!( &(-!&*! " '-!2&-(! 2!&'"!-&*& '" ( *0!5!!

2!5 &*!6-?!-( 2 !0!

&&*!-!-! .&(& 2 8 '" (-68!(5 6-?

@ &*!'-'.

(& '!(,&*!

.8 !2-2!- 27.28 &-!(!&;

(2!*!

"'& #$%(""6!2&(2!'"-!2 &*& &*!

& *"2( ((. '*-8! ( '" !2 5 & 2 (*""5! &&"!2& -;-&2(&-5.& &*!("! -'!!2(&!- ? 8 !'!((- 2!2.'& (&*!-!- *! '"1D.2&-(*""-!;'"'."&!&*! .

&( 2.!&&*!(!'.-!2'-!2&-( ''-2 '!6&*&*(7.28 &&&*!!!'& &*& &*!

& *"2( &*! -(&;'*-8! -!( !'& &*! ((!&( &*!

((. 6&* &*! &*!- -(& '*-8!;*"2!-( *! '" 1D.2&-(*""'"".

&*! -&!(' '!- !2&-!.

2&*!!I'!(( .

6&* &!-!(&&H !-

- &*!2&!-!'! &&*!-!5 &*!

2 (*"" 0!-&*!

&>( 2.! ''-2 '! 6&*"6 5 :G# *!-!(*""*6!0!-5! -2!-(&'(&( A/LM C / A//41C 19th May, 2015 B-0 2!-> Whether to be referred to the reporter or not.

Yes No. √