High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/7/2022allowed

Virender v. State Of Haryana

2024-12-1325 pages

IN THE E HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB B AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CRA-D-7-2022(O&M) Virender . . . . Appellant t Vs.

na State of Haryan . . . . Respondent CRA-D-8-2022(O&M) Darshan . . . . Appellant t Vs.

na State of Haryan . . . . Respondent t R **** ON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJ ON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJ

Reserved on: 20.11.2024

Pronounced on:13.12.2024 CORAM: HO HO JEEV PRAKASH SHARMA JAY VASHISTH **** r. R.N. Lohan , Advocate r the appellant (in CRA-D-7-202

Present:

Mr for Mr for Mr 22).

r. Vivek Suri, Advocate r the appellant (in CRA-D-8-202 22).

r. Apoorv Garg, Sr. DAG-cum P Public Prosecutor, Haryana.

**** SHISTH, J.

SANJAY VAS 1.

($ )) !"

)

" # ! $ ! $

+$, -".)"

$%" &$' " +

/- " $

" )) #! " " ) "

$ 0

/ 1 8581% 1 # 8551% 1 # 3 %'' " 1 5%'' 1 / 1 /4 1

/4 1

""$ $

$ " )

$ +

,12/3

33/9/ $ "

858 8551

% 4

5 61%7

% " +

$ " )

9 "

7 48 $

:7 #

" )&

".% $ #

. !

" 8/9/ :0 )/ / ; )) .

))

$ !"$/ ,1

!$40 3/9 9/

8/9/ 3/9/ / )$

$ ) "" #

!"#

;

$ (

" 1 < !

) " = >

. 3/9/ / - $) #

)) " ! 1 ? # :/9/ #

"!+$ "

$ " 453/%//

" $ 0 @

! "#

% & "(

) * "+

034& 56 .789'6 :;:%(:#<=

8#+

$ '

.78 9 906 &. 8/ '

//:/9/ :0 )/ /#

" &

/+ !

! #

)# $

)$" !0 >

(:#? 7

. 5 *

(8+

(8+ +

* *

3 8

** *

* 3 5 8'

; @3 '

*= '

:/9 9/ :0 )/ / #

" ! A

) " !$ ( . / -

" @

A/ 1

" $) )

))

647 / A B$ ))

6 7 #

# ) /1

4$ !".

# " ) )) !

! $

$ /:5/1

4 )

# " ) ))!

/; #

)" "

"$)$)

/ " )

)$ " 4*8/%// ))

$/ 3/

" 5/4/ 4 " "

"$ " 5 %'

'" " 8*58 1%/ " "

"$ " 858 8551%/ $!

B$ 8/4 /

4" 0

4 (

" "

" $ "

8588 83 85583 8*58 83 1%/ 4 ) " "

"$ " 8*5 1% " 5 %'' "/

) " "

"$ " 3%' '"/ ""$ 4 :/9/ $) 5/9/ $!("

! " ( %A4

)# "" )

1 <

"# ! ))

C&/ %4 ;

$ (

3/9/ / "$ # ) ## " ##

$ !! " ( #

$ " 454 /%//"" ) )

"# )) "$ & ""$ ) /-

$ #

" % " " " $"

!= =#" ;'>

) "/ "") ) "$ & & $ )

$ / )# :/9/

. ) "$ & D#

;

; ) +

" &

)# "

# )" !

$ $ )

" $"$ "

" ! ! #

) !$

0)/

! /-

!)$)

4*!4

(! " )) #

:5 / ;#

2 /1 ! =/$

" ! $)

. !

(

$ $) ) " ) " "# /-

($ "#

)# " $ " 453 /%// ! >

%8 " :/9/

!A%3 &)

" $) ! 4 #

$ #$ )$"

! ) "

" ))&

4 4 ) $ / !

!$)

)

!AB B$""$ 4/1

))

!/ -

( 4 /- $

!4" )

! / ! " # #

)) " $B C&/%:

$ / )# )

$ "# :/9/ / -

)

! .

"" ! 4 ) "

! /'

)$" !

" "

" #

C&/%* ) "/ $ %

& # "

( ) '# "

)) ) )# "! $ " 453/%/"/ C&/%9

)# F

)) "

*$+

% , "

" )

$ +

)$" )) " C&/%: "" )

)

-$.

. ', $!

# C&/%48 !&)

)" " . ,= )

/ / %# !

! 1 1;'? # )#

" $

4C&/%43

" $ C&/ %4: "# ""

2/;84C 4:8 ;84C393

4 )" # / )# "#

C&/ %4* C&/ %4

)" #/ 0$ 1&(%2 (%# )

>. >

% "

# C&/% %

:/9/

)" #

# #

5/9/

) )" )

4 #

! =1 ? # / = )" #

! $

?$ % %A* )

,= =$ / 3$ 14% (%!

$ %A5

$ 15 '2(% (%)#

) C&/% 4/ $5 5 6 7 5% ) ) D#

; ) +

5/9/

# "

# C&/% 8 )# > " &

4 //>= C&/% 5 >= C&/ % : .

))" ""$ / $ 1 4%

(% /*# ) )# = >

. "# #

;

( # "# C&/%4 " $

! #

./ "

' ()"" )

//3/9/ !$*0 )/ / "

)""# #

;

$( $)

") "

!$ $ ! "$

% " / "

"")

) )""# ))

#"# #

)" "#/ !$ 5 5 "8

)# " &

" $" ! :/9/

:0 )/ / #

)

$ 0 @- *

= & &

"" 0 @C&

D- ##:7?(

' -0 <E7 B-8 (%7:<7(:#< - !

= )

")# )) )" "/ "

"" !""

$ $)$

" !$)$$

# "

! ),= = C&/%

)

,=) ! !

/ $1 1 ,'% 5

:/9/

) 1;' % " A +

/ )#

# #

) # C&/%5 5 ! 4 % .+

$ /- $) "

" $

)$ $ "

" "# "

"" )

) $ " 4*8 /%// $ " )

/ "

$ # "

) " # ""$ / 2 "

" # ! ""$

#! .

) ")

! " $" # "

) #

/ $

&") #

) # " ""

) "

" ! ""$ 4

B$ 4!#

$ " 4 453/%//C&/%9 / *+ +5%9'

,1C&/%:! / -$ % ,# 9 9 #

8 "

)# !

" " #

C&/%* * "

3/ / :/ '

4 ,= ) C&/ %

" ,= = $)/ '

// %A> /%

$)!

/- $) # " ) "$

" 4 /4/

4/ *

" $ " 848 /%// ""$ )) 4 "

" )

) "

" /; "

")$

# % ) #

""$ )) "

" #

" /; "

" #

)

" / 2

"# " ! ! )) ( '

' ' %99'' :$ $ ; */ ')

>/ /2/ = "$

)) ""$

) "$ " )

) "$ # "

") "

! ! "# ( !$

" $"+

/; )

$) " #

"! G

# ""$ /= = "$

)

") "

/= "$

$ )

($ ! "

$ $)$

)

!$ ""

= "$

)) )

$ "$ " 453/%//C&/%9

)

) "$ /C# 2

! ) " ! (

; )

" ! ) " ! A A

)# # ! $ $)) "

$/A

)) )

$ $

$ )

. !

$) ) "

)$)

/ A

) "

)) )

! ) "$ &$

//! % " 453 /%// ! A

# ! "

" " #! "/= "$

)

$ $

" $" ! ) "/ C# ) "$

)("

;

( #

"# $

2 / - $

!$ "# #

/$)

2 ! B$ $

)$"! $ ""$

)

$ #

# 4 $!!

"" )

!$ $" # # ) ) ## #! "#! ) " $

/ 9/ >//2/ /= #"))

$) ($ )

$%$ (! ; ;

# $%& ' $'

& (

) *+ , , ,

4/ A $

! >// /2/= #" $!

) )" ""$ " ! #

" )" ""$ " #

! )

" ! #

! ) " $

)

! #! $"

/- $ !

) "$

" )$ ! #! ! )!!

" $ ) "B$ 44/

! )) ) ""$ 4 >/ #.

. $ #" ) $

!>//2/ = #" $!

" # "

$)) ) "$ #

" #

$ $

A $

)

" $!

$ $ !

/ C# ) " ""

# "

$))

4*/C#

) "$ ! # ) $

$))

# " #

" ""

$ "

"" /

) "

4* ! 4

) "$ )" ! )"

)

$ H!

""$

" / $!

. ) $ !$ $ " ! ! / $ #

" !

)" (! ? # ) ) ) !4

$ "

" " )) 4$ ) ) #

"# $

! ) " !

)#! $/ ,$ $ $!

2 2 ( !

! ) "! A

)

) $"

#))

/C#

! $#

) )) ) 4 "

)$) /; ( ! )"

)) $!

)

"$ " )

" $ ! ""$ ) "B$ / '

>/ )# # D / D"$ %$! "

" % "$; $ " ) "$

$)#/1

""$ "G !

H/% %

$ !

! )!4

$ !

$ $ ! ""#

"! $

/= "$

$ "# ) "$ & ! )#

= >

. %A4

! ! ! 1<

2/ :5/ ! = "$

" $"!

/+ %A43 $ & &

($ . !$ ) " )

)

"$ "$ !$ $

! " ! & ""$

" #

/ ; )

$ # )

$ $)$ ! /= "$

! "

" )

$ $ +

%A3

$ #

""$

)

)) " /2

($ "# #

" &

C" "

" ! $

! $

4/ 1 )

$ ) "$ #

" " )

# ) #

#" $

$ " "$ # $

. #! "

""$ $"

. " ! " !& ""$ / ) ( A # $

) # &

"# !! $/A

) "$ )" ! " )

,1 #

"8/9/ :0 ) /2

" )

)

! " )

$ +

# $

,1 3/9/ / )" ) =>

.%A4

2/ :5 ) ;

$ ( ) "$ & "## "#

C&/%4 / "# !

. 1 <

2/ :5 / $

1' B$ ) "$ &#

""$

$ " ) / ) "$ & ""$ )

) ) " !$904: " )"#!$:0 )/ /'

2/ :5%A A 48

%'() " )

$ +

(

)""#!$ " )

! "

$ !

"# / -

)

! $!$/-

;

! / '

! //=>

.% %A4 #

""$ ! ) )

"#/ - $ "

%A4%A48# " )

"##

*/ ' "

") "

!$&) )

$ " ) " /2

) "# )" ) ))!

/A .)

%A4 %A48 #

" )

$ $ +

%A3

) " %A4 %A48 ;

$ ( )$) "#

$ $ / - )

)) !" ) $" ! $ /C#

%A8 #

! $

. (

$) ) " $) ) ""# !"

! ) "/ "

"# # )" "

! "

%A4 %A48

""$ )

" ) " "

"# #

.#)! ) " "# #

)("! ) "$

!" ) / >#

# "

"! ) "$

)

" #

;

$ #

( /2 "$ # # " ! !

!$ "!

$ " " "$

"# #

)("! 1

" ) / 4*/ >

) "$ &

///8/9/

!$:0)/ / ,1

3/9/ !$ 3/9/

8/9/ 3/9/ /% "$ &

! "#

( / - :/9/ )) " "

# !

) "$ & &

)

$ "

453/%//

#$ " $

) / @ - ./ 2

$ ! )$"! $ ""$

" ) "$ "

$ " 453 /%// "$

# ) /'

:/9/ !$:0 #

! /+ %A43

)

!4 "/ !".

# "

"$ 4/ ,

""$ ))

/" $)

$ " 4 453/%// !# $ ) " &

! / // - B$

"$ ) $"

/ -

$ ) &

!4! "

>=!

/ + %A43

! "!&") )#

!))

>=C&/% 9 / -

& &) " " ! "

! #

)#! " ) ))

!&/- "

) )"

4*!)

C" "

$ )#!) "$ /1

)

$" " ! #

" &

! "

>=/ 49/ ,$ &

"# "

$ / + %A43 & &)

)

/ 0

/ * 11 ,=)C&/%

4*/9/ $ ! " $ ! ""$ #

" & !

"$ ! "!

"!/C# ) ! )$ /+

)

!$ "

"$ $) #

$)$

" $)$$

"/ , "# ""$) "

" # ! " "

" $

" ) ) " # " "

"$ $ #

$ )# /

- # " " B$ ) $

# "

" //1 1 <

%A48 1? # %A 4: =>

.%A4 /

3 )

1 <

2/ :5 5 %A48 !

!"" )

.% %A4 (

3/9/ "# #

;

$ (

! ))

"# C&/ %4 #

/ '

& // :/9/

. # ! 1;'?

# %A4: " $ " 454 /%// #

)$"!

! >

$ " 453/%//C&/%9 "/"

! >

C&/%A: #

$!(" " &

; ) +

"1? #

%A4: $) #

# # ) / '

//:/9/

4 % .+

$ /'

" $ ! ""$ "

"" "#/>""

2/; 84C393

4 "# C&/ % %4 "" !

2 /;84C 4:8 "# "# C&/ %4* / ;# $

" "

))

! ""$ )

) """$ "/

" $" $ # "

) "#

""$ /C# " #

)

! ) "$ &#

""$ )

)

! /1

' ""

# "

) ) #

" $"/-

&")

$ !"" # "

) "

" #

/ > ) "

# !

# " " $"

&" ! 1 ? # 1

" %A4:

)$"

!0 > *

5-%

* - &

* *

#FE & -&

#FE& -&

. ,

#! #! # "

!$ #

B$ ) &

$ "# (

$!$/ 2

$ $)

"# # )) "#

;

$ ( /

# $)

:/9/ $ " 453 3 /%//C&/%9 9 /1

$ !"

>= =

/ '

:/9 9/

) " !

$ ( " !

4/1

)) ! ( % "/

" ) " 2

/$)

# ! " ! ) "$ / $

$" $

/ ;

;

"! $

! . !$ ( #

# ))

$)/ 1 )) #

! ""$ !$ ) "$ $!! # ) "$

)$" .

(

!& " # " "$ #)# #

! $! / 2

# !)#

)

4*!4 # "

# ) ) ) !

)

/:5

" 4 "$ "

# ) ) ) ! " "

)

""!

/1 !

" $" # " )) ! $

! ""$ /C#

# ! " )

$" )$! " "

" ) #

)

/>#

) ! 4

) 4* ! !$

!$ " # "

# !) # &$

"$ #

/ -

4* )

$" "

$ $ . ($ "

! ))

" . /; $)

$! .

($ "$;

$ 6* D / 9 6

$ ) $ ) $ " 9 )) )

) "$"

"$ "

:I I 9 %''

'" # !$

) ) $) ""$ )# " /- $

) "$ $ !

)

" "

)) 2 48 $ 0 2%

+;? &

?4%

-3&3 *

-3&3

+; * *

* / 3

' % %!

-3&3

* *

-3&3

** H

3 5 6 9**7$'

* *

# :

9 < , 3 '

9; 8

* *

+ "

%''4

;4%

* 7

* *

; 4%

* *

7 "

* '& 8

-3&3 * *

* 0 * :

% $;- 3&

- 7 "

-3&3 " 3

* *

8/ ($ ) $ )

$ "

9 %''" "

! ""$ ".# "

3/ ; #

# " " " "

$ &

)) "! " ) " # )) "

! ! "$)! "

# " )" ! $/ - $ ))

)# ! ! $!/ C#

" ) # " ) $ ) $

" 9%''" $ !)) "!/

:/ A

! " $" )) 1 ' " )

$ ""

# "/ $ "B$ ""$ "

" ! /- ! !

" /- ))

/ - " " ! !". " " $/ %

" $ )) "

) ""

/ +1.+; :"

:"46 6&,++& ;

"<5= "<5= !

A ).

J 4 A )!J 4 2 2