← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/30/2015dismissed

Commissioner Central Excise Commissionerate, Panchkula v. M/S Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.

2017-08-01Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

Gurbax Singh 2017.08.29 14:38 

     

  !"

 

      

   



 !

   

 "    #

#   $%#  &'

# #%  $%#  &# (% #$%   &'

  

!( 

)

 ! ( !

 **** '

# #%) + 

)   

!   ,-& 

 

   +.// 0  ( 

! !

! +.3+43+- 0 ),2  

$ 4-354336

(

7( 8

9  

7%) :02 ;  8

 (   !(

 

 < '  8 !  #

'

 

 (! = 02 ;   "! 8

    !(

>!! ;

 7   $ <

!

(! !   ! ( ! 8 '    (!   8 

!



! '  8 !   = 02 ; 

 (   !( 8) ,  #  43 

 #  4334 7 



**

8

'

 < 7  (!   !

' 

!   7    7     

 (=?

4  7

  

!@!

 

  '

 !

  

! 

' 8  !   !

   

 " ! 0

 ( <2 & # ! 8



 8

  ( (!   (  )!

!

 ! !  (     8!! 7  

'

 ! '   

 

   (! 7 

 8'  7

 7 !  7 ! 

 

7 

 8'     (!

 ! '  7  

 9 '  !

    !(  9 '  8 

 9 '  < ! 

  

 !  

  ! '  

 !   9 '  ! !



  

  !  8 !  ! 7  <

  !(

)

 ( !(   

 

<  8 9 ' 



   

 ! 7 7



' 

 <



! 7 

 ' 

    

   ! 7  <



  !( ' !



!( 7 

( 

  7     !

! ,3+4+... 0 )+2 7  !

 ! ! 

 ! '  ,6-5B,/) 7

! 8'



( 7    !   ++ > 

7

  

' ! 

 #  +.// 0   1 # 12  ! 7    ++  

  !@!

(   ' !

** ! !

! 4.364336  !

 ! !  ,6-5B,/)

( 7  

!  !

 9



'     ((! 8'

 ! 

8  8

 ! ! !

! +.3+43+-



!  !  !(

 ! '    ' 8 !  

 !

 (! 7   7  

 

 

8'

) , ;    !

! 

 /  8 

(

' !! 8'

   ! !

! +.3+43+- 0 ),2

  

 

 (! 8

( ! !

  ! ' 

8 !    C

' ! '  ! !!  

( !  

 (! !

 

      8 !    7  

 

 (! C

  

!

  !

!

(! 

!  ' 7 

' ! ' C 8 

  8(

 (!  ! ! !! 7   !

 8 

! 

! 8'

  7  (

7! 8'

   

!( !! 8'

  ( !  ! %) :B  7





! '   8 ! !! 8'

 

 ! 

 (! !

'   

 

 

 

 (! !  

( ! !

!   

(



!

 (! 

!  ' 7 

' ! ' C

 

   ! 8'

 8

    

*+* >

  

 "

! 0 2 ! '  8 !

'

 

 



 (!?

D    8  ! 

@!(

( ! !

 

8(

(!  

' ! ' !   ++< 

 #   ' 8   @!(    

   

  

  

! " #$% &! !  

 '

  (

   

  

$)

! " # *  ! - " ! 

)  8

 

' 

(

'   '  !( !! 8'

  

 8 ' 

8 !

 

    8

9  

 9

'

! !! ,'

# #%-   ,# (%- ./.01)"

  +,   

   -    -