Commissioner Central Excise Commissioner Sonepat v. M/S Packotech Industries Safiabad Sonepat
!""#$%$&'()*
++$%%$&", "&!, -.#$%" /",0$#" .1 ++$%%$&", !"1/&"2 !
22"-- &!
0",%3%
4% #5!"#6&73%!,$"%1/&"2 !
"%2&7"&!
'
89
/ /9 89
/ :9 ,"%"&!'
, ;"&7",<%6$170# !" ,!6" 22"-- &!
,/6 !$ 170# !" ,!6","%2&7"&!
6$%$% & 22" - = $&%!!6",7",7 !"7>2 %%"7 ?@!6" 3%!+%.#$%" &7/",0$#" .22"-- !",$?3& -1"A"-6$
, %6,! 8!6" ,$?3& -8 = $&%! !6" ,7", 2 %%"7 $& .#$%" 22" - 4*4BC !$!-"7 %8 4% #5!"#6&73%!,$"%0%
1
6! 58, $%$&=!6"--A$&=%3?%! &!$ -D3"%!$&%- A'B $ :6"!6",,$?3& -A %#,,"#!!6-7!6 !!6" #!$0$!@ +"! --$% !$& &7- +$& !$&!6"-@%!",$-+ 2,$,!* +3&!%!+ &3 #!3,"1#&!, ,@! !6"%! !3!,@2,0$%$&%!6" "&!, -.#$%"1 ,$ #!1*>E $$ :6"!6", !6" ,$?3& - A % ;3%!$$"7 ! 6-7 !6"
"%2&7"&!!2 @ "&!, -.#$%"73!@A6$#6!6",A$%"
BB A %&!73" &7!2 %%&!6" "&0 ! ,"7$!!!6"$, 3@",%1$&!",+% "&0 ! 3-"%1(E $$$ :6"!6",!6",$?3& -A %;3%!$$"7!6 !!6" "%2&7"&!
# &#- $+7$%#6 ,=","0",% -$,,"=3- ,-@ 0 $-"7
"&0 ! ,"7$!& ##3&!!6"3!@2 $7&#-" , &#" &&B".#$% ?-"$!"+%A$!63!--A$&= "&0 ! 3-"%1 (E $0 :6"!6",!6",$?3& -A %;3%!$$"7&!!#&%$7",!6" + &7 !,@2,0$%$&% 3-"( $ "&0 ! ,"7$!
3-"%A$!6/"#!$&B> B !6" "&!, -.#$%"#!1 (( A6"," !6" "%2&7"&! $% &! "&!$!-"7 ! 0 $-
"&0 ! ,"7$! &72 @+"&! "&!, -.#$%"3!@& ."+2!"7 7%E !!6"0",@3!%"!1-" ,&"7#3&%"-,!6" %%"%%""A6$-" ,"",,$&=!!6",7",2 %%"7?@!6$% 3,!$& >!$!-"7 % 8,$&#$2 - ++$%%$&", "&!, -.#$%" &7/",0$#" .19376$ & 0%
4% +76 ,$&73%!,$ -, 7",%817"#$7"7&*)%3?+$!!"7!6 ! %!6"$%%3"$& !6"2,"%"&! # %"$% % !A6"!6",!6" #!$0$!@!6" ,"%2&7"&!# &?"!",+"7 %+ &3 #!3,$&=1&A6$#6".#$%"73!@$% -"0$ ?-"1!6"2,"%"&! 22" -?","!6$% 3,!$%&!#+2"!"&! 9" ,&"7#3&%"-,!6","0"&3"#3-7&!7$%23!"!6 !!6" $%%3" $&0-0"7 $& 4% +76 ,$ &73%!,$ - , 7",8% # %" %32, A % %$+$- ,1 &7!6"% +"6 %?""&7$%+$%%"7 %&!+ $&! $& ?-" ,!6"," %&%%! !"7$&!6" ,"% $7,7",1!6"2,"%"&!
BB 22" -$%7$%+$%%"7 %&!+ $&! $& ?-"?","!6$% 3,!16A"0",1A$!6 -$?",!@!!6","0"&3"! 0 $-$!% 22,2,$ !","+"7@$& ##,7 &#"A$!6 - A
/9 :9 ()* :6"!6",%2" 5$&=4," %&"7'
"%4 :6"!6",,"2,! ?-"'
"%4