Bhupesh Mukhija v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited And ANR
!"
#$%$!&'
()
* +
, ,
'
-, * . *
!" #$
%& $ '
! )" $
%& $ ' *
. * /
,
( ##" + + ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ +(,- #& *2 '# ,- ( ( ( & 3 ## $ +( ' #&&- && + , $ , # & 3 + , ,-
+( ' #
4'#- 5$ ' & &
& 6, )& , "
&& *47 9( *:6, )& (
&(&."
22 +(,- +
&# , #+ ,-
3 ;#-$
$ $
8:
+ ,- 6, )& " && %( #"
&& 9( + $ ,## ' ( *% , 2 9( ,% &# "
+ #+ &(&."
&& < + # % ( +( & ' = - = 2 , !&
/1 >#&&-
&$
,- #
""% :+( + # $ ' #& !& :
)" # !%&
(
&$ 2
,' ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .
0 &$ 6, )& & , ''&
?
! ''
6, )& &(&. 2 2 + ' & -"
' # & 9$ @ # && &- $ &(&."
('$ + ' , "
#+ ,-
3 9( && + (-& ##- &(&. + ' ?
9 + + &( " +( +"
( & +( A 4$ )989 % &&
## && + ( ' "( && &- + &(&. " < + '( # ( @ ' 2
2
&($ &( " ' #+ ,-
+' 9(
0
''
# $ $
8: 9( + && &( " ( &# ,- 6, )& '
>'' ' & ,# # + . ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ (+%$ ' # &#
#
C& !& /1 )" # !%&
(
&$ 2
+ (& ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ 4 (
0 & % # , % & %& ,"( & ,- # &# ' $ ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ " +( & #&
&& + $ (+%$ " + ## 9( % ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ (:
!
" #
)
$
%&'(%&)
%'(%&*
+
,
- ./
,
-.0
&&' (%&*
1 2 # 3 ,
4
5 . 6 # ,$ &!( (%(%
&7%((%(% 8
89 8 2
0 :(; 4 , (%%/3 < 2
0:(;
-
. 0:(;
3
4
, 2
&!:&;:; "
, &*/
8 7 3
=
(*%0(%&*
,
-./
>
%&'(%&)
'(%&*
. /)!/0!'= :
;
&&'(%&*3 ?
2
1
# 3 ,
4
:2;
6
2# 3
*,
(% 6 @
%&'(%&)
%'(%&*
,
&% 3
0%A
&0 B
0%A
/& B
$
# , '>
9
C
""% ('$ + ( '#
) &# ' ( ( " (
' ""
'
(
= - ## = 2 # &, !&
/1 >#&&-
&$
+ - '( & &# ( % & && #&&- && '
+ -
%"
" $ # &# ' 6, )& & " , "
- % # # !&
/1 >#&&-
&$
+# & #- ' (+ ' B( & # $ 6, )& +# , # & #&# ' "
+(&( & '( , ,% ( # - # +( &
!"#$% ! ! & !$ ! $ 4- # &"
# & ' C" $ & # +# , & ' & & & #+ + & ' ' #- +( + &(&. - 2
D
;-$ # &# ' , ,% ( # - ,- #&&- && # -
* ( " (
< ( % ( # &# "
' &% ( % " ("( & #"
+(
2
+( ( ,# & # & ( &% &
9( & % ,## &# ( % & ' & $ ,# %+ C"
!"#$% ! ! & !$ ! $ 9( % C" :
2
2
0:(; 4 , (%%/ - < 0:(; 4 , (%%/ $
C
"
D 2 #
,
4
:&; ,E 5 5 $ "
5 . 6 F .E
# , $ &!( (%(%
2"G :# ; $>0&*% (%&*
&7%((%(%
-
< -
2
0:(; ,
&G
4 , (%%/
3 4 , &*&%
3 2
() 4 , &*&%
<H ' # & (&)(** &( & * & :&;
D
E
=
-
:(; ,
4 3
3
-
3
G
4
D
D
2
#
4 . &*&((%%(
&/ "
2 2
0 (%%/,
2
() &*&% ,
2
#
B
? G
< H 3
C ( 3 2 3 ? 2 4 @ :&**!;*2##)0 #
2
() 3 4 , &*&% <H 0 3
C :4; /2=
:&; 2
0
E
=
:(; 2
0 , )
C =
:(; 2
0
=
3
-
C
E 2
0:(; ! 2
0:(;
-
3
=
-
7,
&7%/(%&) B(%%*
2 (%&&C
E
D 2#
=
C E($ % F,# ! ( ' ( (# + + , & & * ! $-$./ /-
. "
# + - #- ' & ,## ( %"
(+ #&&- ,## , ' &
&$ & "
,- + - &# ( % % - %+ # + +## # 9( & &# ,' . +(&( & #
< # ,## ; ( % , & # & ,- ' &"
#+ ( % 9($
& +( & # & #&&-
,C& &( ##"$ ,## ( % #- %( #"
#+
< ' ,- ( # - & ,- F,# ! + -(*.
( # # +( ,- (
-(*.
# ,- 6, )&
9 ."
& #" # & ' ,% & +## "
"% ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ < ' ( ##" #-$ -$ %- : & # + ' & ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ "
#& ' ,'
9( + &&"#- 9( + ,- ).
# /,#& 0#- !%&1$ ( .$ +(,- #& *2 '# ,- ( $ (#
3 456 (/ )
/. *
5!5
'
<I'$ <I'$