M/S Ceigall India Limited v. M/S Sanghi Distributors




  
   

 !"# $%&'&(""

!") *+'&,
-&.$-

$ /0'1' *+'2,3&&'$0&41$0'5

'-$'
 



 
 
 


 

 0'$( *0  24$&6-7%$60$3$ *0  2&,6-7%$60$30'-$ 9999 
 
 
3&' &'   ,&'$ $3 0-0  $3 0-  1-,:&-&,1$3$%$3,01-$3$&$&'14$ &$'-4$'

0&0$$30-0$3$&$&3-4-&$$-40-0 -;1-,$-$-") !"# 30-1-,63:7063- ,0$- $3 $ 10 $3'< $& $ '$$ &$' -1' 4 '$&, $3 14&%$&  $3 0-0  -&''&  3 $ &- $ 7& $3 0$1&$6'0'1$:30$3$&$&:'-70$&'-

' $3 '&$& 0&- $3 ' - $3 0- 1-, 30&,$3$&$&&0$,0-:&$3$30'&,&$30-0  -&''&6 $3 $ % :' 0-0- $ 4 :1- 1 4 $3 &1,-0-0 = 30'-$,0-$'$$3$%0$&,-' $3$0'-%-&$&'%$&-&-7&-%-4'&>10%3'0-0' %- & 0 41$ 40106 !""

 3 ,-' :0 $ 4 -&70- 4

=!

!""

3$:'$4-:&$3&'7-'$3$0& 4&,'1&-$'&$,&'$%3%'&,$

3 0'-$<' %' - $3 $<' -% & '30$ &' $3&'

 3 0'-$ %$-' $3$ $3 $ 3' $ - $3 1 $&0'%$$3,-''1&-4&$ 3$$3$30 3-:3&-&$$&,$3'%$-'$3$&$01'-$?$3$ $311$%%1$$30'-$<'$37&,-&70-$3 $&0@1$&$&'$310%3'0-0'

30'-$:3&-&$$&,$3$ &$-&-$'1$3$&0@1$&$&',-''0$310%3'0-0' '$$'$3$$3&':'%%1$$3$37&,&-$?$3 $$3,-':&$3&'$&1$-0&-'7-' # A0&,0$:&$3$30-1-,':3%%$-$3 0'-$<'%$$&'

) 3 0-0 - ;1-,$ -$- ") !"# -&$$&, $3 :&-&,1$&$&'$'1$$3-$&'$310%3'0-0'6$3$' - - $3 4% @1$&$&' & %'&-04 -$&  ' : 0 & ,0$:&$3$3&-&,'-$30'&,$30-1-,6&$&'$ %''0 $ '$ 1$ $3 %$' & -$& 
$ &' '1&%&$ $ $ $3$  !"

!" $30'-$0:0--'$$$$3$<'%%1$' &&$'4?'

3%'&,4%'$$'$3$'1
= 6! 6==)+B:'-1 -44$3$$$30'-$ 30'-$-0'-&$' %&0$& $ $3 $ $30  31'6 -&$$-  1$ 
 = 6!

6==)+B :' 4 4 $3 $ $ $3 0'-$ '  !"

!"

!"

3$-100$$'&$3$3*0%36 !" 
#%'%3,,0,$&,$
 !%' 300&-6$3006$ $3-*0%36 !" 1$
" 6!

6==)+B-1-44$3

$$$30'-$ ':$-0&06$3$-'$- $3' 3$%$-'$3$&$-&-$$34%1$' $30'-$3-01'-$-&7010$30@1$&$&'1-0$310%3' 0-0'

A063:706&%&-$%%$$30'-$<'%$$&$3$ &$01'-$-&70$34%@1$&$&'%%1$$3$37&, &-$?$3$:&$3&$3'$&1$-0&-'7-'- %%1$$34%1$'$-&, 3&'$10&-&'%000$3 0'

&0'$6 $3 $ 70 &0- $3 0'-$ $3$ &$ :1-$?$3$1$&-1''$30'-$-&70-$3 4% ,-' ' 0 $3 10%3' 0-0'  2%-6 $30 &' $3&,  0%0-:3&%3&-&%$'1'&40''$:3$30'-$:1- 3701'-$-&70$34%@1$&$&' 
$&'$'$$-$3$&$&-$ -'%%1$0&'&0&%'$3'&-,-' 0&'$30$3&, 0%0- $ &-&%$ $3$ $3 0'-$ :' 14 $ -&70 $3 4% @1$&$&'00' -$30'-$01'-$-&70$3,-' 00%$&40'6$3$:1-&$30%10'37 0%0--$3'&'00$3$30 
$-&-$ 3&'&'$$30 0'$%%$$30'-$<'%' 3$'$1&$'-% &0''$$3'$$1$0$&%1-0'%$& = $3&'%$ '07-4$30'-$

' : $&- 0&06 4 $3 0-0  -&''& -$- ") !"# $3 0-  1-, ,0$- $3 $  0&-  10$3'$'$$&$'-1'


$-&-$7&$30$1&$ 3$&$& :'6$3006-70$&'-

 3 -4$ &' '$4&'3-  3 % $&$& 37&, 4 -&$$--$30-0-&''&37&,4-70$&'-6$3$& 7&4:$$3$&'$$31$-+0'$$$3'$ $3'$&'%$&$30'-$-$$30$0?&%$&$$3  10$ 0 -&&%$& 0 '$$&, '&- $3 0-0 0 $ -$ 00&$0%-&,'0$?&,$3%1$&@1&-$& "!

3  &'6 $3006 -&'&''-  3 &$0& 0-0 '36 3:706 %$&1 1$ - &%1-&, =!

!") 
 $3 $&6 3:706 $3 $ '3 $ -&'' 6 &$6 %1406 0$ :&$3 ''''& 0 %0$  $3&0- 0$ 0&,3$' & 0'%$  &$' 00$&' 740&74 37400$&'4-$:&$3& $30-1'1%10'41'&''


$&'%0&&-$3$$3$'3 4 $&$- $  $3 '$$1$0 -1' - $3 '0&' - :,'  &$' '

E2  /F
 G 

  2
 ""

!")  E

 ..
G H07&-0<