Commissioner Of Central Excise, Rohtak v. Spl Ltd. (Now M/S Somany Ceramics Ltd.)
!"#"$%&
!"# $%
&
'
% '( ) ) '(
) ) )
)&* $
) + , $ .
/
,
$
,
,
$
( ,
) * +,-++ 1
#
&
23 &
(
+,-.++
# &
).
.
"$
564+
788
9
7889'
(
++
3236 !
45'
,
-
"
:
!
9
9'
"%32%33
(,
*4
4 &
((
(;
!#
'
(;
,
, ( #
(
:
& (
<=> ,
, (
)
86>
" "5%334 !"-'
33533
(
33
9 339' ?
&
# 332335
, (
836335
& (
<2> ,
# , (
&
#
)
3=32335 (
( (
<2> ,
5
)
(
$ (
! +
$ (
!1
4 &
)
&
B#
,
52%4
& #
+&+
32338
( #&
,
( #
33
,
788 #&
%
2333=
(
52%4
(
863327%4
==553=%4
,
3
6
33 63333%4
+
$ (
!1
$ (
!
8
( ((
#
,
3236 6 :
4
&
4 &
,
33533 836335
, &
#
&
,
& (
332335
(
<2> ,
# & (
()
& 2> ,
&
, (
C
) (
(&
(
)
52%4
+/+ & &
=
# ( )
# ,
*4 D"
C
(
==553=%4 !
?
&
-
-
&
,
&
,
(
" "=3%3354
33
# ,
!'
, (
E
""
C
(
==553=%4 !
?
&
-
-
&
,
)
&
(
,
)
332335
#
/
E
"""
C
(
333333%4 !
-# ? &'
&
6
33
63333%4 !
1 - ? &'
+0+
F +
$ (
!1
F &
$ (
!
=
33EG
4
(
( &
(
=
33
# & ( #
33
2
)
)
#
&
(
#
836335
(,
)
&
(
(&
#
()
;
@
11"##"$ 2 $ 2 34!"# *
$!5673 8 ( 9 36 !5'
- 58 HB' #
/
( #
+,+
(
(
%
&
( , &
(
)
&
I 33 ! 2 $ 2 3 4!"# * 7$ 8 " !5"
:
2"
( 9 777 !'
- ' #
)
#
)
@ &
)
#
B 9)
, &
,
,
#
(&
& I 2 ! 2 $9
21 ;7"<1 $ ( 9 8 11"##"$ 2 $ 2 34!"# *
"+ 36 !53'
- 56 !$ ' #
#
()
& B 9)
& ,
( ).
4
#
#
I 11"##"$ 2 $ 2 34!"# * 5 $9"= 258) >33?# 8 ( 9 33 !87'
- 67 !B ' #
#
,
,
(
,
,
= !'
++
338 ,
(
B(
B
,
&
(
(
)
& 7 ?
& (
# #
),
&
4 #
()
&
,
& ,
(
)
4
#
#
I &
&
#
) &9
(&
&
)
(,
#
3 @ ,
),
&
) (
)
#
#
(&
,
(
+-+ 1
),
(&
)
& .
C
(%
J %" C
)
J %"