← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/145/2024dismissed

Excise And Taxation Inspectors Association v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-02-28Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji5 pages

LPA-145-2024 ( O&M ) -1- 

     

 

 !"# $$ ""%% &#' (')*+# $ ," - ,.

/01 , 23( !- 4 ( (/.5!6- !/4-.!

723( !- .

/01 ( 23( !- ! 1/ ,2! # # '1%6(#869+ # (+8:(+#:686 #+""%% # ('#8&#:6% 84#%6')*6 #+#";8# <<<<    #%  + #  + "# %# " ""%   + ##  

="*>+%#(?%2'?9#"

-5@  A%*>+""%%;

++9#"+'?+B'+?+ ## 



 '# 6 9+#*>  #"# # ##?+B'"#:+"   #6 98%*%"###+6  6+*#) #+#?%# '% # + "#6 + %# (?% 2'? + #: + %%9? "##    

 

           







 

 ! "

 

!  

# 

     $  % & !  % ! "&     

LPA-145-2024 ( O&M ) -2- $

   

   % ' !  % !

"&  

 !(")

 

 *     

 

     + 

 !# ,   

!   



   !    

 !      "

-"

# 

!                 . ! , =  +%#(?%2'?:+%'+ "6 9+++*#6'%*%%'"%%>*>9>"#:6 9++9+:"%'+ !9*#8++B'%':*# "9+#''#9%%+8*C"8%*%#%%?'"#: + # ##': 6 +##6 + #% "9# # *> + (+>#

  9'%%>*%%9#+"* %%:"##%>#:"#:+B'#'%####': "#:'%*#% 9#'#,'% +')*   "#: ( (#8 -% ; !! ,'%6 @A # +#6 D@A,'%E6+'6'%*##+"'#" ,'%%>6 " /  9  ? + 6  + ?#' + + '+9'%:'*#C?9+B'#'%69++9 ?+:+@A,'%69++9#+" :  ,% 9"% '" +*? "#   

   



      F     !

"# 



$  $% %&   '  (

)  $*+,&-)./0

  

 $&. (    1 +*  &23     1 444 %,& )        5 26 -8% ""% /  =@G AH 6 





LPA-145-2024 ( O&M ) -3- (:%#%>6"/ 9%9#?+ 9+% +%? + +'?+ + "#: '  +% " 8#  *8 +# B'6 + ( 48#: + #?+%> *'# + : +##'8#:%%'"###':"69++ **)  ""#%>6 8#: /   

@

 '# =9'*>+')*'*%(#8-::69+#*> ="    #9#"'#"#*%%'"*>9># ##': !"'+9++8#:9'6+ ')*    "#: 4#'" IJ (#8 ,'%6 

'#    +#6 D  ,'%E6 9++ + :  # 9+  #: =

=

6 9#    + ,'% "#8 + "":+(#8*:+:#""" I1J69+#'#,'%=+(#8+%%:"#+"" ""IJ ,'% "#8+"#+'%*""> "  + (#86 '% + " + '% B'%  "#6"?+"""I1J "#"" IJ6 G "#: " %? 9+ @ :"##> "     #9#8%*% ""I1J9'%?+9+ K "   #9#*%%'"#::?+  !"#6  !"#     !"#6   #9+9#+8?::':"#9#C?

 '+#"#?+>#69+#+#:? K"9#* %% '" #: :?

@  + " +' 8# 9# 

LPA-145-2024 ( O&M ) -4- "'#' ,'%69++"#8 K*'#  +%%*C + ?  + #%# ##?:6 9++ 96  >6 :  + >#

69'%'+%%9+?#' "*)+*C*>+("#?#"+9 :#+9#:++ ,'%+: #6"##:++++8>#?+%+ 9#" 8'% ?#8 #*? # # ?  ! '+#':69#+#"++9#"% 9:*%+++  +*)#+ %*#8#+#"%  +

'++ +'"9+++*#'%>"#'" 9+'9'#+#?+'"#9+9#+%? +6+"#??#8'+9#:?#9# +9   +9 +# # +8 *   ""#%>6  ,'% 9# 8# '*):#  +%%?  ! '+ #':6 # # +#+9++8**>+%#(?%2'?69#+ #"++"'%##':+6 ##%%#+##+%#(?%2'? +#?':#*>%##'%#+""%%; ++#"%?

%'"#8,'% ,'% '+8+9++*C%*#"%% !+%#> **>+%#(?%2'?++'+# "9'%:??+%,'%%9++"#8# K B'#*+6+"#:###': !'+#':6 #%9+++*?+,'%+*#?

LPA-145-2024 ( O&M ) -5- +%#(?%2'?69+%:?+9#"

""%6#?%>6: @ ?""%6>6" 4 ( (/.5! - !/4-.!

723( !-  ! 1/ ,2! 234 7*#'#> 6 ) 5++#"C?H# L 5++##"#*% /