← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/15/2018dismissed

Commissioner Of Central Goods And Service Tax (Earlier Known As Commissioner Of Central Ex v. M/S Delton Cables Limited

2018-09-24The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma5 pages

    

      

  !""#$%$&'()

**$%%$&"+    "&!+ ,  -%  &-  ."+/$#"   0  +,$"+  1&2&  %

"&!+ , 0#$%" ."+/$#" 03 +$- 4 -  55",, &!

6"+%7%

8%",!& 4,"%9!-   "%5&-"&!

 

 

  



 

 

+"%"&!'

+ :"&-"+;%<$3-/# !" +!<" 55",, &!

+ =*< & &% ,3-/# !" +!<"+"%5&-"&!   

 <"+"/"&7"$%$& 55" , = $&%!!<"+-"+5 %%"-4>!<"

7%!*%3 0#$%" ."+/$#" 055",, !"+$47& ,3 < &-$= +< +%<+!

?!<"+$47& ,?- !"-@A$&55" , 8@@3+ $%$&= !<",,2$&=%74%! &!$ ,B7"%!$&%, 2'C D$ E<"!<"+  !<"  "0"#7!$&     4&-  +  ,"!!"+   7&-"+! 1$&=  4>  !<"  &!$#""  $%  &!  !<"  5+"  +"B7$%$!" #&-$!$&+"05+!2$!<7!5 >*"&!-7!>F $$ E<"!<"+!<"$*57=&"-$& ,+-"+$%%7%! $& 4,"$&!<" ">"%, 2FG

&%$-"+$&=!<" #!!< !!<"+$47& ,2<$,"+":"#!$&=!<" 55" ,$,"- 4>!<"+"/"&7"< -5, #"-+",$ &#"75& :7-=*"&! !<"; +& ! 1 $=< 7+!$&?      

CC    

 ?3A  9) ; +32"-&!

-""*$!&"#"%% +>!=$/" #!%$&*7#<-"! $, %$!+"* $&"-#&#"-"-& 4"< ,!<"+"/"&7"!< ! = $&%!!<":7-=*"&!; +& ! 1 $=< $&!<" +"% $-# %"3& 55" ,2 %5+""++"-4>!<"+"/"&7" /"&  !<"  5 +  +*  !<"  ; +& ! 1  $=<  7+!  :7-=*"&!

2<$#<< %4""&+""++"-!$&!<"+-"+!<"+$47& ,+"#+-%!< !!<" -"5 +!*"&!  < -  &!  #< ,,"&="-  " +,$"+  +-"+%  5 %%"-  =+ &!$&=  %$*$, + +",$"%!!<" %%"%%""%"0#"5!$&&"# %"2<$#<$%5"&-$&=+*&?4," !<".75+"*" 7+!3<2"/"+32$!<7! &>$&!"+$*%! >E<"+" %$&%*" # %"%3.5"#$ ,9" /""!$!$&%2"+"-$%*$%%"-<":7-=*"&!; +& ! 1 $=< 7+!$& %<&-7%!+$"% %75+  %< %4""&+""++"-!$&!<"+-"+ $% %7&-"+'C D E"* > ,%+"#+-!< !%$*$, +B7"%!$&# *"!4" #&%$-"+"-4>!<"$=< 7+! 7: + !$&!<"# %"

8%.<$,5  55"+E$+"&-7%!+$"%+"5+!"-$&

@) 9AA

7: &- !"+#&%$-"+$&=!<"%$*$, + B7"%!$& !5 + =+ 5<(3 &-@$!2 %4%"+/"- !<7%'C ( E"< /"<" +-!<"," +&"-#7&%", 55" +$&=+!<" 5 +!$"% &- !"+#&%$-"+$&=!<"$+%74*$%%$&%32" +" !<"/$"2!< !!<"$%%7"+ $%"-4>!<""/"&7"$&!<" 5+"%"&!   0  55" ,  $%  %B7 +",>  #/"+"-  4>  !<" -"#$%$&    *$!"0  .$,1  $,,%  /!  9!-  .75+ 3

**$%%$&"+    "&!+ ,  0#$%"  6%  $&&$ &!"+& !$& ,  9!-  &-  .& =<$  "0!$,"%  9!-  6%

7%!*% &- "&!+ , 0#$%"C@

@ 9( +$ &=. + %!<"-"#$%$& !<"+$47& ,$&!<"# %"*$!"0.$,1 $,,%/! 9!- .75+ $%#&#"+&"-3$!$%!+7"!< !!<" 55" ,$%

CC -*$!!"-4>!<"5"0 7+!3<2"/"+3&%! >2 % =+ &!"-  4>  !<"  5"0  7+!  !  $%3  <2"/"+3  *+"

$*5+! &!!&!"!< !!<"-"#$%$&!<"+$47& ,$& !<"# %" $&&$&!"+& !$& ,9!- .75+ 2 % ,% #< ,,"&="-4"+"!<"5"0 7+! &-!<"5"0 /$-"-"#$%$&+"5+!"-$&A  9 .

<",-2<$,"-$%*$%%$&=!<""/"&7"?% 55" , = $&%!!<" +$47& ,?%+-"+3!< !&#"-"/",5*"&! **$%%$&"+ =$/$&=5"+*$%%$&!!<" 55",, &!3 H

3! %",,=-%$&75! %5"#$$"-/ ,7"3"/"&7" # &&!  =  4">&-  !<"  5"+*$%%$&  &-  -$%57!"  $! <,-$&=!< !+$0$&=!<",$*$!&,>5<>%$# ,"05+!% &-&!-""*"-"05+!%%<7,-< /"4""&! 1"&$&! ##7&!!$% ,%$*5+! &!!&!"!< !!<"-"#$%$& !<"+$47& ,$&!<"# %". &=<$"0!$,"%9!-/%

7%!*%  "&!+ , 0#$%" .75+ 2 % ,%#< ,,"&="-4>!<""/"&7"4"+"!<"5"0

7+! &-!<"5"0 7+!/$-"+-"+- !"-@A -$%*$%%"-!<""/"&7"?% 55" ,E<$,"-$%*$%%$&=!<" % $- 55" ,35"0 7+!< %+""++"-!$!%-"#$%$&$& !<"  # %"    $&&$  &!"+& !$& ,  9!-  .75+   &- +"$!"+ !"-!< !!<"+$47& ,$&$!%$*57=&"-+-"+< - <",-  !< !  &#"  "/",5*"&!  **$%%$&"+  =$/$&= 5"+*$%%$&  !  !<"  55",, &!3   H 

3  !  %",, =-%$&75! %5"#$$"-/ ,7""/"&7"# &&! =4">&-!<"5"+*$%%$& &--$%57!"$!<,-$&=!< ! +  $0$&=  !<"  ,$*$!  &,>  5<>%$# ,  "05+!%  &-  &! -""*"-"05+!%%<7,-< /"4""&! 1"&$&! ##7&!  &  /$"2    !<"  4/"  %"!!,"-  ,"= ,  5%$!$&  &- #&%$-"+$&=!<" #!!< !!<"$%%7"$%%"!!,"-4>!<" 5"0 7+!4>!<%"/"+>:7-=*"&!%&2<$#<!<"

+$47& ,< %5, #"-+",$ &#"2<$,"-"#$-$&=!<"# %"

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

#," + &#"%* -"4>&"H

! &!<"+H

2<$#< +"-""*"-"05+!% +"!4"!+" !"- % 5<>%$# ,"05+!%+!<"57+5%""&!$!,$&=+"7&- 7&7!$,$%"-  #"&/ !  #+"-$!  #&!"*5, !"-  7&-"+  !<" 5+/$%$&%7,"!<" "&/ ! +"-$!7,"%3( @ <"," +&"-#7&%",+!<"+"%5&-"&!< %4+7=<!! 7+&!$#"!< ! +"% $--"#$%$&!<"$=< 7+!

7: + !2 %# ++$"-4>!<""/"&7"4"+"!<"5"0

7+!$&.9)AA8 &-!<"5"0 2<$,"  -$%*$%%$&=  !<"  55" ,  /$-"  +-"+  - !"- @4%"+/"-!<7%'C &/$"2!<"-"#$%$&!<$% 7+!$&!<"# %"

  6$+,&  "0!$,"  $,,%  9!-  6%  **$%%$&"+  

"&!+ , 0#$%"3 7*4 $3+"5+!"-$&A (.

((IA  9 . 3!<"%5"#$ ,," /"

5"!$!$&$%-$%*$%%"-G

CC %!<"+"/"&7"< - ##"5!"-&7*4"++-"+%5 %%"-4>!<" +$47& ,  =+ &!$&=  +",$"  !  !<"  %%"%%""%  7&-"+  %$*$, +  #$+#7*%! &#"% 2<"+""05+!=-%2 %&! "#!"-4>!<" %%"%%""<$*%",47!2 % !<+7=<!<"*"+#< &!"05+!"++H"05+!+$"&!"-7&$!32"-&! $&- &>%74%! &!$ ,B7"%!$&, 2 +$%"$&!<"5+"%"&! 55" , <" 55" ,%! &-%-$%*$%%"- 

 .9  

  E9  

()  

E<"!<"+%5" 1$&=8+" %&"-'

"%8 E<"!<"++"5+! 4,"'

"%8