Commissioner Central Excise Commissioneate Rohtak v. M/S Indian Oil Corpn Ltd

  
  
  
 































 


 




















































  !

#$
%
& 
 
'
(


 !"
"#$ %

"
  !"
"" &! ( #)"

*
) 
* 

 
   #+,
-


* 

  ....

""'()*'+',-'  
 
 

"


) 
1

  


 
22
3


 
4 45


,
"




  6$22$7
,




8
3

"
5



09
 "





)* 
/
 
/ 
6:


3


 4/ 45

/

,
"0 
;"


:
*
0



09



 
 
 





 
 





 !"   # $  #  


   #%  $!"

&    # $  $     '       

  
       




( 
 
 ) *

    


    
        )  

    + ,(+,  ) 

     -  .

& 
  
   
  

 

*


 





   (
/
          +  , (+,
/


  -.

&  
/


*

   
* 
  ", 

:




,



 
09
 
)//
= 
> 
-

0



 ?


 




 

    

  
:
 
 
 


 

09



* 


88

"
5

 ?  
:



 ,,

" "

,
 "
"  
:

"


:
"



8
3

" 5
09
 
 





 




@
-(
:
 

9 

:



 



"9
"  A2
* 
6A$?


3
 5
"

67$?


3
 5

) 
 

6$?


3
 5



:
" 
 
 
 

:
, 
*

6$2?

22
, *

,
 

"  A2
 
09

68?$2?

272
, *

 


272
 
09

62$A?

A 3
 5





:
"


 ? 


9
 

,


"9
  
 
 
0  


:
0

,
 

 


"

:
 
:

@ 
#)
78
  
@

 

  ,




/ ,"






 

*

"




:
0

,
 

 


"


 
"9
 0 9
 
:

0

,
 

 

*

 
 9
,

/ 
"9
 


0

,
 
09
 
 

 

 
 



" 
:

@
-(

 

,9




:
"


 *

"
2

 




3


 
4 5


. 0
* 


0
,
*
:

"
9





"9
* 0



" 

) 9
"
A



,

 

"9
09
 
 
,


0
  
 
 


"
7



0
,

*
:

"
9

,
"
"9


* 
 
   
:

0

,





"



,

 9


 "



 

*
:

0

,





"
  

,9


:
"


:




,


  ,"

 
*  "


 
 
 
 9   
"



0  2


* 



88



 
 
 



"9
"


) 
35

 
 
 


* 
"
"



 9
 ,
:

 

B:*
 
 

,




:
 
 9
:
 9
 ("0
) 
C 


/ 
 
 0(1 "
 )
' #2&#&#3&44     
  "    ' ##&$2&4 %   )  
   ' #2&$&%2&#%$
 
  
  . 
##5 (#"
5 &#322 )
/6
/
  
 )  / - 78" &,


( ,)' #2&$&%2&#%$

 - 78" &,
  . 
##5""
5 &#322 
' %"
'&

( 7

 
  . 
##5+ "
5 &#322 )  / - 78" & ,


( , 

-69&1) -(:
  -   78" &  ,
    +
6  "   9&  "
  :
 -&78" (- 1
/ '8&1
 

;

 

 




09
 / 


,
 
 



 ?

  
09
 
)//
= 
> 
-

0
3 " 5 A "



 
  
"0 
 
 
"9
"   
 


 
* 
 


"







 9
  
:


   
"9 


 
 



 
 

B
 

,9
"0


 9




0
 
 




0"
 :

 
 
 ?  
  
 
  
* 
 9
*



/ 
 :



,



 

 
 
"9
 


 9




0
" 

B

   
 
"

!"#$
%

" 

 "

 &%"'  ( )

"0 


*



0
 9
  
:

 8 "



 
 
 


 
 "  "
7



"0 
 9
 
"9
 


 
09
 

9



,
 
 
0 "  







  
:

:

 
:


,
*

 


 
: 
* 
:

:"


 



   


 7 


,
"



 
 
:


 
* :
 / 
:


:



  

/
 
 0.6%<  


 ) 
&/
   
###:
 ( 5 &#334!7 
  ) ! 
(#. 
%5 "
5 &#322(##322& 
 ! 
 ($ 
###:
 ( 5 &#334(##334 " =/&  
 

   
 
   )
 

/  

 & )%<   
  !

( 

& )/&3%<-

( )6 &

 

/ 

 &%<

 

/


> (  
+7
.  


?3 & 


 )
/
 


 !  :        
  
  0




; 

/
   :
.

  .  .

 "



5 &#34%(%#34 &


 )
/
   :
 ( 5 &#334(##334& 
 



 )/
   
#2?:
 &     (     &    
  )  /  
 



 









  
 
/ 3 ): )& 2 ;






, *




" 

@
   

3-(5
:


0 

@


3 5
 
@
  - 
" 
:
0

,






 


9




 
 
 



"9

 
:

 






"9
: 
 

 

 


:
0
 
-( :

"

 
 9$

9




B:*


 
 
 


"
7
 
"9

 




3 5 
:


;"


 
09

9



,
 

&


"9

 
0
 

:"
0





"



  
"9

"
*
0
 
 

 

,
 
 9


  

%


 

 ?  
 
: ? 9


"9 "  



 
 
:


:

,

  * :

 
?


-

0
:




 



"
7
 
"9
 0 9


0


*
0


,


0 "


90

 

 
 "


1*  
09





"
7
 0'4 -) !@(#  ) /

 ) 
 
)   )
&
 )

 
) 
 6
 % )
&
 ) AB    
 !:
&!

( )


)   / 
  )
) 
 
 

" =/ )

 >;  
 
" 
09
 
  ? 


 '1,2,'34()5367-23!6)
3 " 5
:"

0
  0


 
  % 
 
 " " 
 

 9
:


;"

 


"0 


  

, *
 
"



,


 



 
 

,9

 

 9
 9
 "



*


 
 " ;"


"

0


0
:

"
 9


;"
:

:"

9
 9
 
0 

 


/ 
" 
0:
 " 9
"


,


 

: 
 
"


09 
 
"
 
 


* 

 

" 9
 "0 
;"


:
:


", 

0 







   "

 
 
 

/ 
 


 

,9


  "#'8- )'7

""'()*'+',-'  96-(1
*-2 536-92 5)12 









 3'-,23*