Commissioner Of Central Excise, Chandigarh-Ii v. M/S Hansa Tube Pvt Ltd
!"!
#$%% &&!""!
# '
#'() !"
*+# !,'+ %%%%-- ((# ./"% 0/"% #"12 3%4 % %%%%% "- # # 0$ 5406%6
5406%6 0
!!!!
!1+'!*%
"
" #$ $% #$&% '
(
)%* "
(
+
./ 0 /+,
)1 2
+ 3 $4 $4 #$$5 '
(
)#* ""
+
) ",
7 8 '7 * 7 8 '
* 7 8 '7 * + 9#&$ &4 9#&$ && :
&4%5
0 #$$#)$% #$$%)$; < + ", /, = &#&>?#451) = @
" /
8 =
7 =
7
, 8 A" A #'*
&4;;
' A*
7 ( ," "
+ = >>9&#?41) + "
/,
B + C / $; $5 #$$5 '
(
)&*
/ = &#&>?#451) " = >>9&#?41)
&&
/
, /
$4 $4 #$$5 '
(
)#* ""
/ ) D&;
B
/
/ '
* "
" = &&9;5$991) '= ,
, ,* 1 2
+ 3 )E )BB 3 0+ &# = / &&
< " = >>9&#?41) '= , , / (, ,*
3
< + " " . / ,
&&
'
*
" , = &&9;5$991) '= ,
, ,* 2
+ 3 E )BB 3 '0+ * &% = / &&
F
C + "
(
+ '
+A* = +
/ " 7 / 7 -
"
, G
" + "
= >>9&#?41) &> = (
"
+
/
+
" 7
!"#
, " / +
,
7 " C
"
+ C 3 %
= #$$#
C
+
= 7 7 + " , /, 8
2 + C "
%
= #$$#
) 1( %. '
!$) '&*
C '
*
'
*
:
+
I '
*
+
I
'
*
+ %
0 '
(
(
*
&49> ';$ &49>*I '
*
+ %
0 '7 B" *
&459 '5> &459*I '
* . "
,
+ &%?
:
#$$& '&;
#$$&*I '
*
+ % "
G
'
* '
* '
* '
* '
* + ,
, , #$$#
7 ,
"
"
+)/C + ("
7 " B
, :
'0" = * . #&;1>?) #5 &4>? +
"+ 7 = 5;9 '-* #5 &4>?
" , #$$# -( ) : +
+ % "
4> $& :
"
'#* ./ ,
+) '&* C
,
C
,
C , (" , + " +
%
= #$$# / + '&* C +
B
+ '&*
+ % "
4> $& :
"
2/ + '%*
)
8 '%*
", 8 ," , , ,"
"
,
, ,
8 , (
+ , " ," " , " ," "
(" +
, ," " +) %
, , / #3'
! #2 1!(!9
'-:& #
#: 1:
) !"
##: !#(-'
1 "
'
'-:& #
1: #!#-1" ' -!(,
"+ &"
(3 "!
"1 + !#-1"'
'
& ""1 + ' '2 !#,-'!((:-'
""
'"1 + -!(,
"'
'
& ""1 +
+ ;
"C
) ';*H
+ C "
, , G
+ +
"
+) '#* % ;
;
",
+ "
'5*
+) ';* +
/ + ';* F 2
+) % ;
, / A" A " / A" A
2
" = C C + = >>9&#?41) "
+ "
+ 7
!"#
B 7 ("
,
"
D 0 "F "
= &4;;
/ 0 " "
+
7 :'&* = &4;;
",
"
" , " "
,
B . &$
+ ) B
(
+
"
"
+
$ %"
&"
' ()
; *+ &
$ +
,"
/
+
," " C C "
&$ H
"
+
$ %"
&"
"
+ + 2,
" +
+ B
+
+
$ %"
&"
' () *
+ + D9
"
, + /
" + , / ,"
+
"
"
9 & E
+) '&* 59: /
/ "
, " " ,"
< +
"
+ / ,
" /
B "
, =<:170
+ , , / / -
/ C +
, + , , / " +
, / , +
"
C , / +
, + ," C
+ , J 3
+ +
,
"
/
7
- "
+) %
%
= #$$# "C
, ", 8
," , , ,"
"
, 2
"
, " = > %% =0 > !3:#"+!
?+ + '"- @!#,/'
"
# $ "/
?+ + ''
- '2( $ "/