High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/9/2016dismissed

Commissioner Of Central Excise Delhi v. M/S Maruti Suzuki India Ltd Gurgaon

2016-10-21Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan19 pages

!"!#$%%% $$$$&&!! ' ( ) (*(+(,%- $$$$.& !"# $ %"& !"# "& '"(%'"&% /

%#/(*0# 12 34#5 #&&!!$ 5( *0#5 # & '' )

1# #!! & 5 7 &&!

:!( !7 5!5# ;75 # 0,

1#&&!7 # !!70 ( !<( !7 0( # = :

>#( "* 51"&&!!1 (!/ &!?# 7!# ## @#1 (!@"&&!9

=$9

& 0# >

A B## # &5!'1 ( * 51"&&3&0* 5 .$$ * 5 > 0# &( 5C

B## # &# 5#& 5 ( $.(! .(!9'1 .(!

=C B## #'1 5! ># & ! ! 5 # ( .(! = #.$

= 7#& 5*

? # !" ==C 5 B## # &# # !5! ! &!>( .(! : #'1 .(!

7#*

# !" ==C 5 B## % !5 !#&& & !

5 ! # # !'1 ( .(! = #'1

= 7#

# !" ==CD 1# !5 #& &&! ## & $00# ( ( 5#!& # !!0( #& ;0E8 !"1 E:% !5!0'1 #(>&&(&( 5 &!0(# ( ( 5#!( '1 .(!

= # A#

=.(!D 1# #.5(#( 0#( !!( ( ># (F !; >#0 #

E :

7## &$# & 5"

E=:

)$( &3& * 5 ( 0

8$ E5!'1 # %7! ## &#& 5"

=)$ ( .$$ 5 ( 0 # &

8$ E 5! '1 # %!# &#5!'1 (0E

9)$ ## 5( 0 #&

= #

7##7 !

# # 57 @&( 5@ !# ( ( # !& ( 0!>& ! 7 (#

&)*%- # !> : % # ! >

7## # & &&!& &$#5!'1 (0 :=

E)$=E

8E9G

:E=9 = ==98)$ 99E E=:)$G 8

: )$&3& * 5.$$

* 5 F( 0 /!1# !

"!#$%%%7 #&##&3& * 5( > # 0+ 05 & # & ( (#!(# 75#! ( # "(7## ( ( !& ( 0!>7 @&( 5@* ! !>#.$$ 5( #&( & 5!!0 <( ( 0 5 ! 5 ! H (& 5 #"(7## ( ( # !& (%7 0!>#!5 $$ 0!

"( $9## 5"

& & 3& * 5 .$$ 5 7 !#!!>#7! &> &!>1# & !&&! *11 #- #1 (!5 ! = :

"( $= # !!7#&&! - (! # &&!! # 0( # - # (!# !&& ##5 >( &3& .$$ 5 5!## 5#5 (!+

! #0(&#&! 5!1# 5#5

( ># &7## !> !> ! ( ( !& (! !& ((&#&! 5!;# 5 @&( 5@ > # & ( ( !& ( ;# 0(##

!!> 0 !(! #7 7 # 5# ( ( ( 0 5#! ;# ( # 0(## #5 &3& .$$

5 #! 5( # @&( 5@ 8 - (! # &## # ##5!#&3& * 5 0+ 0 5 & # & ((#75#!!(#! & 5! (! "(5 -5!0 1# 5 & # & & #! 5#!# 0 !!>#

( ( ( # & %7 ( # ( ##I.$$ H 57( ( 05#! #&5#5 ! (& 55#!!(# 1# ! #"&( (

.$$ 5 ("&( (

># & & # ! (0 # (1#3 ,;0#( # * '!+ ,!

! &"- ./!& 0122-03.'

444-5 .#!## ( ( !0 !, .$$

5( & 0 &!># 50 !!> 7## ( # ( ( ; ( # 0(## 5 .$$ &3& 5 & # !5!( # !

& (7##"(>&# # &! 5!#'1 # 5"&(# 5; 0( ##0 (7& !!>&! #1 (!#

(!# >#&&!!

B# &.$$ 57!!> 0( #7!># @&( 5@ & ># '1 .(!

7## 7

#.$$ 57& !!>"!( # I&( 5H; 0!>## > &!# # '1 7 !

& .$$ 5%# 0 #&!> (! =

( >#F5 %! > ( !0'1 .(!*

# (! #<( ! 7 @%# 5! ! 5 5

7## !!77 " &!.$$ 5C@ %7! # I1# (# 5 #!! 5! ! & 5 # &!

H -(! ( #

#( 6 7 ) %"89 "#!: ! &"

/!& )012;-41.'

42- <.7# (0#

.(! !7# ># ( 57 !"!(

# @&( 5@7#!## &!#&

# #5>75 >.(! !1#( # 5# # 575 >.(! !7(! #5 > (# %7! 5 # # 0 &5 7(! &5!> "!(#5> # J # #

#.$$ 5 !!7## I&( 5H & "!(5 #

B #5 # - (! # & 0 # (0##&& $ ,

9! & !!!,:9" "

1# !5.(! ! #'1 .(!

= >'1 .(!

E7## # I&( 5H(

9 '#'1 .(!

E7##

E!(! .(! 7 7# >

#7 I! !& ( #&! 5!H# 7 I! ! & ( (& # &! 5!H 7 ( (

= ?>#'1 .(!

7##

#'1 .(!

=7 0 1# # I

$ (

&'( )(

* %

&'( )(

* %

./0-

: !(

: * : #J = (

$ &'(

' (! =9)=)

K $=$

# F5 % > J & / ! !? "( 7!#(! # ( !0'1 .(!

= !5& 7## " !7 $ A0 -123%0- 4 ''5

+ '&&

2 67'&&-818 2808 8&6'&&8%

2 &67'&&-8182808 86&6'&&8 9

8 %

& && : : &8 ;

& 5'&& < 8 4 <

&5'&& '#:

6& 6""!"6":! 9"#

8 1#& # @&( 5@7 ! >5?# ? >;0#( #&" 9!

/!& * " " 6 7 ) 8)011=-2;.' >;?- .

1# &&!! # ( ( $!#! 5 0 ! ,7 1# 7 !( # &5

(#!J1# 7! ># &&!! !0 &7#( !# 5 0 ( ( # ( 7#( !

! (! !#( 1#<( 77## #&&!!# 7 !0 !5! # 5"&5 0 5!& , # #!,5! ># (!+(# 7 &> "(># # #0 (# # 5 ! ( ( > # &&!!1#( #!# #( #"& @ @ @!(@.(! !! ## "#(5 ?>#7 @!(@ 57## ># 7 7## # !( !( >#7 @ @# "#(5

E !>0# &( 5@#( #!# (! 5!>5# !!70 50 ( (

8 =

1# ( #! # # "& ( 0

0 )(( 5> (! !> # ( ( #& (%# ><(! >07 # @5 ! (@# (7!> 7(!5 !!57##7 !# (0 #

( @

8 0

8; !

* .

88- &??)@18.80866>

* .

88- ''6&(@18.808((=8-88

80 4 !

8 0

# 8#

J( # 57 # ##5 ! & "& # !& ( & #!& # 7##(>7# 0&7#!#.5( (!#5!0 5"7!!7 !1# ( &#+#7# >&( 5 & #5!( # !& (#(! #&(!!> &!> !0 ! # 5

;

- - 8# =

- 88 8#

1#( #!#7 >## # 5 ( # # !& ( ( ( >#& 5 0 !0 # ( ( # # 5 55!#5 &# ( ( # !& ( !## !#& 7#&( 5 # ( ( # !& (# ( ( (!5!# # 5"& ># #(

># 5 # # 0 >.5( #5 5#507## ( ( # !& (%7#!##7(!!&&!># !&

1# 2(0 7 !!7 " " 6 7

(:9 !!

#% !/!&

)0121-0>1. / 3>=- .

7# #<(7 7## ( 0 5 5 ( # !(5 & # A&( 5D 7 0 # 57#! A&( 5D5 >75

!> 57## !> !>( !# ( ( !& ( (!!(5 ( 5(

!# ( ( ( !& (7## & # ( ( !& ( # ( ( !& ( %7 5(

8 ;

# 0

! 8

8 0

8# 0

8 0

A8 8 0

8 B

0 8 80

$ 4 ''5 4

-8+818-8- 28?E 6%

''E8 ;

-8+818-8

@86

8 B

-8+818-8

9 %57 # 7"&5 & # @&( 5@7 #&3& * 5( 0+ 05 & # & ((#75#! !(# ! & 5 ! ( ! "(5-5!07##5 0 &

# && #! 5#! #

( ( ( # & 7###> ! 5!'1 &!!>7##"& & 7##"(>&

= * ! !>#.$$ 5( >#"(5 #

& #&( & 5!!0 <( ( 0 5#! #&5#5 ! ( & 55#!!(# "&(

! ( 0(

># & & # ! (0 # ( 7###> ! 5!'1

: J( # 0( >#-(! # &# 5 .$$ &3& 57 !( # !5!( # !& (7##"(>& 7## # &( >#&&!!# &! 5!#'1 # 5"&(# 5#

##&"(&

1# 57 ( # (&& > ;0#( ! > ?# #1 (!#& 5

!88

8 % 6 7 ) %&"(%8 9

& ( !+ -&"./!& )012;-3=.'

?3;- <.)#<(77##

#*117

#!0## 5 & &!> # ># >7&( 57##

&( 5.(! ! #

=.(! 1#( # 0 #1 (!## & # &!>

# # >& !# ( ( 0 5 7#( 0 # > # & ( 1#& 5 & ! > #& (&> # ( ( 0(!

E % 6 7 )( 89 '!+ ,!

&"- ./!& )0122-03.'

444-5 .#3 ,;0#( #! #.$$ 5& 5 >##7 , ## >& (&( 5 5!0'1 % 5 $

8 3

8 ;

8 0

- -

8 ;

8 &684 -

8 ;

8 +

8 ;

8 0

8 %

8# 1#2(0 # !!7" " 6 7 )( 8 ! :

', !

/!& ) 0120-0??. / 32; -5 .

" " 6 !7#"

)( 89 :%"!

&"/!& ) 0120-0?. '

231 -5 . " " 6 ! 7#"

) ( 89 "# /!& )0120-0;.'

40A-5 .

'"("6"## 60122 & ! :

#"6"#, 7#&"( !88# 9"# 6!% & 6""!"6":! 9"#

%# "#!: ! &"(& # <(77## 5! ( &( 5 ( .(! ! #'1 .(!

=#(0#(# 5# !# ( ( 0& > (5> # 7#7 ( ( !# &

5#! 1#>#5!'1 5"&5!

7 , (0 &!) > # & !> # ( ( 0 !5!( # 5 !& & >! > # 7###&!7 1#.5(##(0# # &( 5775 5#

!> ( (7> (# ( ( # !

& (%7##5 >#75 (! &! ># @&( 5@

#!# 7 7# 5((" # &# @ !> !>@@ !@ >&0 && #% 5 !& & > 0# 5 0&( # (! , !#(0#5! (7 , " ! 5( #J = !!>5!(

! !# 5 !& & ># 0 ! !"(> 1# 5( 7##( 7#### #0 7##( ## '1 ,#"& & #&( 5 (! (!+ ># 7##'1 .(!%0 7####7(! !!7# ## @ @@!(@& * !#&# !0>77 (0#5 # 5# 0 !> !> > 5 0 ! # ( ( # H !

& (1#( #! $ @8 !

8 0

B8% =

D 8# 1,0 # # > #.(! !# >

7## 7 7 =

7# > ( 57 "!( # @&( 5@#;H ! ( #!# # 57 5 >.(!!# 7

> (# 1# ! #&

# 0(& >& & 5 &( 5 !0(# > !!7## @&( 5@ # 7 &57#!5 # #7## !#&

8$ E

& # 1#<(7#(7 0# 5( 5!0 '1 7(&#! J # # $$ 5 # "!( # @&( 5@ >#

# #!#& # $$ 5 7## &( 5# > ( #&

#& # # &!'1 # 5 99 1#&#! ! > (! =

( >#F5 %7# *

#<(7 I% # 5! ! 5 5

7## !!77" &!.$$ 5CH %7! # I1# (# 5#!! 5! ! & 5# &!

&:5

9"#

9= %&# #%("

/!& * 6 7 ) (&)0123-30.'

=;-"

B ". *11B L!?#( #&,& 55! ># !

#(!> ( # &>7##7 > &!># !> 7!!# (7 #!

!&( 5 #(!> (0 !& # (5> # &> 9: %& /!& * " " 6 7

!8) 0122-00.'

4;1-"

B .#<(7## 5 & 3& 5! ># 0 #! 0

&( 577 5( % & 7 , 9!

/!& * " " 6 7

% &&)0122-04.'

A0-"

B%& .#7##7

0 5& 5 ! 0 0( 0# ( 5 0&( !+0& (!# 5 &,& 7##7#! &( 5 !(

98 ( !<( !7 0!>#&&! - '/. - '' .

#! 02)012> (!

B## &,0)

M) B## .& !

M Gianender Kumar 2016.10.28 12:42 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document