Commissioner Of Central Excise , Chandigarh-Ii v. M/S Welspun Corporation Ltd.
! "# $ % & '
! " #$%$&'
# (#)*+$,- $&.# ')&/.&0(&%$, #'+$ )11$,,)&'
#)2&)'+#)*+(-/34)'$ #'+$#$%1&/$&' ( )*+* , + 5'+.%422&#/$#-'6)11$),%*$)#.&0% )&/
)#$*$.&0/.%1%$/ )%'+$.%%($.&3,3$/.%%.2.,)# +$#$3$&($+)% .,$/'+$)11$),%(&/$# $4'.&789 '+$ $&'#),:4.%$4'-;<< = #%+#'- '+$4'
>)0).&%''+$#/$#/)'$/
? 1)%%$/ *5 '+$ (%'2%- :4.%$ @ $#3.4$ ): 11$,,)'$ #.*(&),- +)&/.0)#+ = # %+#'- '+$ #.*(&), > 4,).2.&0 ,,6.&0 %(*%')&'.),A($%'.&% ,)6
B=> !+$'+$# '+$ .21(0&$/ #/$# /)'$/
?- &&$:(#$97.%*)%$/&%(#2.%$%)&/4&C$4'(#$%)&/.% '+$#$ #$1$#3$#%$)&/(&'$&)*,$.&'+$$5$% ,)6D => !+$'+$# '+$ / #.*(&), ).,$/ ' )11#$4.)'$ '+$ $3./$&4$&#$4#/'1#$%(2$'+)''+$.&1('%)''+$%')#' 2)&( )4'(#$ )#$ )3).,)*,$ # 4#$/.' )&/ '+$#$ #$
.##$%1$4'.3$ '+$ )4''+)''+$0/%6+.4+6$#$ .&),,5 4,$)#$/6$#$$:$21'$/-'+$)%%$%%$$6(,/*$$&'.',$/' *$&$ .' (,$?=7> '+$$&3)'#$/.'(,$%D => !+$'+$# '+$ #$%1&/$&' 6+ )' '+$ '.2$
2)&( )4'(#.&0)&/4,).2.&04$&3)'4#$/.'6)%6$,,)6)#$ '+)''+$0/%6$#$$:$21'$/.%$&'.',$/''+$*$&$ .'
$&3)'#$/.'&,5*$4)(%$+$+)%1)./?E '+$/('5.& '$#2% (,$?=7> '+$$&3)'#$/.'(,$%-
<D =>!+$'+$#'+$*$&$ .' #(,$?=7> '+$$&3)'#$/.'
(,$% .% )3).,)*,$ ' '+$ )%%$%%$$- .##$%1$4'.3$ +.% 4&/(4')&/2),) ./$.&'$&'.&')3).,4$&3)'4#$/.'& '+$.&1('%(%$/.&2)&( )4'(#.&0 $:$21'$/0/%D =>!+$'+$#'+$ /#.*(&), ).,$/')11#$4.)'$'+)''+$ )/C(/.4)'.&0)('+#.'5+)/#$,.$/(1&9#$'(#& .,$/ *5'+$#$%1&/$&'.'%$, '42$')4&4,(%.&'+)'
0/%4,$)#$/ #2 ;F
'<
6$#$$:$21'$/ 0/% )&/ '+$#$ #$ '+$ #$%1&/$&' )' '+$ '.2$
1(#4+)%$ .&1('% )% 6$,, )% 2)&( )4'(#.&0 .&), 0/%6)%)6)#$ '+$$:$21'.&4$#'.
.4)'$.& )3(#
'+$ D =>!+$'+$#'+$#$%1&/$&'6++)/2)&.1(,)'$/)1(#4+)%$ #/$#/)'$/8
&,5.&#/$#'*#.&0'+$#6.%$ $:$21'0/%.&)2.:$/*)0)&'+$&'4,).24$&3)' 4#$/.'*51)5.&0 ?E/('5.&'$#2% (,$?=7> '+$ -
<.%$&'.',$/''+$*$&$ .' (,$?=7>')3)., 4$&3)'4#$/.'&.&1('%(%$/.&2)&( )4'(#.&0 $:$21'
7 0/%DG +$ )4'%)#$'+)' F%!$,%1(&#C$4' '/= #%+#'- ! >.% $&0)0$/.&2)&( )4'(#$ .1$%-.'#$4$.3$/#/$# %(11,5 1.1$%
#2 &87
%1$#'+$4&/.'.& 1(#4+)%$#/$#-'+$ 1.1$%6$#$'*$%(11,.$/%(*C$4''$:$21'.&(&/$#'. .4)'.&
9/)'$/H7
)&/.
'+$ ).,$/'0$'$:$21'.& 4$#'.
.4)'$(&/$#'+$%)./&'.
.4)'.&-.&'+)'4)%$/('56)%'*$1)./& '+$1.1$% F%!$,%1(#)'.& '/= #%+#'- ! >)4A(.#$/)(&.'
.&(,5-
)&/%')#'$/2)&( )4'(#.&0 1.1$%! 1,)4$/'+$#/$#&
H
'! #'+$1.1$%6+.4+ 6$#$' *$%(11,.$/ *5.'' &
- *').&$/)&$:$21'.&4$#'.
.4)'$& 8
-! 1,)4$/)&'+$##/$#'! #%(11,5 1.1$%)&/& '+$%(11,5/('56)%,$3.)*,$'6(,/*$6#'+')I.&0&'$)''+.%%')0$ '+)'*'+'+$#/$#%6$#$ #%(11,5 !1.1$%
22 22 6),,'+.4I&$%%+$1$#./.&/.%1('$.% #2 $1'$2*$#-
'(&$-
7 .&6+.4+.'6)%4,).2$/*5)%%$%%$$'+)'$:$21'$//('.)*,$0/%6$#$ 2)&( )4'(#$/)&/%(11,.$/+$/$1)#'2$&'&'+$*)%.% .& #2)'.&'+)'
'+$#$%1&/$&'%6$#$4,).2.&04$&3)'4#$/.'&'+$#)62)'$#.),(%$/ # 2)&( )4'(#$ $:$21'$/0/%-.%%($/%
!
"#"# $%&'()$
*
+" *, ,# )
-
.
+ $ $
%
/
<
) * )
*
)
1
"(# "2#
* *1
"3#
4
5$41
6*
78(3( 594
6*
+
* 5$4
"# (
& *
: *
2 * "# "# ; <"# ) $%&'()
1
*
*
= "
#;
$%&'()
8
> ?
(( $
% *
*
"
# 5 $%&'()
* *
== "# *
== "
#
@ "
#
@ "
# @ "
#
@ "
#
== "
#
@ "
#
*
* @ "
# @
? "
#
* ? $%&'()
= "
# "
# "#
= "
# "
# "
# "#&
= "# "
#*
*
*
* * ;= "
#
1
@ "
#
= "(#@ "
#
*
"# = "
#* ? $%&'()
= "
# "
# "#
= "(#
) = "
# "
# "
# = "
# "
# "# = "(#
*
"
#;
$%&'()
H
*
* ?
"
#
;
1 "
#
1
A *
= *
* * *
==2
*
=&$%&'()
?
"#
C = "
#
= "#*
2
$%&'()
*
"# "
# = C = "#
=
( "
#* ! @ "
#*
= "(#@ = "
#
*
"#
= "
# $%&'()
?
= "
# "
# "#
= "(#
)
*
78(3(
)
?
)
D>
"#
)
)
/
)
"
#
A
;
=
* "#
! ) C +
*5$4
)
/
5
+
*
/
8 =*
*
)
)
*
5$4
+
&
&
)
) -( )*+* ,.-+/0 $' . +1, +1, 77
2I !+$'+$#%1$)I.&0F#$)%&$/
$%F !+$'+$##$1#')*,$
$%F