M/S Girdhari Lal Constructions Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Of India And Others
!" #$ ! % &&"" ' # ( ) % *&
+ ,- ./ $0 1 &/2 3"0 . $. &&"" "./ $0 1 /2 40 . $.
& 55 ./ $0 -+ 16/2 0". $.
& 7 88888 3 &&" 2 6# 21 " /2"9# 2 12 &&"":& ""22
6 3
& " &&"": 5 &$ 2 # "" #2 #&& 1 " #"
*& " #5" + & 1 0 $ # 5#" 2 *& <=#$<2 & *& 7 50 5, & >
3 & ? &&""@#51 0 0
6 5,
11#
A
B1 0 & 3 & 0 " 5 "25"0 ""02 1 + / 1 5 * ;#"
!" # $ ! !" # $ ! ) # "25" & & $ & )) &2 )3 5# 1C: 5 2 5,1 ,2 "#1 #1
,2 # 0 + 5+ 5+ 5 2 & 7 " 1" " $ ;#" 5#
12$ 1 3 " 9# 2 2 ", #& "
& :
6 &&"":5 7 /)) $2 D)EF*3)F>)/3*(3)F/EF*<!) )-)!)3G*)3<*)H "# #
!
"
#
D - #" ""02 ?@ ! "25"1" # 0 + # #"1&" # 2 "$ , ?E 1DH@ ?5@
1 & 0 +
1DH) 1DH H E 1 5 1 & "#1#
! " "25"1" # 0 +1&" # 2 "$, 2& $# , " #51
7 B
A ) 2 1#"1 1#0 5, 5 3 2 "#10"
" 5, &&"" 3 2 1 & 5 5,
& 0 D 0 + 0 5+ 5+ 5G H 3 &&""0" 2 2 D 1 +H 3 0 & , $2 1",
3 & #" 0 " 3 #" 5, &&""1",D0 +1&" 1H 0 +0 5+5+5
3
& 0 . . ",6# 62 B - . " #"&& 25 "
&&"" #51 5, 1 11#
A
B 6 1 ", 5# "#1 E 1 $2 5 0 2", "" 5# 2 # D #1
,2#0 +5+ 5+5H 3 #51 0""
#
11## 5 "+# 3
" 62 5 1# 5 3
6 &&"": 0 5# &&"" 2 "# 0 $0 2 #1 $2
# 0 +5+5+5.0 &&"":5 0
6 5# $2 1 "#1 $2 0 $0 #1
,2# 0 +5+5+ 5 3
6 2 # &&"" "" "#1 E 1
", 3 5 0 " 6 & ", 2 # &&"" #1
,2# 0 +5+5+5 3 5 $ 2 &&"" $2 " 0 " 2 # ", 5 $ #&& 1 # 1", "# $2 5 ""
", 3 " $
1 "# 2 0 & 1 11# ;# " 1", D& 2 & 7 " 1" " $ ;#" 5#
12$ 1H
)" . . 0 2 #"" "#
1 & 0 2 #
6 A 3 " 9# 2" &&"": E . E 1 " "25"1" # 0 + 1&" # 2 " $ , 3 &&"" " & $ , 1 3 0 " ", 1& 15" "#1 111& 5 3 2 0 " 5, &&""
D 2# ,H 3 0 " 1& 15" "#1 E 1& 5 )301 D#" 1&"H 3 2 0 1 "#1 E 1 )30 0D0 <F3 G . ,0 0 #"$, 1&H && 0 6 # 1 0
6 ", 5 1 "# 3 0 55", 5# 3 <$"# 11
# 1 "#5#
6 ) #1 " 9# 2 2 ", 1 & $0 ,$&5" - 2 $ 2 5 $ 5, " /2" 9# 2 1 #&&" 5, & 5 5 $ 0 "5 "1
1 & J#51 0 "1 J #51 #1 0 "20 " 0 +1&" 5, & 0&# ##5 0 5+ 5+ 5 5 $ 1 11# 62 & :
& 1 "#1 E 1 D #1
,2# 0 +5+5+5H0 " #6# ) - " #& "
B# 5,
& & + 5 0 &&"" "1 =& 3 " 0 + 5=# 5+5+5 J
" #& &", 7
B 5, &&""
& 0 &&"" 2 "", 2I 0 + # 0""2 (
F:. 1" ?E@>J E 1 5 =# 5, &&"" 5+ 5+ 5
1 (, )
6 ! # #" 1&" 1 " 0 &&"" 0 + $"# * B & 1 =& 56"" & 1;#" ,2 &&"" 5 3 " 1#5 $# &&"" 2 $0 "
B &", 7
B& 1
& 0 1" 5,
1 "#1 E 1 3
& && $ =& 0 "1 5 5+5+ 3 & . 0$ . #51 "#
5 E 11 ", 5 # 0 + # #"", 1&" 5# # D"25"H 1" # 0 + # #"", 1&" ) 0 5+ 5+ &
1 5, &&"" 0 "25" 0 +1# 5+5+ 0 0 # & 1 & , $2 3
1 E 1 0 " 5+ 5+ 5 ""2"", & 1 1 55 3 $ 1 +0 . .6# 7 2 12 1 C"25":"# ) , &# & &&" 3 0 5 11# A
B 1 0 & 2
0#" 5 6# 5 2#1 5 0 #
2 &&""&& #, 12 1 - & #.&5" &&""
5"$ 0 C"25": "#
0 0 $" ", 5# 0 , 1 "25", "# )3 #
"#$%&'%() *+ )(, )%
3 " #51 5, 5 0"" 5 $"#
""021
3 " & 5 -% % .# 5$ & =& ,&)/)0&, 1" 0 + 1&" . & 11 1 &$,*+2
"# $ 0"" 5 #I 5 :"25",
+5 1 K" )K" FK" <<< 27
3 5 : ;#" ,2 " # & .# 5$ 0"" 5 $"# ""02 5# 5, 2 1 & C<L(*<): 5 " 5, 1 @ E" 2 ?E 1C:>C-: =1#1
1 + 5@ <=& ,&)/)0&, 1" # 0 + # 2"$, ?E 1C:@ =1#1
1 + @
1 0 + ?E 1 C:@ 31 $ # =1#1
1 + @
10 +?E 1C:@M#", =1#17 1 + (%& 3## % 41
351"25" "2 5 1## " , & 1 + ?.5. @ =,& 1 + 22 2 3 & 1. 0$ . $ 2 " # ;#" ,#15 1 #5"5, (, 5, %$, %/, $%&', 6 -, 6 %*+, 6 7 41 6 () , $, '* %*89'%&)(215%&&0,(%4,* *(5,0%1)1 6-, 6 %*+, ,- ( 6(5, ,&)/)0&,1) )&% 7 41: J &&""5
&& #, =&"2 "
1, $ 5 & # #"", # 1C"25":"# 1 = +
"# 0 0 + 0 &
1 &# # 5, 1&", $ 5 ""2"", , 1 2 1 )0#" $5&5" &&"" $ 1C"25": # 5, & . 105 B 3 & $ & " /2" 9# 2
62 & . . #& " J0$ . 5 $
2 &&"" $2 "5 ", " 3 . 0$ .0""& "#
1 +2, &
) $
& 2 . "" +&& 3 &&" 2", & ; < ;
< = 8%2>#3.
$ hether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No