← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/111/2019allowed

Dimple And Others v. Deputy Commissioner-Cum-Chairman Maintenance Appellate Tribunal Rewari And Others

2026-04-20Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari10 pages



               #$% &' %()*)&+  , - 

 =  0             









  !

 



 12  +   

   3  # , 

   # 1

 +   

5

/ 4>  6666



 "  

, * & &- &% %& -  7%*             

 &?

%& -    7/*        

     !" "  #   $  %& &&' 

(

"%&&')* + 

 ," ,

 

 

   %%89%%'

 ":

  % ;          

,    +



&- &%

%& -  7%*   

5

.'8 .'' % %.

&/ %& . + < , "

"#

"%&& &'



" 

 

  " 

   + &?

%& -  7/*  

     

 / ;      "



 

     



   ,

 ,  * *  

 



 @  7   

 "



 

 "   ,+  ""

    "   " 



 #







  "



5

 % ""

  ,

   " ,  + 

"



 

     

"    

 "+  "     $ 

 

 

 

 

"  ,     

  

 



+ 





9

/ >"





 +

    ,

   + 

             

 + < ,

 "

"#

"%&& &'

A   

   " 

 

B ,

   

 + <

 + "# %/

"%&&'



   " ""

 A

 

   

 + +  , 

 +  

   "

"   A   

 

 

  + 

  

  " 1



"   ,

   $

: 

   "   +     , ,

+   ,+ +  ,

 

           

  "



,    """ ,  B " 



.

 

     

  .

E 

    

  "

 

 5

/9   $  

,  

           "



  >



 "  5

/



    5

   % 

       "



 



, ,  *  > "

  

        

     $  > + 

      

 "     

    "  

 "

   5

/

 7  

+ ,

  A 



  5

  %   ,      

  "

 +

     $ 

"

     

,

 

 " 

 ,             "





5

/"





'

 

+     "



     

,  *

    - 3"



 <

     "

 

       +

+  , 



"    

 

  ,  ,

 



?

 

 5

/9     $       "

 % %.

&/ %& .

 :

  



 

 5

/    

    "+  ,

* # 1+D"

"   5

   %  

"   5

/ 

&% &?

%& C  

"

 "

 "

   ,     

,     "  

"+    ""

   

 , %& ?" ,  

 ,

,

   5

 %*

<  + , "  

 

 $ 9

5

/  

     +

    ,

 

 B      "

  

 

   +  ,      

 "

   #

 

"%&&'   " 



5

/9   $  



 "  

     "



5

/" ,



5

/9   $ 

  +  

    ,   



 " 

 "

 ,

 ", + @+  

     

   "  1

   , ,

   $ 9

5

/



 , 

  





 *



 " "# %/ /

"%&&'  +  , "# #

"%&&'

    

   !

 "

#$ # %  # %#%&'%  

 

  

 







    

  

 







   

 





  



   







  



  

   

   



 

   



  



 

   

  

 

 

  

   

 

  

 

!

 "

/ #

   

 

 

 



   

       



   



 

 



     

 



 



 

   

 



$

  

 



 

      

" % &   

  

      

 

 



' 

 #  ( (

 

      

 





  )*  '    +",

% #7 * "#

"%&&' , , "  

  

       

 

 "

 ""   

 "  

  " 1



 "   +

 

  

 "  

 

 " "

<

 

/ > ) #         /&$ ( ((#* " '#  "# $  ( ) +   5

'C " %&% 

&8

% %&%% 







+ "#

%&&'

 

"  +  ,         

 " 7     $   

   "

       + ,      7 %"



  

 

  * 

  

  

   





 



  (

 



 

 

 

"- 

 



  



     

 *

 



"!



 

   

  

    



    '

    .

 #% 

 

     



-

*

     

 



!

 " 0"1





 

.

 #%

 

 "    

 



 

 * *  

  



  

 

 

 

 "  

   

  

    



  ## 

 "" )

   

 

 

   # 2 #34    

 2

 !

      





"&

   

 

    

 "      

   



  

  

 !

     

 

 



 

 * *   



") 

 



 



 





  



 

  

 5 

  

  

    

'   .

 #%"& 

   

  

 



" 

 

 *  



   ",

# + 

   3 

        /#+* , " 

  ($#-( $ (  .) !7C C7% %&%.  /

%&%.  "

   ,

 

  &$ (((#*.% *01 12#  



B ,

 "

   

      $    +  ,     

  

     

  "

         "   "



        

  

 :

  ""



" #

"%&&'   ,

 

 + +

   3     

 

#"







 

 .  1

(  

  (         

     

 



 

     

 



    

    



    

   

  

 

  

 





  



!

 

   

           

     

  

"& 





     

  

        

 

 

   

 

 

  

  





  .

  #%  

 #33 36  

    

 







 % 0

 

 

 

" %")



  

( 

 



  



 







 



 



!

   

 



     



  

    





   



   

 

  

      

    



  



  

   

" 7



  

 

  

  

 

  

   

 ( 



 

  





  

 

 .  1

(  

  

     

      

 ",

.

,

  +   +  



,, + " ,;5

%

"%&%.

> +

  ""  

 +  3 

     ,  

&?

&.

%&%.

 + ,



    3"





 

    

    



    

 

 

  





 

   

  

  

     

     

 





 

.

 #% 

 #336       

    " -   

  

  

 

 

 

    

           

   

". 





    

    

 

 

 2

 !

   



  



 

 " "&



 . 1

( 8 

 



 

.

 #%

#336 



 





*  



 

 

  

.

 #%

#336      

 

   

 2

 !

  

  

  

 







!

  

    ",

   

  " 

   B

    ,  ,

  5

 %

 +

    

 



/9   $   +

 "  

     $  "



         



 

 ,  B ,

 +

<

 "

"#

"%&& '

'

E 

 +

 +,    

 

 "

  #

"%&&'



     ,   ,+ , 1 

         

 + <

 + "#



5



 ,  +   ,  ,  +  

    " + ""  



 "     

   $   

5

/9   $ 

 + +  

     ,   



+  



9 5

/

 

"    

   

      ,

 

7

 , "

"    

 

"

 

   $  +

    "

 ,   

      +      , +  

 "" 

F "

  

 , " <   

:



  

 

,

  

,



  + < ,

 +

  " %&&'

 :

        

 +

"%&&' ,  "



 

  

  

- # "

     "



/9    $ 





"  

 

 " 5

/  + 

,

 

 "

"    

 + < ,

 +

" # %/

  " %&&'

 

 

   

    

 

     



5

/9   $ $ 

    5

/ ,

7 7 * 

"



  



 "

 

?

: 

 "    

  

  "



  

 ,

   

 #55&6%7 %& ,  * & &- &% %& -  7%*             

 &?

%& -    7/*          

*%$ #*)7%"







 ", 

$2#+*'%2 2 7%%7 

2%*$&2%7

 ,   %

# 

 +



   

"" 



"

 



5

/9   $

    ,  ,

 ,

,     

 ,

 + ,



"

  9"



 

  %&%&   &%8 !

< ,9

!

 

G95

G95