Ex Engineer, Transmission System, Hvpnl, Ambala v. Central Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh And Another

    

         

" ($ 7?.;.

<. !$1"$ 7A.=.

<  

'#(

 !

"#""$ %&"# !

!&!

!/(&!"!!

 !# B**))!

 /".

!) "

% !**))!+ !)  ,!

( !,!

(!

$, B"*$ "  


 



     " - - - 

      -.8!&!

! ( $!1$, !**))!

. -.% ", ()", %.%!

(

-./ &0#! ( $!1$

$ ")3, "*$ $.
. 999     

 .  , !**))!

 "2" :!",

 $1 $( (!( ;.<.
= 3,+&"!

!**!)"2

($1,!# #$ (*$"(3!""   !  3!" ("

"#""( +& , "$#"   " 4 %  ! **))!  + !)  ,!

( !,5, !11($!

!"6 %C@
.  **))!

>, !&!

! /(&  !"!!

  !# '#(  !

!

$1 !&!

!  (!2

 " 

(   , 3$2 $1 *$3 !

"#""$ ( ("+$  $1 ) &.  

( -D" ..%.

.

E
F -!

# ")!

  . '(. 51$ ",$ 6, % -!

# G@ $ "**)&" "$1#!

*$3(

,1 !)&!"
<>H!

(
H> ?.""!(,!%-!

# 3!")!+)$*!&" !$ ,   (( +& ,#.  " "!( ,! , !**))! & !)"$ (*$"( " ! $ 
I.?.
H  ?.;.
H !

(H.I.
H$1 ! $!) !#$ $1".< <? =;D>.

,$,,!

( ,%-!

# 3,$3$,3" )!+)  !)"$ (*$"( , "!# !#$  $1 "  ! $  ;.<.
H  A.;.
H!

(H.=.
H  )!$ $," "*$ ((.

$#

$2 $3 ,!**))!

& ,1$ #$ (!**$*!!**)!$ A.=.
? "2

($1,!#$ $1!*!($, !) " (% ! "$ #+!)! &.,&3!"2(+&,!,$" $1)!**)!$  ,1$#!*$ ((.$(

)& "**$

($# " !)$

 3, !**)!$    , :( 1$#! 3 !)"$ (*$"( $
=.
.
? !"(#!

((+&,"*$ ". $*"$1,,!))!

1)

,! , !#$  ,!( +  (*$"( 3 +& , !**))!

 !

( "  *$ (3!)"$"**)(!"(#!

((+&,"*$ " ()(!( 
..
;.$3  ,!**)!

&3!"$

&($ 
.<.
; $1 !

 $( (!( ?.<.
;  8

 , )!# # $

 , 1 !**)!$ $++)!(!

(+&$ ()#!$ . A. "*$ "C!"$ (,!,*!&,!(1)(,1 ()!# 
=.
.
? !

( "  ! *!&# " 3 #!( +& , $#*!

& $
I.?.
H  ?.;.
H !

( H.I.
H  ,1$  1 ( )!# " # +!(!",)!#3!""+#(!1#)#$16$ &!C. <.  !**!)3!"*1(!

! ","!($(+&,!**))!

3,,3!"8( )&

%$ $1, !) " I<<

EAF 51$ ",$ 6,   I<<C@ 3,, ,!" +  #!( !**)!+) $ "  ! #!"+& $1%$ =A$1,  I<< 3,,"*)!" ,!!

&*"$ "2

($1!

&(&#!&#!2!

+1$ ,"""!

D*& $##""$ $1 !) " 3, &!1$# ,) (!., $##""$ 5**!)"@C"$((!(
.I.
;"  ,1$ !)"$ (,!))

+1$," $. H. ,  !**!) 3!" *1( +1$ , "$#"  " !

% !**))!+ !)51$",$6 %C@ 3,,)(*$ , '!

  , $1 , + !) !

( 8( , 1 ( )!# +

 # +!(. ?. '!

( $ ") 1$ , !**))!

 ,!" "+#( ,! , )#!$ $1$ &!"!**)!+)$,(&*!(!

$$ ,!#$ 3,, " (*$"( 3$

)& $  ( #"!2 !

( "+#( ,! , )#!$  (%$ $1, I<<3$)( $+!**)!+)$, !#$ *!(3+&#"!2!"" !!

(" ,!#$ " $! (&+!

$ $"*!&# $1" ! ,*$($1)#!$ 3$)(

$,!

!**)!$ . 3!"1,"!(,!,1 (!**)!$ ,!(+ 1)( 3, A(!&"1$#,(!$12 $1$!

(,!

*!(3  ,1$ ,!**))!

$ ,$+ (,1 (. ;. '!

($ ")"+#",!,!**)!$ 3!"!!))&1)( !"*

D$ A.=.
?!

(!"$ (!**)!$ 3!"1)($
I.I.
? 3,!1 $ A..
? ,*& $##""$   ( +!2,1)$,(*!#  "

,!**))!

C"$#*!

&$1) !*!)!1$#!$1$#>.,"+": !**)!$  ($#> 3!" ,1$ "+#( $ 
=.
.
?. ,"   !

$ + "!( ,! ,

E<F 1 (3!", ,)&+)!(!

()!+)$+8(.'!

($ "))" *$ ,8( $1,-!(!" , $ ,!"$1-D"A  1$,  D
()$$ 3% ". "$#"  "!

(% !**))! + !)
=5=@ %'<.!)"$)"$ ,8( $1,$#+!&  , $ ,!"$1!8! "$ ". $##""$ $1 !) "  !",2
= 5I@ %' =.  !)"$ )" $  , 8( " $1 , 0!

!!2!  , $   -D" ))! ")!

& % " ". ,

$##""$ $1 $#!


5?;@ %'HI 0./.. "$ " ".

$##""$  $1 !) "  !

!)$
 5;@ % ? !

$##""$  $1 !) " 5**!)"@  !

)$ ". 0./..

"$ 

 5
?@ % IH.  !)"$ )" $  , 8(  $1 , *! , $ ,!"$1*! 2""$!$ ".

$ $1  (!!

($,"

A5;@ %'
HI. =. $ ")1$"*$ $.
-.% ", ()", )($ , 8( $1,$ C+)%*# $ -!1!)!) (""'(. ""

$ $1 (!II;5=I@ .'..
<;5%.

.@$"+#,!1,!#$ ,!" +  (*$"( $ $")&  , "!# " $ )!+) $ + 1 ((  ( %$ $1, I<<!

(,%!!

! 3,,+( $1 (&"*!""($ $,,(*!&.!)"$)"*$ /

"!"'(.

". $##""$  $1 !) "  !

,2)!
= 5H@ %' HI  """!

$))$1 "./". !# )!)-!

1!

.II; 5I@ .'.
?5% @  ! !

" $*$!$  .'(.!

(!

$, ".

$  $1  (! !

( $," I== 5A<@ .'.. <?H 5)).@  %$,  %1!  "," ". "". $##. 1 . .  - !*J,!
I 5
=@ .%..'.

 50.@  -.

.-.   !$ !) *$" '(. ". "". $##. 1 %.. 

,

!


5?@ .%..'.H?H5-!(.@ K" )$+!)



% "

EHF .'(. ".&. $##. 1 %4 . . ,

!%$,


5?@ .%..'. AHH5-!(.@!

(%!!!

(! *$"5@'(. ".

$ $1 (!
H5A
@ .'..<A<54@. I. L,!

$ "((,"+#""$ ". . %$ $1, I<< (!)"3,!"")!

$1 $1(&$1"!

( "3,,*$ ("1$",!**)!$ $+1)( +1$,*&$1$ &!1$#,) (!.3$)(+!**$"$ :$) !"$1%$ $1, I<<7> %$ . )!#1$1 ($1(&!

( " 1!

& *!( ",(& 5@ &*"$ )!#

($1!

&(&$1"!

( > " 1!

& *!($ ",(&#!&#!2!

1$> 1 ($1",E(&!

( " 1!

& *!($ ",(&$, """!

$##""$ $1 !) "$*& $##"> "$ $1 !) "+1$,*&$1$ &!1$#, ) (! ",1$#!

(#!

!"#!&+*"+(!

, !**)!$  ",!)) + !$#*!

( +& ", ($# !& $ $, (  5 )(

 ,($# "1($  "$ 
@!",!**)!

#!&1 ",$"!+)",,!,!#$ $1 (&$1"!

( " 1!

& *!($ ",(& )!$ $3,,",1 (")!#(3!"$))(1$# $*!(+&  ,#!

(, ( $1",(&!

( " 1!

& *!($ ",(&,!( $+ *!""($ +&,#$!

&$,*"$ 7 $ ((,!3,!

1$1 (,!"+ #!(+> 1$ , $## #  $1 , !) "" !

"$#" '!3"5# (# @ II ",!**)!$ ",!))+(#( $,!

+ #!( (,""+>"$ !"!# ((+&,"!( !

(,"!#",!))+(!)3, !$(!

3,,*$>

"$ "$1"+>"$ 5
@"+"(+&,!7

E?F $ ((1,,!,)#!$ $1$ &!",!)) $!**)& 3,!

&(&!

( " 1!

& *!($ ",(&,!"+ *!( (*$". . ,""!""!"$3,,,"!$&)#*"+( #" $1 %$   $1 ,   I<<  3$)( !**)& ":!)&   #" $1 %$ =A$1,  II< 3,"*$)!#$1*!&# 1$ 1 ($13$

)&(*$"(!#$ !"" !.%$ $1,  I<<3!"#!(!**)!+)$" !+&%$ =A$1,   II<. 
. $#,*"!)$1,*$ "$ !" $(!+$  " ( ,!*"$ ""2

( #!&#!2!

3, &!1$# ,) (!. ,*" !" !,!"+ (*$"(3 $ +&,  *$ ( !

( $  +& , !**))!

 !

( ,1$  , (#!

( 1$ 1 (3!"#!(+&,!**))!

$ $#

$2 $3!+$(!)(*$"$1 ," !."!)"$!

!(#(*$"$ ,!," $)!+)&$1, !**))!

$*!&," !. A. ,"$) $ ($( &,!**))!

&1$#1 ($1 ,!",!,!**)!$ 1$1 ( ,$1$#!,!(+ #$ ( !1$ &!,!")!*"(. <. , :"$  3,, !"" 1$ $ "(!$  $1 ," $ " 3,,$ &!*$(3$)(+(# (#,!

!))&$1$#,(! $12 $1#"!2$13$

(*$"., $#*!

&)2, !**))!

 " 

 +& " !) (11   ( (!)". , !**)!$  1$ 1 (3$)(+*$""(! !$") )"+1$"!!))&"+#($ , (*!# .

 !

$ )$" " , $1 , 1! ,! , !#$  3!" 3$

)&(*$"(+&"$# ( (!)$11$1,!**))!

$#*!

&3,$

E;F (( $ ,2 3, , "  *$ ( )!

 $ , ! ,!

 + !)!(& *!( +& , "  *$ (.   , #"!

"  , (! $1 $13$

(*$",!"$+$ "((!"!#1$#3,,, (!$1)#!$ 3$)("!!

$1$#,(!3, ,!#$ 3!" (*$"(. H. )
?H$1, "$ $1 (!* ",!,$" 1$# $))

 ! )) !))&.   $, 3$("  !

& !#$  3,, ,!" + (*$"(3,,%! (!,!(!

)&+!))$3($+! (1 , "!# " (*$"( ) !))& !

$ $ $")&  )) !))& $ 3,$ . ?. , )!# $1 , !**))!

 1$ 1 ( ,1$  !

$ + !))$3($+(1!("$))&$ ,+!"",!$ &!,!")!*"(1$#, (!$1(*$"."$+ $(,!,!**))!

&,!($#$ $3!+$,3$

(*$"$1!#$ !"" !$ A.=.
?3, ,& (!

#!)"2

)!"$1!#$ $1".< <? =;D>1$#,  *$ ( !#)& % -!

#  !

( ##(!)& ,!1 $
I.I.
? !

3!"#$ (..3, A(!&".,"!"*,!" $ + $( +$, +& , !,$" $  ( !" 3)) !" , !**))!

!,$& !

( ," $ 1 (" , $(" *!""( +& ,# ,1$  !" $ $". ;. ,!""(!+!!

$(!+$ !1$ ($+$ , $3 1!"!

(#"!

"!

(3)),!

$+!# ($ 1!"$1!, !".," $"$1,1# 3,! ,!"$1-!1!)!)5"*!@ ,

$ 3!" !#

 , :"$  3,, 1 ( $1!

& (& 3,, #!& ,!

+ (*$"(3$

1))&+&#"!2",$)(+#!($ $.,  ( " "$   , $1 , %*# $   $) ( , *!""

 $

E=F ,$&!

(1$ (,!!",(& (, ",!(*!""($ $, "$#"D$ "#" ,)!#1$1 (3!" $!*!+).!)"$$$2 $$ "(!$ ,:"$ !+$()!&!

(,)(,!$ ""(& ,!"+  )(( ,"!)*!

(,!"+ *!""($ $,$ "#"  ,$ !)#!

1!!

$)!#1 (,$!",""!*!($ , $"$,*+),:"!)$ . =.   , *"  !"  "  ! ,!" +  *!( 3 !

( ,  *$ ( ,!" )!#( , "!( !#$  1$# , !**))!

 $#*!

& 3,,!

$+*!""($ " ,!**))!

$#*!

&")1,!"(*$"( ,!#$ 3,,"!,:"."!!"$1(!)*!&# .,$, *!& !#)&%-!

# ,!" $#$ (!

&!**)!$ 1$1 (. , #"!

"  , 1 ( $1 , !**))!

& !

$ + ( ( "$))&$ !$ $1()!&3,,,!"!!))& $$(!""1$#, (!$12 . =. 0*

 3,!+$  3!))$3,!**!)!

((, "*$ " $ 1 ( , !#$  $1 ". < <? =;D> (*$"( +& , !**))!

&!)$

3, ".,1 (",!))+)!"(3, "#$ ,"1$#$(!&.
. ))* (

#".!**)!$ 5"@!)"$"!

(("*$"($1.  

                            A.=.

< !8", .L,,"*!2

D!"$ (M 7 "D$
.L,,*$!+)M 7 "D$