High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/35/2015dismissed

Commissioner Of Central Excise Delhi Iii v. M/S Honda Motorcycles And Scooters India Pvt Ltd

2016-10-045 pages

''

!"

()*+ !

$%&% -.

/

!

"

*- 01*221 01*222

- * &345!

3' !6,7$!

""!

* 5! !!'2% 836,7$!

&'

!9 &3% ,!" 3

%&% !":

3%&$4 !%&% "";% %!"<4 &% "!;! %&% 84 , ,

6'!&& :=4&5&6#$%& !

,2 7%$ !#''

""!

!"6 ; "3%( &3 603 !"0+% ''

!" />?

@A(+- B(%+ C3 20& !" , %&94&% ,!

,"

8!""= $ $;3%$33!&:

$3 %$!"%&&4 ;%34 8% 8% !$&!

,5 %& D (%%+ C3 20& 8& 3! '% ;!&

5

,3 =94&

,3 % &%8 !4 &'

$%7 &3

;

$ $D (%%%+ C3 7% ; ,

55%&&%

&;!&"

8!""=$ $;3%$3;!&&%8

,!,%

'"!$ &D (%7+ C3 7% ; ,

55%&&%

& &%8

, ,%

,!

& &34", :

,!&% ,%7%,4!", $%&% , $%&%

&D (7+ C3 7% ; ,

55%&&%

$!

4"$ &%, !% !$&!

%& %&%""

8!"!

, % !$$ ,!

;%3 ' 7%&% 2 $% 3 6 >..D (7%+ C3 % %& 5!

,! = 3 55%

55%&&%

& $ &%4 , 4

$6

>.. '4 '& 7% ; % !" , &&% 8 !

'"!$ DC3 55 $%&% &!E

:=3

&% 7"7 ,% &!5 &!5

%&&4 :=;!= &%8 8!,%

%5 &;%"" :

,!&9% $%&%

7% ;D (7%%+ C3 3 7% ; , 3!& :

&%8

, ;%34 ' '

!''"%$!% 5%

&D (7%%%+ C3 2;!&$ $% $ &%,

!% ""!3!:!,%834 , $%&%

$!& 6F!

'4 7& 3 5%$!"&

( > +"

G(""+D (%#+ C3 20& !" , ,

%& $ $!

,"

8!""=94&% ,% ,%&5%&&%

!" ,4 % 8 3 '

$= %7%" ''

!"

GH >?

.+ !

, (21

/. ?

.+ , := 3

':

24'

4 ,%!$ !% &%5%"! %&&4 DI

, $4 " 3 !''

""!

6 ;3%"

8 3

94,85

"3%%834 %

2 7%$ !#71 23! 5!6

.( +2( "+!

, 55%&&%

2 7%$ !#7 !'!

% "%

&

!% !"1,6

(>+2 .

( "+6&4:5% 3!

3%

&'%

3!

%& % %"% 8!''

!"6;3%"

!'' 7% '% #'

&& ,:=!

&4: ,%

%$ 63!%&&4

%$%

$5'"%!

' 7%&% 2 $%

( +

$6 >..( &3 603 $0+ 3 3!

,6"

,$4 " !&& &&

&4:5% 3!!&!8!% &3 94,85

"3%%83$4 6:

8 "% ,4' :=3

""!

63

!

; , &'!&& ,:=3%&4 % 6 "3%@7

%$ 45!% ,4$&71,6

( .>+1 .()+ ,55%&&%

63!E7"

8!

' %& &6

( +1()+6;3

%3!&:

'%

,3!!'' 7!":=3

55%

! '44':=3 &4: ,%

%$ %&

&4

%$%

$5'"%!

5% 8!

'% , $%, 3!3 %&

% %"% 8!''

!" 4 3 &4:5% ,3!3 %&&4 3!&"&&%8 %$!

3!3

&'%

,3 :

%

%"% 8!''

!"!E% 8 % $ &%, !% !$3!3

(''

!"&+3!,, $%, ,3 !" !&& &&

%&

!74 "=% 84' , !"%

7 *?& *! 4% ,=8 1,6

. ( G+ 1 H

. (3

,!&0*?&*! 4%,=81,0& &$!& +6!8!% &;3%$3 %7%"''

!"GH >

.;!&'

8!3!%5 :

24'

4

,$4 " &'

4 3 &4:5% ,3!3

!"

0*?&*! 4%,=81,0& &$!&

(&4' !+;!& ,%&5%&& ,7%, , , .

7 *! 4%24J4E% ,%!1,6

( >+1 .>(2+(3

!&0*! 4%24J4E% ,%!1,0&

,$!& +63

6

5 %&63

%& & 4':=3

7

5!

%& 5!

:!$E6%;%"":

!

# $%& 4%"

3 &3 !8 % '4&6!& 4 ,%

$!& *! 4%24J4E% ,%!1,0&

,$!&

(&4' !+;!& .K6;3

!&%

&'

6%;!&5

"=

H K

3 ! % 8"

,$4 " '! % ,;%348% 3 %&&4 ;3 !":

!";!&5!% !% !:"

$% $45&!

&!& %$ ,!:7 6;

,3!3 "

8!"%&&4 ;!&, $%, !74 3 &'

:= 3 55%&&%

(''

!"&+;3%"

83 , !"% *?&*! 4% ,=81,0& &$!&

(&4' !+3 ;!& 4 ,:

% %"% 8!''

!"

:

!" "= 3!3 !"!8!% &3 ,

'!&& !"% *?&*! 4%,=81,0& & $!&

(&4' !+;!& '

8:

24'

4 !3!%5 63;

63 &!5

3!& ;:

,%&5%&& ,&3 "

8!"%&&4 7"7 ,% 3!&!"

!,= :

$%, ,% !74 !&& &&

6;

, ,!

= 8% %&&4 !&;3 !"

:

!"

;!&$5'

7% ; !""

,% 84"! %=% !'' 7!"8 !

55%

&

3 &5

,!:7 6;

, ,3!!

= %!"<4 &% "!;! %& &% '

!"$$ ,% 8"=63

&!5 %&,%&5%&& , (!9 &3% ,!"+ 4,8 (! &3!

2% 83+ 4,8 .

/ 5E