High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA-COM/5/2017allowed

Food Corporation Of India And ANR v. M/S Daniel Masih Satprit Singh Bedi

2017-04-05Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

#"" $

% & ' (

() *" $+ "

,(&-./ "%" ,(- + & "%

, ,& )

"% ", 0000

) " "2&")- "()3&")4) "5 6/" ) - - / 7 -4&"6 8"" "%"& 4&" 6 &" - 6 6 / ) " / 4 " "4 6/ (&

- & #"

&" %) :#1 " &" 4 6" /-

- ") "

" 4/ ,1 " & 6"" " ;* + , -

. /* 00+ -1+,21

<,1

, =,

9 -" "&> 1!, # -- ) &" 4) -

;" " & :,> ?11! " " & > +11!

1" &"

% +8 ") " 1 &/ 6"

- & & '(@'&6 A", - /' % A-" - / ") " ! B !") - &) ) / --"/,1" &" 7&" / --"

") % / 4 8 %&, 1" &"

% "&/ 6"

- & & '(@'.%, '&6 A", - / % A-" ") " ! B " ) - &) , ) / --"/, 1" &" % 7&" / --"

") %/ 4 8 %&, C C -" %& 64 "" ) D + 6 C -" -" %& ) + b) C - %& 6 4 "" " , %& " , !" #$ % &'

"&!()% # *+'("",%"&)"

"#$'("

)&- .)** /" &"0# "1 1 $#& '(" %2&%#!" #$ '(" ",%"&)"

" #$ '(" ) 1)3)12 *% &'

"&!.)** #' /"#2 '"1 !" #$ &'

"&!()% # *+'("",%"&)"

"#$'("

)&-.)**/"&"0# "1 1 $#& '(" %2&%#!" '(" ",%"&)"

" #$ '(" ) 1)3)12 * % &'

"&! .)**

#'/"#2 '"14

* " - &)" 2&")-

"7 ## " ### 1! " ?1 " +1 4 -" " &" ;&/ &"" A & " 6

% - " / 4 7

6&6-"6/ ,# / 7 ! -46 8""

"%"& 4 6&", -" ?1+146

6 4

% , E& F&" -8 / -"- 1! ?1 " +1 ")/ 4 --" ,< >, # -- ) &" - " % / 7 " /

/ F& / ) "

, 1 " - ) 4 &" =,

9 " ))" 6& ")" ") , "5 "

%%7 ")" " ) 6/ % & %) 6

- 4 & &/ - " "

" & - , 1 " "" &" % " F& 7 % / "6&"/- 6 :#1,

=, " "" & / 7 - 4&" 6 8" " "%"& 4&" 6 &" ) 6) / 2&")- (&

! " 2&")- % * & ""

, ,

9 3

+ 0

4 5 %6 71 % :,

9 4 &(,3,GB " 34 /, , #

8 - 1--& %" "

)

" ,1 "% - F& " %

" 7 - )

) " &

" )

/-4 / -

" F& " &6 4 "&- /

" &

" ", 1

" " :,= 4 -) % 6"" , 1

-" 42%& - /-

) %

" 6 #" " 6 ", # " 6 6 " - " "6 -)-- /4 7 "6

)

&6 ) , # ""

2" )

52%& " 6 - & - /

4 )B"- 8" ,1 ?) & " &) --6 2%& " - F& 7

"" % -, 1 (&

- &

" --6 2%& ,1

// "6/ ":,=

/ 4+,H 8 4

" " +,=H 8 ,, / % - & " , # 7 2&")- (&

- & -& 6 " ", ,

" &

) 6 " " & 4) 6 % (&

- & " & -

B"6/& )

> 567I% 6 &-" F& -

) ") 7 & "% - ""

= HH> %) " " 6& )6/ " &) 4 " 6 - " F& - ) ") 6 &" - " &"6 -/,# 6%&&4 %)

7 " " " 6 &6-" -

-4 -/ %/ 7 4 -, 1 " - - 6 8 " , (- / - /

" &" - %) -/ &" ) ) & - ) -)- 4 - / 4 -/ % & 7 " " &6-" - )" - /, # &" 6 &

F& - 6& 7 - /4 - )" )" - / 6 8 " 6& " 6 &6-" - " 6 &6-" - )" - / 4 " % -,% / -/6 - /" 8) & "

6& - / -4- / %),1 4- / &) %) 4 " 7 - )- / %)7 - 8

4 ,

F& -

) ")7 "- ) - / -& 6 " " 6& - &) " % " 4 " ) 4- /6&" %7 - &) %) 7 ", " ) F& - ) ") 6 6 -" "

F& -""&-%) -- , 1 - " " & "&- % 6 &" - "

&" 6&-, 6&- 4 &" - 4 86 -" 8& - 6& " 4 6 &"4 - 4 8,(& " 6 7-" --- %44 - 6 " 4 - / 4 8 68) &" - / "

4 -" / 7& 4 8,?4&")6/ - - /6&6/ 6 " - /, 8 ) %4 7 4&" 8

" F& -"

& " - /,1 - 6

& 4 " ) " %" "% - &"

= HH>,1 4&" F& - -& 6 7-" " / &" / 7 4&" 6 " " " 6/ - 4 8 6 &", ! 2&")) " 4 % 6 " " ) 4

F& -" & %64 ,7 -/6 -& - / " F& - &"", % / 8 7 -/ 6 -" )" 6/ -

%" )/ " 6 F& -, 1 "% - ""

= HH> 4 " 4 %) " "" 9= HH> "

&" " & ,# 1" I%&--

"" "

" "7-" :?A %4&" % &" :?A 6) 2 %& 6

& " ) '4) - 4 "6 -)- " &6 ) ) & - 6& ) - / HH C :?A4"6/#") & - -/ 1# A# A ," & " = C 4" 6/ ##A /4"&6" / () 1-4 4 6 " H9 " %) ) 7

&6 ) ()

" /4 /4

)" " , % 4 / " ##A 4 6

%") &F& ) " " / -)- /- ) 4 -) " -) 46 %/%%"

26 & () "

"#", 68 " :?A2%& -" 6/ " % & & -/ 1# A# " A 4 ##A

" 6 8 " 1" I%& -- " " "

&"6&-, 691 & 4&" 6 " % -

" & / - )"

,# 6 " &" 4 - / ) /" ---6 ,#4""46/ ?& A " JH ") + , %, + , ) K JH

JHH I++ >>LI% " 6 4"6/ & I)" 4 & /, *& % 6 " "

&"" ""6/& /

%46/2&"

&-,*/

--/" 6"; ) %< 4 ) 6 "

/ "%"&--6 ) / - / %& - / &" 6/ ) & " - , 1 & " "4 &"

/ ) /

"2& % +%&,(9 : %

- 0+

,0 2 = I", ,

, 4 " 6";

) %< @" ( 6 & & 6/ (6 3, %, +6; <

4 / K = !" = L ; ) / &" "

&6 % 2& / 4 )

&" " " - 4 4 ) "

,< 6:#&-6 " " ) -

4 )%4 & %8 &, 6;# -

0 $ ++

- 2 %,2 K HH > = >=> HJ > I+ 99 HJ > A+ = =L &" (

- H=J G&(-" F&"4

% 4) 6 % A " " ;# -/ %4 4

& 8) 6& & " " -

4)%4,<

<=1 &

- ) "

" & &

" ) :?A

- " 6/ "% - %) " ""

= HH> & :?A ,, #" ) & - 1# A# " A" () 6"- / ##A 6 8" , :?A #"&A# "

""6&"

" "*-6/ /

HH " () 6" & ##A / M 7

)

" 4 ;/4 )<() ,1 "7 6) "6/ 1" I%&--

& %4 " 7 4 - :?A" :?A"" & " 6& )6/ 4 " , #

") 6 1" I%& -- -)&"" 6& & )

4 - " "

6" &6- " " %)" "" 9= HH>,1 " " &6-" 6/ :?A &" " + " =, 1 -& // "6/+ "=

/ 4 + H 8 4 :?A " " + =H,H 8 ,, / % - -& " 6/ + "=,?%) ) " )- ) -& // " 6/ :?A " " 6/ + "= -&6 " " 1" I%&-- &" :?A " " + " = &

- % 6 "

/ " 66F& ",<,0 600+ 9, " 3&") &

" 6 2&")- % * & ""

, ,

9 3

+ 0

%6 71 % :,

9 4 &(,3,GB " 34 /,1 " 3&") " %4 2&")- &),

, # 3

+ 8 - &

2&")-

60 4

" " 6 ", )

2&")- "&"

;J, 1 2&")- F& / % %& , # -

" 6/ & (&

- & / " 4

%) 7 " " 6&6-" -

-4 -/ % 7 - -& 6 8 " , H, ,*8 "&

)6 " &) ")& 2&")- (&

- & ") )&) -"" " 6 & /" ,") , 2&")- (&

-& , # F& 7 68 " 4 " -) )6/ 6" &6-"6/ -,& )6/" ,1 ) &"& ")& 2&")- - 6 &,

, - " % " " ) 7, 1 - - / - "& - " " 6) , 1 " 7 6 " 6)6,?-/6 ) 6 7 "7 4 " 6& -" 6/ 6 -,1 4 / &) 6 8 " 6 -

%&) 7 - 6" ,(&

)% - "" -- /,

, %4 / 4&" 6 "%" / -- /, - " / % -F& %4 -))/)%& ,1 )%& & /

-/ 4 F&

4 " 7 ,! 4 8 &" F& /) ,#4&" F& & /"6&

" ) &, # "5 %4 4 6 " 4&" F& % / -

% &" %) " , 1 - 4&" 6 )6 / % /

F&7 ,I%4

6) -

/ -/

%7 -8",18 4 %) " F& 6"" % 7 & / ) ) , --/6 ) 6& 4 7 " " ) ),1 4 -4 "% /,A )4 - 84 % 4 7 " 6 4, @ %)" 4 7& - -

) &" -" % F&7 &) - - F& 4&"62& ",<,0 600+ J, &6 2&")-"" / / 7 -" 7 "%"& 4&" 6 8 " , 2&")-"""4 4 47

%"" / 7 -" - 468 " , 1 & 6 & 4

" 6 " " , : 2&")- (&

-& 2&")- & "4 && 6 &,

H, &

60 &" " &" % -" ,1 &3

+ : " "&" ;

= 1 F& 1 *" " 6 4 $,, $,, $,, $,, 1 " -& " - 7 4 / " ) " -&6 -7" 7& N*5 4 -& 6 " 6/ ) ")/,# 6% -"7

6 1" - --

1& % / 66"/ 5&

% ") & ",( ,:,

% " /) 4 & +F& -&- 1& % 'I7 +, ,

1 =

, >

1 J

9, =

1 >

$,,$,,$,,$,,< !

- )

+ 8 -. %" & 4

" F& ) -, 1 & 4

" - " 4 %" "

""& 7 6)/ - " "%"& ,#

)

+ 8-.47

/ "

;@ %) " 4 7& - - "

) &" - " %

F&7 &) - - F&7 4&"62& "<,

,* 2&")- / " F& &" - 4 & 7&") F& , / " " 4 4 " " )6/ -& 6 & " 6/ / "%"& 6&6/ - ,1 2&")-"

6& -,1 F&4 & - 4),

, & 4%"/

% 4

6 / %) " - &) & ",1 42&")-4 %7 "" " 4,& 4%"/ 2&")- " 4 -& 4 F&

, # /%)" & - " " )6/, " F& )6/-&6 & "6/ - "6// - / 4 6 -- /, : & " ) / -- % 4

- - " )6/,

>, I% / " / " "/ "/ 6& - % -)- 4 8 -" 6/ -, I%

- 4 F& F& &" %) " -/ %

"/ -,?-/% " )/ -,?-/ / 6 %- , (& 4&" )6 7 - 4 8 4 " F& ", # & F& &" %) " 4&" 6 / -), 1 / %) " 4&" 6 " & - %) 7&" & &"8""%&,

=, 4 - )/" --"/6& - "& -"

) %/,

" & 6 / 6& - %) / - - 7& 4 8 - " ,1 & --/ ), 1 4 F& 7 4

-" " " - )6 -/

% -,1 -) 6/ -% % 4 4 -/ % F& "/ -4&"6)6,1 " &/

4% &"

)/& - /

" &"

% - , 1 7&" & 4 6& - / " F&F& -/% - /, 1 -) -/ %

F& 7 " / - / 4&" 6 " " %) F&F&

, & 6 &) 6& 6/ 7) 6&, # ") -- " 6&

"% -"- " ")4 -,*&" -& 6 / %) " , 1 -/ 6 % - " ") 4 &, # - - 6

-"", # - 6 %&B

%" % / %&/ " )& " ) % / & /, 1 / %) " -& 4 & - &6 -"" )6/,& " &) 4 & ",

9, # /%)" && ""- /& 6""

% / F& 4 4&" & %7& 4 8 4 %", 1 " / & -/ - F& -,#

66/ -""-

%" & - ") - / - & )" "& ) 7& 4 8, 1 & " % ))

4% " " "& - &)" "

) - / 6& " " )& 6&/ F& - /%)" ,

, %44 2&")- :4? B5A"," 5,1 - )6/ " - )6/ 6 & 6&" 4/ & )

- - &66"" ,# & - ", & " , &

" & - " " 4 / 6% 4&" /

F& -, 4 -" - &)" - 4&" & - F& F& ,1

4&"62& "

&-) - /6& F&7

" / 4 4&" 6 ) 6 "F& 7& 4 8 %",1 - &

" , I% 4& " " )& " " &, 1 & 2&")-% 6&"

/ /%)" ,

J, # &-

4", 1 - &)" " "2&")-"" "-",1 4% 6 " ,

!"#$%& Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No