High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/68/2024disposed of

Manoj Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-04-30Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger11 pages

" !

#$#%&#'

!+,# '#./$/()

* * +)(0 123+% ****** #,/,/()#% 4#%$2$ 5,+,# +%6+)+ (,7#%$

******

#$8()'#),$

9 : *

5 5

%#$#), %* *1* +);+< '&(.+,#

-(% 8#,/,/()#%*

%* 1+8/= +)$+=< ! +%6+)+*

* * 5 <

* #,/,/()#%

+)(0 123+% 7+$ -/=#'

/)$,+), ./&/= >%/, 8#,/,/() 2)'#% %,/.=#$ ()$,/,2,/() )'/+< /),#% +=/+< $##?/);

>%/, )+,2%# .#%,/(%+%/ -(% $#,,/);

+$/'#

A< (==#.,(%< 5/%$+< >7#%#B6 7+$ B##) %#3(&#'

%+3 +).7+6+, 7/=?+)/ !7+B< #7$/= !/$,%/., 5/%$+*

-2%,7#% 8%+6#% 7+$ B##) 3+'# -(% $#,,/);

+$/'# **

< /$+% !/&/$/()< /$+%

$7(%, 9!/&/$/()+= (33/$$/()#%9< >7#%#B6 +) +88#+= -/=#'

+;+/)$,

A< 7+$ B##) '/$3/$$#'*

* %/#-=6<

+)(0 123+% #=#.,#'

%+3 +).7+6+, 7/=?+)/ !7+B< #7$/= !/$,%/., 5/%$+<

8+).7+6+, #=#.,/()$ 7#='

5,+,# +%6+)+ ** ,7#%#+-,#%< ,((?

(+,7 (--/.# ***

* +88#+%$ %#$8()'#), (* =(.?

!#&#=(83#), +).7+6+,

--/.#%< ==#)+B+'< =#,,#% A**

(B$#%&/);

%#.(;)/C#'

B(+%'

-+==$ =/$, -+?# B(+%'

$.7((=$< ,7#%#-(%#< .#%,/-/.+,# -+?#*

* 8() =#+%)/);

+B(2, =#,,#% A**

< $2B3/,,#'

%#8%#$#),+,/() **

5/%$+< #@8=+/)/);

7/$ 8($/,/() 7# 7+'

+88#+%#'

#@+3/)+,/() 7#='

+6< 2)'#% %(== (* A A $+/'

#@+3/)+,/() >/,7 $#.()'

'/&/$/() ,7#%#+-,#% 3/;%+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# *** +$$#%,#'

+== '(.23#),$ +%# -+/% ;#)2/)#< +..(%'/);=6< +$?#'

-(% 8%(8#% &#%/-/.+,/() '(.23#),$ '()# B#-(%# ,+?/);

+'&#%$# +.,/() +;+/)$, 7/3*

* 5/32=,+)#(2$=6< +=$( +88%(+.7#'

,7/$ (2%, -/=/);

>%/, 8#,/,/()

A $##?/);

$#,,/);

+$/'# =#,,#% A**

< 7(>#&#%< $+3# '/$3/$$#'

>/,7'%+>)< &/'# **

>/,7 =/B#%,6 ,+?# +== 8=#+$ 8%(.##'/);$ 3+6 B# /)/,/+,#'

+;+/)$, 7/3*

* ,%+)$8/%#$ 5/%$+< &/'#

A< %#3(&#'

;%(2)'

.(),#$,#'

#=#.,/() B+$/$ -+?# #'2.+,/()+= .#%,/-/.+,# +)'< ,7#%#-(%#< 7# /)#=/;/B=# 2)'#% 5#.,/()

& +%6+)+ +).7+6+,/

+0 .,< AA

$7(%, 9AA .,9*

##=/);

+;;%/#&#'

+;+/)$,

A< 8%#-#%%#'

+) +88#+= B#-(%# !/&/$/()+= >7/.7 '/$3/$$#'< &/'# **

7(='/);

.#%,/-/.+,# 8%#$#),#'

+, ,/3# -/=/);

7/$ )(3/)+,/() 8+8#%$ %#.(;)/C#'

B(+%'*

* ) +-(%#3#),/()#'

./%.23$,+).#$< 7+$ -/=#'

/)$,+), ./&/= >%/, 8#,/,/() B#-(%# ,7/$ (2%, -(% %#=/#-

$< )(,/.#'

7#%#/)+B(&#*

* #+%'* * :#+%)#'

.(2)$#= -(% $2B3/,$ >#== !/&/$/()+= (33/$$/()#% 7+&# #%%#'

=+> -+.,$ 8+$$/);

/382;)#'

(%'#%$*

$2B3/,,#'

.#%,/-/.+,#

+0+$,7+) %#.(;)/C#'

(&#%)3#), )'/+ >#== (&#%)3#),

>7/.7 #D2/&+=#), .#%,/-/.+,# (,7#% (+%'$ 5,+,#$*

-2%,7#% $2B3/,,#'

7+$ B##) ,+%;#,#'

=($/);

.+)'/'+,#$ 8+).7+6+, #=#.,/()$ +..(2), 8(=/,/.+= %#+$()$*

+$$#%,#'

'(.23#),$ $2B3/,,#'

+, ,/3# -/=/);

7/$ )(3/)+,/() 8+8#%$ +%# ;#)2/)# (,7#% $,2'#),$ 7(='/);

$/3/=+% .#%,/-/.+,# $ 7+&# B##) ;/&#) +'3/$$/() -(% 7/;7#% #'2.+,/()

7+&# +=$( B##) (--#%#'

0(B$ B+$/$ $/3/=+% .#%,/-/.+,# $ $2B3/,,#'

8#,/,/()#%< +..(%'/);=6< .#%,/-/.+,# $2B3/,,#'

+, ,/3# 7/$ )(3/)+,/() 8+8#%$ .+))(, B# '#.=+%#'

B# -+?#*

+=$( $2B3/,,#'

.+$# .#%,/-/.+,# $2B3/,,#'

+, ,/3# 7/$ )(3/)+,/() -+?#< ,7#) 8%(8#% %#3#'6 -(% +;;%/#&#'

8+%,6 -/=# #=#.,/() 8#,/,/()< >7/.7 .+$# 7+)'*

)#@, $2B3/,,#'

7+$ 8%(.##'#'

%#3(&# >/,7(2, +--(%'/);

7/3 (88(%,2)/,6 7#+%/);

>/,7(2, 7(='/);

8%(8#% %#;2=+% /)D2/%6< >7/.7 ,#)+B=# =+>* $,/== -2%,7#% $2B3/,,#'

+, ,/3# >7#) 7/$

$+/'

B(+%'

=/$, -+?# B(+%'$

+0+$,7+) 7+$ B##) $7(>) =/$, -+?# B(+%'$ ()=6 6#+% *

..(%'/);=6< 8%+6#% 7+$ B##) 3+'# -(% $#,,/);

+$/'# /382;)#'

(%'#%$*

* ) %#$8()$# $2B3/$$/()$ %+/$#'

B#7+=- >#%# (88($#'

.(2)$#= +88#+%/);

-(% %#$8()'#),$ $2B3/,,/);

**< +) +88=/.+,/() %#.#/&#'

()# +%7=+'

$() 57%/ +)/

+3 &/==+;# 7/=?+)/ !7+B< >7#%#/) /, +==#;#'

7#%#/) 7+'

-/=#'

)(3/)+,/() 8+8#%$ -(% +,,+.7/);

-+?# $,+)'+%'

.#%,/-/.+,#<

+0+$,7+)*

$2B3/,,#'

.(38=+/), +;+/)$, ;(, /)D2/%#'

/),( 52B !/&/$/()+=

--/.#%

< ==#)+B+'< >7( $2B3/,,#'

7/$ /)D2/%6 %#8(%,< &/'# =#,,#% **

>/,7 (B$#%&+,/() /)$,/,2,# -+?# #'2.+,/()+= .#%,/-/.+,# ,7/$ /)$,/,2,#

+=$( -+?#*

)#@, $2B3/,,#'

$/).# '/'

7+&# %#D2/$/,# #'2.+,/()+= D2+=/-/.+,/() +, ,/3# #=#.,/()< ,7#%#-(%#< 7# /).2%%#'

'/$D2+=/-/.+,/() 8%(&/'#'

2)'#% 5#.,/()

& AA .,* ..(%'/);=6< $7(> .+2$# )(,/.# ** 8#,/,/()#%< 7(>#&#%< )( %#8=6 $+/'

$7(> .+2$# )(,/.# ;/&#) >/,7/) 8%#$.%/B#'

,/3# ,7#%#+-,#%< 5/%$+< +--(%'#'

(88(%,2)/,6 8#%$()+= 7#+%/);$ * *< ** **< 7(>#&#%< %#3+/)#'

+B$#), ()# 8%#,#@, (% (,7#% #&#%6 '+,#*

$,+,#'

-/)+==6 +88#+%#'

** B#-(%# $2B3/,,#'

%#8=6 $7(> .+2$# )(,/.#*

5/).# -+/=#'

$2B3/, #&/'#).# 8%((- %#;+%'$ 7/$ #'2.+,/()+= D2+=/-/.+,/()< +..(%'/);=6< 7# %#3(&#'

5+%8+).7< &/'#

A #&#) 7/$ +88#+= '/$3/$$#'

!/&/$/()+= &/'# **

/,7 $2B3/$$/()$< 8%+6#% 7+$ B##) 3+'# -(% '/$3/$$+= /)$,+), >%/, 8#,/,/()*

* #+%'*

* ) 8%#$#), .+$#< .(),#$,#'

#=#.,/()$ %+3 +).7+6+, 7/=?+)/ !7+B*

, ,/3# -/=/);

)(3/)+,/() 8+8#%$< $2B3/,,#'

.#%,/-/.+,#<

+0+$,7+)

* 52B$#D2#),=6< B+$/$ .(38=+/), $2B3/,,#'

()# +%7=+'< 3+,,#% ;(, /)D2/%#'

/),( 52B !/&/$/()+=

--/.#%

/&/=< ==#)+B+'< >7( $2B3/,,#'

7/$ %#8(%,

** (B$#%&/);

.#%,/-/.+,# #'2.+,/()+= D2+=/-/.+,/()

-+?#*

) B+$/$ /)D2/%6 %#8(%,< 5/%$+< +)

A< %#3(&/);

5+%8+).7*

A* #%#< /, >(2='

B# +88($/,# 3+?# %#-#%#).# /)D2/%6 %#8(%, **< %#=#&+), #@,%+.,$ >7/.7 %#+'

2)'#%

! " #$ !

% &

'( ! )*))+, - .()() )) / /

'(01+! !

)2( 1() ))!

! & !

4 # /

/ ! " # $ !

% & & !

4 # ( / 5 '( 2))+ &

)-( () )1/ /

! 5 '(!)*)1+), -( () )1

! " # $ / !

% & & 6

7 ) ,

8 /

/ ( 6 / /

! ! " #$

% & / ( (9

! " # $ !

& ( 9 / / /

,-+ *) )1+

1 (() )1

(6 /

2);+ & 0( )() )1 ( / 7

/ /

(

/ 3 !

! " #$ / !

% &

( 9 1- + *) )1+ + ) ( )() )1

/ /

( 9 / /

3 !

( ! 3

/ '( ,1+ <+9*1

)1( )() )1 7

& !

4 # =!

>? @ :

(

( 6:

/ ///( (

(( 6

(

'(9

*)*)1+ 0( 1() )1 &

=4 # >

4 #

& !

4 # (9

! ! 3 !

/ (

( 6 ! 3

/ & !

4 # =!

> ' 7

& !

4 # =!

> @ :

4 #

/ ( 6 ! !

8#%2$+= +B(&# #@,%+.,#'

/)D2/%6 %#8(%, >(2='

$2;;#$, )( (B$#%&+,/() 7+$ B##) 3+'# %#;+%'$ 8=#+ +, ,/3# >7#) 7# 7+'

6#+% <

+0+$,7+) '#.=+%#'

9-+?# /)$,/,2,#9* =,7(2;7< .(),#),/() -/)'$ 3#),/()#'

/)D2/%6 %#8(%, ()=6 (B$#%&+,/() -(%,7.(3/);

)( #@+3/)+,/() .()'2.,#'

B(+%'< )+3#=6<

>7/.7 %#.(;)/C#'

#D2/&+=#), #@+3/)+,/() .()'2.,#'

+%6+)+ (+%'

7/>+)/ )(% $+3# /).=2'#'

#D2/&+=#).# =/$,< ,7#%#-(%#< $+3# -+?# B(+%'* -2%,7#% 3#),/()#'

8#% %#8(%, 7/#- =(.?

--/.#%< 52%+,;+%7< !/$,%/., 5%/ +);+)+;+%<

.().#%)#'

/)$,/,2,# -(2)'

+, $8(,* A* +&/);

.()$/'#%#'

/)D2/%6 %#8(%,< +3 .()$/'#%#'

&/#> )( '#-/)/,/&# -/)'/);

7+$ B##) %#,2%)#'

#/,7#% /)D2/%6 %#8(%, (% (%'#%$ (% !/&/$/()+= (33/$$/()#%

+0+$,7+) %#.(;)/C#'

-+?# /)$,/,2,# #&#) +, ,/3# >7#) 7+'

.=#+%#'

7/$ #@+3/)+,/() +6< *

2%,7#%3(%#< %#D2/%#3#), 5#.,/()

& AA ., >7#,7#% 3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# 82,-(%,7 .+)'/'+,# %#.(;)/C#'

/)$,/,2,/() B(+%'* )#.#$$+%6 $2.7 %#.(;)/,/() 32$, B# =(.+= B(+%'

(% /)$,/,2,/() 5,+,# +%6+)+ ()=6*

&#) /- 3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# /)$,/,2,/() B(+%'

(,7#% 5,+,#< /, >(2='

$#%&# 82%8($#*

* 88+%#),=6< +B$#).# -/)'/);

+6< >7#)

7+'

3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# 8#,/,/()#%< +, ,/3# +=$( $+/'

/)$,/,2,# -+?# (% 3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# 82,-(%,7 %#.(;)/C#'

/)$,/,2,/() B(+%'

(,7#% 5,+,# )'/+<

A< **

< !/&/$/()+= .+))(, B# $2$,+/)#'

$+3# +%# 7#%#B6 $#, +$/'#*

* 7# >%/, 8#,/,/() +..(%'/);=6 '/$8($#'

>/,7 '/%#.,/() /)D2/%# /),( .(38=+/), $2B3/,,#'

+;+/)$, -(==(>/);

,>( /$$2#$

/ >7#,7#% +6< < >7#) 3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# 8#,/,/()#%< +, ,/3#<

+0+$,7+) '#.=+%#'

-+?# /)$,/,2,#

// >7#,7#% 3+,%/.2=+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# 8%('2.#'

+, ,/3# .(),#$,/);

#=#.,/() %#.(;)/C#'

/)$,/,2,/() B(+%'*

* :#, /)D2/%6 B# ;(, .()'2.,#'

+..(%'+).# >/,7 =+> +-,#% +$$(./+,/);

+--(%'/);

'2# (88(%,2)/,6 7#+%/);

+== .().#%)#'

8+%,/#$ -%#$7 (%'#%$ B# >/,7/) 8#%/('

,7%## 3(),7$ '+,# %#.#/8, .#%,/-/#'

.(86 ,7/$ (%'#%* * #)'/);

+88=/.+,/()

$< /- +)6< $7+== +=$( $,+)'

.=($#'*

* *

$0?$ 7#,7#% $8#+?/);

%#+$()#'

"#$

( 7#,7#% %#8(%,+B=# "#$

(