M/S Shreewood Products Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner Of Central Excise Gurgaon
!"#$%&'
(( "#
)*+,
%&'& .
/
+. 01+22 1 01+2 22 !
. +!"34 5" " '"#6-7 %"
##" +!"8 !9 '5&6-7 %"
"8 '5& -"# "#:"'
"!&'& 3 =
& "# !- ! >
?>
@A ) , -"
- B
6 ("''
- ;< ='
4'6$%&'
*2 !7&% "$(( ##"
!&;= "#6 :
#5&)
!'5 ! 6 0 5 !&;= "#0,!"&'& 3 5
## :& 3'=;' " &"#C= ' & '
#":.
D)&, E5 ! 5 ##" &' & ' :
F
FG )&&,E5 ##" &' I !/I & !4'
2 % &
% G )&&&,E5 & -& 3'
-!&;= "#"!
!7 " - !"!< !-GJ
##" '=;4& - 5" 5 ##" &'
3"3 -& 5 4" = "% =!
(#<:
-6;# %K;
"!-'6 #='5-
!'" -( "#
!' 5 !
&''= - '5 : %"='
&% 5
B ?? (!
'& 3 7< $%&'
-= <" -( "# <
+"!%56??
+"!%56??/5 "-8=-&%" & 3"= 5 !& <67&- !- !@& @ !&3& "#-"
-
%
&!4 - 5 =
-= <"4 = & 3 ??
#"%' "--& & 6 ( "# <
?F #"%' :"' "#'
&4( - 33!& - "3"& ' 5 !6 5 ##" (!
- "(( "# ;
5
!&;= "#"# 3:& 5"((#&%" &
$ 4( & 4(!
@- '& ' 5
##" % =#- % 4(#<:& 5 5 ' "< !&;= "#7&- -"
/-&'4&''
- 5 "#
##" 5
##" -&'(
& ' "% !<" -- - 5 &!
=
-= <6 ' " -( "# <"4 = & 3 6?
6?6 >@ - '& 5
"#
##" :"'!
!&;= "#" -5 "!- !& ' L&- ! -"
F6 5 "# (!
- ;< 5 ##" :"'
"## !&;= "#5 4" -:"''
" - 5 4"
!:"'
4& -;"%K -&'(
& !4'
-&!
% & '&''= -' 5
!:"''
##" ;
%"4
= -;<& !
C= 5"
% :"'4"- ;< 5 ##" 7&-
-"
F65 "%% 7 4& - '=;'
C= #<:
"#'
!
7 =35 5 4" - (!
-& 3':
%&- "-8=-&%" & 3"= 5 !& <7&-
F" - & "##<- 4" -
#< 6F?6 >@:"'%
&!4 "3"& ' 5 ##" :& 5 C=&7"# ( "# < "! &"##< 5 !
= - :"'
3!"
?6:5 "' ("! &"##< 5 :"'
3!"
B
?5 ##" %#"&4 -& #"< -!
= 5
!!
= "# 3:& 5&
:"'- "# :& 5;< 5 ''&' " 44&''&
! ;<("''& 3 5
!- !@& @(( "#
?"
!"((!
(!&" & 3("!
= "3"& '
4" -!"&'
-7&- -
FFF6 6/F/>@:
-&!
;
%!
-& '=4 !E = -" -!
/6BB6 >@:"'
-&!
-5 ##" (!
-"(( "#5 44&''&
!)(( "#',67&-
! -"
-
? "%% - 5 "# - ;< 5 ##" " - -&!
FF6 6/F/>@ (& & 3 5" 5 5& ;< ;"!
= 8=' !&%54 (=!'=" %
'"&-"4 = :"'
("&- 5 B
? ' 5 %#"&4
5
("<4
& ' :"' - %#& 5 3!
= - 5" 5 "4 = :"'
-:& 5& 5!
5' %#"&4
F" - ("! &"##< 5 = :"'!
-:& 5& 5!
("''& 3
!33!& -"3"& ' 5 ##" (!
-"(( "#;
!&;= "#6:5&%5:"'-&'4&''
-7&- -B
- %#& & 3 5
#&
' - % #
! 5 ##" '=;4& - 5" 5 &''=
3"!-& 3
=
@- '& 4"- ;< 5
"''
!- %&'&
%"'
%"4 =(
!% '&- !" &
2=(!
=! & 44&''&
!"#$%&'
6<- !";"-7 1 -6
) ?,1)2,5 "#':
-&'(
;<
2=(!
=! "K& 3 & % '&- !" & " %&!%=#"! &''= - ;< 5
! 4
-&"6+& &' !<
& " % > > 9@AF-"
!6&
%"'
';
2=(!
=! 6 !"
' :"'!
-=% 4I !" =45 %&!%=#"!
! 4
-&"(!
7&- - 5"
!4"#"((#&%" &
!!
= -:"'
B
C=&!
-'&4(#
&''=
&%& "# 3:& 5% (<
!6 ;"'&'
:5&%5 5
= -;
%"4 -= =! 5 !!
#& =( " &7&'& %58=-34
5&'% =! & E
B
M +>'122 %=!& & '1 -7''&' " 44&''&
!62 !7&% "$ &7&'& 5" -&3"!56- %&- /
B6:5 ' HI( !" =4:"'
-&!
("&-
-"
! 5!
4 -"
= -;
%"4 -=
:"'"#'
4"- &7&'& %5 8=-34
5&' =! & E /
BM"!<" "L" "'(" &*
!"#+&##75 2 "
"!<" "" -"
!6- %&- F
6 :5 = - "!<" "
!"#2"# '"$% 6? 6 5&'% =! -&!
!("<4
!" =4 = -
-"
'& ':
4"- "' & "##< 5
'=%%
-& #& &3" & '=;4&''& &' 5" "
!&;= "#'
4" -"3"& ' 5
F6& ;
%"4
= - -
!!
= -:"'4"- &44 -&"
#< 5
F ' 5 = :"'!
-& " ="!<" -(!
?6 5 ##" :"'
-;
< - 5!
-"
("''& 3
!&;= "#H !" =46"'":"!- -;< 2=(!
=! & 1 -0'%"'
)'=(!", 5 !5" -6#
'=;4& 5" "'&' 7&- !("''
!&;= "#6 5
= -:"'
F" -("! &"##< 5 = :"'!
:& 5& 5!
5' 5
6"'
!("!
= 5 :"'-&'(= E5 :"''
-6 5 = :"'&44 -&"
#<!
-65 ##" &' " <& ' =! 5 !'=;4& - 5"
!" <("!
-&' ("&-6 5 '5 =#- " "
!"
5" /I( !" =4 "!-#
("! & '" -( !='
- 5 ("( ;
K = -&'(= "% ' !-"!
5" - 4" -
-= <
??
#"%':"'!"&'
-"3"& ' 5 ##" 7&- !- !@& @!&3& "#-"
"--& & 6( "# <
?F #"%':"'"#'
&4( -5
##" - -6?
6?6 >@5 "#:"'5 "!-;< 5 !&;= "#6 :5&%5:"'"## -7&-
F" - 5 4" -:"''
"!
= 6& 6 /6BB6 >@ :"'!
##" & " ="!<6
?6:5 "'!
4"& & 3("!
= 6& 6 FF6 6/F/>@ :"'!
-& (!
?'( %&!%=#"!
! 4
-&"6 +& &' !<
& " % 6"'!
";
6& %"'
= &'
:& 5& 5!
-"
("''& 3
&'
'
!4"#"((#&%" & &'!
C=&!
-'&4(#
!&''=
&%&
5 & 5 %"'
;< 5
F5 &' !& 5 -"
&% -& 5 ("''
"= 5 !& <
&#& 3 5 "'
F
2=(!
=! & 1 -0'%"'
)'=(!","## - 5
= -"# 3:& 5 !" =4
(& 3& 7& : 5
'"&- "% '" -%&!%=4' " % '6& =!
(& & ##" 5 & &' ("<4
" =4
-"
! 5!
5' &## 5
= -:"'3!"
-"
("''& 3
!;< 5 !&;= "#
F5 C= ' & '6!
";
6"!
" ':
-"%% !-& 3#<
/ "#' " -'-&'(
)"8 '5& -"#, =-3 )"!& - !2& 352&-5=, =-3
/ 4K E5 !'( "K& 3>!
"'
'>
E5 ! ! ";# .
'>