← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/128/2006allowed

M/S Smi Electrowire Pvt. Ltd. v. Commr. Of Central Excise,

2015-01-23Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages



           

 !

" "#$%   &'()&*

+,- .+/0+/  /////11 **"+    2 3 44-((- 5 +"*6 -( $ *3-44-((- "+ $ "-"7"

/////

(1 +  &   80& / ) 200  80& / )& 90

 ( + &/&":;

4")$. "+ $5+3 "11 **"+/ &/;"4"*) 3<"*$. "+ $5+3  (1 +/

200$/ 







 

$$ !

&'

))



*+,

$ - .

&!'

 !

"



0+

$ - 1!2 %  !

"

&! 3!

!3!!

414'



$3! !

!

# 

 $#  !

!

(!

 # !

 !

! !!

!

!!

!

!$



   

2!



# 3 

"

!

!2!#  "9

!""!

$

 3

2"52"



! !2



 !: !

#



!#

7 0, *5

!# !3 

 # 

!!

!3!!

# !

7., ! !

 ! 33

3$ 7 !! !"# !2

!!

$

!!

7. ! !

 2!!

!!

#$ !  #

$$ !

)) & ;

!

#'



, !;

4 %

$

7 0, *5 2

$

< # !

2

 $$ !

&'

$ 

  

!3!



,

1

$ 

*+, 

 2

!  # 7 

!3!

 !

$ 

! 0+ !

!

 !  !

!

1

2#

$ 

*+

 "$ !

 

 !

# 

1 !2 !

!!

!

!!

 !

!

$  $!



!3!!

" !!

$!

$# "  # " 252



3! !# $ 

8.



$ 

!!

 

 !!

" %  

2

)

3!!

!

#$

 !2 3!$

!: !

!

#

!



$

! 3#

+

# 3

 !3! # !2 !  $!

 2

 !2 





252

" !



   !

!#

!!2  $# #

!# 3!# $ 4  

! $$  " 3#

$ 

$ !

 !2 "$

$

! 

2



# 

$

! $# " 33 !$

 $# "

$ 

= !

 !







 

$$ !

&'

))



*+,

$ - .

&!'

 !

"



0+

1 ! !



# !



!!

!

78!!

 



# 

2!# "

 !

"

!

!

 !$

!2!# 2$ 

!

$  2



   39 .7 "9 $"!

$  "9 $ 33 !

)  ! !

33

>!

"

 !$ 9 !

#   !  





6!

2!

$ 

!   " 

!!

2 %  3?



@ A ! 16) ! ! B2 C

32!

$# !$  $# !$ ! # # 

6!

 

"2 %    !"#

3!!

" %   

  %  $!



 %!

$

! !



78C. ! 3 @ 1$ $# "#! 2!#  # 

$

#

&6 2"'



2!# # !$ # $$  ! ! 

 

     " 2"

3

!

!

!

 " 2"



>"

***  $# !$ ! !

!  !$   !

 3 " 2"

 ! # $"!



 " 2"

!

#!

 $

<

&6 2"'



$# !$ "





2!# 2!

2!

33

)    #

#   !



3!

$ 

.7 E9

$ !! 

  !

3#  $ 

$# !

 % D !

  !2 ;

!

# 

"  

 ! 

!! $ $ 

.7 "9 

!



33! !

$

!!

33! !

!3!!

%! !3!!

$ !

 " !

!#



! %! 

!3! 



3!$

!

3!#

 

!

!;  # 

 

: $  !!

!2

#   # 

252

! !$ !3! 

!

 

$ !

# " !2

!  2  

=! 2!



!

$3 !2



 

 3  !2  

!

. 

$# !2!

!$

!

!



!

33! !! $ 

!

$

.7 "95!  !""!

$ !2!

33

!3! 4

%!

%$ 7.

, 7.

, ))



2 !!

 7

&'

7 *++

7.

 "$ 

(!$ >!

"

$! !



3

3! "

# !



= !3!   

1

!$ $!

1 ;

3! 3!

%$







3!$

!

B!

!

!

$ - 1!2 %  !

"

0

= 200>    ,!

F!# 

=& 90> 1$!

11"!   SHAMSHER SINGH 2015.01.27 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh