Punjab Urban Planning And Dev Authority Mohali Thr Chief Administrator And ANR v. Tril Amritsar Projects Ltd And ANR
!" #"! $%$&'()$ * *+'#,*-. +!/! .00!1!# '+!&, ! '*+$# 2(($&&! *3 4$#3 5)#,*3!# #' $6*35*728'#)$#&-9 '/ !3 )#,*3!#
#' $6*35*72
)"!,! 7! '*+$# 2 $3(' 7$ *3
$3$#%$7' :22;
#' '
6$7' :2<2;
71)$ * (&'!7$7' :=2<2;
: >5
2 00?
0 >5
2 0 ?
!
"
#
$ % & ' (
?
.2 @ (
) * !
+!,(-& .*&&
/
' ( - . !
! ! ! ! + * ! &! ! 0! !
2 !
+!,(-& . %
&
!6* !& !*#,A:
5 ! 6 /7 /889 !0*:* $ ! &-:$., ' (! ! ' ",3 ! /7;<( /8=
) , !* * (;<48(8388>, (/ /889 "!4-. =! ! & ! *! *& ! & *! *&
"!;-. + ! !*!*0 & +
) , /9 8( /88<// /88< ) , !* *! !
' /(9 /88< /7 /88<
" :$ 2 !* (/ (( /88< * (< 8( /8(8
) , (8 /8(8 * ! & ?'6"@ 2 ) !& /;
/8(8 ?'6"@ 6// (/ /8(( , !* A 6 ! * *! !*=! &8;
/8(/& , !* ! &> 5 ?B@ ! (8-(. !0* :* # $ ! &-B! . !(<<7- ?
! (<<7@.
!0*! " B 8( /8(/-+!,(& . ! 0 & %**& 6 * * *
)?'6*0 " @ $56 !(< 8;
/8(/ *! !* *& , // /8(/ ) 81 8< /8(/ ! !*
5 B !
A ! ! !
* *!*
)!
(/ 8< /8(/ % % ! ! * ! ! ! >! ) , !* >A !
*(4 8< /8(/ B (; * ( 6 */8(/ , !* ! !
%5 $ '6"! B" B!&C5 ;
' /! 81 (8 /8(/ -+!,9. *& (/ (/ /8(/-+!, (8. + >, !
1;/;;/81>, ! ! ! & ) , (( (8 /8(/ * & &! *& % ! 34 !
*! 0 * % /7 /8(1 " ! * =! * ! *! ) ! *
& ! : & , ! ! !* ! ! ! ! "! *&
!(1 !0* ) $ -D. ! (<<4- ?
! (<<4@. + + *& &
, 7, 13'8*+$&$!# $70, 1&$ 71$:
) E! + ! * ! & ! 0 , & =! ! *! 5 B ! *& >! * 2 =! * ! // (/ /8(/ * & 0 5 $ !* ,! ! & ! ! 2 & ! & =! +! ,9 ,(8 =! ! ! *& , !! F<G !
' *$ *,' 3 <
H! !
!* & >!*
(8
H! * !
0!
! E! ! ! , ! =! ! *! ! & !* *! & ! *& ! , *
((
2 ! % !
! *!
// (/ /8((- !
. !**& ,&
(9 (/ /889 6! * // (/ /8((-+!,4. *5 &!
! %" 5 " (/
2 * ! & ! !(1
! (<<4 5 ! !
& , ! >+ & H! & ! ! * %& *! !
! + *& *! ) *& ! B H!+ !
*& " % ! + + 2 ! E! & & ! * , ! >+ ! !(1 ! (<<4& * ! (1
H! * , !* * *& ! 0 !
"!4-.-. !1
! (<<7 % *! & *!
=! ! & !
2 !* !
// /88<& !
! ! * *! &
& (8 /8(8 /;
/8(8 2 ! ! ! !/7 /8(1 *! &
! ! ! & , ! 0 *
(3
2 ! , ,! *! ! 0 /( (/ /8((-+!,4. &*0
(4
"!4-.-. !* ! !
* ! 2 ! , ! & *! * *&!*
5 B 8;
/8(/ // (( /8(( !(8-(. (<<7 !"!;
-++. ! * !* > ! &5 B
$ !* 5 B * !
=! ! ! C !(8-/. !*
& ! ! 0 *&! 5 $
&& !5 !& ! & ! 33 (<<4 *& !! * &! * (7
B& ! 8;
/8(1 -+!,(/. ! B & + & ! & & ) !
! 0! , ! ! &@ %&+ (;
H! & *& ! !
*!
*&& 2 ! ! ! 0 ! %&! % % ! ! ) =! ! ,
? ! @ *
! 2 ! &*! !
! ! * !! ! & ! ! ! *! * * & + *& ! & & &!*! ! ! ! &
,36 33,' ! 7! !&-3,3
(9
C! !
* * ) ,! =! * !
(<
!
! ! !
* E! * "! * ! =! 0!
-.
C ! & & *! I -.
C & & *! * , ! I -.
C , ! >+ ! !0! * &I /8
B ! ! !
& + ! & &
!" $1,' !&! 7'/ &! , 1! 7$%$&'()$ * 6*.BB<
!
"#$%%% %%% %%% "&$' () "#$ ((
( ( (
%
%
%%% %%% %%%
"#$ *
"
$ ( + (+
(+ !, "
$ (
( ( +(+- .
+ % ( (
( ( (
(
(
%%% %%% %%% #/0 "#$ '1 2
+( + *
"&$ 3
+
+
+ "
$"$ %%% %%% %%% "
$ (
% (
() "&$ !
"$"44$ %%% %%% %%%
+$
!" $1,' !& ! 7 '/ &! , 1 ! 7 $%$&'()$ *$ $#!&
&$3.BB< #!
'
( ( 5"#$' (
(
+
- .
( (+
(
6
- .
%
+ ( ( ( (
+
( (
% %#& + ( %
7 %%% %%% %%%
!" #"! &! , 1 ! 7 $%$&'()$ * *+'#,*- ,&7, 1
&$3.BB;
#0 .
) "#$ -
( * (
898 8 8
"&$'
8:8 %%% %%% %%%7
/(
! * ! ! + !
;
.11-113. :.-<1=3 ) "
$ ' ( >0" $
3
*
3 ( (
' ( * ( (
( ?:
"
$"
$%%% %%% %%%
.1'<? '3..9?3@:32) "
$ '
(
(
?:
( ( ( ( ?(
:
"
$ ( (
?:
"9 $< +#>>A
"
$
9
B9 < (
"
$ 9
( ( C (
B
- . + ?:
+
%%% %%% %%%
-E'-13.--) "
$ 3 % ( (
%
( =+% ( (( - .
(
(
"
$"%% $%%% %%% %%% "%%
$ 9
( ( C (
B
- . +
"%%
$"%% $%%% %%% %%% 33 $'2,
//
) (<<4
*0
% * ! ! ! !*, -/.
31 % !*0 ! &* * !(1 (<<4 ! ! *! * & ? @ ! & &!
*! * ) A 6 + & % + !
>*! !, ! *& J +
&* !*0 & + )* /1
" 22 ! (<<7 ! !* B! !1& , *! ! ! & !4 !!
=! * * ?@ ) !* !* ! &*=!*& ! & !*,!/ !7; *!
& ) !(8+ * 6! " !* ! /3
J +
! (<<4(<<7 ! & !4-. *! !! * & !(1 (<<4! J *% *! * * C * 0! !*& E!
) !
, !4-. *0! !*!
-. !& ! ! *! ! *! &! !
!
/4
C!* !
, ! ! ! ! *! ! ) * ! *!
! ,&
! ! ! ! ! & ) , & ! ! ! ! ! & *! & ! & !!4-. !
& !! & ! & C& * , *! * & 0 & ! 5&&*& + !*0 & + &!
=! * ! !
+ !
"! & + ! //7 " ! 2!* * * !*& *& ! & + ! ** &! ! !0!
) !* !
-.
=!
,& ! *! , *! 2!' -. &
33 $'2,,
/7
) , , !
& ! * 5 & & ! ! // (/ /8(( -+!,4. !* ! !
! /8(1 %
!
! /8(8 & =! ! & ! !(8 (<<7 ! & & & ! C !
* & ! ) & + /8(/!
*! * ) // (/ /8(( =! >A !
*& ! *!
)!
!* ?5 B@8;
/8(/ 2 + !(8 (<<7 ! ) =! ?' @ 5 B * ?5 "@ !
) !0 ! ?5 $@
)=! * 5 B!* J * &*& % * ! ! * & &
) ! (8 5 B
!
* & !
: ! & ! !
!* 8;
/8(/ + & ,& /8(/ A !
* !
*! ! */8(/ ) ! 0 6! " 5 $ =!
!
! ! /9 /8(/ * , %* ! *! 2 & * , !* *!
!
! /8(/ ! & * ! *% *!
/;
) ! & *! *! 6 & !
*& , ! ! * !
, *& * ! =!'6" 2 2 &
! *& , &! * & ! & !
:!!
* * &&! -. ! ,
33 $ '2,,,
/9
!
+ * ! * ! 0! ** &
! 33 &
! ! ! & * ? &@! , & & & !! & ) & ! & * , ! >+ ! , !* ! ) ! !& /<
A , ! 0! ! * ! ! 0! ) !& * ! & ! ! &!& & & !* !
+ ' 0! * *! ! & , ! & * * ! ** * C "!
4) ) 4 & + B & ! &+ ! !
*!
5 ! ! ! 2 % *& A "
+ B
+ ! ! !
) , !
!!+
* % & 1(
B & *!
"
* &! * * *& , ! & ! !+ 2 * ! & * * ! ! &
C !
! *=! & ! , !0! 2!
-. &
1/
5 * !
0!
*& E! )
-. & &
0?
0
?
*+ !-.;
F B G * B H < ( H