Chandigarh Public Health Governement Contractores Welfare Society v. Fincance Secretary Ut Chandigarh And ORS

I N THE HI GH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDI GARH CA- CWP- 4- 2017 ( O&M) Dat e of deci si on: - 08. 03. 2017 Chandi gar h Publ i c Heal t h Gover nment Cont r act or s Wel f ar e Soci et y, Chandi gar h.

. . . Appel l ant Ver sus Fi nance Secr et ar y, Uni on Ter r i t or y, Chandi gar h and ot her s . . . Respondent s CORAM: HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE S. J. VAZI FDAR, CHI EF JUSTI CE HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL Pr esent : - Dr . Anmol Rat t an Si dhu, Seni or Advocat e, wi t h Mr . Ar un Wi l l i am, Advocat e, and Ms. Sudha, Advocat e, f or t he appel l ant .

* * * * S. J. VAZI FDAR, C. J. ( ORAL) Dr . Si dhu, l ear ned seni or counsel appear i ng on behal f of t he appel l ant f ai r l y i nvi t ed our at t ent i on t o t he or der and j udgement of a Di vi si on Bench of t hi s Cour t dat ed 23. 11. 2016 i n a gr oup of wr i t pet i t i ons i ncl udi ng CWP- 9711- 2016 t i t l ed as Enl i st ed El ect r i cal Cont r act or s Associ at i on ( Regd. ) Vs St at e of Punj ab and ot her s whi ch cover s t he case agai nst t he appel l ant . The cont ent i on t hat t he j udgement does not appr eci at e t he i ssues i n t he cor r ect per spect i ve and al so does not cor r ect l y anal yze t he j udgement s r ef er r ed t o t her ei n cannot be consi der ed by us. The appel l ant ' s r emedy i s t o chal l enge t he j udgement . 2.

I n t hese ci r cumst ances, t he appeal i s di smi ssed i n vi ew of t he sai d or der and j udgement dat ed 23. 11. 2016 i n CWP- 9711- 2016 and ot her connect ed mat t er s.

( S. J. VAZI FDAR) CHI EF JUSTI CE ( ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL) JUDGE

08. 03. 2017 Amodh Whet her speaki ng/ r easoned Yes/ No Whet her r epor t abl e Yes/ No Amodh Sharma 2017.03.09 14:10 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh